p.3 #1New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
philip_pj wrote:
Hard to leave the 65/2 at home, I imagine. But you do gain with the 75/1.5, as you say, and the flexibility really matters for our kits, it can crop to 85-90mm at workable apertures (f8-f11). Without meaning to, I have assembled the 'Vintage line' 75/1.5, 21/3.5 and 50/3.5 - it covers a lot of ground (literally). Some (most?) of their more endearing VM lenses are 'Vintage Line'.
I am curious about the 75's performance at f22-f32, if one of us can do a quick check - no need for photos.
'One final notable difference is that unlike the Nokton 75mm f/1.5 in VM mount, which stops down to f/16, the new version for RF/Z/E’s minimum aperture is f/32.'
In the back of my mind is this factoid: the only CV lenses we have MTF for are the four E-mount APO-Lanthars and the two M-mount lenses - the 35/50 pair. The larger 35/50s are different, in favour of the E/Z-mount pair, a little better wide open than their offering for Leica. Now, wouldn't it be nice of the E/Z/RF 75s were similarly improved? Zeiss were adamant that larger = better. Are the elements identical in size? ...Show more →
We already know that one specification is different and better in the mirrorless mounts and strangely a little better for Z and RF than E mount and that is minimum focus distance. It is .7M for the VM version, .55M for the E mount version, and .5M for the Z and RF versions. I see performance at MFD as one of the weaknesses of the VM version so perhaps making it even shorter in the mirrorless mounts isn't much of an advantage, but perhaps Cosina has improved this close up performance for the mirrorless lenses.
p.3 #2New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
I don't see softness ('glow' might be better) that was a deliberate outcome of the design process as a weakness - while being aware it is indeed so, in technical terms. It's a large part of the dreamy rendering some astute reviewers have noted. It goes together with the fast aperture 'weaker' performance.
I'm glad they had the courage to go this way, in a portrait lens. It's where it earns its 'Vintage Line' status. It's a serious Dr Jeckyll and My Hyde lens - the dreaminess is strongest at f1.5, f2 is the transition aperture, and f2.8 see it grow teeth. What a pleasant change! It's easy to endorse Fred's review on this point:
'..this new CV 75/1.5 put up a great fight when I compared the two. They performed similar at smaller apertures - by f/2.8 it matches the CV 65/2 APO's center, by f/4 it matches its mid-field and at f/8 it comes close to the CV 65/2's corners.'
That's a superb APO he is talking about.
For focus then stop down users, f2.8 is the aperture to focus on your subject with. They may even have designed in better performance at small apertures, but f32 is a big stretch.
Doing what I do, I have this concept of subject matter 'beating the bokeh'. You know, tree leaves, brush, etc. can be an ever-present threat. So far, nothing beats this one's bokeh at these wider apertures. Bokeh remains composed and low contrast, relative to light conditions.
p.3 #5New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
davidjl wrote:
Ha! You noticed it first.
> I'm looking forward to receiving mine on that date
Me too: the first day of my 73rd year on this planet...
It will be a nice birthday present for you I'm still at 54 and counting but my birthday was back in February.
I wasn't actually expecting the announcement today but I check their site on most weekdays just after 3pm (if I don't forget) in case some new announcements might be coming I was more expecting them to do the announcement on a Friday but the release date announcements are not following a very clear pattern.
p.3 #6New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Juha Kannisto wrote: davidjl wroteHa! You noticed it first.
> I'm looking forward to receiving mine on that date
Me too: the first day of my 73rd year on this planet...It will be a nice birthday present for you I'm still at 54 and counting but my birthday was back in February.
I wasn't actually expecting the announcement today but I check their site on most weekdays just after 3pm (if I don't forget) in case some new announcements might be coming I was more expecting them to do the announcement on a Friday but the release date announcements are not following a very clear pattern.
Thank you Juha for keeping us updated.I wait impatiently for this lens.My german distributor,who usually has all new lenses soon after their launch in Japan,keeps my order for 4 weeks now.He was very quick with GF Fujinon 500/5.6 lately,so I thing the beginning of August is realistic for me.
p.3 #7New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Peire wrote: Juha Kannisto wrotedavidjl wroteHa! You noticed it first.
> I'm looking forward to receiving mine on that date
Me too: the first day of my 73rd year on this planet...It will be a nice birthday present for you I'm still at 54 and counting but my birthday was back in February.
I wasn't actually expecting the announcement today but I check their site on most weekdays just after 3pm (if I don't forget) in case some new announcements might be coming I was more expecting them to do the announcement on a Friday but the release date announcements are not following a very clear pattern.Thank you Juha for keeping us updated.I wait impatiently for this lens.My german distributor,who usually has all new lenses soon after their launch in Japan,keeps my order for 4 weeks now.He was very quick with GF Fujinon 500/5.6 lately,so I thing the beginning of August is realistic for me.
Hey Peire, who's your German distributor? If I buy new, I usually buy my Voigtlander lenses from Jo Geier at "mintandrare" (Vienna, Austria). Last week I have received the Heliar 2.8/40 and the Ultron 1.9/75 lenses from him.
p.3 #8New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
catacore wrote: Peire wroteJuha Kannisto wrotedavidjl wroteHa! You noticed it first.
> I'm looking forward to receiving mine on that date
Me too: the first day of my 73rd year on this planet...It will be a nice birthday present for you I'm still at 54 and counting but my birthday was back in February.
I wasn't actually expecting the announcement today but I check their site on most weekdays just after 3pm (if I don't forget) in case some new announcements might be coming I was more expecting them to do the announcement on a Friday but the release date announcements are not following a very clear pattern.Thank you Juha for keeping us updated.I wait impatiently for this lens.My german distributor,who usually has all new lenses soon after their launch in Japan,keeps my order for 4 weeks now.He was very quick with GF Fujinon 500/5.6 lately,so I thing the beginning of August is realistic for me.Hey Peire, who's your German distributor? If I buy new, I usually buy my Voigtlander lenses from Jo Geier at "mintandrare". Last week I have received the Heliar 2.8/40 and the Ultron 1.9/75 lenses from him.
I don't know his name.An old,good friend of mine,who is running the well established photographic shop locally,does all businesses with him directly,so as all I need to do is to order,receive a good after 3-4 working days (earlier and cheaper than through official brand distribution) and pay if satisfied.
p.3 #10New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Same year, same month.
Juha Kannisto wrote: davidjl wroteHa! You noticed it first.
> I'm looking forward to receiving mine on that date
Me too: the first day of my 73rd year on this planet...It will be a nice birthday present for you I'm still at 54 and counting but my birthday was back in February.
I wasn't actually expecting the announcement today but I check their site on most weekdays just after 3pm (if I don't forget) in case some new announcements might be coming I was more expecting them to do the announcement on a Friday but the release date announcements are not following a very clear pattern.
p.3 #12New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
My lens has been shipped today and should arrive tomorrow morning I'll share some samples as soon as I can. We are still in rainy season so weather is often rainy and cloudy but there should be some sunshine later this week.
p.3 #14New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
davidjl wrote:
They've shipped mine, too.
I hope it arrives in the morning, since we're going to be out in the afternoon....
But the sun should be out on Thursday. Should...
I always write a request of 午前中 delivery in the free text entry box when pre-ordering although they don't allow setting delivery date & time on pre-orders and it seems to work reliably. I hope you get it early tomorrow as well
Yes, weather looks promising from Thursday to end of the week. I won't have much time to shoot on Thursday though but hopefully later in the week.
p.3 #15New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
It's here.
At first grab, it didn't seem over;y heavy, but the camera gradually does get a bit weighty as you use it.
Focus is just stiff enough to allow you to focus and then do something else (recompose, change f stop).
Bokeh is sweet. Corners need some amount of stopping down to sharpen up. But images at f/8 and f/11 are fine, so should be good for landscape/cityscape things.
Focussing at f/1.5 handheld for things relatively close to the camera is really hard.
As expected, f/22 and f/32 are useless.
Seriously boring test shots out my study window
(same image, f/1.5, f/2.8, f/5.6, f/11, f/22, f/32) start at:
Click "next" in the upper right to walk through them.
At the bottom, click "auto" to see a reasonable size image, and "original" to see the original.
(To get back to the "auto"/"original" controls from the "original" view, move to the lower left of the screen.)
p.3 #16New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
My copy arrived too but based on just a couple of trial shots I'm feeling it's not centered well. I need to produce more test shots and check with Map Camera about getting it exchanged... Bummer😞
p.3 #17New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
I need to check more carefully as well. At first try the upper left corner seemed to need a bit more stopping down, but that was handheld with a backlit test subject (f/5.6 is fine).
I'll try later with a tripod + afternoon sun.
Infinity focus (for both f/1.5 and f/80) is closer (by quite a bit) than the infinity mark, which is at the post infinity stop.
p.3 #18New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
With my copy, best infinity focus centrally (testing from balcony and shooting some big buildings that are a few hundred meters away) requires focusing a bit further than midpoint of infinity symbol. Closer to the right edge of the symbol. I'm testing on my A7CII but it should be the same with other E-mount cameras and I've not noticed any differences in infinity focus distance between my Sony cameras. The plane of best focus is very narrow, which is not a problem in itself.
I did a bit of a comparison shooting horizontally at f4, I framed a top part of a big building in the upper left corner and focused on that area, it was well in focus but rest of the frame wasn't, then I flipped the camera upside down and tried to frame exactly the same without changing focus. Then the corresponding corner (which would have been lower right when shooting in normal orientation) was pretty soft. So I'm feeling that the centering is not good between all the corners.
So far I just shot handheld with IBIS on. I'm also feeling that IBIS is behaving strangely when used in automatic mode. I'm getting pretty jumpy frame when focusing and if I set IBIS focal length manually things seem to be more stable.
Afterwards I will do some tripod testing from balcony with IBIS off and will try to confirm the centering with some careful test shots. Once I have enough evidence on the centering issue I'll contact Map Camera and see if they agree to exchange... I'll probably go to their physical store (although I bought online) and show them some example shots on my phone or laptop. I think the correct protocol would be to contact their online store but it's going to be difficult to explain the problem on the phone without showing any evidence.
I have to work today as well so not enough time to test everything carefully yet.
p.3 #19New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
I got my lens exchanged at Map Camera physical store without trouble once I showed my photos and the staff could see that there was a problem. Decentering is always a bit gray zone so I was worried if it would work out smoothly but it went well. Hopefully the new copy is all good. I need to test it in daylight tomorrow and later this week as it's already dark.
p.3 #20New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
My new copy of the lens looks much better in terms of centering based on my short test this morning so I think I will be happy to stick with it
It also has the optimal infinity focusing point slightly over the center point of the infinity symbol, closer to the right edge of the symbol, pretty much at the same place as my first copy.