fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Z9 Firmware Update 4.10

  
 
George Welch
Offline
Details
p.9 #1Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Z9 managed eye focus in this mess of pine needles this morning. No manual focus assist. All half dozen or so images equally sharp.

Female Magnolia Warbler.

Cheers

George




  NIKON Z 9    NIKKOR Z 400mm f/4.5 VR S lens    400mm    f/4.5    1/1600s    2200 ISO    0.0 EV  

Oct 08, 2023 at 06:48 PM
Gary Irwin
Offline
Details
p.9 #2Z9 Firmware Update 4.10

Oct 08, 2023 at 07:27 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Gary Irwin wrote:



Thanks for sharing that, its a very good video. I feel it faithfully describes the new bird mode, or faithful to my experience I should probably say. Particularly WRT Auto Area AF. Hopefully Nikon will now bring out more species-specific AF modes!
Oct 08, 2023 at 08:29 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.9 #4Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
dalegaspi wrote
duncang wrote- 9mp EVF, 5mp at 240Hz - 3mp c'mon that's also so '2017'.
let's talk about the EVF.

the criticism towards the Z9 having only 3mp is really dumb by just citing the resolution alone...it's a cheap shot from anyone who favors a competing brand.

what's usually never pointed out that Z9 has no lag (i.e., very low latency), no jitter (frame drop) nor blackout (without using frame substitution!) with and has a very bright EVF and all of these are not compromised even when AF is engaged. i admit that when Z9 was released there were jitters and even early firmware updates didn't fix them but it's flawless now (i think it was since 3.1). i cannot stress how important this is (to me) and it clearly shows what's important to Nikon WRT EVF and i'm glad it's in line with what i need. would i have preferred a higher resolution? yes, but not at the expense of brightness and having lag or not absolutely jitter-free. Nikon didn't think that the technology or cost-effectiveness is there yet and i'm totally fine with that.

compare that to Sony A7 IV (which i owned for a significant period) that jitters and drops in resolution when AF is engaged. no Sony hate here but this behavior is so jarring to me especially when shooting moving subjects.

same with Leica SL2. absolutely beautiful EVF but jitters is absolutely way worse and also drops in resolution when AF is engaged. i put up with it because I use it for static/macro subjects most of the time.
Careful mentioning the bullet point list of situations the A1 EVF can't perform at max specs

The Sony trolls are well known at this point. Just stop replying to and engaging with them.


The EVF resolution differences between Z9 and A1 aren't as meaningful as one would infer from the specs alone. A1 drops to ~5M in all shooting conditions one would use for bird/wildlife photography so already is getting closer to the 3M Z9. A1 is nicer to review images in the EVF at 9M if one is into that. Otherwise the 9M spec is not realized in bird/wildlife shooting.

I found two main difference between the EVFs....one favouring Z9, the other A1.

Z9 is the best for actively shooting and having no "reset" the EVF image as you stop firing. So it has the most fluent view while actually firing a 20FPS and following a subject. Firing, letting off for a split-sec and firing again is better on the Z9/Z8 than any other MILC I've used. A1 is almost as good while actively firing but there is a small reset to the EVF image on letting off the shutter which can affect tracking if you are doing a fire, let-off, fire etc method.

A1 is much better for WYSIWYG especially for evaluating brightness levels. With the Z9 I struggled to figure out the proper exposure via WYSIWYG in the EVF (particularly in cloudy to low light levels). I found this the poorest flagship EVF I've used in this metric. You basically had to have the EVF look like it was blowing out to have proper white levels or crank the EVF brightness to +6 to have a more accurate image.
The A1 also has the added benefit of live zebras in photo mode which is a feature very hard to let go once you have it. I'm sure Nikon will add it at some point and I'm sure Nikon bros will rave about it once they get it. If they added that then it would probably make the poor WYSIWYG a moot point as you could just set the proper zebra level and not care about what the EVF looks like.

One other spec sheet thing to mention is the option to go up to 240hz on A1. This forces a smaller image in the EVF where you get black borders. I've never liked this view and never found a noticeable difference in how well I can track and follow action with the 240 vs 120 modes on the A1. So I shoot in 120 which is the same as the Z9 anyways. Call that one a draw.

A final footnote is that IMO the Canon EVF is the nicest image of all of them (5M resolution, great colours, great exposure evaluation) but has the worst image reset during a shooting burst. This was expected in the R5 without a stacked sensor but actually wasn't all that better with the R3 despite the stacked sensor.
Oct 09, 2023 at 08:05 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #5Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
FWIW, you can get pseudo-zebras on Nikon via picture controls. https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/65652133

The Z9-sized-caveat is it records the zebras into the JPEG used for review, so it works for RAW shooting only.
Oct 09, 2023 at 08:51 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #6Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
For the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

https://i.imgur.com/KO8uDe0.jpg

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Oct 09, 2023 at 09:08 AM
carl_g
Offline
Details
p.9 #7Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
just curious, did this firmware have any impact on other subject detection or AF modes? I know what the release notes say but wondering if anyone has found that Nikon added any tweaks to the current people detection AF algorithms.
Oct 09, 2023 at 09:28 AM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
carl_g wrote:
just curious, did this firmware have any impact on other subject detection or AF modes? I know what the release notes say but wondering if anyone has found that Nikon added any tweaks to the current people detection AF algorithms.


No, Animal and Vehicle are the same as the previous FW 4.01 or prior. This is a separate bird SD mode with the improvements. Same as Airplane as seen in the Z8. Same vehicle SD, but airplane SD will ignore other vehicles like trucks if taking images on a tarmac with a truck in the frame and better recognition of planes as it locks on to the cockpit windows instead of the wing or fuselage.

Oct 09, 2023 at 12:30 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.9 #9Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
https://youtu.be/3YWMyw6csp4?si=N9u6aJnRX4WI1mVr
Another look at 4.1 - plenty of live viewfinder footage here which is useful.
Oct 09, 2023 at 12:42 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Alistair1 wrote:
https://youtu.be/3YWMyw6csp4?si=N9u6aJnRX4WI1mVr
Another look at 4.1 - plenty of live viewfinder footage here which is useful.


Yep that's the friend I was shooting with the day after the FW release. We were shooting in Bombay Hook NWR. He wasn't getting great results with 3D and I told him to switch to Auto Area AF mode and that was the solution.

He made a nice video on this subject.
Oct 09, 2023 at 01:53 PM
Gary Irwin
Offline
Details
p.9 #11Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
For the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

https://i.imgur.com/KO8uDe0.jpg

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the
...Show more →

Suggest putting your "internet filter" hat on and don't think too hard. He wasn't interested in trying for keepers as he repeatedly said the light was terrible and was obviously pressed for time. For me it was worthwhile which is why I posted the link.


Edited on Oct 09, 2023 at 03:51 PM · View previous versions
Oct 09, 2023 at 03:01 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.9 #12Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Gary Irwin wrote:
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

https://i.imgur.com/KO8uDe0.jpg

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Suggest putting your "internet filter" hat on and don't think too hard. He wasn't interested in trying for keepers as he repeatedly said the light was terrible and was obviously pressed for time. For me it was a worthwhile which is why I posted the link.


I am not a particular fan of this Wild Alaska guy overall as some of his comparisons and reviews are pretty flawed (only seen maybe 5 or 6 of his videos total) but I agree with you it was an initial comparison that was just to show the recognition speed and tracking improvements and was nice to see for people that don't shoot regularly to notice the difference maybe compared to a non updated Z9 still on FW 4.01.
Oct 09, 2023 at 03:04 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
For the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

https://i.imgur.com/KO8uDe0.jpg

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the
...Show more →

I am not sure anyone is saying that the new Bird AF is perfect. No camera is. Not the A1 or the R5/R3. But the new Bird SD mode is a significant improvement. To the point there is no clear advantage between the Z9, A1, R5/R3

He wasn't trying to expose properly due to being in the harsh afternoon light. He was trying to expose for the bird in dark areas and not even really taking any pics, just showing the recognition speed and tracking.
Oct 09, 2023 at 03:15 PM
FrankA373
Offline
Details
p.9 #14Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
I took a photo of a squirrel this afternoon using the Z9 updated to 4.1 and 400 f/4.5. I was using the new bird SD and wide L. It immediately locked on the eye of the squirrel without hesitation. Hmmmm…. Maybe we sometimes don’t need animal SD. One photo is not a confirmation but bird SD worked.
Oct 09, 2023 at 03:52 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #15Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
arbitrage wrote:
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I trust you....because your Z9 complaints mirror mine and you use A1 so know where it has always been superior. If this 4.1 has finally got Auto to work like it did on Nikon DSLR and/or A1's Wide then I will think about purchasing a Z9 again and see for myself.

But please tell me you are being sincere because I wasted time and money (well actually not money as I resold for the same as I bought) when people raved about the 3.X FW.

I want the Nikon lenses but need the Z9 to match A1 and to date it just
...Show more →

Well I wouldn't want you to waste money based on my recommendation but I would recommend you test a Z9 out again.

It's like night and day the difference is. Acquisition of that chat is impressive even by A1 standards, which bodes well for an incoming swallow 30 meters away.

Best ignore most of the other feedback - half these folks were claiming a 100% hit rate previously and now they are claiming a 10 to 20 percent improvement. Can't do math I guess.

As far as I am concerned it's gone from totally unusable in Auto Area mode to being like an A1 in Auto Area mode.

My impression is quite a few folks are also still using the Zone focus areas or 3D or modes rather than auto area - they probably don't really even understand how to use Auto Area mode yet. Why would they, it has never been a viable option until now, or they are still just determined to turn the camera back into a DSLR.

I did get out again in better light and didn't have any trouble tracking terns down to the water and back up again - severely hampered of course by the 800PF at 1200mm (don't even ask). I will try and take a look at those images to check the focus accuracy today.

Not sure how I can put it but my initial impression was that it was "Crazy good" - which is exactly how I felt coming from a D850 to an A9 many years ago.

Unfortunately I cannot vouch for focus accuracy yet as I have not had any real success with tack sharp BIF with either the Z8/Z9 and the conditions were crap. The shutter speed was 1/1600 while tracking the swallows at 1200mm - nothing will ever be sharp so only conclusion is that tracking is very good and background is pretty much just ignored.

You should not be surprised though - as I mentioned previously these cameras are all processor constrained (yes even the A1 is) and by creating a specialised bird mode Nikon (and Sony) are able to substantially improve the speed of the algorithm so that it can a) work in full frame mode, and b) track fast action edge to edge. You will find they have done this by tuning to focus on near objects and hence the tendency to now focus on the grass in front of the subject. However just switch to the animal mode in that scenario.

I think this is where the a6700/a7rv with the neural engine have the advantage - with that processing power they can handle both scenarios nearly flawlessly. Most likely the future for the A9/a1 as well.

As for speed - well I was able to pan the camera left and right as fast as I could while the camera was focussed on a small bird and the yellow focus box stays locked on no matter how fast a I panned or how close to the edge of the frame the bird got.

I am hoping the focus accuracy turns out to be very good because Nikon might then have just earned their ticket back in to the "Big Boys" club. I will defer that decision to you though.

For me you don't get into that club without having a tack sharp 600 zoom and iso on the rear dial as well

Will update once I have looked at the other images.

Oct 09, 2023 at 04:30 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #16Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Gary Irwin wrote:
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

https://i.imgur.com/KO8uDe0.jpg

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Suggest putting your "internet filter" hat on and don't think too hard. He wasn't interested in trying for keepers as he repeatedly said the light was terrible and was obviously pressed for time. For me it was worthwhile which is why I posted the link.


If you're testing AF on a MILC, you need to balance the exposure as best you can since the data feed to the EVF is the same one used for AF calculations. If you are creating a harsh, contrasty, over exposed EVF image, AF will suffer.

It proves why so many Youtubers are completely useless. Anyone can strap an Atomos to their camera, but it seems like almost no one knows what the hell they are talking about.
Oct 09, 2023 at 06:11 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
arbitrage wrote
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I trust you....because your Z9 complaints mirror mine and you use A1 so know where it has always been superior. If this 4.1 has finally got Auto to work like it did on Nikon DSLR and/or A1's Wide then I will think about purchasing a Z9 again and see for myself.

But please tell me you are being sincere because I wasted time and money (well actually not money as I resold for the same as I bought) when people raved about the 3.X FW.

I want the Nikon lenses but need the Z9 to match A1 and to date it just never has.
Well I wouldn't want you to waste money based on my recommendation but I would recommend you test a Z9 out again.

It's like night and day the difference is. Acquisition of that chat is impressive even by A1 standards, which bodes well for an incoming swallow 30 meters away.

Best ignore most of the other feedback - half these folks were claiming a 100% hit rate previously and now they are claiming a 10 to 20 percent improvement. Can't do math I guess.

As far as I am concerned it's gone from totally unusable in Auto Area mode to being like
...Show more →

Can't this discussion between you and Arbitrage be done via PM? That is a very unpleasant post.
Oct 09, 2023 at 07:03 PM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.9 #18Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Bird detection seemed to have no problem detecting and locked on to a monkey as well when I tried it over the weekend. No idea if human face/eye detection is improving or not. If not, it is coming though.
One of Zf promo mentioned that Zf will detect human face as small as 3% of the frame so I assume that that feature will make its way to Z8/Z9 sometimes soon as well. My Nikon friend told me that Nikon is not done with Z9 AF yet and they still have a few things to add.
Oct 09, 2023 at 07:05 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.9 #19Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
suteetat wrote:
Bird detection seemed to have no problem detecting and locked on to a monkey as well when I tried it over the weekend. No idea if human face/eye detection is improving or not. If not, it is coming though.
One of Zf promo mentioned that Zf will detect human face as small as 3% of the frame so I assume that that feature will make its way to Z8/Z9 sometimes soon as well. My Nikon friend told me that Nikon is not done with Z9 AF yet and they still have a few things to add.


I tested Bird SD on a red fox yesterday and it was a touch slower then with a bird but it had no issue with the fox either. That honestly wasn't unexpected by me as when in Animal SD mode previous and pointed at a person, it would be a tad slower but would recognize the person and eye track fine as well.
Oct 09, 2023 at 07:27 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.9 #20Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Gary Irwin wrote
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

https://i.imgur.com/KO8uDe0.jpg

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Suggest putting your "internet filter" hat on and don't think too hard. He wasn't interested in trying for keepers as he repeatedly said the light was terrible and was obviously pressed for time. For me it was worthwhile which is why I posted the link.
If you're testing AF on a MILC, you need to balance the exposure as best you can since the data feed to the EVF is the same one used for AF calculations. If you are creating a harsh, contrasty, over exposed EVF image, AF will suffer.

It proves why so many Youtubers are completely useless. Anyone can strap an Atomos to their camera, but it seems like almost no one knows what the hell they are talking about.


Normally yes,. but if you watched the video, the Z9 in Bird SD had no issue with the bird eye detection in high key scenes or in over exposed frames exposing for the bird in trees shaded well. So this is even a more impressive example for the new Bird SD mode.
Oct 09, 2023 at 07:37 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister