fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Z9 Firmware Update 4.10

  
 
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.10 #1Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
suteetat wroteBird detection seemed to have no problem detecting and locked on to a monkey as well when I tried it over the weekend. No idea if human face/eye detection is improving or not. If not, it is coming though.
One of Zf promo mentioned that Zf will detect human face as small as 3% of the frame so I assume that that feature will make its way to Z8/Z9 sometimes soon as well. My Nikon friend told me that Nikon is not done with Z9 AF yet and they still have a few things to add.
I tested Bird SD on a red fox yesterday and it was a touch slower then with a bird but it had no issue with the fox either. That honestly wasn't unexpected by me as when in Animal SD mode previous and pointed at a person, it would be a tad slower but would recognize the person and eye track fine as well.



Yes, I think that is to be expected. For eye detection, the camera was basically looking for round thing. However, unlike fw 1.0 where it does not discriminated much between eye and any other round object in the scene, it is now more selective and go for
round thing that is in something resembling a face. I think bird focus certainly will concentrate more on anything with bird shape but failing that, it will fall back on other subject recognition/contrast detection etc. On Sunday, I turned off bird detection as I was concentrating on Bryde's whales and dont' want the camera to focus on the seagulls instead

If the rain finally stop, hopefully I will have some chance to shoot more birds soon.
Oct 09, 2023 at 07:43 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #2Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Here is a link to the more recent images. Not the best light but I don't see too many issues with the focus keeping up with the tracking.

One or two with some motion blur but far less than I expected given it's at 1200mm.

https://duncangroenewald.com/pages/collections/2023-10-06-z9-1.html

Of course your mileage may vary but a shorter lens and better light should give the same or better results.

Tomorrow is looking like a perfect weather so will see if we can give it a proper test with the 500PF.
Oct 09, 2023 at 11:59 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #3Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Alistair1 wrote:
duncang wrote
arbitrage wrote
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I trust you....because your Z9 complaints mirror mine and you use A1 so know where it has always been superior. If this 4.1 has finally got Auto to work like it did on Nikon DSLR and/or A1's Wide then I will think about purchasing a Z9 again and see for myself.

But please tell me you are being sincere because I wasted time and money (well actually not money as I resold for the same as I bought) when people raved about the 3.X FW.

I want the Nikon lenses but need the Z9 to match A1 and to date it just never has.
Well I wouldn't want you to waste money based on my recommendation but I would recommend you test a Z9 out again.

It's like night and day the difference is. Acquisition of that chat is impressive even by A1 standards, which bodes well for an incoming swallow 30 meters away.

Best ignore most of the other feedback - half these folks were claiming a 100% hit rate previously and now they are claiming a 10 to 20 percent improvement. Can't do math I guess.

As far as I am concerned it's gone from totally unusable in Auto Area mode to being like an A1 in Auto Area mode.

My impression is quite a few folks are also still using the Zone focus areas or 3D or modes rather than auto area - they probably don't really even understand how to use Auto Area mode yet. Why would they, it has never been a viable option until now, or they are still just determined to turn the camera back into a DSLR.

I did get out again in better light and didn't have any trouble tracking terns down to the water and back up again - severely hampered of course by the 800PF at 1200mm (don't even ask). I will try and take a look at those images to check the focus accuracy today.

Not sure how I can put it but my initial impression was that it was "Crazy good" - which is exactly how I felt coming from a D850 to an A9 many years ago.

Unfortunately I cannot vouch for focus accuracy yet as I have not had any real success with tack sharp BIF with either the Z8/Z9 and the conditions were crap. The shutter speed was 1/1600 while tracking the swallows at 1200mm - nothing will ever be sharp so only conclusion is that tracking is very good and background is pretty much just ignored.

You should not be surprised though - as I mentioned previously these cameras are all processor constrained (yes even the A1 is) and by creating a specialised bird mode Nikon (and Sony) are able to substantially improve the speed of the algorithm so that it can a) work in full frame mode, and b) track fast action edge to edge. You will find they have done this by tuning to focus on near objects and hence the tendency to now focus on the grass in front of the subject. However just switch to the animal mode in that scenario.

I think this is where the a6700/a7rv with the neural engine have the advantage - with that processing power they can handle both scenarios nearly flawlessly. Most likely the future for the A9/a1 as well.

As for speed - well I was able to pan the camera left and right as fast as I could while the camera was focussed on a small bird and the yellow focus box stays locked on no matter how fast a I panned or how close to the edge of the frame the bird got.

I am hoping the focus accuracy turns out to be very good because Nikon might then have just earned their ticket back in to the "Big Boys" club. I will defer that decision to you though.

For me you don't get into that club without having a tack sharp 600 zoom and iso on the rear dial as well

Will update once I have looked at the other images.
Can't this discussion between you and Arbitrage be done via PM? That is a very unpleasant post.


To say nothing of posts that disparage individuals simply because they happened to have different opinions on the performance of certain camera gear, despite the fact that poster hasn't even deemed it necessary to try out the gear under discussion to educate themselves on what it is all about.

Just as a matter of interest why don't you feel it necessary to call out those posts ?


Oct 10, 2023 at 12:56 AM
George Welch
Offline
Details
p.10 #4Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
This series of posts you are simply a discussion between two well respected members.

Not sure what you find problematic about it.

Respectful discourse is very useful and can be very helpful for people to see an opposing point of view.

Cheers

George
Oct 10, 2023 at 03:08 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.10 #5Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
For the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the
...Show more →

Obviously it's not perfect for birding (nothing is), but I've been trying to replicate the false positives as well as see how far I can push the subject detection and all I can say is that in the scenarios I've been testing it, it has not been a problem. The Z9 seems to be able to lock onto birds even in situations where my own eyes struggle due to either lack of contrast or similar coloring to its surroundings. It also seems to do really well with partial obstructions - even though those images are throwaways, it will stay locked on which is useful in case the bird moves. Here are some examples of some low-contrast birds in busy surroundings and it locks onto the bird without any trouble. I used a mixture of different AF modes:

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-2FLr7X3/0/807670d6/L/i-2FLr7X3-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-GLc5CBn/0/59031114/L/i-GLc5CBn-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NmXRJzh/0/ae01c341/L/i-NmXRJzh-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-WbhxP9p/0/481caf8b/L/i-WbhxP9p-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-rQFbQx9/0/04c18a75/L/i-rQFbQx9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-nDFs7dk/0/b74c3b24/L/i-nDFs7dk-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-gCgm9W2/0/bb2d3982/L/i-gCgm9W2-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-xvfsdSg/0/904b1aeb/L/i-xvfsdSg-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-F4MGjhj/0/f15246a1/L/i-F4MGjhj-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tSWPxQ9/0/7d71762c/L/i-tSWPxQ9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-n8Q4JTJ/0/9897e31b/L/i-n8Q4JTJ-L.jpg


As for your last question, I think maybe he was taking the "ETTR" mentality a little too far Also, frankly, a lot of YouTubers in general confidently talk about things they don't understand while trying to 'educate' people - not sure if that's the case with your example or not, I'm not familiar with that YouTuber.
Oct 10, 2023 at 10:02 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.10 #6Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
The new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
Oct 10, 2023 at 10:24 AM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.10 #7Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
molson wrote:
The new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).


I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is ahead of all the other AF modes with SD. After today and 5 days out testing, for me and others I know, there is little doubt Auto Area is king right now.
Oct 10, 2023 at 03:48 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.10 #8Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
CanadaMark wrote:
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Obviously it's not perfect for birding (nothing is), but I've been trying to replicate the false positives as well as see how far I can push the subject detection and all I can say is that in the scenarios I've been testing it, it has not been a problem. The Z9 seems to be able to lock onto birds even in situations where my own eyes struggle due to either lack of contrast or similar coloring to its surroundings. It also seems to do really well with partial obstructions - even though those images are throwaways, it will stay locked
...Show more →

I am not sure why RomaingScott keeps badgering the point of Auto Area is fault and that Bird SD is giving false positives and that Auto is flawed and such. I have been trying to tell him Auto has been really really good even before FW 2.0 but got better then and 3D was a tad better at that point and the 2 have been equal since 3.10 and now with 4.10 and bird SD, Auto is where you need to be shooting. The Bird SD has given me no false positives yet.

Results are the only thing that matters.
Oct 10, 2023 at 04:03 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #9Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
CanadaMark wrote
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Obviously it's not perfect for birding (nothing is), but I've been trying to replicate the false positives as well as see how far I can push the subject detection and all I can say is that in the scenarios I've been testing it, it has not been a problem. The Z9 seems to be able to lock onto birds even in situations where my own eyes struggle due to either lack of contrast or similar coloring to its surroundings. It also seems to do really well with partial obstructions - even though those images are throwaways, it will stay locked on which is useful in case the bird moves. Here are some examples of some low-contrast birds in busy surroundings and it locks onto the bird without any trouble. I used a mixture of different AF modes:

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-2FLr7X3/0/807670d6/L/i-2FLr7X3-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-GLc5CBn/0/59031114/L/i-GLc5CBn-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NmXRJzh/0/ae01c341/L/i-NmXRJzh-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-WbhxP9p/0/481caf8b/L/i-WbhxP9p-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-rQFbQx9/0/04c18a75/L/i-rQFbQx9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-nDFs7dk/0/b74c3b24/L/i-nDFs7dk-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-gCgm9W2/0/bb2d3982/L/i-gCgm9W2-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-xvfsdSg/0/904b1aeb/L/i-xvfsdSg-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-F4MGjhj/0/f15246a1/L/i-F4MGjhj-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tSWPxQ9/0/7d71762c/L/i-tSWPxQ9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-n8Q4JTJ/0/9897e31b/L/i-n8Q4JTJ-L.jpg

As for your last question, I think maybe he was taking the "ETTR" mentality a little too far Also, frankly, a lot of YouTubers in general confidently talk about things they don't understand while trying to 'educate' people - not sure if that's the case with your example or not, I'm not familiar with that YouTuber.
I am not sure why RomaingScott keeps badgering the point of Auto Area is fault and that Bird SD is giving false positives and that Auto is flawed and such.


Because it's true. I get false positives every single time I go out and shoot perched with 4.10 and sometimes you have to fight it to get it to latch onto the actual bird in Area mode with Bird AF. I don't know why YOU, a person who says they don't shoot small perched birds, continues to talk about things you have no experience with. There is no mode that should require less skill than Area + Bird AF. Hand the camera to anyone with stock settings in that mode and you'll still get false positives that require some finesse to work around for perched. Get over it. It is what it is. It's not an attack on you.

The flip side is that motion/contrast detection is PHENOMENAL with moving subjects. The old Z9 fw would never get a photo like this in Area. F*** swallows. Child's play. Critical focus on the bug in the dragonfly's mandible. Wow.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53249692393_c01d361379_o.jpg
Oct 10, 2023 at 04:07 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.10 #10Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Eric214 wrote
CanadaMark wrote
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Obviously it's not perfect for birding (nothing is), but I've been trying to replicate the false positives as well as see how far I can push the subject detection and all I can say is that in the scenarios I've been testing it, it has not been a problem. The Z9 seems to be able to lock onto birds even in situations where my own eyes struggle due to either lack of contrast or similar coloring to its surroundings. It also seems to do really well with partial obstructions - even though those images are throwaways, it will stay locked on which is useful in case the bird moves. Here are some examples of some low-contrast birds in busy surroundings and it locks onto the bird without any trouble. I used a mixture of different AF modes:

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-2FLr7X3/0/807670d6/L/i-2FLr7X3-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-GLc5CBn/0/59031114/L/i-GLc5CBn-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NmXRJzh/0/ae01c341/L/i-NmXRJzh-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-WbhxP9p/0/481caf8b/L/i-WbhxP9p-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-rQFbQx9/0/04c18a75/L/i-rQFbQx9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-nDFs7dk/0/b74c3b24/L/i-nDFs7dk-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-gCgm9W2/0/bb2d3982/L/i-gCgm9W2-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-xvfsdSg/0/904b1aeb/L/i-xvfsdSg-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-F4MGjhj/0/f15246a1/L/i-F4MGjhj-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tSWPxQ9/0/7d71762c/L/i-tSWPxQ9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-n8Q4JTJ/0/9897e31b/L/i-n8Q4JTJ-L.jpg

As for your last question, I think maybe he was taking the "ETTR" mentality a little too far Also, frankly, a lot of YouTubers in general confidently talk about things they don't understand while trying to 'educate' people - not sure if that's the case with your example or not, I'm not familiar with that YouTuber.
I am not sure why RomaingScott keeps badgering the point of Auto Area is fault and that Bird SD is giving false positives and that Auto is flawed and such.
Because it's true. I get false positives every single time I go out and shoot perched with 4.10 and sometimes you have to fight it to get it to latch onto the actual bird in Area mode with Bird AF. I don't know why YOU, a person who says they don't shoot small perched birds, continues to talk about things you have no experience with. There is no mode that should require less skill than Area + Bird AF. Hand the camera to anyone with stock settings in that mode and you'll still get false positives that require some finesse
...Show more →

I don't know what to say then as a dozen people I know with the Z9 and other Forums people are not having that issue you are describing. It just instantly locks up the birds eye.

Maybe you have a borked FW update? Have you tried resetting you Z9 and reinstalling the 4.10 FW?
Oct 10, 2023 at 04:19 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.10 #11Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
molson wroteThe new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is
...Show more →

You're more than welcome to come to my house and try photographing the Anna's hummingbirds in and out of the cedar trees. No matter what AF settings I use, it won't lock onto them in flight - although it will usually snap into focus the instant they land on a perch.
Oct 10, 2023 at 05:14 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.10 #12Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
CanadaMark wrote
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Obviously it's not perfect for birding (nothing is), but I've been trying to replicate the false positives as well as see how far I can push the subject detection and all I can say is that in the scenarios I've been testing it, it has not been a problem. The Z9 seems to be able to lock onto birds even in situations where my own eyes struggle due to either lack of contrast or similar coloring to its surroundings. It also seems to do really well with partial obstructions - even though those images are throwaways, it will stay locked on which is useful in case the bird moves. Here are some examples of some low-contrast birds in busy surroundings and it locks onto the bird without any trouble. I used a mixture of different AF modes:

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-2FLr7X3/0/807670d6/L/i-2FLr7X3-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-GLc5CBn/0/59031114/L/i-GLc5CBn-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NmXRJzh/0/ae01c341/L/i-NmXRJzh-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-WbhxP9p/0/481caf8b/L/i-WbhxP9p-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-rQFbQx9/0/04c18a75/L/i-rQFbQx9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-nDFs7dk/0/b74c3b24/L/i-nDFs7dk-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-gCgm9W2/0/bb2d3982/L/i-gCgm9W2-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-xvfsdSg/0/904b1aeb/L/i-xvfsdSg-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-F4MGjhj/0/f15246a1/L/i-F4MGjhj-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tSWPxQ9/0/7d71762c/L/i-tSWPxQ9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-n8Q4JTJ/0/9897e31b/L/i-n8Q4JTJ-L.jpg

As for your last question, I think maybe he was taking the "ETTR" mentality a little too far Also, frankly, a lot of YouTubers in general confidently talk about things they don't understand while trying to 'educate' people - not sure if that's the case with your example or not, I'm not familiar with that YouTuber.
I am not sure why RomaingScott keeps badgering the point of Auto Area is fault and that Bird SD is giving false positives and that Auto is flawed and such. I have been trying to tell him Auto has been really really good even before FW 2.0 but got better then and 3D was a tad better at that point and the 2 have been equal since 3.10 and now with 4.10 and bird SD, Auto is where you need to be shooting. The Bird SD has given me no false positives yet.

Results are the only thing that matters.


The above examples I posted are mostly, if not all, actually pre-4.1. The Z9's ability to pick out birds in busy scenes, even those where there are distracting high contrast elements, or scenes where there is almost no color differentiation between the bird and its surroundings, has been nothing short of amazing at least in the scenarios I find myself in. I am not seeing the same level of improvement with this FW as some others have (so far anyway) and I think part of the reason is I was simply having fewer issues pre-4.1. If, for example, my hit rate went from ~90% to ~94%, that's great, but I can't easily confirm that, at least not without lots of time and thousands of photos. The faster birds have all gone to warmer climates for the winter, so admittedly there are some tests I can't try with 4.1, and there will probably be yet another FW update before Spring. That being said, the camera had no problem whatsoever tracking Swallows or other small, fast birds on prior firmware with extremely high hit rates as long as I was doing my part. If others are noticing bigger improvements, I think that's fantastic, as obviously some part of their usage seems to really benefit from whatever improvements Nikon made.

Auto Area has been working well for me too for as long as I can remember. I wish I had something more interesting to say, but in my experience, it "just works". As with every camera, you always need to dive into the menus to get the absolute maximum out of any given AF system, but Auto has been very good in terms of just being able to point & shoot. I try out different AF modes a lot and frankly I just don't find that one works dramatically better than the next, but they all have their nuances. 3D and Auto probably do the best at picking perched birds out of busy scenes. Of course I can only speak for myself and the situations I shoot in so I am not trying to discredit anyone else's experience. I believe Scott when he says he's having issues, but I have spent quite a lot of time experimenting and I simply can't replicate the false positives in the scenarios I have access to. It doesn't mean he's wrong, it just means that the AF behavior he is experiencing isn't universal, so either more troubleshooting might be required or the scenarios I'm testing in aren't provoking the same behavior for whatever reason.

Using myself as an example, there were things I couldn't get the Sony bodies to do no matter how hard I tried, but I can see that some other Sony users are not having the same problem. You will never see me on the Sony forums trying to claim the issues I was having were some kind of factual shortcoming of the bodies themselves as if I was some kind of authority on the subject - there are way too many variables, the biggest one being me. I'll never understand why some people try to peddle their various personal experiences as facts when they are highly controversial and evidence of the contrary is so easy to find. What it does do is reveal various confirmation biases and insecurities. (By the way Scott, to be clear, I am not talking about you or anyone in particular, I'm off on a tangent )

All this AF hair splitting is getting ridiculous. I think part of the problem is that any modern camera, especially the flagships, all perform about the same in terms of being able to quite easily 'get the shot'. So when one tries to dive deeper and decide which is best, they enter a world of almost unlimited variables and subjectivity. At that point, I think we're well into personal preference territory, and some people are just going to get along better with certain setups - nothing wrong with that.
Oct 10, 2023 at 05:25 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.10 #13Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
molson wrote:
Eric214 wrote
molson wroteThe new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is ahead of all the other AF modes with SD. After today and 5 days out testing, for me and others I know, there is little doubt Auto Area is king right now.
You're more than welcome to come to my house and try photographing the Anna's hummingbirds in and out of the cedar trees. No matter what AF settings I use, it won't lock onto them in flight - although it will usually snap into focus the instant they land on a perch.


I don't know my birds well enough to know if this is the same species of hummingbird, but I have no issues tracking humming birds in flight darting in and out of trees on pre-4.1 FW - should have probably used a faster shutter speed though

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-jGFfnbw/0/d3ae51fc/L/i-jGFfnbw-L.jpg
https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NzM5SzF/0/fbe622c0/L/i-NzM5SzF-L.jpg



Oct 10, 2023 at 05:31 PM
James Farrell
Offline
Details
p.10 #14Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Looks more like a Rufous to me; not an Anna's
Oct 10, 2023 at 06:22 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.10 #15Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
CanadaMark wrote:
molson wrote
Eric214 wrote
molson wroteThe new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is ahead of all the other AF modes with SD. After today and 5 days out testing, for me and others I know, there is little doubt Auto Area is king right now.
You're more than welcome to come to my house and try photographing the Anna's hummingbirds in and out of the cedar trees. No matter what AF settings I use, it won't lock onto them in flight - although it will usually snap into focus the instant they land on a perch.
I don't know my birds well enough to know if this is the same species of hummingbird, but I have no issues tracking humming birds in flight darting in and out of trees on pre-4.1 FW - should have probably used a faster shutter speed though

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-jGFfnbw/0/d3ae51fc/L/i-jGFfnbw-L.jpg
https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NzM5SzF/0/fbe622c0/L/i-NzM5SzF-L.jpg



It looks like you have lots of light there, so focusing should be fairly easy. I'm normally having to shoot at ISO 3200, 6400, or higher.

My Panasonic G9 can handle shots like this with no issues. With the Z9 I can fire off a hundred shots without it ever locking focus, under the exact same conditions. As soon as the bird lands, the Z9 finally recognizes it and locks focus instantly.

Same bird, same location, much different results:





Most of the Z9 sequences look like this

  NIKON Z 9    NIKKOR Z 400mm f/4.5 VR S lens    400mm    f/8.0    1/320s    6400 ISO    0.0 EV  







Most of the G9 sequences look like this

  DC-G9    LEICA DG 50-200/F2.8-4.0 lens    200mm    f/4.0    1/500s    2500 ISO    0.0 EV  

Oct 10, 2023 at 07:18 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #16Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Oct 10, 2023 at 11:30 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #20Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Raw files download links for the swallows. Let me know if interested in the tern raw files.


https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7188.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7189.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7190.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7191.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7192.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7193.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7194.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7195.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7196.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7197.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7198.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7199.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7200.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7201.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7202.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7203.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7204.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7205.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7218.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7219.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7220.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7221.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7222.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7223.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7224.NEF
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/raw/DSC_7225.NEF

Oct 11, 2023 at 01:11 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister