fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Z9 Firmware Update 4.10

  
 
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.11 #1Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6655_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6656_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6657_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6684_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6685_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6686_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6687_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6688_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6689_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6690_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6691_DxD.jpg


Seems to be favouring the wing in a few frames when the wing gets into a position where it presents high contrast which is frustrating. It does regain the eye though later in the sequence which 4.0 would seldom do once it lost it. Also in the swallow sequence, focus is regained after being lost for a couple of frames which is an improvement. I have not been able to find any swallows to try it on yet but your tern sequences are consistent with what I am seeing on seabirds.
Oct 11, 2023 at 02:50 AM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #2Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Looks pretty good to me. For reference here are some A1/200-600 images taken at the same time. 30fps and a zoom makes it a little easier and a few more bug shot poses but there is not a lot in it in terms of acquisition, tracking or focus accuracy.

https://duncangroenewald.com/pages/collections/2023-10-11-tern-a1.html

Oct 11, 2023 at 05:25 AM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.11 #3Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
molson wrote:
Eric214 wrote
molson wroteThe new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is ahead of all the other AF modes with SD. After today and 5 days out testing, for me and others I know, there is little doubt Auto Area is king right now.
You're more than welcome to come to my house and try photographing the Anna's hummingbirds in and out of the cedar trees. No matter what AF settings I use, it won't lock onto them in flight - although it will usually snap into focus the instant they land on a perch.


Unfortunately I live in Maryland and Canada is a bit far for me lol. I am not sure why you are having that much of a problem as the new Bird SD has no issue picking up and tracking Tree Swallows for me some 30-35 yards out yesterday
Oct 11, 2023 at 07:21 AM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.11 #4Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
CanadaMark wrote:
Eric214 wrote
CanadaMark wrote
RoamingScott wroteFor the hardheads that insist 4.1 is perfect for birding, here's a screenshot from the above Youtube with a typical Area AF/Bird AF false positive. You can even see it go green when he engages the shutter shortly after this. The entire series with this magpie is a hot mess.

Just as I've described multiple times in detail, high contrast areas can confuse the Bird AF algo for busy, high contrast perched shooting.

As an aside, can anyone explain to me why this dude is purposefully blowing the highlights on every one of his photos? Have to love how he has the histogram on and the highlights are absolutely pegged.
Obviously it's not perfect for birding (nothing is), but I've been trying to replicate the false positives as well as see how far I can push the subject detection and all I can say is that in the scenarios I've been testing it, it has not been a problem. The Z9 seems to be able to lock onto birds even in situations where my own eyes struggle due to either lack of contrast or similar coloring to its surroundings. It also seems to do really well with partial obstructions - even though those images are throwaways, it will stay locked on which is useful in case the bird moves. Here are some examples of some low-contrast birds in busy surroundings and it locks onto the bird without any trouble. I used a mixture of different AF modes:

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-2FLr7X3/0/807670d6/L/i-2FLr7X3-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-GLc5CBn/0/59031114/L/i-GLc5CBn-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NmXRJzh/0/ae01c341/L/i-NmXRJzh-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-WbhxP9p/0/481caf8b/L/i-WbhxP9p-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-rQFbQx9/0/04c18a75/L/i-rQFbQx9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-nDFs7dk/0/b74c3b24/L/i-nDFs7dk-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-gCgm9W2/0/bb2d3982/L/i-gCgm9W2-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-xvfsdSg/0/904b1aeb/L/i-xvfsdSg-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-F4MGjhj/0/f15246a1/L/i-F4MGjhj-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tSWPxQ9/0/7d71762c/L/i-tSWPxQ9-L.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-n8Q4JTJ/0/9897e31b/L/i-n8Q4JTJ-L.jpg

As for your last question, I think maybe he was taking the "ETTR" mentality a little too far Also, frankly, a lot of YouTubers in general confidently talk about things they don't understand while trying to 'educate' people - not sure if that's the case with your example or not, I'm not familiar with that YouTuber.
I am not sure why RomaingScott keeps badgering the point of Auto Area is fault and that Bird SD is giving false positives and that Auto is flawed and such. I have been trying to tell him Auto has been really really good even before FW 2.0 but got better then and 3D was a tad better at that point and the 2 have been equal since 3.10 and now with 4.10 and bird SD, Auto is where you need to be shooting. The Bird SD has given me no false positives yet.

