GreenRay wrote: Danpbphoto wroteJames Markus wroteDan, there is bit of a learning curve to IR.
#1-Autofocus is usually off - even if calibrated. Some services will calibrate for a particular lens. Therefore, manual focus is really the best way to go. Some MF lenses have a red dot near infinity focus to approximate where infinity is in the infrared spectrum. With my 5D I had to chimp for focus, and exposure, but once you have it nailed it works well. Otherwise, I would get a camera that has excellent live view with almost no lag to the rear screen
#2-some lenses are not good at IR. They generate "hot shots" usually in the middle of the frame, and worsen as you stop down. Almost all my Nikkor lenses work great at any f-stop, but I do have one that has stellar performance in the visible light spectrum, but makes hot spots in IR. A separate F-ring is a big plus for me.
#3-Generating a white balance profile is done a number of ways. I initially followed Robert Reiser's tutorial using Adobe's free DNG profile editor. There are some really wacky colors in IR, but I prefer the black and white profiles I created. However, you can approximate a 830nm profile easily in Photoshop. ctrl + U and desaturate completely. Find the D-max and D-min (brightest highlight, darkest shadow). Then ctrl + M click highlight eye dropper on D-min, repeat clicking the shadow eyedropper on D-max. If it removes too many gray levels use the fade adjustment.
Jim
Danpbphoto wroteSuper composition Joe. Along with the church! I must start experimenting with IR.
Anyone have a suggestion for a novice?
Thanks!
DanThanks for all the info Jim! Yes I realized it was lot more "involved" than just a filter. You, and others, make it look so easy IMHO..and I know it isn't.
My post processing skils are minimal at best but Adobe, and your advice, make it a bit more understandable Ps wise!
THANKS!
DanJim is totally on point. I would add:
1. Autofocus is not an issue if you are using a mirrorless camera as far as I know. It can be an issue with DSLRs and film cameras, without infrared focusing markers.
2. Nothing to add.
3. Capture One (I use an older version) has a white balance slider that starts -- I think -- at 100 or maybe even 0. Sorry I am not looking at it right now. But it can handle IR white balance easily like you are editing any other photo, and then you can edit further, if you want, in Exposure X7, which I just discovered today thanks to the OP of this thread, or Photoshop, etc.
There really is no magic to IR. Editing color IR besides aerochrome can involve channel swapping and some playing around in alpha channels in photoshop but it is just a few steps extra steps. It really is simple after the first time. The first time for me was intimidating. But you might prefer to watch a tutorial rather than read a how to get a better handle on how this works. Up to you.
The filters I like the most require no channel swapping.
The hardest IR range to edit is 550nm to 590nm because white balance can be elusive at all stages of image development.
Aerochrome is in the same range at 550nm but easy. White balance is in the zone of any editor and no channel swapping necessary. Some cameras veer orange like mine does, some veer red with aerochrome.
Above 800nm you have basically entered a black and white world and in all editors I know of except Capture one the white balance slider won't be able to correct the white balance. The raw file will always be purple in all editors I know of except capture one. Of course you can just make it a black and white photo in other editors. I actually don't think you lose anything by doing it that way above 800nm.
Someone mentioned getting a cheap starter camera. I bought the cheapest digital one imaginable on ebay about 5 years ago. It is still working perfectly. I don't have an anti glare glass on my sensor but I don't feel I need a better one. I never have had an issue with a lens not focusing on it. If I were to get another one, I would get a full spectrum like the one I have but you might decide something else. I use aerochrome, the ha astrophotography filter, an 850 filter and then a filter that makes it possible to use it as a regular camera. Also drop in filters that can be placed between the lens and sensor are better than ones you can put on a lens because you can't go wider than 20mm in my experience than with a filter on a lens without the edges smearing and stretching. I deal with it. My camera isn't popular enough to have drop in filters.
Also I use a grey card to set white balance whenever the light shifts. It makes editing afterwards really easy in my opinion.
Hope my experience with digital IR helps you in some way. Cheers.
Many thanks "GR"! Most insightful and helpful! Appreciate you taking the time for such a detailed reponse and not "blowing me off" like some do to members.
Again THANKS!
Dan
I have used both film and digital for IR photography. Both have their pros and cons. What I like with B&W IR film is that PP is very simple and does not require much - no specific sliders to use, no WB adjustment, just maybe a bit tweaking the contrast/highlight curve. Best IR film I have experienc ed so far is the Rollei 400 IR film, I am not a big fan of the Ilford SFX 200 IR film which is not as IR sensitive and more grainy. I found the Rollei film much harder to have available for purchase.
Rollei 400 IR film, +1 stop overexposed, developed with Rodinal
retrofocus wrote:
I have used both film and digital for IR photography. Both have their pros and cons. What I like with B&W IR film is that PP is very simple and does not require much - no specific sliders to use, no WB adjustment, just maybe a bit tweaking the contrast/highlight curve. Best IR film I have experienc ed so far is the Rollei 400 IR film, I am not a big fan of the Ilford SFX 200 IR film which is not as IR sensitive and more grainy. I found the Rollei film much harder to have available for purchase.
Rollei 400 IR film, +1 stop overexposed, developed with Rodinal
...Show more →
Oh no doubt "rf"! There is always some "give" in the latest technology or retro- film...it goes with the ":territory". The outcome belays the hassles!
Couple days ago with the 665nm converted Canon 5DmkII and a Nikkor 24mm f2.8 ais. This is an 8 image stitch of the flooded forest floor. The river is running parallel to the railing on the left side of the image, and has gone under the walkway into the forest.
This is Paw Paw Park in Holland shot with a 665nm converted Canon 5D using a Nikon f-mount 17mm f3.5 Tokina ai. I normally do not keep the color infrared images - preferring just the black and white ones. However, I sometimes can not decide which I like better - color or B&W - today it's color.
Can't believe I haven't seen this thread before now. Here are some of my favs from 2023 when I was concentrating more on IR. This year not as much though but I'll include one of an interesting cloud.
Canon EOS M6Canon EF-M 15-45mm f/3.5-6.3 IS STM lens45mmf/8.01/800s100 ISO-1.0 EV
NIKON Z 7-- mm f/-- lens1/500s200 ISO+1.0 EV
Canon EOS M6Canon EF-M 15-45mm f/3.5-6.3 IS STM lens19mmf/8.01/640s100 ISO-1.3 EV
NIKON Z 7NIKKOR Z 14-30mm f/4 S lens14mmf/8.01/200s64 ISO+1.3 EV
NIKON Z 7NIKKOR Z 14-30mm f/4 S lens21mmf/8.01/40s200 ISO-0.3 EV
Canon EOS M6Canon EF-M 15-45mm f/3.5-6.3 IS STM lens22mmf/8.01/320s400 ISO-2.0 EV
James Markus wrote:
Toned in Photoshop IR from mid February.
Canon 5DmkII-IR with the Nikkor 24mm f2.8 ais
I'd love to know how you find shooting IR with a DSLR. I'm actually thinking about going that direction as I am tired of dealing with the banding of the Z7 and I'm finding I like shooting with DSLRs more for some reason.
I got out and shot some local scenes today, just to get out and enjoy the evening. All were shot with my Nikon Z7 and 850nm filter.
NIKON Z 7Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens66mmf/8.01/125s200 ISO-0.7 EV
NIKON Z 7Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 18-35mm f/3.5-4.5G ED lens24mmf/8.01/100s200 ISO-0.7 EV
NIKON Z 7Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens70mmf/8.01/50s400 ISO-0.3 EV
NIKON Z 7Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens52mmf/8.01/250s400 ISO-0.3 EV
NIKON Z 7Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens62mmf/8.01/200s400 ISO-0.7 EV
First off - all of your IR photos look great to me.
I enjoy using my two dslr's to shoot IR. The first go was with 720nm lens filters; which resulted in very long exposures due to the hot box still being in the camera to cancel or lessen IR from reaching the sensor. Then I got a converted 5D, but discovered that AF doesn't work properly in the IR band length - so I went with manual focus lenses. Then I had my 5DmkII converted by the same company, and the live view is instant + easy to use. Not only can I see focus , but exposure in real time. Usually I carry two cameras - visible light and IR. As to banding - the only time I encountered that was pushing a file too much for over or under exposure. It may also be possible to get banding imaging from jpgs (8-bit) - instead of raw (12-14bit depending on the camera)
Jim
Harold Carlson wrote: James Markus wroteToned in Photoshop IR from mid February.
Canon 5DmkII-IR with the Nikkor 24mm f2.8 aisI'd love to know how you find shooting IR with a DSLR. I'm actually thinking about going that direction as I am tired of dealing with the banding of the Z7 and I'm finding I like shooting with DSLRs more for some reason.
I got out and shot some local scenes today, just to get out and enjoy the evening. All were shot with my Nikon Z7 and 850nm filter.
First off - all of your IR photos look great to me.
I enjoy using my two dslr's to shoot IR. The first go was with 720nm lens filters; which resulted in very long exposures due to the hot box still being in the camera to cancel or lessen IR from reaching the sensor. Then I got a converted 5D, but discovered that AF doesn't work properly in the IR band length - so I went with manual focus lenses. Then I had my 5DmkII converted by the same company, and the live view is instant + easy to use. Not only can I see focus , but exposure in real time. Usually I carry two cameras - visible light and IR. As to banding - the only time I encountered that was pushing a file too much for over or under exposure. It may also be possible to get banding imaging from jpgs (8-bit) - instead of raw (12-14bit depending on the camera)
Jim
...Show more →Harold Carlson wroteJames Markus wroteToned in Photoshop IR from mid February.
Canon 5DmkII-IR with the Nikkor 24mm f2.8 aisI'd love to know how you find shooting IR with a DSLR. I'm actually thinking about going that direction as I am tired of dealing with the banding of the Z7 and I'm finding I like shooting with DSLRs more for some reason.
I got out and shot some local scenes today, just to get out and enjoy the evening. All were shot with my Nikon Z7 and 850nm filter.
I was curious if you used the viewfinder (contrast-detect AF) for focusing in IR but it doesn't sound like it and I have read a single lens generally needs to be tuned to a converted camera when it's converted.
I have enjoyed using an OVF so much these days but it sounds like it's not really plausible for IR.
To keep this thread on-topic, I'll post another Z7 image I took from last June.
NIKON Z 7Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens32mmf/10.01/30s200 ISO+1.0 EV
I only tried AF lenses at the very beginning, and haven't used one for IR in two years. The only way I could be sure of focus with the 5D was to chimp shots, but with the 5DmkII I can see critical focus at 16x on the screen - as well as the exposure. I always intended to use many lenses - so I didn't get one lens focal length calibrated to the sensor. I got quite fixated on an old lens early on - the Nikkor-P.C 55mm f3.5 ai'd micro. It is a superb landscape lens, and can resolve fine details very well. However, I love wide lenses like 14mm all the way up on IR.
I've read the link, and only one person commenting called it "banding". I would call the horizontal, vertical, or both at the same time "crosshatch". I have run into that when I missed exposure and pushed the file too hard to try and get better highlights or shadows. When in doubt - I bracket exposure.
I will say something I noticed in that link - He missed focus on most of the examples. You have posted super 850nm photos - so you know your gear can produce excellent results. Maybe try bracketing some shots - like 3-5 different exposures under and over exposed. Your camera probably has an auto bracketing mode - see if the lines carry over in each frame. I've some brackets with, and the next frame nothing?
Jim
Harold Carlson wrote: James Markus wroteHarold,
First off - all of your IR photos look great to me.
I enjoy using my two dslr's to shoot IR. The first go was with 720nm lens filters; which resulted in very long exposures due to the hot box still being in the camera to cancel or lessen IR from reaching the sensor. Then I got a converted 5D, but discovered that AF doesn't work properly in the IR band length - so I went with manual focus lenses. Then I had my 5DmkII converted by the same company, and the live view is instant + easy to use. Not only can I see focus , but exposure in real time. Usually I carry two cameras - visible light and IR. As to banding - the only time I encountered that was pushing a file too much for over or under exposure. It may also be possible to get banding imaging from jpgs (8-bit) - instead of raw (12-14bit depending on the camera)
Jim
Harold Carlson wroteJames Markus wroteToned in Photoshop IR from mid February.
Canon 5DmkII-IR with the Nikkor 24mm f2.8 aisI'd love to know how you find shooting IR with a DSLR. I'm actually thinking about going that direction as I am tired of dealing with the banding of the Z7 and I'm finding I like shooting with DSLRs more for some reason.
I got out and shot some local scenes today, just to get out and enjoy the evening. All were shot with my Nikon Z7 and 850nm filter.Thanks much for the reply. The banding I speak of is from the phase-detect AF inherent in most newer cameras. Kolari talks about it some here: https://kolarivision.com/nikon-z7-infrared-photography-review/
I was curious if you used the viewfinder (contrast-detect AF) for focusing in IR but it doesn't sound like it and I have read a single lens generally needs to be tuned to a converted camera when it's converted.
I have enjoyed using an OVF so much these days but it sounds like it's not really plausible for IR.
To keep this thread on-topic, I'll post another Z7 image I took from last June. ...Show more →