p.7 #1Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
...and fhere he goes again. gaslighting. yikes, what an insufferable individual.
Nov 06, 2023 at 04:48 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.7 #2Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Glad yall are finally waking up. Now hide him. Trolls starve when you take away responses to their prodding, calculating posts. Leave this sad troll to rot away in an empty room.
p.7 #3Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
The whole "look what you made me do" attitude followed up by endless gaslighting is classic abuser/bullying behavior. These are the same types of people who will (metaphorically) poke an animal with a stick 20 times and when it finally reacts in a very predictable way, point and say "hey everyone, look how aggressive it is".
p.7 #4Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Max Power wrote:
I like all brands too. I just don't like constantly being bombarded by Sony content in a Nikon room. If any of us wanted that, we would go to the Sony room.
Put yourself in our shoes. How well would one of us be received over there if we engaged in the behavior you are exhibiting here year in year out?
You just get old, man. You don't have to defend and promote Sony at every turn in the Nikon room, even if some of us might be wrong every once in a while. Just let it go. Better yet, just go. ...Show more →
The video was comparing A1 vs Z9 AF so of course you are going to get Sony people in here.
p.7 #5Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
aboutthelight wrote:
Folks I am going to try this one more time. The issue is content for me of the video and any other related claims. I own an A1, it is irrelevant if it is the best or not because that is what I have. Being the best or not gives me zero extra in the field when trying to get photos. That is all work and knowledge based and how we use the particular tools that we pick to get the job done. I am excited by the prospects of subject recognition and would not be surprised in any way that Nikon has pulled ahead. That is nothing but great for the market and us consumers. The 3 people that I shoot most often with shoot an R5, Z9 and A1. It is very rare that any of us walk away having missed a photo that we thought was the cameras fault and not our own. All of the makers are so close that it is very rarely even an issue.
That said to make a claim of superiority for me it has to be content based. Acquiring initial focus is only part of the story. Staying locked on is the other part. Accurate tracking, staying on the eye, not jumping to the closest wing and things like that all play a vital part in getting a photo. To assess those things I think you need to have done direct side by side comparisons with difficult subjects, not motionless birds. Others are free to disagree and take Steve at his word. That is your right as it is mine to have a different criteria to make that claim. Again for me I don't care which is better because I don't own both. But as I mentioned close friends do so I wish them nothing but the best that Nikon has to offer. But again making claims of superiority require side by side comparisons with difficult species in my book. For the last decade people have been taking killer shots of eagles and ospreys and slow moving herons with 7d's,1dx.s, d500's, d5's, d850's and so on. Those birds are easy in comparison to much smaller, faster and more elusive subjects. So when you claim one is better but your proof is from experience with easy birds once again I have a problem with the content.
It is important for me to understand all of the systems as I have clients who use them and I have people who ask me quite often what they should be buying. So please this is not me claiming Sony superiority in anything. I have not spent any time with the Z9 and newest firmware. I have zero basis to even make the claim and have it mean anything. And I also have zero motivation to make that claim as well. I have birded my whole life, seen thousands of species and photographed hundreds of species. That is relevant because the auto focus requirements for flying tiny and fast birds is quite different from ducks on the water or small songbirds in foliage or shorebirds running in water or owls at dusk.
If this is about the photos look at my Instagram and let the photos do the talking. I only say that because I have not posted photos on FM in years. There are photos with my 1dx, many with the d850 and many with the A1. I doubt you could tell which camera took which photo and I don't think it is important. Only that we use the cameras to our best ability to get the photos. There are maybe 175 species on there (I have not counted) and have loads I can and eventually will add. So when you talk to me about autofocus and your reference is a vulture in a tree or a woodpecker or something else and nothing difficult this is again a content issue and nothing else. If people take pride in owning the best that is great. I just want great photos with what I own and to have an understanding of what else is out there so I can help others when asked to.
I won't engage in any nikon vs sony bashing comments. I won't engage in any best vs worst or trolling comments. I'd love to hear from folks who have used both cameras side by side with the most recent firmware and has formed an educated decision with difficult species. ...Show more →
Ok, let's try again. What are the claims in Steve's video that you disagree with?
p.7 #6Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
arbitrage wrote: Max Power wroteI like all brands too. I just don't like constantly being bombarded by Sony content in a Nikon room. If any of us wanted that, we would go to the Sony room.
Put yourself in our shoes. How well would one of us be received over there if we engaged in the behavior you are exhibiting here year in year out?
You just get old, man. You don't have to defend and promote Sony at every turn in the Nikon room, even if some of us might be wrong every once in a while. Just let it go. Better yet, just go.The video was comparing A1 vs Z9 AF so of course you are going to get Sony people in here.
Given the interest from Sony shooters, perhaps a thread could be started on the Sony forum.
p.7 #7Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
RoamingScott wrote:
Glad yall are finally waking up. Now hide him. Trolls starve when you take away responses to their prodding, calculating posts. Leave this sad troll to rot away in an empty room.
Yes, please. I encourage all the bullies here to hide me, then maybe we can have some nice discussions about gear. I will treat those remaining with respect even when disagreeing.
Same small group of guys, with the same insecurities, giving the same attacks. I thought I got lucky and Scott was going to hide me. But it still seems I am still occupying way to much of his thoughts. Oh well, there is always hope.
p.7 #9Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote: Alistair1 wroteGiven the interest from Sony shooters, perhaps a thread could be started on the Sony forum.Or, just treat them with respect here?
I'm sure they get a great deal of respect in return for the respect they show their hosts.
p.7 #10Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Alistair1 wrote: 1bwana1 wroteAlistair1 wroteGiven the interest from Sony shooters, perhaps a thread could be started on the Sony forum.Or, just treat them with respect here?I'm sure they get a great deal of respect in return for the respect they show their hosts.
I am very happy to show respect to all that do the same. I prefer to discuss subjects not personalities. In this thread I responded in the same tone I was addressed in. No more. You will note that I started in this thread being very positive about Steve's Video, and very congratulatory on Nikon's firmware accomplishment. As far as I can see re-reading the thread you were the first to insult aboutthelight questioning his motives for posting in the Nikon forum. Then attacking him for being factually incorrect when in fact everything he said was true. Aboutthelight's post were always polite and respect. Yours not so much.
If you are respectful, I will be respectful. It doesn't mean we have to agree.
p.7 #11Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Steve,
To be 100% clear, I do not care about your assessment of Nikon equipment since you are no using any Nikon mirrorless nor for stills, nor for video. I believe that most photographers in the Nikon forum share my feeling.
You can call Nikon great or awful, it makes no difference whatsoever.
The same applies to your opinion about videos related to Nikon equipment.
p.7 #12Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote: Alistair1 wrote1bwana1 wroteAlistair1 wroteGiven the interest from Sony shooters, perhaps a thread could be started on the Sony forum.Or, just treat them with respect here?I'm sure they get a great deal of respect in return for the respect they show their hosts.I am very happy to show respect to all that do the same. I prefer to discuss subjects not personalities. In this thread I responded in the same tone I was addressed in. No more. You will note that I started in this thread being very positive about Steve's Video, and very congratulatory on Nikon's firmware accomplishment. As far as I can see re-reading the thread you were the first to insult aboutthelight questioning his motives for posting in the Nikon forum. Then attacking him for being factually incorrect when in fact everything he said was true. Aboutthelight's post were always polite and respect. Yours not so much.
If you are respectful, I will be respectful. It doesn't mean we have to agree....Show more →
Well I did not intentionally insult aboutthelight. Can you point out the phrase you consider an insult?
p.7 #13Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote: Alistair1 wrote1bwana1 wroteAlistair1 wroteGiven the interest from Sony shooters, perhaps a thread could be started on the Sony forum.Or, just treat them with respect here?I'm sure they get a great deal of respect in return for the respect they show their hosts.I am very happy to show respect to all that do the same. I prefer to discuss subjects not personalities. In this thread I responded in the same tone I was addressed in. No more. You will note that I started in this thread being very positive about Steve's Video, and very congratulatory on Nikon's firmware accomplishment. As far as I can see re-reading the thread you were the first to insult aboutthelight questioning his motives for posting in the Nikon forum. Then attacking him for being factually incorrect when in fact everything he said was true. Aboutthelight's post were always polite and respect. Yours not so much.
If you are respectful, I will be respectful. It doesn't mean we have to agree....Show more →
By describing me pointing out the factual inaccuracies of abouthelight's adulation of the A1 as an attack is a biased, inaccurate and unconstructive use of language. If you care to revise your characterisation, I will be happy to address your concern.
p.7 #15Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
JustShootMe wrote: Gary Irwin wroteWhat we just had confirmed, is that there's no point in choosing/switching brands due to AF differences (assuming Canon is right there, which by all accounts it is). Hopefully this will end the AF wars (for now). End the AF wars , you sir have forgotten this is the Internet ! Sparta would have sounded better , but oh well.
I always thought the systems were closer than most wanted to admit. Hats of to Nikon for the firmware updates, and not forcing users to upgrade the camera to get it.
Damn spoke to soon … THIS IS SPARTA ! Chill out it ain’t worth arguing over.
p.7 #16Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Alistair1 wrote:
By describing me pointing out the factual inaccuracies of abouthelight's adulation of the A1 as an attack is a biased, inaccurate and unconstructive use of language. If you care to revise your characterisation, I will be happy to address your concern.
You accused him of being factually incorrect when he was correct.
You also questioned his motives for posting in a Nikon forum.
I can tell you he was very upset by those things you said.
p.7 #17Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
bernardl wrote:
Steve,
To be 100% clear, I do not care about your assessment of Nikon equipment since you are no using any Nikon mirrorless nor for stills, nor for video. I believe that most photographers in the Nikon forum share my feeling.
You can call Nikon great or awful, it makes no difference whatsoever.
The same applies to your opinion about videos related to Nikon equipment.
Cheers,
Bernard
Of course you care. You consistently answer and challenge my every post. What is 100% clear is that If you didn't care you wouldn't do that.
I wonder if you have the same opinion about all those that don't shoot Sony posting opinions on those cameras?
A little balance please...
But in the end I know it is not whether I shoot Nikon or not. I got the same attitude when I was only shooting Nikon and bought a Z7 on release. I posted my opinion on my disappointment with that camera. What I was seeing in that camera's deficiencies 100% got confirmed in the press. I was attacked in the way I am being attacked now. I had never been in any sort of on-line arguments prior to that. I was shocked to even learn that such things even existed. The one thing that is the same then and now is that I wasn't following the Nikon faithfull line. So whether I shot Nikon as my main system or not was not the determining issue then and is not now.
p.7 #18Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Well, I enjoyed using my Z9 today for some personal family photos. It appears to have been a lot more enjoyable than the two and a half fresh pages of nothingness on this thread.
I think I will do that again tomorrow and give FM a pass for awhile. This is getting tiring.
p.7 #20Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote: bernardl wroteSteve,
To be 100% clear, I do not care about your assessment of Nikon equipment since you are no using any Nikon mirrorless nor for stills, nor for video. I believe that most photographers in the Nikon forum share my feeling.
You can call Nikon great or awful, it makes no difference whatsoever.
The same applies to your opinion about videos related to Nikon equipment.
Cheers,
BernardOf course you care. You consistently answer and challenge my every post. What is 100% clear is that If you didn't care you wouldn't do that.
I wonder if you have the same opinion about all those that don't shoot Sony posting opinions on those cameras?
A little balance please...
But in the end I know it is not whether I shoot Nikon or not. I got the same attitude when I was only shooting Nikon and bought a Z7 on release. I posted my opinion on my disappointment with that camera. What I was seeing in that camera's deficiencies 100% got confirmed in the press. I was attacked in the way I am being attacked now. I had never been in any sort of on-line arguments prior to that. I was shocked to even learn that such things even existed. The one thing that is the same then and now is that I wasn't following the Nikon faithfull line. So whether I shot Nikon as my main system or not was not the determining issue then and is not now. ...Show more →
I do not care at all about what you think, but I do care about the negative impact your constant sharing of biased information may have on uninformed bystanders. This is what motivates my answers to your posts.
I shoot several brands, have owned Sony equipment and have a huge amount of respect for the brand for various reasons I won't go too much into. But one of them is that I have several close friends working for Sony while I don't know anyone working for Nikon.
And no, I do not think that Nikon is perfect at all.
That is beside the point.
Like many other who have not observed your posts closely enough, I was first under the assumption that you were actually attempting to take an objective view on things and I would have welcomed that 100%. But you are clearly not. Apparent objectivity is a disguise for what is very clearly a strong agenda.