fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?

  
 
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.6 #1Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
molson wrote:
It would just be nice if Nikon would put a higher resolution EVF in some of their cameras. The first thing I noticed with the Z9 was that there just isn't enough resolution for precision manual focusing while looking through the viewfinder. The EVF of the Sony A7R V, on the other hand, was a real epiphany the first time I used it with a Zeiss Loxia lens - the amount of detail was shockingly better.

Fortunately, Nikon has nicer rear LCD screens, so if the ambient light isn't too bright, they provide a useful alternative to the EVF for precision
...Show more →

I see no issue with the resolution of the Z9 EVF in general and when you have focus peaking on, that makes it stupid easy to nail focus manually.
Nov 03, 2023 at 08:36 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.6 #2Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
tzhang4284 wrote:
If I'm going to use Sony lenses, I might as well as use a Sony body - they're shaped the same and about the same size.


I have an adapter for my Sony bodies, but haven't used it in years now. No point as every lens I need/want is available in a native e-mount. They work perfectly, why complicate things.
Nov 03, 2023 at 08:40 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.6 #3Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
1bwana1 wrote:
bernardl wroteExactly.

Nikon Z lenses are all absolutely amazing, but any FE mount is now also part of the line up with excellent AF.

Btw far better AF that what Canon users used to experience with their EF lenses when then fled in mass to Sony mirrorless 7-8 years ago. And let's not forget that the ability to adapt EF mount lenses with reasonable AF was the #1 reason why Sony was able to gain high end market share so quickly.

So any Sony user dismissing adapters is simply forgetting the very origin of the alpha system. There would probably not have been an a1 at all had Canon EF lenses not been adaptable so well to FE mount. And to add another bit of history, there would have been to exmor mirrorless sensors had Nikon not funded through their DSRL sales most of the Sony Semi-conductor camera sensors R&D for years. That fact tends to be easily forgotten as well.

Cheers,
Bernard
But somehow Canon maintained its market share, Sony grew its market share hugely, and Nikon lost a huge amount of market share. That just doesn't reconcile well with your version of history.

Yes Canon lenses adapted better to Sony than Nikon lenses. This meant that the transition was easier for them. Nikon shooters ended up doing a complete swap right away. But proportionally I think more Nikon shooters probably switched than Canon shooters.

Sony's revenue from ICL cameras is small compared to its other markets. The DSLR + Mirrorless camera market is only 5.7 Million units a year, other sensor markets use
...Show more →

The main motivation of early switchers to mirrorless were the better Sony sensors. Second one was size.

There were way fewer reasons for Nikon FF DSLR owners to switch because the Nikon version of those sensors delivered at least the same level of performance as Sony bodies while still offering overall better AF until at least the a9.

The market share numbers you are referring to and use to defend your version of history are completely dominated by cheap apps-c bodies and tell us absolutely nothing about what happened among full frame users.

Cheers,
Bernard
Nov 03, 2023 at 09:51 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.6 #4Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Eric214 wrote:
molson wroteIt would just be nice if Nikon would put a higher resolution EVF in some of their cameras. The first thing I noticed with the Z9 was that there just isn't enough resolution for precision manual focusing while looking through the viewfinder. The EVF of the Sony A7R V, on the other hand, was a real epiphany the first time I used it with a Zeiss Loxia lens - the amount of detail was shockingly better.

Fortunately, Nikon has nicer rear LCD screens, so if the ambient light isn't too bright, they provide a useful alternative to the EVF for precision focusing.
I see no issue with the resolution of the Z9 EVF in general and when you have focus peaking on, that makes it stupid easy to nail focus manually.


The Z9 EVF is nice in general; the lack of resolution is only an issue when you want to see critical focus (without the annoyance of focus peaking, which only gives an approximation of precise focus). The difference between the Z9 EVF and that of the latest Sony cameras is like night and day for manual focusing, but I guess we're stuck with what Nikon is willing to give us.
Nov 03, 2023 at 10:21 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.6 #5Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
bernardl wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wroteExactly.

Nikon Z lenses are all absolutely amazing, but any FE mount is now also part of the line up with excellent AF.

Btw far better AF that what Canon users used to experience with their EF lenses when then fled in mass to Sony mirrorless 7-8 years ago. And let's not forget that the ability to adapt EF mount lenses with reasonable AF was the #1 reason why Sony was able to gain high end market share so quickly.

So any Sony user dismissing adapters is simply forgetting the very origin of the alpha system. There would probably not have been an a1 at all had Canon EF lenses not been adaptable so well to FE mount. And to add another bit of history, there would have been to exmor mirrorless sensors had Nikon not funded through their DSRL sales most of the Sony Semi-conductor camera sensors R&D for years. That fact tends to be easily forgotten as well.

Cheers,
Bernard
But somehow Canon maintained its market share, Sony grew its market share hugely, and Nikon lost a huge amount of market share. That just doesn't reconcile well with your version of history.

Yes Canon lenses adapted better to Sony than Nikon lenses. This meant that the transition was easier for them. Nikon shooters ended up doing a complete swap right away. But proportionally I think more Nikon shooters probably switched than Canon shooters.

Sony's revenue from ICL cameras is small compared to its other markets. The DSLR + Mirrorless camera market is only 5.7 Million units a year, other sensor markets use over 1.5 Billion units a year, amounting to TRillions of Yen a year. So the funding story also makes no sense.

But, by your logic Nikon continues to fund Sony sensor development as all of Nikon's mirrorless sensors are also Sony. The entire industry is grateful for that contribution.
The market share numbers you are referring to and use to defend your version of history are completely dominated by cheap apps-c bodies and tell us absolutely nothing about what happened among full frame users.

Cheers,
Bernard


Nonsense. Where did all the Nikon shooters go? The market share that props up Nikon's numbers are still to a large extent cheap DSLR shooters. If you just take ICL mirrorless cameras Nikon's market share numbers look even worse. Untill recently 4th or 5th place. In the sub 8% range.

https://petapixel.com/2021/03/03/nikon-only-has-7-5-share-of-the-mirrorless-market-report/

This is documented history. It has nothing to do with this thread. You brought it up, but best to move on.
Nov 03, 2023 at 10:23 PM
dcisive
Offline
Details
p.6 #6Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
molson wrote:
It would just be nice if Nikon would put a higher resolution EVF in some of their cameras. The first thing I noticed with the Z9 was that there just isn't enough resolution for precision manual focusing while looking through the viewfinder. The EVF of the Sony A7R V, on the other hand, was a real epiphany the first time I used it with a Zeiss Loxia lens - the amount of detail was shockingly better.

Fortunately, Nikon has nicer rear LCD screens, so if the ambient light isn't too bright, they provide a useful alternative to the EVF for precision
...Show more →

I had a A7RV and the moire of the EVF annoyed the crud out of me. Although I don't typically bother with manual focus in general, using that on a Z9 is a piece of cake and highly accurate with the Red sparklies it produces to aid in that.
Nov 04, 2023 at 12:10 AM
tzhang4284
Online
Details
p.6 #7Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
bernardl wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wroteExactly.

Nikon Z lenses are all absolutely amazing, but any FE mount is now also part of the line up with excellent AF.

Btw far better AF that what Canon users used to experience with their EF lenses when then fled in mass to Sony mirrorless 7-8 years ago. And let's not forget that the ability to adapt EF mount lenses with reasonable AF was the #1 reason why Sony was able to gain high end market share so quickly.

So any Sony user dismissing adapters is simply forgetting the very origin of the alpha system. There would probably not have been an a1 at all had Canon EF lenses not been adaptable so well to FE mount. And to add another bit of history, there would have been to exmor mirrorless sensors had Nikon not funded through their DSRL sales most of the Sony Semi-conductor camera sensors R&D for years. That fact tends to be easily forgotten as well.

Cheers,
Bernard
But somehow Canon maintained its market share, Sony grew its market share hugely, and Nikon lost a huge amount of market share. That just doesn't reconcile well with your version of history.

Yes Canon lenses adapted better to Sony than Nikon lenses. This meant that the transition was easier for them. Nikon shooters ended up doing a complete swap right away. But proportionally I think more Nikon shooters probably switched than Canon shooters.

Sony's revenue from ICL cameras is small compared to its other markets. The DSLR + Mirrorless camera market is only 5.7 Million units a year, other sensor markets use over 1.5 Billion units a year, amounting to TRillions of Yen a year. So the funding story also makes no sense.

But, by your logic Nikon continues to fund Sony sensor development as all of Nikon's mirrorless sensors are also Sony. The entire industry is grateful for that contribution.
The main motivation of early switchers to mirrorless were the better Sony sensors. Second one was size.

There were way fewer reasons for Nikon FF DSLR owners to switch because the Nikon version of those sensors delivered at least the same level of performance as Sony bodies while still offering overall better AF until at least the a9.

The market share numbers you are referring to and use to defend your version of history are completely dominated by cheap apps-c bodies and tell us absolutely nothing about what happened among full frame users.

Cheers,
Bernard


The last time I had a DSLR was actually a Nikon D7000. I upgraded from that to the Sony A7 II because it was significantly smaller than any Nikon DSLR and much cheaper than a D750 even with the inflated lens costs of the Zeiss 55mm f1.8. The sensor performance was really secondary to size as a value proposition and eventually the capabilities that mirrorless offered and also new fresh lens designs that were sharper than legacy DSLR ones.

During the last 10 years, you could've gotten the Sony A6000, A7, A7R and A7R II sensor via the Nikon D7100, D750, D810, and D850 yet market share for Nikon collapsed. They missed the boat - it was not an intentional grand strategy - Nikon is now less than half the size it used to be 10 years ago by market capitalization. They're doing a good job of recently digging themselves out of the hole but it was a deep hole - lots of missteps (nikon 1, tons of garbage volume DSLRs, canceling the DL point and shoots, not launching a full frame mirrorless camera 10 years ago) from the launch of the Sony A7 series to finally the launch of the Z9.
Nov 04, 2023 at 12:34 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.6 #8Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Guys, whatever makes you feel better...

The high end DSLR listed here never represented more than a few % of the volume.

Nikon owners didn't go anywhere, market share is about only about new sales and they are driven mostly by the level of discount/marketing/sales tactics on low end DSLR and low end mirrorless (mostly M mount for Canon).

Cheers,
Bernard
Nov 04, 2023 at 03:26 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.6 #9Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
bernardl wrote:
Guys, whatever makes you feel better...

The high end DSLR listed here never represented more than a few % of the volume.

Nikon owners didn't go anywhere, market share is about only about new sales and they are driven mostly by the level of discount/marketing/sales tactics on low end DSLR and low end mirrorless (mostly M mount for Canon).

Cheers,
Bernard


Things like these business discussions don't make me feel better or worse.
I currently have no skin in the game. Numbers are just numbers. They can't be rationalized away. Nikon's market share and market cap are hugely diminished. Not true of Sony and Canon. Even Leica grew tremendously recently having by far its best year ever this year. This also has no bearing on the quality of Nikon's current offerings, which are in some cases excellent.

Since anecdotal statements seem to resonate with you why not talk to some higher end Sony shooters. You will see that the vast majority came over from another brand. If they have been shooting more than 5 years it is almost guaranteed. Their high end Sony is not their first camera.

How many here who shoot an A7RIV. A7RV,A9II, A1 are first time camera buyers. Anyone?
Nov 04, 2023 at 04:37 AM
pietipe
Offline
Details
p.6 #10Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Just changed my Sony A1, 600/4 GM, 200-600 G, 1.4x, 2x to Nikon Z9, 800/6.3, 180-600, 1.4x. I got tired of Sony's non-existent FW updates. And those minor FW updates which have come, only worsened the accuracy of the A1 autofocus. Also the downside of the otherwise good lens 200-600 is, that it is nowhere near 600mm, at most 530mm. With 600/4 I normally used 1.4x so 800/6.3 replace that quite well. Of course lost 0.3EV but this is an insignificant loss. And EVF difference between A1 and Z9 is not as clear as the numbers suggest.
Nov 04, 2023 at 05:39 AM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.6 #11Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
molson wrote:
Eric214 wrote
molson wroteIt would just be nice if Nikon would put a higher resolution EVF in some of their cameras. The first thing I noticed with the Z9 was that there just isn't enough resolution for precision manual focusing while looking through the viewfinder. The EVF of the Sony A7R V, on the other hand, was a real epiphany the first time I used it with a Zeiss Loxia lens - the amount of detail was shockingly better.

Fortunately, Nikon has nicer rear LCD screens, so if the ambient light isn't too bright, they provide a useful alternative to the EVF for precision focusing.
I see no issue with the resolution of the Z9 EVF in general and when you have focus peaking on, that makes it stupid easy to nail focus manually.
The Z9 EVF is nice in general; the lack of resolution is only an issue when you want to see critical focus (without the annoyance of focus peaking, which only gives an approximation of precise focus). The difference between the Z9 EVF and that of the latest Sony cameras is like night and day for manual focusing, but I guess we're stuck with what Nikon is willing to give us.



Yes I'm aware and again have no issue with critical focus with focus peaking,
Nov 04, 2023 at 05:55 AM
akul
Offline
Details
p.6 #12Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
tzhang4284 wrote:
bernardl wrote
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wroteExactly.

Nikon Z lenses are all absolutely amazing, but any FE mount is now also part of the line up with excellent AF.

Btw far better AF that what Canon users used to experience with their EF lenses when then fled in mass to Sony mirrorless 7-8 years ago. And let's not forget that the ability to adapt EF mount lenses with reasonable AF was the #1 reason why Sony was able to gain high end market share so quickly.

So any Sony user dismissing adapters is simply forgetting the very origin of the alpha system. There would probably not have been an a1 at all had Canon EF lenses not been adaptable so well to FE mount. And to add another bit of history, there would have been to exmor mirrorless sensors had Nikon not funded through their DSRL sales most of the Sony Semi-conductor camera sensors R&D for years. That fact tends to be easily forgotten as well.

Cheers,
Bernard
But somehow Canon maintained its market share, Sony grew its market share hugely, and Nikon lost a huge amount of market share. That just doesn't reconcile well with your version of history.

Yes Canon lenses adapted better to Sony than Nikon lenses. This meant that the transition was easier for them. Nikon shooters ended up doing a complete swap right away. But proportionally I think more Nikon shooters probably switched than Canon shooters.

Sony's revenue from ICL cameras is small compared to its other markets. The DSLR + Mirrorless camera market is only 5.7 Million units a year, other sensor markets use over 1.5 Billion units a year, amounting to TRillions of Yen a year. So the funding story also makes no sense.

But, by your logic Nikon continues to fund Sony sensor development as all of Nikon's mirrorless sensors are also Sony. The entire industry is grateful for that contribution.
The main motivation of early switchers to mirrorless were the better Sony sensors. Second one was size.

There were way fewer reasons for Nikon FF DSLR owners to switch because the Nikon version of those sensors delivered at least the same level of performance as Sony bodies while still offering overall better AF until at least the a9.

The market share numbers you are referring to and use to defend your version of history are completely dominated by cheap apps-c bodies and tell us absolutely nothing about what happened among full frame users.

Cheers,
Bernard
The last time I had a DSLR was actually a Nikon D7000. I upgraded from that to the Sony A7 II because it was significantly smaller than any Nikon DSLR and much cheaper than a D750 even with the inflated lens costs of the Zeiss 55mm f1.8. The sensor performance was really secondary to size as a value proposition and eventually the capabilities that mirrorless offered and also new fresh lens designs that were sharper than legacy DSLR ones.

During the last 10 years, you could've gotten the Sony A6000, A7, A7R and A7R II sensor via the Nikon D7100, D750,
...Show more →

One other thing happened was Nikon kept wasting their resources on numerous PS cameras that could not even distinguish between the models for too long. Combined with the missed forecasts on the tidal wave towards mirrorless, with natural disasters in Japan,and flood in Thailand, COVID and subsequent supply problems etc. It is really a combination of human error, mismanagement,and natural disasters all played against Nikon. That is how I see it. I am glad they are digging themselves out of the hole.

Luka
Nov 04, 2023 at 07:11 AM
Jepser
Online
Details
p.6 #13Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
I have no (zero) problems manual focusing on either the Zfc or Zf, and I only use manual focus lenses. Have never tried any Sony though.
Nov 04, 2023 at 07:13 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.6 #14Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
dcisive wrote:
molson wroteIt would just be nice if Nikon would put a higher resolution EVF in some of their cameras. The first thing I noticed with the Z9 was that there just isn't enough resolution for precision manual focusing while looking through the viewfinder. The EVF of the Sony A7R V, on the other hand, was a real epiphany the first time I used it with a Zeiss Loxia lens - the amount of detail was shockingly better.

Fortunately, Nikon has nicer rear LCD screens, so if the ambient light isn't too bright, they provide a useful alternative to the EVF for precision focusing.
I had a A7RV and the moire of the EVF annoyed the crud out of me. Although I don't typically bother with manual focus in general, using that on a Z9 is a piece of cake and highly accurate with the Red sparklies it produces to aid in that.



I never saw any moire with my A7R V viewfinder - perhaps you had yours set up differently.

When I bought my second Z9, I sold all of my manual-focus lenses, so the low resolution finder is now a moot point. I imagine Nikon choose this EVF panel as a cost-saving measure on the Z8, but it's disappointing they made the same choice with their "flagship" mirrorless camera.
Nov 04, 2023 at 07:32 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.6 #15Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
pietipe wrote:
Also the downside of the otherwise good lens 200-600 is, that it is nowhere near 600mm, at most 530mm.



It's 545mm, actually - measured at 5m - and the focal length increases as the focus point moves towards infinity.

It's obviously still short of the advertised focal length, but the Sony cameras have enough extra resolution to make up for it with a very small crop.
Nov 04, 2023 at 07:39 AM
patotts
Offline
Details
p.6 #16Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
molson wrote:
dcisive wrote
molson wroteIt would just be nice if Nikon would put a higher resolution EVF in some of their cameras. The first thing I noticed with the Z9 was that there just isn't enough resolution for precision manual focusing while looking through the viewfinder. The EVF of the Sony A7R V, on the other hand, was a real epiphany the first time I used it with a Zeiss Loxia lens - the amount of detail was shockingly better.

Fortunately, Nikon has nicer rear LCD screens, so if the ambient light isn't too bright, they provide a useful alternative to the EVF for precision focusing.
I had a A7RV and the moire of the EVF annoyed the crud out of me. Although I don't typically bother with manual focus in general, using that on a Z9 is a piece of cake and highly accurate with the Red sparklies it produces to aid in that.
I never saw any moire with my A7R V viewfinder - perhaps you had yours set up differently.

When I bought my second Z9, I sold all of my manual-focus lenses, so the low resolution finder is now a moot point. I imagine Nikon choose this EVF panel as a cost-saving measure on the Z8, but it's disappointing they made the same choice with their "flagship" mirrorless camera.


This is the Nikon forum, so the vast majority of you won't care, but I guess it is good to know that while the Sony a7RV has a fantastic EVF of 9.4 mdot, but in reality, if you have the display setting set to high quality (for best results to review images in the EVF), the resolution drops when you engage the autofocus. It is pretty frustrating, actually. It feels a lot worse in low-light condition.
Nov 04, 2023 at 07:48 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.6 #17Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
patotts wrote:
molson wrote
dcisive wrote
molson wroteIt would just be nice if Nikon would put a higher resolution EVF in some of their cameras. The first thing I noticed with the Z9 was that there just isn't enough resolution for precision manual focusing while looking through the viewfinder. The EVF of the Sony A7R V, on the other hand, was a real epiphany the first time I used it with a Zeiss Loxia lens - the amount of detail was shockingly better.

Fortunately, Nikon has nicer rear LCD screens, so if the ambient light isn't too bright, they provide a useful alternative to the EVF for precision focusing.
I had a A7RV and the moire of the EVF annoyed the crud out of me. Although I don't typically bother with manual focus in general, using that on a Z9 is a piece of cake and highly accurate with the Red sparklies it produces to aid in that.
I never saw any moire with my A7R V viewfinder - perhaps you had yours set up differently.

When I bought my second Z9, I sold all of my manual-focus lenses, so the low resolution finder is now a moot point. I imagine Nikon choose this EVF panel as a cost-saving measure on the Z8, but it's disappointing they made the same choice with their "flagship" mirrorless camera.
If you have the 9.4 mdot EVF set to high display quality, it will drop in resolution when focusing. It feels a lot worse in low-light condition. It is pretty frustrating actually.


I never saw this claimed resolution drop using my Zeiss Loxia lenses. What does the resolution supposedly drop to - only twice as much as the Nikon EVF?
Nov 04, 2023 at 07:54 AM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.6 #18Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Agreed .. I too prefer the EVF on z8/z9 more than the "better on paper" EVF of a1/a7R5. That drop in resolution during focus makes the experience feel cheap.
Nov 04, 2023 at 07:56 AM
pietipe
Offline
Details
p.6 #19Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
molson wrote:
pietipe wroteAlso the downside of the otherwise good lens 200-600 is, that it is nowhere near 600mm, at most 530mm.
It's 545mm, actually - measured at 5m - and the focal length increases as the focus point moves towards infinity.

It's obviously still short of the advertised focal length, but the Sony cameras have enough extra resolution to make up for it with a very small crop.


It's quite big different if You put 180-600 and 200-600 side by side, take a picture and compare.
Nov 04, 2023 at 08:01 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.6 #20Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
pietipe wrote:
molson wrote
pietipe wroteAlso the downside of the otherwise good lens 200-600 is, that it is nowhere near 600mm, at most 530mm.
It's 545mm, actually - measured at 5m - and the focal length increases as the focus point moves towards infinity.

It's obviously still short of the advertised focal length, but the Sony cameras have enough extra resolution to make up for it with a very small crop.
It's quite big different if You put 180-600 and 200-600 side by side, take a picture and compare.


No, the facts don't change, whether I try the 180-600 or not...
Nov 04, 2023 at 08:10 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister