fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?

  
 
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
@Douglas L .. I still can't believe you bought the 600 TC and a Z body just for the convenience of the TC !!!
Man !!!
Nov 01, 2023 at 02:31 PM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.5 #2Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
saaketham wrote:
@Douglas L@ .. I still can't believe you bought the 600 TC and a Z body just for the convenience of the TC !!!
Man !!!


I know! It's crazy. I am having some second thoughts after I actually held the Z9 in my hand. I will play with it for 6 months to see how it goes. Maybe Sony will announce its 600 TC by then
Nov 01, 2023 at 02:41 PM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
Douglas L wrote:
saaketham wrote@Douglas L@@@ .. I still can't believe you bought the 600 TC and a Z body just for the convenience of the TC !!!
Man !!!
I know! It's crazy. I am having some second thoughts after I actually held the Z9 in my hand. I will play with it for 6 months to see how it goes. Maybe Sony will announce its 600 TC by then


Please post some images in the 600 TC Image Thread - would love to see how you use it
Nov 01, 2023 at 02:45 PM
Knut.
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
C_n_red_again wrote:
2 year old camera with replacements on the near horizon. No. It’s not increasing in value. Is it still the best all around camera on the market even at its pretty advanced age. Yes. Likely more a sign of the lackluster competition that Nikon and canon have provided but nonetheless the a1 is still the thoroughbred to beat.


What is the evidence that a replacement is on the horizon?

To my mind this is wishful thinking. The A1 is more likely at the zenith of of it‘s 4-5 year cycle and anyone in the market for the unique feature set of the A1 must decide if he needs it now, or in 2-3 years.

Looking at the replacement rates of comparable camera lines (A7s or A9) the gap between consecutive cameras easily comes close to 4-5 years. Such a spacing is not unique for a typical high end niche camera.

To my mind the A1 is still at it‘s prime for what it does. Of course other lines (A7r for example) have newer features that will eventually end up in the A1ii, but not now, and very likely not in the next year and a half.

Reasonable estimates would put the next A1 model some 4 or 5 years after the initial launch date.
(The camera market is declining and the improvements are no longer that big, there must be more than 1 or 2 things better in a new model for Sony to consider launching it …)

Edited on Nov 07, 2023 at 04:04 AM · View previous versions
Nov 07, 2023 at 03:23 AM
Knut.
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
jhapeman wrote:
I think a major firmware update is a pipe dream. … Also, the big new feature we are likely to see on any A9 or A1 update is the new AI-focusing technology, which requires a different chip, so that's not something you can do in firmware.


I agree that even a major firmware update is unlikely for Sony.

I nevertheless want to point out that even a hardware requirement does not necessarily limit the possibility of an update.
Pentax did this for the K1. For a limited time users were able to get an addditional chip installed into the K1 effectively morphing it into a K1ii (the costs were around 500€).

This is often much more about company policy than real technical limitations. Olympus, Fuji and Ricoh are much more open to customer service with firmware updates while Sony isn‘t even likely to remove obvious bugs.

Such alternative approaches are often influenced by how quickly a company thinks it can churn out new models / how many pieces of a certain model a company believes it will sell. If a complete redesign consumes more money than what they can make with the size of the batch they expect to sell, then firmware updates are an interesting and viable way to keep interest in a certain camera model high.

Sony is known for churning out many different models a year. They are not in the „firmware update“ camp…. (unfortunately)


(PS: I wonder how increasing resource limitations and awareness of the ecological impact will influence company decissions in the future).


Nov 07, 2023 at 04:03 AM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.5 #6Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
To me personally, the only FW "update" for the A1 that's worth anything to me is the fix for the EVF shutoff with the sun in my back in the first couple months after the launch. I didn't really care for other "updates", I am sure they are useful for others.
Nov 07, 2023 at 04:23 AM
sashasud
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
I am considering the same switch for the 600TC. Have full Sony system with a9s a1s and big telephoto. Dipping my toes with a Z8 and the 600 PF lens.. Will make a call after seeing g how that goes. Curious to hear how your experience has been so far. My z8 is on its way.

Douglas L wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
Douglas L wrote
RoamingScott wrote
Dave Sanders wrote
RoamingScott wroteThis discussion, along with prices, makes you really appreciate what Nikon was able to do with the Z8. No reason to have to pick speed or resolution and still comes in cheaper than the A9ii.

And yes, Sony is ALL ABOUT market segmentation. They withhold features from every camera they make to ensure you have to upgrade to a more expensive model to get it, even if the hardware supports it, or pay $6000 for a 2 year old camera. Very old school Canon.
Have you had a chance to get the Z8 in your hands yet? I know lots of folks think it's too big, but it's the one Nikon I'd love to check out. Ok, that's a total lie, I'd love to check out the Z9 too
Had the Z9 for a year, traded it for a Z8 at Z8 launch, and just traded the Z8 back for a Z9

In the end, it feels amazing in hand ergo wise, but it's still quite a bit larger than something like the A1. Packing it was still more cumbersome than it was easy. I figured if I was going to be annoyed every time I packed my gear, I should have the best camera instead of the 2nd best camera

I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.

I miss the size of Sony cameras...packing them into a 10L bag inside a backpack and hiking with them is a dream.
Scott, I just bought a Z9, I can tell you I hate that size, but I love the 600 TC's convenience so I will deal with it. It will never be a camera that I want to use to shoot anything other than birds and planes, I won't buy another Nikon lens to use with it. It's just stupid big and heavy, for me anyway. I carry my A1s around the world to shoot landscape, travel, cities... Can't imagine lugging a Z9 monster for that type of fun.
And I've dragged mine through deserts and the woods and everywhere inbetween and I'm still alive to talk about it

I take the X100v along with it for daytrip jaunt type documentation. The Z9 is simply too much for that, but at the end of the day, I was never grabbing my Alpha and a zoom because that was too big for my liking too for that job.
I guess we are all different. Today I put my A1 with the RRS L bracket next to the Z9, Even with the RRS bracket the A1 isn't as tall as the Z9 minus the battery grip. The A1 with the RRS L bracket fits my medium-sized hand PERFECTLY. I have never like huge cameras but I bought the Z9 to go with the 600 TC because of the new 4.10 FW which won't be available for the Z8 for some time. I need the new level of bird AF before the Z8 gets it. Funny how some folks
...Show more →
Nov 08, 2023 at 11:18 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.5 #8Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
sashasud wrote:
I am considering the same switch for the 600TC. Have full Sony system with a9s a1s and big telephoto. Dipping my toes with a Z8 and the 600 PF lens.. Will make a call after seeing g how that goes. Curious to hear how your experience has been so far. My z8 is on its way.

Douglas L wrote
RoamingScott wrote
Douglas L wrote
RoamingScott wrote
Dave Sanders wroteHave you had a chance to get the Z8 in your hands yet? I know lots of folks think it's too big, but it's the one Nikon I'd love to check out. Ok, that's a total lie, I'd love to check out the Z9 too
Had the Z9 for a year, traded it for a Z8 at Z8 launch, and just traded the Z8 back for a Z9

In the end, it feels amazing in hand ergo wise, but it's still quite a bit larger than something like the A1. Packing it was still more cumbersome than it was easy. I figured if I was going to be annoyed every time I packed my gear, I should have the best camera instead of the 2nd best camera

I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.

I miss the size of Sony cameras...packing them into a 10L bag inside a backpack and hiking with them is a dream.
Scott, I just bought a Z9, I can tell you I hate that size, but I love the 600 TC's convenience so I will deal with it. It will never be a camera that I want to use to shoot anything other than birds and planes, I won't buy another Nikon lens to use with it. It's just stupid big and heavy, for me anyway. I carry my A1s around the world to shoot landscape, travel, cities... Can't imagine lugging a Z9 monster for that type of fun.
And I've dragged mine through deserts and the woods and everywhere inbetween and I'm still alive to talk about it

I take the X100v along with it for daytrip jaunt type documentation. The Z9 is simply too much for that, but at the end of the day, I was never grabbing my Alpha and a zoom because that was too big for my liking too for that job.
I guess we are all different. Today I put my A1 with the RRS L bracket next to the Z9, Even with the RRS bracket the A1 isn't as tall as the Z9 minus the battery grip. The A1 with the RRS L bracket fits my medium-sized hand PERFECTLY. I have never like huge cameras but I bought the Z9 to go with the 600 TC because of the new 4.10 FW which won't be available for the Z8 for some time. I need the new level of bird AF before the Z8 gets it. Funny how some folks said a long time ago that the Z9's AF was as good as the A1's and now after the new FW they say it's as good as the A1's. . I may swap the Z9 for a Z8 when the new AF FW gets filtered to the Z8. I have a built-in distain to built-in grip. I can't imagine lugging this beast to shoot landscape and travel. Just packing it is a hassle for me already. My hat off to you for lugging this beast around. But I do think the Z9 and the Z8 are giving Sony a run for the money. But in my case, it's not the Z9 or Z8, it's the 600 TC.

Added: Just took some pictures of the A1 with RRS L bracket vs the Z9


As you go into it, know that Bird AF specifically will improve significantly next year on the Z8. Look at any Z9 FW 4.1 review on youtube to see what's coming for the Z8.
Nov 08, 2023 at 11:19 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
The Z8 will almost match the 2 year old A1 with the firmware upgrade, still probably way behind the A9III.
Nov 08, 2023 at 11:24 AM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
sashasud wrote:
I am considering the same switch for the 600TC. Have full Sony system with a9s a1s and big telephoto. Dipping my toes with a Z8 and the 600 PF lens.


If you were my friend, I'd strongly discourage you.
z8 AF is not good, especially for fast action.
z9 is better, but it's also about 10x the size of the awesome a1, which works and works without any fuss.
Just 1 thing - don't update the a1 firmware - Sony seems to be degrading it with each FW.
I am still 2 FW versions behind and have no issues with mine.
Nov 08, 2023 at 12:28 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister