fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Z9 Firmware Update 4.10

  
 
lukemeup
Offline
Details
p.8 #1Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
I don't see any Sony trolling in this thread. Does it mean my ignore list is perfect now?
Oct 07, 2023 at 01:32 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
arbitrage wrote:
groob wrote
arbitrage wrote
RoamingScott wroteI see every one of these significant firmware updates as a glorious middle finger aimed directly at Sony
And yet Sony still just sits there smirking knowing that Nikon still hasn't matched the AF performance that Sony FW released 2.5 years ago



Sorry I had to take the bait....
Can't wait to find out whether a Z9 will track a swallow at 35 yards now--a life changing development!
It won't. Nikon needs a full re-write of the FW before it can do that. Maybe Z9II? I'm hoping because the lenses are to die for and I'd switch in a second if the camera matched my A1.


It definitely will - I have witnessed it myself many times. It's really not that hard to do because the shooter's tracking movements aren't as exaggerated as when the bird is closer. Small birds at distance are generally not a problem but a small bird at 100+ feet away usually doesn't make for a good photo unless you have a ton of reach. If you do have plenty of reach, the subject is larger in the viewfinder again, making the distance less of a factor as it becomes even easier for the AF (if you can track it).

It might be more accurate to say that you personally didn't have success with it, rather than trying to state it as a factual limitation of the camera.

Here is a Kingfisher diving off a branch at 56.23m (61.5 yards), and I was even using (gasp!) 3D AF. It's an unedited image and might even be a throw-away, but it's the most similar example I was able to find quickly:

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-PgwjGmK/0/6eac771c/X2/i-PgwjGmK-X2.jpg

Oct 07, 2023 at 01:59 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.8 #3Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
lukemeup wrote:
I don't see any Sony trolling in this thread. Does it mean my ignore list is perfect now?


You've also probably cut it down to only 2 or 3 pages
Oct 07, 2023 at 01:59 PM
George DeCamp
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
arbitrage wrote:
groob wrote
arbitrage wrote
RoamingScott wroteI see every one of these significant firmware updates as a glorious middle finger aimed directly at Sony
And yet Sony still just sits there smirking knowing that Nikon still hasn't matched the AF performance that Sony FW released 2.5 years ago



Sorry I had to take the bait....
Can't wait to find out whether a Z9 will track a swallow at 35 yards now--a life changing development!
It won't. Nikon needs a full re-write of the FW before it can do that. Maybe Z9II? I'm hoping because the lenses are to die for and I'd switch in a second if the camera matched my A1.


Borrow one and give it a "shot"
Oct 07, 2023 at 02:35 PM
lukemeup
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
CanadaMark wrote:
You've also probably cut it down to only 2 or 3 pages


You should see the Plena thread from my viewpoint - some pages have 2-3 posts .

Oct 07, 2023 at 03:23 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.8 #6Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Eric214 wrote
RoamingScott wrote
Eric214 wrote
RoamingScott wrotePerfect auto area is not, I’ve gone out three times in different light today and gotten strange false positives in all sorts of scenarios. Most usually it’s some high contrast gap in foliage that registers as a bird. That said, it’s a minor quibble in relation to how much better actual bird focus is.

Eric214 wroteI agree. I have been seeing no issues whatsoever using Auto Area AF mode. it seems to be a bit more intelligent in recognizing and acquiring/locking/tracking. 3D is lagging a bit but now that I am thinking about it, that sounds about right. 3D defaults to using 3 for the blocked shot setting. I have my blocked shot set to 5 for my Auto Area and Wide Area AF modes and that will use the setting of 5 when using Auto Area or Wide Area AF modes.
Well 2 days, 260 and 592 images and only 3 soft/missed focus frames total. Auto Area is better on my Z9 then 3d currently and virtually instant recognition, Lock on and Tracking including Snowy Egrets and sandpipers, American Avocets flying right at me.
Shoot some more and you'll see what I'm talking about. I took about 1200 images today and by the end I started knowing what would register as a false positive...saw a particular cloud formation that I figured would trip it and lo and behold, instantly thought it was a bird
I shoot plenty. I have been teaching people Z9 setups and techniques since February of 2022 in person and over video chat. I'm near 400k image count on my Z9.

There is nothing wrong with Auto Area AF mode since the launch of the Z9. 3D on the other hand had been ok, then good, then bad over the few updates and then good again since FW 3.0. But I'm seeing 3D slightly behind Auto Area AF with the new Bird SD mode. I'm not alone as a friend with me today was witnessing the same thing.
There has been plenty wrong with Area compared specifically compared to Sony since the Z9 launch, and lucky for us, it's gotten better and better with every X.0 firmware. It was so bad on 1.0 that most other modes were more reliable.

My comments today refer SPECIFICALLY to Area with Bird AF applied at the same time. No clue how Area is working on 4.1 away from Bird AF because I haven't had a reason to test it yet.

Anyone who says unequivocally "there is nothing wrong with X" over and over is the last person to be listened to when it
...Show more →

As I am only referring SPECIFICALLY with Auto Area with Bird SD. That is all I am talking about since were talking about the new FW update.

I never said anything is perfect, but Auto has been as good as 3D and it's currently better then 3D for me in BIRD SD. Shot another 2,000 images today, about 1,000 on each, 3D and Auto. with Auto, and 1,013 images I had only 22 images with missed focus. 3D I shot 1,045 images and had 92 images with missed focus. Still great, but I will be sticking with Auto for the time being along with 4 other Z9 shooters with me today.

Not sure what you are doing wrong with Auto, but there is something not right based on your experience. There is nothing wrong with Auto in the sense you are talking about it. There are ways to manipulate the AF system (I do not mean changing AF modes like Wide to 3D).

I dont pay a lot of mind to many YouTubers. I go out and shoot and I take my experiences for my own thoughts. Most of them have no clue how to shoot with the Z9 properly to get good results. So I will refrain from being biased by others and go with my results. Results others are getting with what I am seeing.

But if you want to shoot 3D then go for it it's still much improved with Bird SD. I always say shoot with what works for you. I am not trying to argue with you or change what you do, I am just relaying info that I am seeing in case that helps some others.
Oct 07, 2023 at 03:49 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #7Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
Not sure what you are doing wrong with Auto, but there is something not right based on your experience. There is nothing wrong with Auto in the sense you are talking about it.


I said there is an issue with Bird AF and false positives, most easily seen in Area because the entire frame is open to interpretation.

If you haven't seen a false positive in Bird AF, you're probably not shooting perched birds in high contrast foliage. It's extremely easy to replicate.

I very rarely shoot in 3D because I've never found it particularly reliable. However, for perched birds, sometimes it's preferred, especially if the camera is trying to jump between a bird and a false positive.

As I said, I found it odd that handing Area off to 3D would often lead to tighter eye boxes in 3D vs the same exact post in Area.

I'm not doing anything wrong, I know what the hell I'm talking about
Oct 07, 2023 at 04:07 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.8 #8Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Eric214 wroteNot sure what you are doing wrong with Auto, but there is something not right based on your experience. There is nothing wrong with Auto in the sense you are talking about it.
I said there is an issue with Bird AF and false positives, most easily seen in Area because the entire frame is open to interpretation.

If you haven't seen a false positive in Bird AF, you're probably not shooting perched birds in high contrast foliage. It's extremely easy to replicate.

I very rarely shoot in 3D because I've never found it particularly reliable. However, for perched birds, sometimes it's preferred, especially if the camera is trying to jump between a bird and a false positive.

As I said, I found it odd that handing Area off to 3D would often lead to
...Show more →

I don't shoot many small birds in general, not at all interesting to me (mostly Warblers and such) but I have been shooting everything I see as where I live in Maryland/Delaware/PA corner, we are in between seasons. Things left and things are just starting to migrate in.

I am not seeing any false positives as in a green lock on a bird's eye in branches and leaves and getting a soft image. I use 3D for this as Auto Area was never the best for this scenario. But for birds Like Marsh Hawks, Bald Eagles, Terns Osprey from a clear sky to in front of a busy background and then to the water 3D and Auto Area were about the same in Animal SD prior to the FW 4.10 with very few issues.

Since the new Bird SD, I am seeing Auto virtually instantly recognize the bird, lock and track significantly better and without manipulating the AF system. This is where the butter is right now. I just hit Auto no matter where the bird is, in front of a busy tree line, reeds, on the water, it just grabs it. It was also grabbing and tracking Swallows at Bombay Hook NWR on Wednesday at about 25-30 yards in Auto Area.
Oct 07, 2023 at 04:27 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #9Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
All of this said, did headshots for football today and Auto AF worked much better than whatever firmware was on my Z9 this time last year. Rock solid and no brainer shooting.
Oct 07, 2023 at 04:29 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
I took it out again this morning. Trying to pin down the tangible changes Nikon have made to the AF system for birds. So far I think I can pinpoint 3:

1. They have made improvements in ignoring BG's. Below is a single pull at 20FPS of a gull over a ~200 degree arc around me over a variety of BG's. Using the 800mm lens, Auto Area AF.
2. They have increased the speed of recognition. Previous releases needed around 0.5 secs to analyse a scene and determine what subject it is going to follow. That delay has largely disappeared.
3. I suspect they have integrated the movement detection functions from previous firmware release into the AF algorithm. Pointing the lens at a tree with a songbird feeding behind branches deepish into the tree, the focus box will go to the shadowy shape moving behind the branches. It may not be able to recognise and focus on the bird but it will hover in that area until it can. I see this also in clear skies when an OOF bird flies across. The AF box immediately goes to the movement even though it could not recognise the shape. I would be interested in views on this - placebo or feasible observation ??!!!

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53241865761_f3ecd0722b_o.png
Oct 07, 2023 at 07:00 PM
JERRY_S
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
I think the FW 4.1 improved quite a lot considering I'm an inexperienced amateur。

I can strongly feel the focus speed and tracking capability gets better.

Before FW 4.1 I didn't trust auto-area focus mode, now I beleive it's quite usable.

Good job Nikon.
Oct 07, 2023 at 07:19 PM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.8 #12Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Alistair1 wrote:
I took it out again this morning. Trying to pin down the tangible changes Nikon have made to the AF system for birds. So far I think I can pinpoint 3:

1. They have made improvements in ignoring BG's. Below is a single pull at 20FPS of a gull over a ~200 degree arc around me over a variety of BG's. Using the 800mm lens, Auto Area AF.
2. They have increased the speed of recognition. Previous releases needed around 0.5 secs to analyse a scene and determine what subject it is going to follow. That delay has largely disappeared.
3. I
...Show more →

I think your description regarding movement is accurate. In fact, I was told a several months ago that next step in Nikon’s AF algorithm was to add movement detection, something that Sony has for awhile now apparently. I also observe focus box hovering over moving blurry blob as you describe.
Oct 07, 2023 at 07:25 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #13Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Quoting myself: "The Z9 is HEAVILY prioritizing extremely high contrast moving targets, which isn't exclusively an expanded bird shape/pose algorithm."

There is most definitely a prioritization of moving, high contrast objects that assists with BIF acquisition. Once the lens focuses, it seems probable that the actual bird shape portion of the algorithm kicks in and takes over if the shape is obvious. That said, this behavior working with dragonflies that look nothing like birds in flight means they are probably prioritizing contrast over shapes for moving targets.

I also believe they have added a predictive element to keeping focus through obstructions based on the object movement speed across the frame/background.
Oct 07, 2023 at 07:27 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
arbitrage wrote:
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I trust you....because your Z9 complaints mirror mine and you use A1 so know where it has always been superior. If this 4.1 has finally got Auto to work like it did on Nikon DSLR and/or A1's Wide then I will think about purchasing a Z9 again and see for myself.

But please tell me you are being sincere because I wasted time and money (well actually not money as I resold for the same as I bought) when people raved about the 3.X FW.

I want the Nikon lenses but need the Z9 to match A1 and to date it just
...Show more →

Personally I would not claim parity with the A1, maybe but it has been too long since I shot one to remember.

But I too would be very interested in your opinion if you were able to borrow or rent a Z9.

Oct 07, 2023 at 08:07 PM
Gary Irwin
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Alistair1 wrote:
arbitrage wrote
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I trust you....because your Z9 complaints mirror mine and you use A1 so know where it has always been superior. If this 4.1 has finally got Auto to work like it did on Nikon DSLR and/or A1's Wide then I will think about purchasing a Z9 again and see for myself.

But please tell me you are being sincere because I wasted time and money (well actually not money as I resold for the same as I bought) when people raved about the 3.X FW.

I want the Nikon lenses but need the Z9 to match A1 and to date it just never has.
Personally I would not claim parity with the A1, maybe but it has been too long since I shot one to remember.

But I too would be very interested in your opinion if you were able to borrow or rent a Z9.



I do remember the A1 and Nikon's AF still can't compete and may never be able to best Sony at the performance margins IMO. But that doesn't mean Nikon's AF isn't good enough -- it is (good enough) for me. But if I was shooting Sony I'd probably sit tight until the A1MK2 is released and to see if Sony finally gets around to releasing some additional wildlife lenses.
Oct 08, 2023 at 07:32 AM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
I was shooting side by side Z9 and Z8 today for a bit. At the moment for birds, auto area with bird detection on Z9 is probably at least as good as wide area-L with animal detection on Z8 (assuming that I got the focus box on the subject immediately), may be even latch onto the bird a little faster even. However, I did not try it on any complex or difficult background
so I wonder if it still beat Z8 with wide area-L or not in that situation.
Oct 08, 2023 at 07:38 AM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
- 9mp EVF, 5mp at 240Hz - 3mp c'mon that's also so '2017'.



let's talk about the EVF.

the criticism towards the Z9 having only 3mp is really dumb by just citing the resolution alone...it's a cheap shot from anyone who favors a competing brand.

what's usually never pointed out that Z9 has no lag (i.e., very low latency), no jitter (frame drop) nor blackout (without using frame substitution!) with and has a very bright EVF and all of these are not compromised even when AF is engaged. i admit that when Z9 was released there were jitters and even early firmware updates didn't fix them but it's flawless now (i think it was since 3.1). i cannot stress enough how important this is (to me) and it clearly shows what's important to Nikon WRT EVF and i'm glad it's in line with what i need. would i have preferred a higher resolution? yes, but not at the expense of brightness and having lag or not absolutely jitter-free. Nikon didn't think that the technology or cost-effectiveness is there yet and i'm totally fine with that.

compare that to Sony A7 IV (which i owned for a significant period) that jitters and drops in resolution when AF is engaged. no Sony hate here but this behavior is so jarring to me especially when shooting moving subjects.

same with Leica SL2. absolutely beautiful EVF but jitters is absolutely way worse and also drops in resolution when AF is engaged. i put up with it because I use it for static/macro subjects most of the time in manual focus.

ninja edit: grammar


Edited on Oct 08, 2023 at 11:04 AM · View previous versions
Oct 08, 2023 at 09:04 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #18Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
dalegaspi wrote:
duncang wrote- 9mp EVF, 5mp at 240Hz - 3mp c'mon that's also so '2017'.
let's talk about the EVF.

the criticism towards the Z9 having only 3mp is really dumb by just citing the resolution alone...it's a cheap shot from anyone who favors a competing brand.

what's usually never pointed out that Z9 has no lag (i.e., very low latency), no jitter (frame drop) nor blackout (without using frame substitution!) with and has a very bright EVF and all of these are not compromised even when AF is engaged. i admit that when Z9 was released there were jitters and even early firmware updates didn't fix them but it's flawless now (i think it was
...Show more →

Careful mentioning the bullet point list of situations the A1 EVF can't perform at max specs

The Sony trolls are well known at this point. Just stop replying to and engaging with them.
Oct 08, 2023 at 09:05 AM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Careful mentioning the bullet point list of situations the A1 EVF can't perform at max specs

The Sony trolls are well known at this point. Just stop replying to and engaging with them.


if it's something to do with AF performance, i don't respond to the criticism/trolling even coming from Nikon owners themselves...because a lot is based on conjecture and rarely based on practical use...which makes it easy to argue in bad faith...so responding to them is an exercise in futility.

but when it comes to something a little more tangible, like in this case the EVF, it's easier to stop Z9/Z8 critics ("OmG EvF is 3Mp OnlY LoL") dead on their tracks.
Oct 08, 2023 at 09:23 AM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/NZ92559_DxO-1.jpg

Just wanted to see how small a bird auto area AF with bird detection will focus

With 800PF.
Oct 08, 2023 at 05:29 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister