fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?

  
 
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #1Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
Douglas L wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
Dave Sanders wrote
RoamingScott wroteThis discussion, along with prices, makes you really appreciate what Nikon was able to do with the Z8. No reason to have to pick speed or resolution and still comes in cheaper than the A9ii.

And yes, Sony is ALL ABOUT market segmentation. They withhold features from every camera they make to ensure you have to upgrade to a more expensive model to get it, even if the hardware supports it, or pay $6000 for a 2 year old camera. Very old school Canon.
Have you had a chance to get the Z8 in your hands yet? I know lots of folks think it's too big, but it's the one Nikon I'd love to check out. Ok, that's a total lie, I'd love to check out the Z9 too
Had the Z9 for a year, traded it for a Z8 at Z8 launch, and just traded the Z8 back for a Z9

In the end, it feels amazing in hand ergo wise, but it's still quite a bit larger than something like the A1. Packing it was still more cumbersome than it was easy. I figured if I was going to be annoyed every time I packed my gear, I should have the best camera instead of the 2nd best camera

I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.

I miss the size of Sony cameras...packing them into a 10L bag inside a backpack and hiking with them is a dream.
Scott, I just bought a Z9, I can tell you I hate that size, but I love the 600 TC's convenience so I will deal with it. It will never be a camera that I want to use to shoot anything other than birds and planes, I won't buy another Nikon lens to use with it. It's just stupid big and heavy, for me anyway. I carry my A1s around the world to shoot landscape, travel, cities... Can't imagine lugging a Z9 monster for that type of fun.


And I've dragged mine through deserts and the woods and everywhere inbetween and I'm still alive to talk about it

I take the X100v along with it for daytrip jaunt type documentation. The Z9 is simply too much for that, but at the end of the day, I was never grabbing my Alpha and a zoom because that was too big for my liking too for that job.
Oct 31, 2023 at 03:21 PM
k-h.a.w
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
1bwana1 wrote:
I think the Ai AF is probably even better, but honestly my A1 almost never misses focus now. It will be something else that inspires me to upgrade, but I honestly can't think of what that would be except maybe increased dynamic range, pre shot, in camera focus stacking, or a big leap in IBIS.


+1!

K-H.
Oct 31, 2023 at 03:56 PM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.4 #3Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
RoamingScott wrote:
Douglas L wrote
RoamingScott wrote
Dave Sanders wrote
RoamingScott wroteThis discussion, along with prices, makes you really appreciate what Nikon was able to do with the Z8. No reason to have to pick speed or resolution and still comes in cheaper than the A9ii.

And yes, Sony is ALL ABOUT market segmentation. They withhold features from every camera they make to ensure you have to upgrade to a more expensive model to get it, even if the hardware supports it, or pay $6000 for a 2 year old camera. Very old school Canon.
Have you had a chance to get the Z8 in your hands yet? I know lots of folks think it's too big, but it's the one Nikon I'd love to check out. Ok, that's a total lie, I'd love to check out the Z9 too
Had the Z9 for a year, traded it for a Z8 at Z8 launch, and just traded the Z8 back for a Z9

In the end, it feels amazing in hand ergo wise, but it's still quite a bit larger than something like the A1. Packing it was still more cumbersome than it was easy. I figured if I was going to be annoyed every time I packed my gear, I should have the best camera instead of the 2nd best camera

I also thought the Z8 build quality felt suspect and left much to be desired. The Z9 is better in every way in that aspect, feels like a military grade piece of equipment compared.

I miss the size of Sony cameras...packing them into a 10L bag inside a backpack and hiking with them is a dream.
Scott, I just bought a Z9, I can tell you I hate that size, but I love the 600 TC's convenience so I will deal with it. It will never be a camera that I want to use to shoot anything other than birds and planes, I won't buy another Nikon lens to use with it. It's just stupid big and heavy, for me anyway. I carry my A1s around the world to shoot landscape, travel, cities... Can't imagine lugging a Z9 monster for that type of fun.
And I've dragged mine through deserts and the woods and everywhere inbetween and I'm still alive to talk about it

I take the X100v along with it for daytrip jaunt type documentation. The Z9 is simply too much for that, but at the end of the day, I was never grabbing my Alpha and a zoom because that was too big for my liking too for that job.


I guess we are all different. Today I put my A1 with the RRS L bracket next to the Z9, Even with the RRS bracket the A1 isn't as tall as the Z9 minus the battery grip. The A1 with the RRS L bracket fits my medium-sized hand PERFECTLY. I have never like huge cameras but I bought the Z9 to go with the 600 TC because of the new 4.10 FW which won't be available for the Z8 for some time. I need the new level of bird AF before the Z8 gets it. Funny how some folks said a long time ago that the Z9's AF was as good as the A1's and now after the new FW they say it's as good as the A1's. . I may swap the Z9 for a Z8 when the new AF FW gets filtered to the Z8. I have a built-in distain to built-in grip. I can't imagine lugging this beast to shoot landscape and travel. Just packing it is a hassle for me already. My hat off to you for lugging this beast around. But I do think the Z9 and the Z8 are giving Sony a run for the money. But in my case, it's not the Z9 or Z8, it's the 600 TC.

Added: Just took some pictures of the A1 with RRS L bracket vs the Z9





















Edited on Oct 31, 2023 at 07:38 PM · View previous versions
Oct 31, 2023 at 05:33 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
I just went for a photowalk with a group and the Leica rep who was loaning out cameras and lenses. There were a few people who brought their own gear as well. Mostly Sony stuff so it didn't look that different. But one had a Z9 and a 50mm Nikon. He looked positively comical with that huge thing hanging around his neck. It was also interesting to see the reaction of the people as we were mostly street style shooting. Largely very positive a curious about the Leicas, very intimidated and put off by the Z9 kit. It is so large I bet even the birds don't like having their picture taken by it. (don't freak out, that was just a joke).
Oct 31, 2023 at 06:05 PM
C_n_red_again
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
2 year old camera with replacements on the near horizon. No. It’s not increasing in value. Is it still the best all around camera on the market even at its pretty advanced age. Yes. Likely more a sign of the lackluster competition that Nikon and canon have provided but nonetheless the a1 is still the thoroughbred to beat.
Oct 31, 2023 at 06:16 PM
jhapeman
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
wordfool wrote:
Much as I'd love a nice firmware update for the A1 I'm perfectly happy with the camera as it is. And the A93 will no doubt be a nice update to that sports/PJ focused camera that will have features the A1 doesn't, but then that's the nature of tech these days -- products tend to leapfrog each other based on release dates. And to the OP's question, I've never known firmware affecting resale value of a camera.

For the A9 update I'm expecting 24MP (higher MP is wishful thinking IMO), very fast stills framerate, the best anti-flicker capabilities, the A7R5's
...Show more →

This IMO is the most likely scenario for an A9III if they introduce it. To keep the price at the same point it would make sense to just re-use the same sensor it has now, but with faster Bionz processor, updated IBIS and AI chip from the A7RV. Maybe add some of that re-click jpg capture from the Nikon world, updated WiFi, new CFe cards. But it seems highly unlikely to see a new sensor design.

BTW, for those who haven't used it, that AI focus on the A7RV is really, really nice. I drool thinking about that on an A1 successor. I just couldn't take the VF blackout after using the A9II and A1 for years, so I quickly sold my A7RV, but I was very, very impressed. Now that they've had a year to improve it, I am sure whatever version we see in a new camera will be even better.
Oct 31, 2023 at 07:52 PM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
The other night I parked my Ferrari next to my plane and went for a run with my $8000 Leica with the $7000 fixed focal length f/9 lens in one hand and my z8 in the other. Muggers started chasing me. They eventually caught up to me. They yanked the z8 and ran away. I now only have my Leica gear to shoot walls with. 😩😩😩😩
Nov 01, 2023 at 04:05 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?

saaketham wrote:
The other night I parked my Ferrari next to my plane and went for a run with my $8000 Leica with the $7000 fixed focal length f/9 lens in one hand and my z8 in the other. Muggers started chasing me. They eventually caught up to me. They yanked the z8 and ran away. I now only have my Leica gear to shoot walls with. 😩😩😩😩


Low hanging fruit is my guess. As they tried to grab stuff the lugs instantly pulled out of the Z8 but not the Leica. So they quickly ran away with it. It is a Z8 saftey feature so you won't get hurt in such circumstances.
Nov 01, 2023 at 05:25 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
You lot really need to stop camera shaming if you expect me to take your opinions seriously. I see cameras all the time in various professional settings. I don't give a single crap about the size of a persons camera or lenses as long as they get the job done with them.
1bwana1 wrote:
I just went for a photowalk with a group and the Leica rep who was loaning out cameras and lenses. There were a few people who brought their own gear as well. Mostly Sony stuff so it didn't look that different. But one had a Z9 and a 50mm Nikon. He looked positively comical with that huge thing hanging around his neck. It was also interesting to see the reaction of the people as we were mostly street style shooting. Largely very positive a curious about the Leicas, very intimidated and put off by the Z9 kit. It is so
...Show more →

Nov 01, 2023 at 07:56 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #10Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
Douglas L wrote:
Added: Just took some pictures of the A1 with RRS L bracket vs the Z9


And yet, despite its size, I find the Z9 balances better and feels better in hand with a 100-400 attached than the Sony did, even with a grip extension/bottom plate. Being one of my most used lenses, the Z9 suddenly started making more sense as a primary camera. I suppose if you shoot a 600/4, it doesn't really matter which body is hanging off the back, since you're rarely handholding at that point.

No question the Sony is the better size for small primes or smaller zooms.
Nov 01, 2023 at 08:08 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
JadedWriter wrote:
You lot really need to stop camera shaming if you expect me to take your opinions seriously. I see cameras all the time in various professional settings. I don't give a single crap about the size of a persons camera or lenses as long as they get the job done with them.
1bwana1 wroteI just went for a photowalk with a group and the Leica rep who was loaning out cameras and lenses. There were a few people who brought their own gear as well. Mostly Sony stuff so it didn't look that different. But one had a Z9 and a 50mm Nikon. He looked positively comical with that huge thing hanging around his neck. It was also interesting to see the reaction of the people as we were mostly street style shooting. Largely very positive a curious about the Leicas, very intimidated and put off by the Z9 kit. It is so large I bet even the birds don't like having their picture taken by it. (don't freak out, that was just a joke).


The guy with the Z9 and I are good friends and we joke about such things with good humor. He has some really good Sony size zingers in his arsenal. He is a pro in a certain type of sport shooting, and works part time at a camera store. We have no conflict about this. He absolutely prefers the larger size as do others I know. I fully understand that and agree everyone should shoot what works for them. But in a Group of Leica M and Q shooters the size differences really stood out. We both found humor in that.

We were out walking and street shooting. I think even you may agree that this is not the enviornment the Z9 was designed for.

I think my Leica M11 and 35mm Summilux would look equaly out of place on a tripod in the phitographer lineup trying to shoot flying Eagles at the dam. I am sure there would be be some humor in that too.

A little humor in our pursuits and choices is a good thing. I ended up loaning him my M10-P and a tiny 28mm Voigtlander. He loved the experience and is now looking at getting a Nikon Fz or Leica Q3 for future events like this.

I was not shaming, just commenting on a real life occurrence. You will notice that I posted in the comment that I was joking. Just as I was joking in my response to the Ferrari post that was also made tongue in cheek. In neither of these posts was I trying to have you or anyone else take them seriously. Why so sensitive? I don't get that at all.

Nov 01, 2023 at 08:43 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
I'll get back to answering the posted question . Firmware will not increase any value per se. What it may do is owners that have them hold onto them longer if the firmware proves to be of value. It could also help make someone's buying decision a better option with it. If it adds value in features than it is more desirable option but really don't add value(money) to it. Personally I buy feature sets im looking for those first and foremost so I tend to look at that
Nov 01, 2023 at 09:18 AM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
RoamingScott wrote:
Douglas L wroteAdded: Just took some pictures of the A1 with RRS L bracket vs the Z9
And yet, despite its size, I find the Z9 balances better and feels better in hand with a 100-400 attached than the Sony did, even with a grip extension/bottom plate. Being one of my most used lenses, the Z9 suddenly started making more sense as a primary camera. I suppose if you shoot a 600/4, it doesn't really matter which body is hanging off the back, since you're rarely handholding at that point.

No question the Sony is the better size for small primes or smaller zooms.


YMMV

I hand-hold the a1+600 GM frequently, and I find the balance of the a1+100-400 GM quite good. I also find that 2 a1 bodies are a lot easier to pack than 2 Z9-sized bodies.
Nov 01, 2023 at 09:46 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
You are talking to a guy that walked around Manhattan shooting street photography with a Z9 and a 50 1.2 and once a 85 1.2 until my job moved me to a different office and the street shooting here is bland. I honestly care less about camera size and more about just blending into a crowd better But it's good you guys are on good terms though.
1bwana1 wrote:
JadedWriter wroteYou lot really need to stop camera shaming if you expect me to take your opinions seriously. I see cameras all the time in various professional settings. I don't give a single crap about the size of a persons camera or lenses as long as they get the job done with them.
1bwana1 wroteI just went for a photowalk with a group and the Leica rep who was loaning out cameras and lenses. There were a few people who brought their own gear as well. Mostly Sony stuff so it didn't look that different. But one had a Z9 and a 50mm Nikon. He looked positively comical with that huge thing hanging around his neck. It was also interesting to see the reaction of the people as we were mostly street style shooting. Largely very positive a curious about the Leicas, very intimidated and put off by the Z9 kit. It is so large I bet even the birds don't like having their picture taken by it. (don't freak out, that was just a joke).
The guy with the Z9 and I are good friends and we joke about such things with good humor. He has some really good Sony size zingers in his arsenal. He is a pro in a certain type of sport shooting, and works part time at a camera store. We have no conflict about this. He absolutely prefers the larger size as do others I know. I fully understand that and agree everyone should shoot what works for them. But in a Group of Leica M and Q shooters the size differences really stood out. We both found humor in
...Show more →

Nov 01, 2023 at 10:04 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
1bwana1 wrote:
It is so large I bet even the birds don't like having their picture taken by it. (don't freak out, that was just a joke).


I know you're lust joking about scaring the birds with the big Nikon, but in reality, I often find the big white Sony lenses actually do startle the birds noticeably more than the Nikon lenses do. I have to put a camouflage cover on my Sony lenses if I want to get closer to small birds without disturbing them, but they don't seem to pay any attention to the Z9 with its black lenses.
Nov 01, 2023 at 10:06 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
molson wrote:
1bwana1 wroteIt is so large I bet even the birds don't like having their picture taken by it. (don't freak out, that was just a joke).
I know you're lust joking about scaring the birds with the big Nikon, but in reality, I often find the big white Sony lenses actually do startle the birds noticeably more than the Nikon lenses do. I have to put a camouflage cover on my Sony lenses if I want to get closer to small birds without disturbing them, but they don't seem to pay any attention to the Z9 with its black lenses.


makes sense to me.
Nov 01, 2023 at 10:42 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
JadedWriter wrote:
You are talking to a guy that walked around Manhattan shooting street photography with a Z9 and a 50 1.2 and once a 85 1.2 until my job moved me to a different office and the street shooting here is bland. I honestly care less about camera size and more about just blending into a crowd better But it's good you guys are on good terms though.


I fully understand what you are saying. As I have said do what works best for you. I am on your side about that. I have certain injuries that make it unreasonable for me to walk around with a large heavy kit anymore. I do envy the ability to blend in to a crowd. I am 6'5" 300 lbs so no matter what size camera I carry, I don't blend in very well.

Too bad about the move messing with your street photography. That is something I enjoy doing. Hopefully that will improve for you some day soon.


Nov 01, 2023 at 10:50 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
It's kinda time and energy and I don't feel like doing that much walking after work since I'm a lot busier these days and after work I either just go home or to the gym now. I'll get the motivation for it at some point.
1bwana1 wrote:
JadedWriter wroteYou are talking to a guy that walked around Manhattan shooting street photography with a Z9 and a 50 1.2 and once a 85 1.2 until my job moved me to a different office and the street shooting here is bland. I honestly care less about camera size and more about just blending into a crowd better But it's good you guys are on good terms though.
I fully understand what you are saying. As I have said do what works best for you. I am on your side about that. I have certain injuries that make it unreasonable for me to walk around with a large heavy kit anymore. I do envy the ability to blend in to a crowd. I am 6'5" 300 lbs so no matter what size camera I carry, I don't blend in very well.

Too bad about the move messing with your street photography. That is something I enjoy doing. Hopefully that will improve for you some day soon.



Nov 01, 2023 at 10:58 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
JadedWriter wrote:
It's kinda time and energy and I don't feel like doing that much walking after work since I'm a lot busier these days and after work I either just go home or to the gym now. I'll get the motivation for it at some point.



We are blessed when we are busy and gainfully employed as well. I am in my 70s a still work every day. I don't get the whole attraction of retirement.

Nov 01, 2023 at 11:03 AM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.4 #20Will the Sony A1 Value Increase with New Firmware?
RoamingScott wrote:
Douglas L wroteAdded: Just took some pictures of the A1 with RRS L bracket vs the Z9
And yet, despite its size, I find the Z9 balances better and feels better in hand with a 100-400 attached than the Sony did, even with a grip extension/bottom plate. Being one of my most used lenses, the Z9 suddenly started making more sense as a primary camera. I suppose if you shoot a 600/4, it doesn't really matter which body is hanging off the back, since you're rarely handholding at that point.

No question the Sony is the better size for small primes or smaller zooms.


Actually I shoot my A1+600 GM+1.4TC hand held 95% of the time. I can do it for maybe 2 minutes. That's all I need. I don't usually wait for a perched bird to do something, when I do, I do use a monopod or tripod for sure. I have never used a battery grip on all the cameras I have owned and never felt the balance issue some folks experience with the 100-400, 200-600 or the 600 GM, not saying it's not affecting some shooters, I just don't feel it when my left hand is holding the lens barrel. Will see how long I can hand hold the Z9+600TC. Will try out the combo next week for bald eagles.
Nov 01, 2023 at 11:32 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister