p.3 #1Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
RoamingScott wrote: jhapeman wroteRoamingScott wrotejhapeman wroteRoamingScott wroteBoth the A9 and A9ii launched at $4500 US. The Z8 ~simply existing~ this time around will prevent them from launching the A9iii for more than $4500 unless it has some killer new feature, which...highly doubtful. Sony will save that for the A1ii.
The market will not bear more than $6500 for the A1ii based on the ramped up competition from the other 2 sides now. The A1 is terribly overpriced there now, not that anyone is actually paying that.
The market analysis seems very straightforward to me here They seem to have sold bucketloads at $6500 and they have *never* priced their cameras based on what competitors are charging. Nikon *has* to charge less as they are struggling with market share loss. Sony has no such problem.You do realize that between EDU and dealer specials, few are ACTUALLY paying $6500, though...right? Either way, when you google a camera and see the MSRP...that number has to make some sort of sense in the market.You really think everyone is buying them with EDU and dealer special discounts? Absolutely not. Look at what B&H and Adorama and the big places are selling them for. That's the market price. Some small fraction get those discounts, yes, but that is absolutely the exception and not the norm.You clearly want the A1ii so badly that it's clouding your critical thinking but that's ok. Hopefully for your sake Sony abandons their well defined business model for this one camera that you want so very badly
p.3 #2Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
Alright guys stop being ridiculous with this A1ii vs A9iii talk.
Obviously Sony is going to announce the new 50mm f/1.3 lens to slot perfectly between the current 50 f/1.2 and the 50 f/1.4 lenses. It's a pretty glaring hole in the lens line up to be honest and I can't believe it hasn't been filled sooner.
p.3 #3Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
formula4speed wrote:
Alright guys stop being ridiculous with this A1ii vs A9iii talk.
Obviously Sony is going to announce the new 50mm f/1.3 lens to slot perfectly between the current 50 f/1.2 and the 50 f/1.4 lenses. It's a pretty glaring hole in the lens line up to be honest and I can't believe it hasn't been filled sooner.
p.3 #4Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
So all quibbling aside here's a thought:
Could the A9III come out as the first mirrorless camera with a global shutter? That would be a great reason for it to be released and precede an updated A1 release. It would be a new technology, easier to prove out and work out on a smaller pixel count first. Crazy fast.
It would certainly steal any thunder from the Canon R1 which is rumored to have a 2024 release and global shutter.
Now *that* would be a very interesting camera indeed.
p.3 #5Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
RoamingScott wrote: Dave Sanders wroteRoamingScott wroteThis discussion, along with prices, makes you really appreciate what Nikon was able to do with the Z8. No reason to have to pick speed or resolution and still comes in cheaper than the A9ii.
And yes, Sony is ALL ABOUT market segmentation. They withhold features from every camera they make to ensure you have to upgrade to a more expensive model to get it, even if the hardware supports it, or pay $6000 for a 2 year old camera. Very old school Canon.Have you had a chance to get the Z8 in your hands yet? I know lots of folks think it's too big, but it's the one Nikon I'd love to check out. Ok, that's a total lie, I'd love to check out the Z9 too Had the Z9 for a year, traded it for a Z8 at Z8 launch, and just traded the Z8 back for a Z9
In the end, it feels amazing in hand ergo wise, but it's still quite a bit larger than something like the A1. Packing it was still more cumbersome than it was easy. I figured if I was going to be annoyed every time I packed my gear, I should have the best camera instead of the 2nd best camera
I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.
I miss the size of Sony cameras...packing them into a 10L bag inside a backpack and hiking with them is a dream....Show more →
Scott, I just bought a Z9, I can tell you I hate that size, but I love the 600 TC's convenience so I will deal with it. It will never be a camera that I want to use to shoot anything other than birds and planes, I won't buy another Nikon lens to use with it. It's just stupid big and heavy, for me anyway. I carry my A1s around the world to shoot landscape, travel, cities... Can't imagine lugging a Z9 monster for that type of fun.
Oct 30, 2023 at 01:11 PM
berimbolo
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.3 #6Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
I have recently considered switching to a Z9 (Z8 is unsuitable for my needs for a variety of reasons). But the size is prohibitive for me. Many small planes have 12-15kg limits on what you can carry with you, which means I dont have too much extra weight to play with.
p.3 #7Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
berimbolo wrote:
I have recently considered switching to a Z9 (Z8 is unsuitable for my needs for a variety of reasons). But the size is prohibitive for me. Many small planes have 12-15kg limits on what you can carry with you, which means I dont have too much extra weight to play with.
I’ve been on multiple planes with a 7kg carryon limit.
Oct 30, 2023 at 02:02 PM
berimbolo
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.3 #8Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
chez wrote: berimbolo wroteI have recently considered switching to a Z9 (Z8 is unsuitable for my needs for a variety of reasons). But the size is prohibitive for me. Many small planes have 12-15kg limits on what you can carry with you, which means I dont have too much extra weight to play with.I’ve been on multiple planes with a 7kg carryon limit.
Im not even sure if that's enough for 2 Z9s, 600 or 400mm primes and 1 shorter lens
p.3 #9Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
jhapeman wrote:
So all quibbling aside here's a thought:
Could the A9III come out as the first mirrorless camera with a global shutter? That would be a great reason for it to be released and precede an updated A1 release. It would be a new technology, easier to prove out and work out on a smaller pixel count first. Crazy fast.
It would certainly steal any thunder from the Canon R1 which is rumored to have a 2024 release and global shutter.
Now *that* would be a very interesting camera indeed.
Global Shutter became a hype word for some time now, so I don't think it will be a revolutionary approach, just a very fast sensor that will be marketed as kinda Global Shutter. Now, I do expect pro-capture, but no MF aids improvements ever...
p.3 #10Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
RoamingScott wrote: Dave Sanders wroteRoamingScott wroteThis discussion, along with prices, makes you really appreciate what Nikon was able to do with the Z8. No reason to have to pick speed or resolution and still comes in cheaper than the A9ii.
And yes, Sony is ALL ABOUT market segmentation. They withhold features from every camera they make to ensure you have to upgrade to a more expensive model to get it, even if the hardware supports it, or pay $6000 for a 2 year old camera. Very old school Canon.Have you had a chance to get the Z8 in your hands yet? I know lots of folks think it's too big, but it's the one Nikon I'd love to check out. Ok, that's a total lie, I'd love to check out the Z9 too Had the Z9 for a year, traded it for a Z8 at Z8 launch, and just traded the Z8 back for a Z9
In the end, it feels amazing in hand ergo wise, but it's still quite a bit larger than something like the A1. Packing it was still more cumbersome than it was easy. I figured if I was going to be annoyed every time I packed my gear, I should have the best camera instead of the 2nd best camera
I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.
I miss the size of Sony cameras...packing them into a 10L bag inside a backpack and hiking with them is a dream....Show more →
Dammit, this is not what you were supposed to say
While I loved my D810, the D2/3/4 were and are my all time favourite cameras for feel in the hand and ergonomics. Loved!
My thoughts on the D700 v. D3 were similar to your thoughts on the Z8 v. Z9...I was never convinced that the extra weight and size was enough extra to cancel out how much I preferred the feel and handling.
Your thoughts on the build and feel of the Z8 are interesting...I guess Nikon really overbuilt the Z9, just like they used to do to their DSLR flagships, and did less with the Z8.
I'm still happy with my A7RII, so dreaming of an RV or a Z9 is a very expensive pipe dream, really
Oct 30, 2023 at 04:30 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.3 #11Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
Dave Sanders wrote: RoamingScott wroteDave Sanders wroteRoamingScott wroteThis discussion, along with prices, makes you really appreciate what Nikon was able to do with the Z8. No reason to have to pick speed or resolution and still comes in cheaper than the A9ii.
And yes, Sony is ALL ABOUT market segmentation. They withhold features from every camera they make to ensure you have to upgrade to a more expensive model to get it, even if the hardware supports it, or pay $6000 for a 2 year old camera. Very old school Canon.Have you had a chance to get the Z8 in your hands yet? I know lots of folks think it's too big, but it's the one Nikon I'd love to check out. Ok, that's a total lie, I'd love to check out the Z9 too Had the Z9 for a year, traded it for a Z8 at Z8 launch, and just traded the Z8 back for a Z9
In the end, it feels amazing in hand ergo wise, but it's still quite a bit larger than something like the A1. Packing it was still more cumbersome than it was easy. I figured if I was going to be annoyed every time I packed my gear, I should have the best camera instead of the 2nd best camera
I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.
I miss the size of Sony cameras...packing them into a 10L bag inside a backpack and hiking with them is a dream.Dammit, this is not what you were supposed to say
While I loved my D810, the D2/3/4 were and are my all time favourite cameras for feel in the hand and ergonomics. Loved!
My thoughts on the D700 v. D3 were similar to your thoughts on the Z8 v. Z9...I was never convinced that the extra weight and size was enough extra to cancel out how much I preferred the feel and handling.
Your thoughts on the build and feel of the Z8 are interesting...I guess Nikon really overbuilt the Z9, just like they used to do to their DSLR flagships, and did less with the Z8.
I'm still happy with my A7RII, so dreaming of an RV or a Z9 is a very expensive pipe dream, really ...Show more →
I suppose it's fair to say that if I had not used the Z9 for a year prior to the Z8, and had instead stuck with my original Z7ii, the Z8 would have felt like an upgrade in every way.
That said...I knew too much and couldn't unknow it, so now I'm cursed to roam the lands with the Z9 brick in my hands.
Many have said the Z8 feels very much like the D810/D850 so if you liked those, you're in for a treat.
One thing no one really talks about are the illuminated buttons...an excellent feature to have in a camera in the Z8's price point. And once you get used to the literally bottomless buffer that CFE-B provides with HE* files, you'll find yourself coming home with 2000 pictures to sort through, so both a blessing and a curse.
p.3 #12Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
berimbolo wrote: chez wroteberimbolo wroteI have recently considered switching to a Z9 (Z8 is unsuitable for my needs for a variety of reasons). But the size is prohibitive for me. Many small planes have 12-15kg limits on what you can carry with you, which means I dont have too much extra weight to play with.I’ve been on multiple planes with a 7kg carryon limit.Im not even sure if that's enough for 2 Z9s, 600 or 400mm primes and 1 shorter lens
Nikon does give your the option of some very good, light-weight telephoto primes, which offsets the weight savings of the Sony camera bodies... but there's no getting around the fact that the Z9 is a ponderous beast.
p.3 #13Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
Hmm... announcing the A9III and a 'Major' firmware to the A1? That would seem to indicate Sony is positioning itself to maintain the current A1 in the short haul while introducing a A9III with some improvements. I highly doubt Sony would introduce changes to the A9 that might detract sales away the their A1 market segment. Regardless, we will all know what's happening in a couple more days.
p.3 #14Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
schlotz wrote:
Hmm... announcing the A9III and a 'Major' firmware to the A1? That would seem to indicate Sony is positioning itself to maintain the current A1 in the short haul while introducing a A9III with some improvements. I highly doubt Sony would introduce changes to the A9 that might detract sales away the their A1 market segment. Regardless, we will all know what's happening in a couple more days.
I think a major firmware update is a pipe dream. The A9 update was an anomaly and won't be repeated IMO, same with the early A7 series updates. Sony was feeling out the market back then and agressively working to grab market share. Things are different now. Also, the big new feature we are likely to see on any A9 or A1 update is the new AI-focusing technology, which requires a different chip, so that's not something you can do in firmware. At best it will another lame firmware update to enable the "Creators" app junk.
I went back and looked at the releases and on the "flagship" cameras--like the A7R and A9, the releases have been very evenly spaced out over approximately 2-3 year windows. Remember, everyone thought the A1 was going to be the A9III back in 2021, because it had been like this: A9 (2017), A9II (2019), then ooops, A1 (2021).
The only other cameras that have stretched longer than the 24-30 month window in the last 8 years have been niche cameras like the A7 and A7S series: 44 months between the A7III and A7IV and 58 months between the A7SII and A7SIII. Even then it's quite likely the pandemic caused a delay in the A7IV. I suspect that's also why they dribbled out an A7RIVa in 2021 only to have the new A7RV come out in only 18 months later.
If they do release a new A9III I will be surprised. The cadence of releases would imply it won't happen IMO but if it does I also would expect the A1 to be updated very soon as well if not at the same event. It's been 34 months since it was released, and that's a relatively long period on the top of the line/top dollar cameras. On top of that, the Olympics are coming and there a ton of current sports shooters using A1's that would no doubt want any new AI features baked into a hypothetical A9II but would also still want the extra megapixels of the A1.
p.3 #15Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
RoamingScott wrote:
I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.
p.3 #16Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
Much as I'd love a nice firmware update for the A1 I'm perfectly happy with the camera as it is. And the A93 will no doubt be a nice update to that sports/PJ focused camera that will have features the A1 doesn't, but then that's the nature of tech these days -- products tend to leapfrog each other based on release dates. And to the OP's question, I've never known firmware affecting resale value of a camera.
For the A9 update I'm expecting 24MP (higher MP is wishful thinking IMO), very fast stills framerate, the best anti-flicker capabilities, the A7R5's AI focusing chip, and some sort of pre-shot capability -- ie. all features that'll make a PJ or sports photog's job easier. And it'll hopefully be the same price as the A92 release price. And then in a year or so when the next A1 comes out I expect it to get all that and probably more (focus stacking, perhaps?) with its 50MP sensor. And then all the A93 and A7R5 folks will be bent out of shape awaiting their firmware updates!
p.3 #17Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
After all these years in the market the A1 is still the camera that all the others are benchmarked against. That says a lot about how far ahead it was on release. I am still very happy with mine. If we get some new things it is an appreciated extra.
p.3 #18Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
I'm getting a little gassy re: the AI trained autofocus. My buddy's A7R V is pretty cool to shoot but I really don't want to give up the stacked sensor goodness.
Considering selling my backup A9 II and replacing with the RV since used ones are dropping in price now. First world problem, I guess.
And while I'd welcome some enhancements to the A1 - there's pretty much a zero percent chance the resale value goes up via firmware.
IMO it remains about as good a camera as you can buy to this day. Nikon mad a strong move with the Z9/Z8 and I'm sure the inevitable Canon R1 will be a beast but yeah - still loving the A1.
p.3 #19Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
jhapeman wrote:
I think a major firmware update is a pipe dream. The A9 update was an anomaly and won't be repeated IMO, same with the early A7 series updates. Sony was feeling out the market back then and agressively working to grab market share. Things are different now. Also, the big new feature we are likely to see on any A9 or A1 update is the new AI-focusing technology, which requires a different chip, so that's not something you can do in firmware. At best it will another lame firmware update to enable the "Creators" app j
Hard to argue with your logic Jeff, and everything Sony has done so far points in that direction. Yeah, as soon as ya think ya got a camera company pegged, they'll take hard a right or left turn.
p.3 #20Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
I think the Ai AF is probably even better, but honestly my A1 almost never misses focus now. It will be something else that inspires me to upgrade, but I honestly can't think of what that would be except maybe increased dynamic range, pre shot, in camera focus stacking, or a big leap in IBIS.