fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video

  
 
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.8 #1Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video

bernardl wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wroteSteve,

To be 100% clear, I do not care about your assessment of Nikon equipment since you are no using any Nikon mirrorless nor for stills, nor for video. I believe that most photographers in the Nikon forum share my feeling.

You can call Nikon great or awful, it makes no difference whatsoever.

The same applies to your opinion about videos related to Nikon equipment.

Cheers,
Bernard
Of course you care. You consistently answer and challenge my every post. What is 100% clear is that If you didn't care you wouldn't do that.

I wonder if you have the same opinion about all those that don't shoot Sony posting opinions on those cameras?

A little balance please...

But in the end I know it is not whether I shoot Nikon or not. I got the same attitude when I was only shooting Nikon and bought a Z7 on release. I posted my opinion on my disappointment with that camera. What I was seeing in that camera's deficiencies 100% got confirmed in the press. I was attacked in the way I am being attacked now. I had never been in any sort of on-line arguments prior to that. I was shocked to even learn that such things even existed. The one thing that is the same then and now is that I wasn't following the Nikon faithfull line. So whether I shot Nikon as my main system or not was not the determining issue then and is not now.
I do not care at all about what you think, but I do care about the negative impact your constant sharing of biased information may have on uninformed bystanders. This is what motivates my answers to your posts.

I shoot several brands, have owned Sony equipment and have a huge amount of respect for the brand for various reasons I won't go too much into. But one of them is that I have several close friends working for Sony while I don't know anyone working for Nikon.

And no, I do not think that Nikon is perfect at all.

That is beside the
...Show more →

But I have no negative agenda against Nikon. I do however challenge some of your posts like the recent one on video. Not a negatve thing about Nikon in my posts. Just positive linking of facts that challenge some of your broad claims of superiority. Aparently, that upsets you for some reason.


I think people can judge things for themselves. They will see in my posts it is rare for me to criticize Nikons latest products. I do challenge incorrect information. I also do object strongly to some statements and behaviors of a few on the Nikon boards. They don't need you to protect them.

You have generally been polite in our discussions as I have posted more than once.
Nov 06, 2023 at 10:59 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote:
Alistair1 wroteBy describing me pointing out the factual inaccuracies of abouthelight's adulation of the A1 as an attack is a biased, inaccurate and unconstructive use of language. If you care to revise your characterisation, I will be happy to address your concern.
You accused him of being factually incorrect when he was correct.



His claim about the A1 was: "It is the smallest, lightest and fastest camera in this range. It is the only one that can do full raw at 20fps and only that can do compressed raw at 30fps"

Of course the Z9 also does full raw at 20 fps and the A1 does not do compressed raw at 30 fps, it does lossy raw at 30 fps. Compression is a different consideration. The point is that a file contains the full raw data set. He is also incorrect about the the speed; start up times, buffer clearing, highest lossy raw capture speed (Z9 60 fps raw video), card write speeds are all faster in the Z9. Smallest and lightest is also a false claim if you want to shoot 12 bit video with a long lens attached.

What I would have accepted, and said this to him, was that "It is the smallest, lightest and fastest camera in this range for what I shoot.". And for the second part of his statement; "like the Z9 it can do full raw at 20fps and the only one that can do lossy raw at 30fps".

As an educator and self pronounced doyen of bird photography, I think I can hold him to that standard of precision.

You also questioned his motives for posting in a Nikon forum.

Yep. Why did he? When he stated up front he had no interest in using anything other than Sony equipment and he still has not said what part of Steve's video he disagreed with. I also did not like that he came here criticizing a competitor's work without declaring his conflict of interest.

I can tell you he was very upset by those things you said.
Well, I wasn't that happy myself but pulled up my big boys' pants and soldiered on.
Nov 06, 2023 at 11:13 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.8 #3Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video


Alistair1 wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Alistair1 wroteBy describing me pointing out the factual inaccuracies of abouthelight's adulation of the A1 as an attack is a biased, inaccurate and unconstructive use of language. If you care to revise your characterisation, I will be happy to address your concern.
You accused him of being factually incorrect when he was correct.
His claim about the A1 was: "It is the smallest, lightest and fastest camera in this range. It is the only one that can do full raw at 20fps and only that can do compressed raw at 30fps"

Of course the Z9 also does full raw at 20 fps and the A1 does not do compressed raw at 30 fps, it does lossy raw at 30 fps. Compression is a different consideration. The point is that a file contains the full raw data set. He is also incorrect about the the speed; start up times, buffer clearing, highest lossy raw capture
...Show more →
Earlier quoteYou also questioned his motives for posting in a Nikon forum.
Earlier quoteI can tell you he was very upset by those things you said.


I guess there is disagreement on what is full RAW. The Sony does full uncompressed RAW at 20fps. The z9/8 do a compressed RAW at 20fps. He is not incorrect in saying that. You then say that the A1 does a lossy form of compressed RAW at 30 fps. It is still RAW. You are trying to have it both ways. The Fact is that the A1 does RAW it both 20fps and 30fps though different forms of RAW. JPEG is not a form of RAW.

He honestly stated his view of speed and form factor. Many would agree with him, many with you. But he was not factually incorrect.

He posted because he had an opinion on the content of the video being discussed. He needs no further qualification than that. You implying malicioureasons is insulting to him.

You are correct. He is not as comfortable with conflict as you and I are. But that is also OK. He was really confused and surprised by the behavior in the Nikon Forum. I guess you will consider that a job well done.
Nov 06, 2023 at 11:54 PM
MikeInPa
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
bernardl wrote:
Like many other who have not observed your posts closely enough, I was first under the assumption that you were actually attempting to take an objective view on things and I would have welcomed that 100%. But you are clearly not. Apparent objectivity is a disguise for what is very clearly a strong agenda.

Cheers,
Bernard


This partial comment from Bernard deserves to be repeated over and over and over everytime he posts.

Bernard quite rightly states “ but I do care about the negative impact your constant sharing of biased information may have on uninformed bystanders”. This is a trend I have seen on several forums, I was banned from DPR for raising exactly the same proposition. Does Sony pay these people? The guy obviously has his Sony anti Nikon agenda otherwise why would he spend so much time and effort in the Nikon Forum making his many barbed disparaging remarks about Nikon gear?



Nov 07, 2023 at 01:14 AM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote:
Alistair1 wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Alistair1 wroteBy describing me pointing out the factual inaccuracies of abouthelight's adulation of the A1 as an attack is a biased, inaccurate and unconstructive use of language. If you care to revise your characterisation, I will be happy to address your concern.
You accused him of being factually incorrect when he was correct.
His claim about the A1 was: "It is the smallest, lightest and fastest camera in this range. It is the only one that can do full raw at 20fps and only that can do compressed raw at 30fps"

Of course the Z9 also does full raw at 20 fps and the A1 does not do compressed raw at 30 fps, it does lossy raw at 30 fps. Compression is a different consideration. The point is that a file contains the full raw data set. He is also incorrect about the the speed; start up times, buffer clearing, highest lossy raw capture speed (Z9 60 fps raw video), card write speeds are all faster in the Z9. Smallest and lightest is also a false claim if you want to shoot 12 bit video with a long lens attached.

What I would have accepted, and said this to him, was that "It is the smallest, lightest and fastest camera in this range for what I shoot.". And for the second part of his statement; "like the Z9 it can do full raw at 20fps and the only one that can do lossy raw at 30fps".

As an educator and self pronounced doyen of bird photography, I think I can hold him to that standard of precision.

Earlier quoteYou also questioned his motives for posting in a Nikon forum.
Yep. Why did he? When he stated up front he had no interest in using anything other than Sony equipment and he still has not said what part of Steve's video he disagreed with. I also did not like that he came here criticizing a competitor's work without declaring his conflict of interest.

Earlier quoteI can tell you he was very upset by those things you said.
Well, I wasn't that happy myself but pulled up my big boys' pants and soldiered on.
I guess there is disagreement on what is full RAW. The Sony does full uncompressed RAW at 20fps. The z9/8 do a compressed RAW at 20fps. He is not incorrect in saying that. You then say that the A1 does a lossy form of compressed RAW at 30 fps. It is still RAW. You are trying to have it both ways. The Fact is that the A1 does RAW it both 20fps and 30fps though different forms of RAW. JPEG is not a form of RAW.

He honestly stated his view of speed and form factor. Many would agree with him,
...Show more →

Had he used your words "Sony does full uncompressed RAW at 20fps" and possibly added that "Nikon does full RAW compressed at 20fps" I would not have considered his words disingenuous and would not have been so hard on him. I am happy to leave it at that.
Nov 07, 2023 at 01:52 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.8 #6Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video


Alistair1 wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Alistair1 wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Alistair1 wroteBy describing me pointing out the factual inaccuracies of abouthelight's adulation of the A1 as an attack is a biased, inaccurate and unconstructive use of language. If you care to revise your characterisation, I will be happy to address your concern.
You accused him of being factually incorrect when he was correct.
His claim about the A1 was: "It is the smallest, lightest and fastest camera in this range. It is the only one that can do full raw at 20fps and only that can do compressed raw at 30fps"

Of course the Z9 also does full raw at 20 fps and the A1 does not do compressed raw at 30 fps, it does lossy raw at 30 fps. Compression is a different consideration. The point is that a file contains the full raw data set. He is also incorrect about the the speed; start up times, buffer clearing, highest lossy raw capture speed (Z9 60 fps raw video), card write speeds are all faster in the Z9. Smallest and lightest is also a false claim if you want to shoot 12 bit video with a long lens attached.

What I would have accepted, and said this to him, was that "It is the smallest, lightest and fastest camera in this range for what I shoot.". And for the second part of his statement; "like the Z9 it can do full raw at 20fps and the only one that can do lossy raw at 30fps".

As an educator and self pronounced doyen of bird photography, I think I can hold him to that standard of precision.

Earlier quoteYou also questioned his motives for posting in a Nikon forum.
Yep. Why did he? When he stated up front he had no interest in using anything other than Sony equipment and he still has not said what part of Steve's video he disagreed with. I also did not like that he came here criticizing a competitor's work without declaring his conflict of interest.

Earlier quoteI can tell you he was very upset by those things you said.
Well, I wasn't that happy myself but pulled up my big boys' pants and soldiered on.
I guess there is disagreement on what is full RAW. The Sony does full uncompressed RAW at 20fps. The z9/8 do a compressed RAW at 20fps. He is not incorrect in saying that. You then say that the A1 does a lossy form of compressed RAW at 30 fps. It is still RAW. You are trying to have it both ways. The Fact is that the A1 does RAW it both 20fps and 30fps though different forms of RAW. JPEG is not a form of RAW.

He honestly stated his view of speed and form factor. Many would agree with him, many with you. But he was not factually incorrect.

He posted because he had an opinion on the content of the video being discussed. He needs no further qualification than that. You implying malicioureasons is insulting to him.

You are correct. He is not as comfortable with conflict as you and I are. But that is also OK. He was really confused and surprised by the behavior in the Nikon Forum. I guess you will consider that a job well done.
Had he used your words "Sony does full uncompressed RAW at 20fps" and possibly added that "Nikon does full RAW compressed at 20fps" I would not have considered his words disingenuous and would not have been so hard on him. I am happy to leave it at that.


Me too.
Nov 07, 2023 at 03:31 AM
Buckeye2604
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Just for clarity… in case anyone reading this is confused. The most commonly used terminology I’ve seen is:
1. Uncompressed raw (A1 @ 20fps)
2. Lossless compressed raw (A1/Z9 @ 20fps)
3. Lossy compressed raw (lower quality lossy raw, A1 @ 30fps)

1 and 2 are identical in quality, both are what I consider to be “full” raw because they contain all of the raw data. 3 is a lower quality. Nikon completely eliminated the option for uncompressed raw with the Z8/9 regardless of shooting speed.
Nov 07, 2023 at 03:45 AM
Max Power
Offline
Details
p.8 #8Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
molson wrote:
Max Power wrote
molson wrote
Vinnie_VdB wroteEntirely poisonous and venomous.
That pretty much sums up the Nikon Forum experience for anyone who admits they like some aspect of any other brand, doesn't it?
Any Fuji blow ups here? Any Canon blow ups here? Any Leica blow ups here? Any Sigma blow ups here? Any OM blow ups here?

Negatory.
Selective blindness is another aspect of toxic delusion, I guess.


Well, I have to bow to your knowledge on toxicity. Seems to be your currency.
Nov 07, 2023 at 06:02 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #9Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Buckeye2604 wrote:
Just for clarity… in case anyone reading this is confused. The most commonly used terminology I’ve seen is:
1. Uncompressed raw (A1 @ 20fps)
2. Lossless compressed raw (A1/Z9 @ 20fps)
3. Lossy compressed raw (lower quality lossy raw, A1 @ 30fps)

1 and 2 are identical in quality, both are what I consider to be “full” raw because they contain all of the raw data. 3 is a lower quality. Nikon completely eliminated the option for uncompressed raw with the Z8/9 regardless of shooting speed.


This is one of those "stat sheet" things Sony shooters love to point to...and yet, even the lossy compressed option on the Z8/Z9 (HE*) is just as good as the lossless compressed. There is simply no need for uncompressed RAW on the Z8/Z9 because what is there is SO GOOD. Please go find people complaining about the lack of uncompressed RAW on these cameras. I've simply never seen it.

Again, it's one of those things where if you ACTUALLY USE NIKON, you know what the hell you're talking about, and if you don't, you're a sad little troll just regurgitating spec sheets.
Nov 07, 2023 at 08:00 AM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.8 #10Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Regardless of brand, I don't know why anyone would shoot uncompressed RAW instead of lossless compressed RAW. It's just adding huge storage overhead for zero increase in quality. I understand if there is no lossless format, but that's not the case here.
Nov 07, 2023 at 08:21 AM
Buckeye2604
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Jman13 wrote:
Regardless of brand, I don't know why anyone would shoot uncompressed RAW instead of lossless compressed RAW. It's just adding huge storage overhead for zero increase in quality. I understand if there is no lossless format, but that's not the case here.

Jared Polin lol touts uncompressed raw as an advantage and all I can do is shake my head.
Nov 07, 2023 at 08:34 AM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.8 #12Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
BTW....injecting more fun into this - did you guys see the A9 III announcement? Holy crud. Global shutter, 1/80,000s shutter speeds with flash sync at all shutter speeds, 120fps RAW with AF / AE between frames.

I have no need for that level of speed, but my god. I'm just imagning some of the photos we'll get of golf, baseball, racket sports, etc, that were literally impossible before, since they'll be able to freeze motion, almost certainly get impact shots, and with zero distortion.
Nov 07, 2023 at 08:44 AM
Creative Edge
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Jman13 wrote:
BTW....injecting more fun into this - did you guys see the A9 III announcement? Holy crud. Global shutter, 1/80,000s shutter speeds with flash sync at all shutter speeds, 120fps RAW with AF / AE between frames.

I have no need for that level of speed, but my god. I'm just imagning some of the photos we'll get of golf, baseball, racket sports, etc, that were literally impossible before, since they'll be able to freeze motion, almost certainly get impact shots, and with zero distortion.


wow...those are some crazy specs.. amazing
I love the flash synch at all speeds, that is a game changer for me
Nov 07, 2023 at 08:51 AM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Jman13 wrote:
did you guys see the A9 III announcement?


Yep. Incredible specs on a9iii, but I am more interested in that lightweight 300mm f/2.8 GM lens.
Christmas came early for some?
Nov 07, 2023 at 09:08 AM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Creative Edge wrote:
Jman13 wroteBTW....injecting more fun into this - did you guys see the A9 III announcement? Holy crud. Global shutter, 1/80,000s shutter speeds with flash sync at all shutter speeds, 120fps RAW with AF / AE between frames.

I have no need for that level of speed, but my god. I'm just imagning some of the photos we'll get of golf, baseball, racket sports, etc, that were literally impossible before, since they'll be able to freeze motion, almost certainly get impact shots, and with zero distortion.
wow...those are some crazy specs.. amazing
I love the flash synch at all speeds, that is a game changer for me


Global shutter is very very nice and it has been long time coming for CMOS sensor.
Back in the good old days when Nikon was CCD and Canon was CMOS, one advantage of
CCD was global shutter so D70 could sync with flash at any SS that it supports.
Then Nikon gave up on CCD and went with CMOS in D2X.
I can't remember what was the last CCD with autofocus, may be it was D70 but I am not certain.
Leica M9 is the last FF camera with CCD and global shutter, I think.
Finally Sony can make CMOS with global shutter, well done Sony. But nah, too many lenses I love on Nikon, so may be
in 5 years Nikon might get something similar



Edited on Nov 07, 2023 at 09:12 AM · View previous versions
Nov 07, 2023 at 09:11 AM
MikeInPa
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
RoamingScott wrote:
Buckeye2604 wroteJust for clarity… in case anyone reading this is confused. The most commonly used terminology I’ve seen is:
1. Uncompressed raw (A1 @ 20fps)
2. Lossless compressed raw (A1/Z9 @ 20fps)
3. Lossy compressed raw (lower quality lossy raw, A1 @ 30fps)

1 and 2 are identical in quality, both are what I consider to be “full” raw because they contain all of the raw data. 3 is a lower quality. Nikon completely eliminated the option for uncompressed raw with the Z8/9 regardless of shooting speed.
This is one of those "stat sheet" things Sony shooters love to point to...and yet, even the lossy compressed option on the Z8/Z9 (HE*) is just as good as the lossless compressed. There is simply no need for uncompressed RAW on the Z8/Z9 because what is there is SO GOOD. Please go find people complaining about the lack of uncompressed RAW on these cameras. I've simply never seen it.

Again, it's one of those things where if you ACTUALLY USE NIKON, you know what the hell you're talking about, and if you don't, you're a sad little troll just regurgitating spec
...Show more →

Excellent post Scott, that's certainly telling like it is.

What possible motivation is there for someone to continue posting disparaging propaganda not once or twice but what seems to be nearly 24 hours a day. Look at the timing of his posts over just the 6th and 7th. I don't care what time zone the Forum uses but see for yourself the post times recorded below.

November 6th.
3:27AM
12:13PM
2:11PM
2:13PM
2:23PM
3:14PM
4:04PM
5:06PM
5:07PM
5:10PM
7:04PM
8:10PM
9:25PM
11:59PM

November 7th.
12:54AM
4:31AM


Are we looking at a single individual or perhaps an entire Troll Farm posting under a single username?



Nov 07, 2023 at 09:11 AM
JustShootMe
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
The lens is more interesting than the camera to me , at this point those frame rates are just video . Video and Stills are on the verge of a collision. Nice job Sony , I’m sure the others will soon follow.
Nov 07, 2023 at 09:12 AM
shutterbug40
Offline
Details
p.8 #18Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Creative Edge wrote:
Jman13 wroteBTW....injecting more fun into this - did you guys see the A9 III announcement? Holy crud. Global shutter, 1/80,000s shutter speeds with flash sync at all shutter speeds, 120fps RAW with AF / AE between frames.

I have no need for that level of speed, but my god. I'm just imagning some of the photos we'll get of golf, baseball, racket sports, etc, that were literally impossible before, since they'll be able to freeze motion, almost certainly get impact shots, and with zero distortion.
wow...those are some crazy specs.. amazing
I love the flash synch at all speeds, that is a game changer for me


The all-speed flash sync seemed like it got the most ohhs-and-ahhs
Nov 07, 2023 at 09:13 AM
sum1sgrampa
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
bernardl wrote:
Steve,

To be 100% clear, I do not care about your assessment of Nikon equipment since you are no using any Nikon mirrorless nor for stills, nor for video. I believe that most photographers in the Nikon forum share my feeling.

You can call Nikon great or awful, it makes no difference whatsoever.

The same applies to your opinion about videos related to Nikon equipment.

Cheers,
Bernard


Personally, I'm very much interested in hearing from folks who use different gear. If someone is using something other than say, Nikon, I like knowing the reasons for their choices. There's no such thing as too much information. Just take what you can use and leave the rest. All this talk about "hiding" and "ignore buttons", what are we 13 year old schoolgirls ? Most adults have a "hide me" button built into their developed brains.

Edited on Nov 07, 2023 at 09:30 AM · View previous versions
Nov 07, 2023 at 09:15 AM
lukemeup
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
MikeInPa wrote:
Are we looking at a single individual or perhaps an entire Troll Farm posting under a single username?


There's a simple fix for that - 'hide me' button. Trolls die when not fed.

Nov 07, 2023 at 09:16 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister