fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?

  
 
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #1Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
gear-nut wrote:
I've shared this image elsewhere on the forum, but figure this a good place to repeat it. I really enjoy this lens on my camera as my "walk around at night" lens while traveling -- no other gear carried, just this lens on the body. I grabbed this snap in the town of Oban at night when we were there back in July. It's handheld at ISO 25,000. (As a side note, a lot of folks complain about the Z9 noise -- I personally don't find it that bad at all even here at 25K, but respect YMMV):


I'm really struggling to understand what this photo is trying to prove.
Oct 11, 2023 at 08:31 AM
akul
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
It kind of does prove how this lens is so small, can go anywhere with you, and capable with a certain character that some of us find its images to be even attractive. Also, interestingly, I tend to be attracted to their night shots, both DeltaSigma, and gear-nut. May be it is the film noir ,or may be it is the combination of the lens, what the lens allows (to carry. Always), and the mood, or the story it captures.

Edited for error correction.

Luka

Edited on Oct 15, 2023 at 08:04 PM · View previous versions
Oct 11, 2023 at 08:04 PM
BSPhotog
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I'll add to this a bit, as a big fan of 50mm-ish lenses as a whole. The 50mm f/1.8S was my first Z lens, purchased as a pre-order with my original Z6. It replaced my Sigma Art 50, which I feel it shares a lot with in terms of look and performance. I bought the 40 when it came out, and sold it after a few months. It was slower and less sure-footed to focus. When the SE version came out, I bought it again. Maybe becuase it is more handsome, but I like it better now than the first time around. I think the speed and assertiveness of the AF is better with the Z6II/7II generation bodies than the first gen, but there is still a noticable difference from the 50 f/1.8S.

The 40 is a $200 used lens all the time, so it is a pretty low-risk experiment if you want to buy and sell if you don't enjoy.
Oct 12, 2023 at 02:33 PM
DeltaSigma
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
akul wrote:
RoamingScott wroteInteresting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- has no fluorine coating, which is an odd choice for a lens that is meant to be carried everywhere, especially with its weather sealed designation
- tends to have nervous bokeh
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
This lens is a bit of mystery to me. I have seen samples matches your criticism, but I also have seen images that just draws me in. Samples from Scott ( Digital Sigma) or gearnut come to my mind. It could be purely their style of photographies that draws out characters, but not for others, While, I don’t see any room for this lens in my setup, and my style of shooting probably only exasperate its weakness, but I keep enjoying seeing shots that amazse me and go ‘hmm’ .

My 2 cents.

Luka


Hi Luka,
Did you perhaps mean me? (Deltasigma)
I don't have any top end modern gear so cannot comment on the cons of the 40/2 relative to the 50/1.8
All I can say is that I own it and use it. Since I shoot a lot of MF Nikkors the relatively compact Z lens does what I want it to do and fulfills my needs for a small light, unobtrusive AF lens when I am wandering the streets at night. An album of some shots is here if anyone is interested.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/deltasigma/albums/72157720045197860

Colin (a Scot)
Oct 15, 2023 at 11:32 AM
akul
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
DeltaSigma wrote:
akul wrote
RoamingScott wroteInteresting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- has no fluorine coating, which is an odd choice for a lens that is meant to be carried everywhere, especially with its weather sealed designation
- tends to have nervous bokeh
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
This lens is a bit of mystery to me. I have seen samples matches your criticism, but I also have seen images that just draws me in. Samples from Scott ( Digital Sigma) or gearnut come to my mind. It could be purely their style of photographies that draws out characters, but not for others, While, I don’t see any room for this lens in my setup, and my style of shooting probably only exasperate its weakness, but I keep enjoying seeing shots that amazse me and go ‘hmm’ .

My 2 cents.

Luka
Hi Luka,
Did you perhaps mean me? (Deltasigma)
I don't have any top end modern gear so cannot comment on the cons of the 40/2 relative to the 50/1.8
All I can say is that I own it and use it. Since I shoot a lot of MF Nikkors the relatively compact Z lens does what I want it to do and fulfills my needs for a small light, unobtrusive AF lens when I am wandering the streets at night. An album of some shots is here if anyone is interested.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/deltasigma/albums/72157720045197860

Colin (a Scot)


Colin,



First off,sSorry! Yes I meant you. Corrected my previous posts..

Thank you for the Flickr link. I love those shots.


Luka
Oct 15, 2023 at 08:06 PM
aerospace99
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
gear-nut wrote:
There’s no argument the 50/1.8 is the better lens optically, but it’s so good it’s almost clinical in the way it renders. The 40 is a simpler design, rendering in a rounder, more classical way. And then there’s just something unique about the 40 focal length that differentiates it from the 35 or 50; it’s hard to define unless you’ve used it and seen it for yourself...


I picked up the 40 based on some reviews and my own impressions of the "almost clinical" look on the 50 1.8S you mentioned. I have been going back and forth on the 58 1.4G and the 50 1.8S but decided that the slightly wider 40 paired with the 58 would be a nice (normal lens combo). The 50 1.8S is a very capable, best bang for the buck offering but I find deep down I gravitate towards the character side of the optical equation. It is a very subtle thing, kind of hard to explain.
Oct 28, 2023 at 02:07 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Yup. I use the 40 and 58 combo myself. Regardless, folks that like the clinically clean look, will prefer the Z 50 — it’s outstanding optically.
Oct 28, 2023 at 07:40 AM
aerospace99
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
gear-nut wrote:
Yup. I use the 40 and 58 combo myself. Regardless, folks that like the clinically clean look, will prefer the Z 50 — it’s outstanding optically.


I did not make the decision easily. The 50 1.8 is a very good lens. But I wanted to limit my indecision. The 58 was going no where but sometime I needed something a bit wider. I am warming up to the 40mm focal length.


Oct 28, 2023 at 03:41 PM
runamuck
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
My problem is I vacillate between artsy and clinical. Now I have both. I use the 40 more but I always have the 50 nearby.
Oct 28, 2023 at 04:07 PM
scalanc2
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I have both but I’m selling the 50.
Perfect and clinical but limited soul.
Jan 05, 2024 at 12:25 PM
rick-reno
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I have both. 50 is sharper, but the 40 lives on my Zf. it’s compact and the differences in IQ just aren’t that great,
Jan 06, 2024 at 09:28 AM
TCinFL
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Interesting read. I’m definitely not a pro but the first time I bought the 40 f2 (for a Z6ii) I sold it. It was blah wide open and close. It wasn’t an ‘attractive’ lens. Fast forward and I picked up a Zf and 40 f2 as well as the Z 50 1.8. The 40 was definitely more fun. The 50 was more razor sharp. The more I used the Zf the more I left the 50 at home. The 40 is fun. I am not advanced enough to know clinical vs ‘not’. The images from the 40 aren’t as sharp but have a look I enjoy. That look seems to be exacerbated when using the Dream profile. I’ve come to love the 40. The 50 went back. I don’t miss it. Loving the images from my Zf/40 combo.
Jan 23, 2024 at 10:13 PM
aerospace99
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Agree on interesting read. The 40 has loads of character to be sure and has a retro look and feel. A little erratic on close focus results and eye focus in low light is not so hot. The 50 blows it away on that score. There is a lot of coma on this lens as well but if makes for some interesting shots. I did decide however to return to a Zeiss Distagon 35 F2 for my character shots in this focal length. The microcontrast characteristic of that lens is remarkable. Provides a nice offset to the more "clinical: 50 1.8S. The 40 on a Zf is got to be a nice combination I would imagine.
Jan 24, 2024 at 03:35 AM
baneand
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Another vote from me to 40 f2. Stopped carrying the 50 around when I did some comparison shots, it all comes down to if you are missing something with your old lens when get to the new one. I am now considering Voigtlander 50 1f for the slower shooting situations.
Jan 24, 2024 at 04:20 AM
roybenjey
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Picked up the 40mm today. Excited to give it a try.
Jul 22, 2024 at 01:57 PM
chatcher
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
The 50 is built better, as well as being heavier, bulkier, more expensive, and better corrected. The 40 feels cheap and “plasticky”. But the combination of small size and pleasing results make the 40 my favorite Nikkor Z lens. I have all the 1.8 Z primes, including the Plena. They are all good, but the lowly 40 remains my favorite for everyday use.
Jul 22, 2024 at 02:13 PM
PixiPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
If you aren't pixel peeping, the 40mm 4/2 is nice, fast, sharp enough, smaller, lighter, and cheaper. The 50mm 1.8 as everyone said is just stupid sharp, its still light. In the end, it's $190 vs $400. I was in the same boat, but because I've had the 50mm 1.8 S a few times, I went with the 50mm 1.8 because of its optical quality.
Jul 22, 2024 at 02:19 PM
Adamwilbert
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I’m curious how you find the 28 compared to the 40 in terms of image quality. I grabbed both the 40 and the 50 (I’m usually a 35 guy but was waiting to see the 35 1.4) and have been very impressed with the 50. The 40 is great for size, but like you’re saying I almost feel like I could get the 28 instead of the 40 if the iq is decent wide open.

Nwright09 wrote:
I owned both at the same time so I could evaluate them side by side. Can you swing this by utilizing return policies or renting?

I ended up going with the 50mm 1.8 because I felt that the added sharpness and additional 10mm of focal length helped provide just a touch more "pop" to my images - especially of people. Also I found 50mm gapped better with the 28mm prime I already had than 40mm.

Both lenses are great options but only you can determine which one makes the most sense for you given your situation.

Build quality and sharpness for
...Show more →
Jul 22, 2024 at 03:08 PM
KLaban
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I have the Z 40mm f/2, the Z 50mm f/1,8 and the 58mm f/1.4 G + FTZ.

The 40 is used when I need to be discrete and the 58 when I don't. The 50 sees the least use.

I also have the Voigtlander 40mm f/1.2 in Nikon Z Mount for when I need to be discrete.

I also have two other normal range primes, a fetish perhaps?
Jul 22, 2024 at 03:09 PM
itai195
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I’d rather have the 50. Just don’t find the 40 very interesting. Cheap and small, yes.
Jul 22, 2024 at 05:42 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister