p.6 #1Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
henry albert wrote: MikeInPa wroteAll these Sony fanboys with their barbed praise as their reason for posting on the NIKON forum.Agreed. However, this thread and the "where's the mirrorless D500" thread demonstrate that pomposity and arrogance are also alive and well in the Nikon forum.
As I’m very rarely here I’m unaware of the D500 thread unfortunately, it’s not something I would read anyway. Do they troll on the Sony forum? I bet not.
p.6 #2Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
MikeInPa wrote: 1bwana1 wroteYou guys need to get your sense of humor back. That post was entirely tongue in cheek. Jeez, so sensitive. Time to get over it.Which one of the hundreds of Sony fanboy posts on the Nikon forum are you referring to this time, as if there’s only one.
p.6 #3Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote:
You guys need to get your sense of humor back. That post was entirely tongue in cheek. Jeez, so sensitive. Time to get over it.
Your tongue is entirely poisonous and venomous. You get off from answering posts you have nothing to do with and get an even bigger hard on when you get replies. One sick puppy.
p.6 #4Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Vinnie_VdB wrote: 1bwana1 wroteYou guys need to get your sense of humor back. That post was entirely tongue in cheek. Jeez, so sensitive. Time to get over it.Your tongue is entirely poisonous and venomous. You get off from answering posts you have nothing to do with and get an even bigger hard on when you get replies. One sick puppy.
p.6 #5Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote: RoamingScott wroteA genius in his own mind, sadly. All those hobbies he claims to have, and yet he sits around Nikon forums with a persistent case of butthurt
It's a tired schtick from a tired ol poster that just can't let it go.Hey, I thought you hid me? Darn...
He doesn't have to see your most recent work to make that statement. Its been going on for years.
p.6 #6Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Vinnie_VdB wrote: 1bwana1 wroteYou guys need to get your sense of humor back. That post was entirely tongue in cheek. Jeez, so sensitive. Time to get over it.Your tongue is entirely poisonous and venomous. You get off from answering posts you have nothing to do with and get an even bigger hard on when you get replies. One sick puppy.
Seems to me that is exactly what you just did. There is a word for that you know.
p.6 #9Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
It was a good but limited video from Steve. I've discussed it with him a bit on the BCG forum thread.
Steve is very clear in the video that during the comparison to the A1 he was only testing this one part of the overall AF system. He had no available subjects to test BIF or other more challenging aspects to the AF.
I think the Z9 is certainly better now than the A1 at what is shown in the video. Even back when I owned it on 1.1 FW it was on par with the A1 for BEAF. It has been improved upon since then. I believe back when I reviewed the Z9 on 1.1 FW I said the Z9 was on par with the A1 and that the Canon R5 was still the best for BEAF. Not sure if the Z9 has now bested R5...would need to get one back in the hand to try that out.
I did give Steve some suggestions on how to get better results from the A1 in that gull test he did in the video. He is going to try that out next time. The short of it was to not use "Tracking" Wide and instead just use Wide. Tracking Wide is garbage when distractions like rippled water are present. With non-tracking Wide the results would have been closer to the Z9 but I think Z9 would still have been better.
I'm still waiting to get my hands on a Z9 with FW 4.1 to see if the Z9 has caught up to the BIF capabilities of the A1. That will probably have to wait till the Z8 FW comes out with Bird mode as I have a friend I could borrow a Z8 from and test but no one with a Z9.
p.6 #11Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Max Power wrote:
Man, a 70 year old troll on the internet.
Over a camera brand.
Momma would be proud.
Actually I am not the one brand sensitive here. You are. I like Sony, Nikon, and Leica for personal use. I don't use any others but have nothing but respect for all of them. The only place I see the weakness and vitriol you guys display is on Nikon forums. Even then it only the same few of you. Now that is what upsets Mothers.
You should see what the PMs think about your behaviour.
p.6 #12Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
I like all brands too. I just don't like constantly being bombarded by Sony content in a Nikon room. If any of us wanted that, we would go to the Sony room.
Put yourself in our shoes. How well would one of us be received over there if we engaged in the behavior you are exhibiting here year in year out?
You just get old, man. You don't have to defend and promote Sony at every turn in the Nikon room, even if some of us might be wrong every once in a while. Just let it go. Better yet, just go.
p.6 #13Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
molson wrote: Vinnie_VdB wroteEntirely poisonous and venomous.That pretty much sums up the Nikon Forum experience for anyone who admits they like some aspect of any other brand, doesn't it?
Any Fuji blow ups here? Any Canon blow ups here? Any Leica blow ups here? Any Sigma blow ups here? Any OM blow ups here?
p.6 #14Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Max Power wrote: molson wroteVinnie_VdB wroteEntirely poisonous and venomous.That pretty much sums up the Nikon Forum experience for anyone who admits they like some aspect of any other brand, doesn't it?Any Fuji blow ups here? Any Canon blow ups here? Any Leica blow ups here? Any Sigma blow ups here? Any OM blow ups here?
Negatory.
Selective blindness is another aspect of toxic delusion, I guess.
p.6 #15Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Folks I am going to try this one more time. The issue is content for me of the video and any other related claims. I own an A1, it is irrelevant if it is the best or not because that is what I have. Being the best or not gives me zero extra in the field when trying to get photos. That is all work and knowledge based and how we use the particular tools that we pick to get the job done. I am excited by the prospects of subject recognition and would not be surprised in any way that Nikon has pulled ahead. That is nothing but great for the market and us consumers. The 3 people that I shoot most often with shoot an R5, Z9 and A1. It is very rare that any of us walk away having missed a photo that we thought was the cameras fault and not our own. All of the makers are so close that it is very rarely even an issue.
That said to make a claim of superiority for me it has to be content based. Acquiring initial focus is only part of the story. Staying locked on is the other part. Accurate tracking, staying on the eye, not jumping to the closest wing and things like that all play a vital part in getting a photo. To assess those things I think you need to have done direct side by side comparisons with difficult subjects, not motionless birds. Others are free to disagree and take Steve at his word. That is your right as it is mine to have a different criteria to make that claim. Again for me I don't care which is better because I don't own both. But as I mentioned close friends do so I wish them nothing but the best that Nikon has to offer. But again making claims of superiority require side by side comparisons with difficult species in my book. For the last decade people have been taking killer shots of eagles and ospreys and slow moving herons with 7d's,1dx.s, d500's, d5's, d850's and so on. Those birds are easy in comparison to much smaller, faster and more elusive subjects. So when you claim one is better but your proof is from experience with easy birds once again I have a problem with the content.
It is important for me to understand all of the systems as I have clients who use them and I have people who ask me quite often what they should be buying. So please this is not me claiming Sony superiority in anything. I have not spent any time with the Z9 and newest firmware. I have zero basis to even make the claim and have it mean anything. And I also have zero motivation to make that claim as well. I have birded my whole life, seen thousands of species and photographed hundreds of species. That is relevant because the auto focus requirements for flying tiny and fast birds is quite different from ducks on the water or small songbirds in foliage or shorebirds running in water or owls at dusk.
If this is about the photos look at my Instagram and let the photos do the talking. I only say that because I have not posted photos on FM in years. There are photos with my 1dx, many with the d850 and many with the A1. I doubt you could tell which camera took which photo and I don't think it is important. Only that we use the cameras to our best ability to get the photos. There are maybe 175 species on there (I have not counted) and have loads I can and eventually will add. So when you talk to me about autofocus and your reference is a vulture in a tree or a woodpecker or something else and nothing difficult this is again a content issue and nothing else. If people take pride in owning the best that is great. I just want great photos with what I own and to have an understanding of what else is out there so I can help others when asked to.
I won't engage in any nikon vs sony bashing comments. I won't engage in any best vs worst or trolling comments. I'd love to hear from folks who have used both cameras side by side with the most recent firmware and has formed an educated decision with difficult species.
p.6 #16Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
arbitrage wrote:
It was a good but limited video from Steve. I've discussed it with him a bit on the BCG forum thread.
Steve is very clear in the video that during the comparison to the A1 he was only testing this one part of the overall AF system. He had no available subjects to test BIF or other more challenging aspects to the AF.
I think the Z9 is certainly better now than the A1 at what is shown in the video. Even back when I owned it on 1.1 FW it was on par with the A1 for BEAF. It has been improved upon since then. I believe back when I reviewed the Z9 on 1.1 FW I said the Z9 was on par with the A1 and that the Canon R5 was still the best for BEAF. Not sure if the Z9 has now bested R5...would need to get one back in the hand to try that out.
I did give Steve some suggestions on how to get better results from the A1 in that gull test he did in the video. He is going to try that out next time. The short of it was to not use "Tracking" Wide and instead just use Wide. Tracking Wide is garbage when distractions like rippled water are present. With non-tracking Wide the results would have been closer to the Z9 but I think Z9 would still have been better.
I'm still waiting to get my hands on a Z9 with FW 4.1 to see if the Z9 has caught up to the BIF capabilities of the A1. That will probably have to wait till the Z8 FW comes out with Bird mode as I have a friend I could borrow a Z8 from and test but no one with a Z9....Show more →
As always, clear, concise level and accurate. FM is lucky to have you. And nice catch on his use of tracking for the gull. I did not notice that which makes sense and is why I don't use tracking in zone or wide. I find it will often jump to water and stay on the water. It is always zone and wide with no tracking. Which is also why I would never have had that issue in the first place with the gull.
p.6 #18Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Max Power wrote:
Put yourself in our shoes. How well would one of us be received over there if we engaged in the behavior you are exhibiting here year in year out?
History shows that you would be well received, welcomed, and treated with respect. I am not the only one who posted sincerely and respectfully in this thread that was attacked by the gang. Neither of us was attacking Nikon in any way. Just posting honessting opinions. The brand stuff was started by the gang, not him, or me. If you will go back and read my first post in this thread it was 100% positive. Then you guys started with the brand bashing BS. His posts were only about the content of the video. He also never bashed Nikon. You guys just try to intimidate anyone who is not a full sycophant in their post.
FM belongs to everyone. Everyone is allowed to post their opinion anywhere they want as long as the are within the rules. You guys have no standing to demand otherwise or try to bully people the way you do. No one is trying to troll you. Just have sincere discussions about photographic technology. If that offends you don't respond, don't attack. You will see how nice discussion go when you do that.
p.6 #19Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Max Power wrote: molson wroteVinnie_VdB wroteEntirely poisonous and venomous.That pretty much sums up the Nikon Forum experience for anyone who admits they like some aspect of any other brand, doesn't it?Any Fuji blow ups here? Any Canon blow ups here? Any Leica blow ups here? Any Sigma blow ups here? Any OM blow ups here?
Negatory.
You guys seem to have a particular sensitivity to all things Sony.
p.6 #20Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
aboutthelight wrote:
Folks I am going to try this one more time. The issue is content for me of the video and any other related claims. I own an A1, it is irrelevant if it is the best or not because that is what I have. Being the best or not gives me zero extra in the field when trying to get photos. That is all work and knowledge based and how we use the particular tools that we pick to get the job done. I am excited by the prospects of subject recognition and would not be surprised in any way that Nikon has pulled ahead. That is nothing but great for the market and us consumers. The 3 people that I shoot most often with shoot an R5, Z9 and A1. It is very rare that any of us walk away having missed a photo that we thought was the cameras fault and not our own. All of the makers are so close that it is very rarely even an issue.
That said to make a claim of superiority for me it has to be content based. Acquiring initial focus is only part of the story. Staying locked on is the other part. Accurate tracking, staying on the eye, not jumping to the closest wing and things like that all play a vital part in getting a photo. To assess those things I think you need to have done direct side by side comparisons with difficult subjects, not motionless birds. Others are free to disagree and take Steve at his word. That is your right as it is mine to have a different criteria to make that claim. Again for me I don't care which is better because I don't own both. But as I mentioned close friends do so I wish them nothing but the best that Nikon has to offer. But again making claims of superiority require side by side comparisons with difficult species in my book. For the last decade people have been taking killer shots of eagles and ospreys and slow moving herons with 7d's,1dx.s, d500's, d5's, d850's and so on. Those birds are easy in comparison to much smaller, faster and more elusive subjects. So when you claim one is better but your proof is from experience with easy birds once again I have a problem with the content.
It is important for me to understand all of the systems as I have clients who use them and I have people who ask me quite often what they should be buying. So please this is not me claiming Sony superiority in anything. I have not spent any time with the Z9 and newest firmware. I have zero basis to even make the claim and have it mean anything. And I also have zero motivation to make that claim as well. I have birded my whole life, seen thousands of species and photographed hundreds of species. That is relevant because the auto focus requirements for flying tiny and fast birds is quite different from ducks on the water or small songbirds in foliage or shorebirds running in water or owls at dusk.
If this is about the photos look at my Instagram and let the photos do the talking. I only say that because I have not posted photos on FM in years. There are photos with my 1dx, many with the d850 and many with the A1. I doubt you could tell which camera took which photo and I don't think it is important. Only that we use the cameras to our best ability to get the photos. There are maybe 175 species on there (I have not counted) and have loads I can and eventually will add. So when you talk to me about autofocus and your reference is a vulture in a tree or a woodpecker or something else and nothing difficult this is again a content issue and nothing else. If people take pride in owning the best that is great. I just want great photos with what I own and to have an understanding of what else is out there so I can help others when asked to.
I won't engage in any nikon vs sony bashing comments. I won't engage in any best vs worst or trolling comments. I'd love to hear from folks who have used both cameras side by side with the most recent firmware and has formed an educated decision with difficult species. ...Show more →
And you guys thought it was appropriate to attack this guy for such posts. Shame on you for that!