palmor wrote:
trippalhealick wrote
arbitrage wrote
trippalhealick wrote
palmor wrote
First time out with the camera, crappy conditions (misty, rainy, cloudy) so not much chance to catch things in motion. My initial impressions is that the bird detection is far superior to the A1 (not real surprise there) and the AF did feel snappier to me (used it it with the 600 F4 with and without the 1.4x TC).
Last photo of the Wilson's Warbler was a good test of the Eye AF (using the XS focus point) IMO, the 24megapixel sensor seems to be outperforming what i'd initially expect just comparing stats on paper. From 50 or 61 megapixel to 24, you'd expect a lot less detail, but in reality, it's not much different at all. Any chance you could share an uncropped version of one of the Warbler shots? I'd like to see how much detail can be retained from cropping. There is nothing magical about the 24MP of the A9III. It has the resolution of 24MP. It performs the way you would expect with any previous 20-odd MP sensor. I shot 1DX (18), 1DXII (20), A9/A9II (24) and have used R3 (24). If you fill enough of the frame you will have a razor sharp, beautiful image. If you have to crop big you will get a way nicer image out of an A1. The reason I didn't add an A9III to my bag after having my 3 weeks with it is I lost too many cool images due to lack of resolution. I'm typically a one camera at a time shooter so the A1 gets me more shots in the end of the day than an A9III. I'd have to be very selective with what I was shooting and going to use an A9III with and accept that anything random happening further away could be a lost opportunity. With the A1 the only thing I can't pull off is great launching pre-capture shots. Really the only place I was happy to have the A9III as my only camera was my backyard as I have everything controlled at reasonable distances so the A9III was perfect and great for passerines in flight.
It should also be noted that with those past 18-24MP cameras they all had a bit of an advantage because their high-ISO performance would make up for some of the lack of MP compared to a high-MP sensor. But because of the GS limitations the A9III has given up that advantage so now it only excels if you get close enough. I haven't shot any wildlife with smaller sensors, which is why your feedback and everyone's image examples here are very helpful to me. I'm going to have to wait until the A1mk2. For the birds I shoot in my most common scenario (currently), I need to do a lot of cropping, and more importantly, lighting conditions are not always great. LOTS of shade being provided by tons of trees. I think that is a good plan, as others have said for wildlife in situations where you need to crop the A1 is the way to go. The reason I added the A9 III to my bag was a need for a 2nd body and I wanted something different than another A1. I also plan on using it in situations where I won’t have to crop. If the A1 II had been out I would’ve gotten that for sure but for now the A9 III will work great.
This is the exact same reason I have one. I don't know if you read my report on my A9III on my trip to Colombia in late March but I found that I used is way more than I realized. Back here now for warbler migration it's been a mixed bag, as you can't count on them getting close at feeders, etc. so the A1 has been out more often.