Results are the only thing that matters.
The above examples I posted are mostly, if not all, actually pre-4.1. The Z9's ability to pick out birds in busy scenes, even those where there are distracting high contrast elements, or scenes where there is almost no color differentiation between the bird and its surroundings, has been nothing short of amazing at least in the scenarios I find myself in. I am not seeing the same level of improvement with this FW as some others have (so far anyway) and I think part of the reason is I was simply having fewer issues pre-4.1. If, for example, my hit
...Show more →

Yes, I have been teaching setups and techniques for the Z9 in person and over video calls since Feb 2022 and what i mean by techniques isn't changing what AF to use but how to manipulate the AF system. I also have had zero issues with Auto Area AF modes even back on fW1.10. Though since FW3.0 till 4.01 3D was a smidgen better. With FW 4.10, and Bird SD, Auto Area is unquestionably better in ever scenario i have shot the 5 days shooting since the update. The difference pre 4.10 and now is I don't have to manipulate the AF system and don't need multiple AF modes. I literally can just use Auto Area AF mode in every scene and immediately acquire focus and track. I was also in the 90% hit or in focus rate prior to the FW4.10 update. it is higher now no doubt.

I agree and have been saying all along that there is no real difference in the flagships, Z9, A1, R5/R3 there isn't anything one can get the other can't and all miss the same type shots as well if you know how to use the camera. Granted the Z9 took a little more behind the camera to achieve, this is no longer the case.

YouTuber's I generally take with a grain of salt. I use them for specific things I am looking for and completely ignore their opinions. Most with videos on a Z9 you can see aren't even using the right settings most of the time from their Atomos recordings. They never spend enough time time to truly use the camera.

I am also not saying Scott isn't seeing what he's seeing but there must be a reason is all. Shooting with my friend Dave who put the YouTube video up about the FW4.10 channel is Knight's and Weekends that someone linked here. He has had trouble with the Z9 since he got his back in 1st or 2nd batch. We would switch cameras mine with the 800PF and his Z9 with the 600f4TC. There was a difference between the 2 and he reinstalled the current FW at the time (last December) and it improved for him but wasn't still like mine. We switched again and I had no issues and he has issues with my gear. So there is something about the user.

But in the end, you need to shoot with works for you and the settings that work well for you. I always say this. I just got the feeling Scott wasn't even trying AA AF with the new FW and Bird SD because of his past experiences with it.
Oct 11, 2023 at 07:46 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #5Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
I just got the feeling Scott wasn't even trying AA AF with the new FW and Bird SD because of his past experiences with it.


I really can't be any more clear in my posts about this topic. If I dumb my posts down anymore, I'm the one that starts looking dumb. How many times must I say I am using Area with Bird AF before you believe me

I have posted screenshots from youtubes where others are having the exact same issue. Really couldn't care less if YOU aren't seeing it because your use case is, as you admitted, completely different when it comes to birds than what I'm describing. I have also confirmed that I’m finding 4.1 in flight detection to be as stellar as you claim. It wasn’t always for me with my 100-400 with 1.4x on.

About a year ago I compared notes with Mark about how my Z9 was set up in regards to animal AF for birding. Not surprisingly, I'd mostly come to all the same conclusions he had and our settings were roughly the same.

Given that, where is there possibly room for "user error" when the test is:

- Set Z9 to Area AF
- Set detection mode to bird
- Half press shutter when a non-obstructred stationary bird is in the frame among high contrast foliage (extremely common perched scenario)

That's as dead simple of a control test as you can get. If the camera has a bird taking up 15% of the frame and the white subject detection box chooses a bright leaf instead of the bird, the Bird AF system has failed, not the user.

Does it happen more than half the time? Nope. But when it does, it can be an actual struggle to shake the false positive and get the camera to realize there IS a bird on the other side of the frame, especially if you're trying to hold a certain composition.

It could totally be my lens choice, or even possibly the 1.4x TC. Who knows.
Oct 11, 2023 at 07:57 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.11 #6Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
molson wrote
Eric214 wrote
molson wroteThe new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is ahead of all the other AF modes with SD. After today and 5 days out testing, for me and others I know, there is little doubt Auto Area is king right now.
You're more than welcome to come to my house and try photographing the Anna's hummingbirds in and out of the cedar trees. No matter what AF settings I use, it won't lock onto them in flight - although it will usually snap into focus the instant they land on a perch.
Unfortunately I live in Maryland and Canada is a bit far for me lol. I am not sure why you are having that much of a problem as the new Bird SD has no issue picking up and tracking Tree Swallows for me some 30-35 yards out yesterday


I think the birds that are much closer (3-4 yards) are more challenging because the DOF is so shallow , and I also think the lenses have a harder time making quick adjustments because it takes a greater degree of movement in the focusing elements in that part of the focusing range. I have (anecdotally) noticed that the AF performance at really short distances improves a bit if I have a short extension tube attached.

It's not that the Z8/Z9 can't focus on these birds, but I find it a bit frustrating that a $1000 camera, that almost everyone trashes as having the worst AF system on the market, can often do a better job...






  NIKON Z 8    NIKKOR Z 400mm f/4.5 VR S lens    400mm    f/4.5    1/400s    2000 ISO    -0.3 EV  

Oct 11, 2023 at 08:31 AM
ilkka_nissila
Offline
Details
p.11 #7Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
I'm wondering if it would help to use focus+release priority as in that case the camera makes more of an effort to achieve successful focus on the first frame of the sequence.

Very short distances can be challenging for AF for sure.

The Micro Four Thirds camera has in this instance the advantage of a shorter focal length which means the lens can move the focus group by a shorter distance which can be achieved faster than with a longer lens on an FX camera.

Small subjects are an area where smaller sensors have advantages. There is no reason to have to justify using the gear that works best for a situation; simply use each camera setup where it excels. Macro and close-up subjects are great to shoot with DX and MFT.


molson wrote:
CanadaMark wrote
molson wrote
Eric214 wrote
molson wroteThe new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is ahead of all the other AF modes with SD. After today and 5 days out testing, for me and others I know, there is little doubt Auto Area is king right now.
You're more than welcome to come to my house and try photographing the Anna's hummingbirds in and out of the cedar trees. No matter what AF settings I use, it won't lock onto them in flight - although it will usually snap into focus the instant they land on a perch.
I don't know my birds well enough to know if this is the same species of hummingbird, but I have no issues tracking humming birds in flight darting in and out of trees on pre-4.1 FW - should have probably used a faster shutter speed though

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-jGFfnbw/0/d3ae51fc/L/i-jGFfnbw-L.jpg
https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NzM5SzF/0/fbe622c0/L/i-NzM5SzF-L.jpg
It looks like you have lots of light there, so focusing should be fairly easy. I'm normally having to shoot at ISO 3200, 6400, or higher.

My Panasonic G9 can handle shots like this with no issues. With the Z9 I can fire off a hundred shots without it ever locking focus, under the exact same conditions. As soon as the bird lands, the Z9 finally recognizes it and locks focus instantly.

Same bird, same location, much different results:

Oct 11, 2023 at 09:21 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.11 #8Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
I really can't be any more clear in my posts about this topic. If I dumb my posts down anymore, I'm the one that starts looking dumb. How many times must I say I am using Area with Bird AF before you believe me

I have posted screenshots from youtubes where others are having the exact same issue. Really couldn't care less if YOU aren't seeing it because your use case is, as you admitted, completely different when it comes to birds than what I'm describing. I have also confirmed that I’m finding 4.1 in flight detection to be as
...Show more →

Even on the Sony A1 which is said by many to be the benchmark in Wide Area AF, this technique would lead to a high number for misses and false AF subjects like leaves.

Wide Area AF with subject detection is not the best mode to pick birds out of small holes in branches. That is anomalous to a sniper trying to make a shot through a small window with a shotgun. A sniper would never make such a choice. A more precise mode will likely preform better.

On my A1 I have two modes I can toggle on and off. Each configures the camera and all of its setting for exactly these kinds of situations. One uses Wide Area AF with subject detection (birds), a fast shutter speed, fast frame rate, max aperture, and high ISO. This is for fast moving subjects (lile BIF) without or few obstacles in front of the subject. The other i cal "sniper mode". It uses a spot area, a slow shutter speed, slow frame rate, max aperture, and low ISO. This is designed to produce the highest precision in picking out the subject, and the highest IQ with the lower ISO. I can toggle back and forth between these modes instantly with the push of a button. When I lift off the button the camera instantly reverts to whatever setup I had prior to pushing the button. This shas worked well for me.

I recognize that this will not be directly repeatable in the Nikon Z8/9 cameras due to differences in customization features. But it is probably possible to get something very close. As the Nikon AF system gets closer to the A1 in such things as Wide Area AF with subject tracking, some of the techniques that have been developed over the last few years may be useful for Z users. I am not saying one system is better than the other. Only that as the features are getting somewhat closer in concept, work flow may also get closer in practice. I expect that differences will remain. But variations on a theme will likely be applicable.
Oct 11, 2023 at 09:38 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #9Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Of course you can have multiple AF size boxes available at the press of a button, that's functionality 101.

I posted this example early in the thread. This is NOT what I'd consider a "sniper" perched shot. The bird shape is completely unobstructed down to the shoulders, the eye is directly lit, there is a nice buffer around the head, and here's the thing...Area AF did find the head, obviously.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53237204435_99a5fa846d_o.jpg

The problem is it also thought the orange leaf on the far left edge of the frame was a bird and so it kept jumping between the two, racking focus every time. Eventually, I just hit my 3D Tracking override when it jumped to the bird so that the focus would no longer move around.

If I'd used Wide L or Wide S, I wouldn't have had this issue at all.

And yet, I keep getting told by know-nothings that this behavior is all in my head or is "user error" despite my still camera shooting a still subject with little extra movement in frame. My goal was to test Area to see if it was a good as claimed. It's not, for perched birds, in certain scenarios. Shocking.
Oct 11, 2023 at 09:54 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.11 #10Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
molson wrote:
CanadaMark wrote
molson wrote
Eric214 wrote
molson wroteThe new bird detection does seem to perform better overall, but it still struggles with backlit subjects and with smaller birds in front of very busy backgrounds (but then so do most other systems).
I had no issues today with it tracking Tree Swallows 30-35 yards out in front of brown reeds and the tree line in the background. I disabled the shutter AF and put the default AF mode to Auto Area and also on my AF ON button in Bird SD. No matter how OOF they were, the Auto Area AF mode just snapped on to the swallows faster then any of the Wide Area AF modes used to.

I would assume at this point everyone is or should be trying Auto Area AF mode with the new Bird SD. Auto Area is ahead of all the other AF modes with SD. After today and 5 days out testing, for me and others I know, there is little doubt Auto Area is king right now.
You're more than welcome to come to my house and try photographing the Anna's hummingbirds in and out of the cedar trees. No matter what AF settings I use, it won't lock onto them in flight - although it will usually snap into focus the instant they land on a perch.
I don't know my birds well enough to know if this is the same species of hummingbird, but I have no issues tracking humming birds in flight darting in and out of trees on pre-4.1 FW - should have probably used a faster shutter speed though

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-jGFfnbw/0/d3ae51fc/L/i-jGFfnbw-L.jpg
https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-NzM5SzF/0/fbe622c0/L/i-NzM5SzF-L.jpg
It looks like you have lots of light there, so focusing should be fairly easy. I'm normally having to shoot at ISO 3200, 6400, or higher.

My Panasonic G9 can handle shots like this with no issues. With the Z9 I can fire off a hundred shots without it ever locking focus, under the exact same conditions. As soon as the bird lands, the Z9 finally recognizes it and locks focus instantly.

Same bird, same location, much different results:


I was shooting into a shaded tree with strong backlighting (into the sun), looks like I used ISO 1000, 1/1600, F5.6. 3D AF. If I needed ISO 3200 due to it being a bit darker, frankly I don't think that would have made any difference at all, I am often shooting around ISO 6400 in similar situations. Hard to say for sure.

What AF mode were you using? Maybe try 3D or Auto Area with blocked shot response set to zero. Also if you are having trouble with backlit subjects, remember that the camera uses what you see in the EVF to AF, so make sure you have your exposure set such that the subject is clearly visible and not a silhouette. For the same reason I also dial in some extra sharpness to the picture control, there is some evidence to suggest that helps a bit because your picture control settings are applied to the EVF.
Oct 11, 2023 at 10:29 AM
reggieb
Offline
Details
p.11 #11Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Anyone else notice a massive uptick in the standby battery drain when they did the update? I think it was the download when off option for me, I don't know if I had previously turned that off and the update ticked it back on, or if it's some software change. Either way, I went on a trip without my charger with the fam, because 3 batteries would easily last me the 4 day weekend just doing family photos.

Literally went through 2 batteries the first day, glad I can do in camera charging. But after I changed that setting it seemed to settle back down and I didn't drain single battery in the next 3 days (though I was topping batteries off at the room whenever I had a chance).
Oct 11, 2023 at 10:31 AM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.11 #12Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Of course you can have multiple AF size boxes available at the press of a button, that's functionality 101.

I posted this example early in the thread. This is NOT what I'd consider a "sniper" perched shot. The bird shape is completely unobstructed down to the shoulders, the eye is directly lit, there is a nice buffer around the head, and here's the thing...Area AF did find the head, obviously.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53237204435_99a5fa846d_o.jpg

The problem is it also thought the orange leaf on the far left edge of the frame was a bird and so it kept jumping between the two, racking focus every time.
...Show more →

We'll a lot of most of the "know-nothings" aren't seeing the same thing as you are and having none of the issues you are. So it works as claimed, just not for apparently.

We'll just leave it at that

Edited on Oct 11, 2023 at 01:22 PM · View previous versions
Oct 11, 2023 at 01:18 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #13Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
Will just leave it at that


Considering you've offered nothing of value to this conversation thus far, I see this as a good thing
Oct 11, 2023 at 01:21 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.11 #14Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Of course you can have multiple AF size boxes available at the press of a button, that's functionality 101.

I posted this example early in the thread. This is NOT what I'd consider a "sniper" perched shot. The bird shape is completely unobstructed down to the shoulders, the eye is directly lit, there is a nice buffer around the head, and here's the thing...Area AF did find the head, obviously.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53237204435_99a5fa846d_o.jpg

The problem is it also thought the orange leaf on the far left edge of the frame was a bird and so it kept jumping between the two, racking focus every time.
...Show more →


Why not post a full frame un-cropped version of this frame so we can see the challenges the subject detection algorithm faced in context. The size of the subject in the context of the entire frame likely has a significant impact on results.

What is really at issue is not what one thinks things should be, but what they are. Then the attention switches to how to handle the issues.

My A1 solution addresses many more things that just the size of the AF Area Box.
Oct 11, 2023 at 02:50 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #15Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
RoamingScott wroteOf course you can have multiple AF size boxes available at the press of a button, that's functionality 101.

I posted this example early in the thread. This is NOT what I'd consider a "sniper" perched shot. The bird shape is completely unobstructed down to the shoulders, the eye is directly lit, there is a nice buffer around the head, and here's the thing...Area AF did find the head, obviously.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53237204435_99a5fa846d_o.jpg

The problem is it also thought the orange leaf on the far left edge of the frame was a bird and so it kept jumping between the two, racking focus every time. Eventually, I just hit my 3D Tracking override when it jumped to the bird so that the focus would no longer move around.

If I'd used Wide L or Wide S, I wouldn't have had this issue at all.

And yet, I keep getting told by know-nothings that this behavior is all in my head or is "user error" despite my still camera shooting a still subject with little extra movement in frame. My goal was to test Area to see if it was a good as claimed. It's not, for perched birds, in certain scenarios. Shocking.
We'll a lot of most of the "know-nothings" aren't seeing the same thing as you are and having none of the issues you are. So it works as claimed, just not for apparently.

We'll just leave it at that


Why is it people have to claim - "you're the only one having the issue" - when quite clearly that is not the case. I already posted that I was seeing many false positives, rs mentioned many examples of others where he had seen the same. Steve Perry mentioned it.

I recall not so long ago a Z9 user claimed they have never experienced the small bird in the foreground focus problem under discussion and implied that it was another case of user error, or just didn't know how to use the camera.

This is another case where your claim that you and these others have never experienced this issue is simply not plausible.

As rs has pointed out there is simply now way this can be user error.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6262_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6263_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6264_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/Z9-focus-miss.png
Oct 11, 2023 at 04:15 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.11 #16Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
Eric214 wrote
RoamingScott wroteOf course you can have multiple AF size boxes available at the press of a button, that's functionality 101.

I posted this example early in the thread. This is NOT what I'd consider a "sniper" perched shot. The bird shape is completely unobstructed down to the shoulders, the eye is directly lit, there is a nice buffer around the head, and here's the thing...Area AF did find the head, obviously.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53237204435_99a5fa846d_o.jpg

The problem is it also thought the orange leaf on the far left edge of the frame was a bird and so it kept jumping between the two, racking focus every time. Eventually, I just hit my 3D Tracking override when it jumped to the bird so that the focus would no longer move around.

If I'd used Wide L or Wide S, I wouldn't have had this issue at all.

And yet, I keep getting told by know-nothings that this behavior is all in my head or is "user error" despite my still camera shooting a still subject with little extra movement in frame. My goal was to test Area to see if it was a good as claimed. It's not, for perched birds, in certain scenarios. Shocking.
We'll a lot of most of the "know-nothings" aren't seeing the same thing as you are and having none of the issues you are. So it works as claimed, just not for apparently.

We'll just leave it at that
Why is it people have to claim - "you're the only one having the issue" - when quite clearly that is not the case. I already posted that I was seeing many false positives, rs mentioned many examples of others where he had seen the same. Steve Perry mentioned it.

I recall not so long ago a Z9 user claimed they have never experienced the small bird in the foreground focus problem under discussion and implied that it was another case of user error, or just didn't know how to use the camera.

This is another case where your claim that you
...Show more →

I did say that a lot or most right? Not all, and it's never going to be perfect like I also said. But the misses are extremely far and few between overall and some scenes will still prove to be difficult but nothing like it was prior and I mean for all cameras.

You can think it's not plausible, but I am only giving my experience. I have seen the foreground focus issue but has been overall rare, I never said I never see that but overall one of the AF modes usually overcame that for me making it generally a non issue. That was also an issues with DSLR's to a small degree. There were times if so far OOF you had to point the D850 or the D500 to the ground and then back up and it would grab focus. This just wasn't small birds or foreground birds either.

I also asked if any of the people mentioning they have these issues if they tried resetting the camera and reinstalling the FW but no one has replied that I noticed.
Oct 11, 2023 at 04:34 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #17Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
duncang wrote
Eric214 wrote
RoamingScott wroteOf course you can have multiple AF size boxes available at the press of a button, that's functionality 101.

I posted this example early in the thread. This is NOT what I'd consider a "sniper" perched shot. The bird shape is completely unobstructed down to the shoulders, the eye is directly lit, there is a nice buffer around the head, and here's the thing...Area AF did find the head, obviously.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53237204435_99a5fa846d_o.jpg

The problem is it also thought the orange leaf on the far left edge of the frame was a bird and so it kept jumping between the two, racking focus every time. Eventually, I just hit my 3D Tracking override when it jumped to the bird so that the focus would no longer move around.

If I'd used Wide L or Wide S, I wouldn't have had this issue at all.

And yet, I keep getting told by know-nothings that this behavior is all in my head or is "user error" despite my still camera shooting a still subject with little extra movement in frame. My goal was to test Area to see if it was a good as claimed. It's not, for perched birds, in certain scenarios. Shocking.
We'll a lot of most of the "know-nothings" aren't seeing the same thing as you are and having none of the issues you are. So it works as claimed, just not for apparently.

We'll just leave it at that
Why is it people have to claim - "you're the only one having the issue" - when quite clearly that is not the case. I already posted that I was seeing many false positives, rs mentioned many examples of others where he had seen the same. Steve Perry mentioned it.

I recall not so long ago a Z9 user claimed they have never experienced the small bird in the foreground focus problem under discussion and implied that it was another case of user error, or just didn't know how to use the camera.

This is another case where your claim that you and these others have never experienced this issue is simply not plausible.

As rs has pointed out there is simply now way this can be user error.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6262_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6263_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6264_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/Z9-focus-miss.png
I did say that a lot or most right? Not all, and it's never going to be perfect like I also said. But the misses are extremely far and few between overall and some scenes will still prove to be difficult but nothing like it was prior and I mean for all cameras.

You can think it's not plausible, but I am only giving my experience. I have seen the foreground focus issue but has been overall rare, I never said I never see that but overall one of the AF modes usually overcame that for me making it generally a
...Show more →

Well your wording was "having NONE of the issues you describe" and "just not for you apparently". Now that very clearly is implying something wrong with the camera man as no one else is having the issue.

And here you are also completely ignoring the fact that RS has reference others with the same problem as if they simply don't exist. You're also ignoring completely my post and Steve Perry's comments describing what seems to be the same sort of issue.

Now I don't mean to offend but this seems like you are denying reality by purposely excluding all these examples and trying s little too hard to live in some kind of bubble - the tune "living in a yellow submarine" has now started playing in the background.. never mind, just Alexa or Siri being too smart for their own good - reading my posts again I guess <sigh>

If what you meant to say is "experiencing it very infrequently such that it is not a problem for us" - as you appear to have just done then that is saying a very different thing.

In my experience it happens and it happens far more frequently than one would expect it should in both the old and the new FW. It is not something I have experienced with other cameras, and no I haven't tried them all, but enough to be surprised at the frequency with which I have encountered it on the Z8/Z9.

Sure there are work arounds but, as my friend and I have both found - it is nearly impossible for us to see that the focus has just missed when reviewing images in the camera (the low resolution evf I dislike) while in the field. The focus box appears to be spot on and the images look sharpish but when reviewing on computer it turns out the focus has missed the subject.

So the issue becomes - how can one reliably be sure you have nailed to focus when in the field if you can't rely on Bird detect ?

I have a solution to that which doesn't involve a Z8 or Z9 but I am interested to see how my friend fares because he has all his eggs in one basket, so to speak.

As for reset or FW reinstalls - if it were only one person who experienced this you might think there may be a camera specific problem, but the minute there are multiple reports one can only really conclude this is a feature on them all.

Also resetting would only really be a consideration if the problem only starts manifesting itself over time. In my experience that is not the case - under certain conditions it seems to happened quite consistently from the get go.

Firmware installs are usually all or nothing affairs. There are software and hardware level checks to ensure the firmware is not corrupted before or during installation so it is very unlikely a FW reinstall would fix anything like this. You may patch a corrupt configuration file with a reinstallation of the FW but it is a little unclear how this problem could be the result of a corrupt configuration file.

And given I have experienced this with the exact same subject on both the Z8 and Z9 with FW4.1 is seems it's just a feature of the subject detection in both cameras.

In general I would say that mirrorless subject detection gets a little confused in very bright conditions - the stilt was in early morning light but rather over exposed because I had just been focussing on a bird in a shaded area.

Here is another example, which I think I posted elsewhere already but to me the left post looks to be the one that is clearly in focus, but the focus box is bang on the right post and the right post is clearly out of focus.

The possibility that this is caused by user error seems unlikely. Camera is set to focus priority as well.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Z8-180-600/DSC_0858_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Z8-180-600/DSC_0858.NEF

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Z8-180-600/Z8-focus-issue.png

Bottom line is rather than pretend the problem doesn't exist, give feedback to Nikon and with any luck they will improve it over time.
Oct 11, 2023 at 09:32 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.11 #18Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
Eric214 wrote
duncang wrote
Eric214 wrote
RoamingScott wroteOf course you can have multiple AF size boxes available at the press of a button, that's functionality 101.

I posted this example early in the thread. This is NOT what I'd consider a "sniper" perched shot. The bird shape is completely unobstructed down to the shoulders, the eye is directly lit, there is a nice buffer around the head, and here's the thing...Area AF did find the head, obviously.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53237204435_99a5fa846d_o.jpg

The problem is it also thought the orange leaf on the far left edge of the frame was a bird and so it kept jumping between the two, racking focus every time. Eventually, I just hit my 3D Tracking override when it jumped to the bird so that the focus would no longer move around.

If I'd used Wide L or Wide S, I wouldn't have had this issue at all.

And yet, I keep getting told by know-nothings that this behavior is all in my head or is "user error" despite my still camera shooting a still subject with little extra movement in frame. My goal was to test Area to see if it was a good as claimed. It's not, for perched birds, in certain scenarios. Shocking.
We'll a lot of most of the "know-nothings" aren't seeing the same thing as you are and having none of the issues you are. So it works as claimed, just not for apparently.

We'll just leave it at that
Why is it people have to claim - "you're the only one having the issue" - when quite clearly that is not the case. I already posted that I was seeing many false positives, rs mentioned many examples of others where he had seen the same. Steve Perry mentioned it.

I recall not so long ago a Z9 user claimed they have never experienced the small bird in the foreground focus problem under discussion and implied that it was another case of user error, or just didn't know how to use the camera.

This is another case where your claim that you and these others have never experienced this issue is simply not plausible.

As rs has pointed out there is simply now way this can be user error.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6262_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6263_DxD.jpg
https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/DSC_6264_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-11/Z9-focus-miss.png
I did say that a lot or most right? Not all, and it's never going to be perfect like I also said. But the misses are extremely far and few between overall and some scenes will still prove to be difficult but nothing like it was prior and I mean for all cameras.

You can think it's not plausible, but I am only giving my experience. I have seen the foreground focus issue but has been overall rare, I never said I never see that but overall one of the AF modes usually overcame that for me making it generally a non issue. That was also an issues with DSLR's to a small degree. There were times if so far OOF you had to point the D850 or the D500 to the ground and then back up and it would grab focus. This just wasn't small birds or foreground birds either.

I also asked if any of the people mentioning they have these issues if they tried resetting the camera and reinstalling the FW but no one has replied that I noticed.
Well your wording was "having NONE of the issues you describe" and "just not for you apparently". Now that very clearly is implying something wrong with the camera man as no one else is having the issue.

And here you are also completely ignoring the fact that RS has reference others with the same problem as if they simply don't exist. You're also ignoring completely my post and Steve Perry's comments describing what seems to be the same sort of issue.

Now I don't mean to offend but this seems like you are denying reality by purposely excluding all these
...Show more →

And I have not to this point. I am not having issues with acquiring and tracking with busy backgrounds in AA AF. I am in 3D with the new Bird SD mode. I have had days of 900+ images with 3 missed focus image total. I have had another day out with 110 images in AA AF mode with 23 missed focus image and the same day shot 1000 images in 3D in Bird SD mode with 92 missed focus images.

So is it perfect? No, but a hit rate like 1000 images and 23 missed focus and 900 with only 3.... I will say I am not seeing any troubles with AA AF mode in Bird SD mode.
Oct 11, 2023 at 09:42 PM
reggieb
Offline
Details
p.11 #19Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Man, Eric and Scott, you two should get a room. There are many factors that could lead to the fact that you're seeing different results. A few off the top of my head:

1. Different environments wherein Scott's foliage is more difficult for the algorithm to handle for one reason or another
2. Different standards for critical focus
3. Model to model variation - or some piece of corrupted data in Scott's camera
4. One of you just fanbois harder than the other

I am sure I am missing some, but I think you've both made your positions and reasons for them abundantly clear. Must be rainy days where you guys are sitting.
Oct 12, 2023 at 08:54 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #20Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
reggieb wrote:
One of you just fanbois harder than the other


I'm not the one with "Nikon" in my IG handle sooooooooo
Oct 12, 2023 at 09:14 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister