p.3 #1What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
QuietOC wrote: goodbokeh wroteQuietOC wrotegoodbokeh wroteI also have the 24-70 GM II. The huge fly in the ointment for me is it's now 6 months after introduction and the GM II still does not have a full lens profile for distortion corrections from Adobe for use in Adobe Camera Raw and Lightroom. And there is no Adobe lens profile update in sight. That is a Big Deal and disappointment I have with the GM II.
So for now 24-70 GM II owners are stuck either using Jpegs, eyeballing Raw corrections themselves, or trying the 24-70 GM I Adobe profile and eyeballing corrections there also. Not good, not good at all.I've been seeing posts like this for years, and I wonder why people continue to put up with it. Sony has been embedding distortion correction parameters in ARW files since 2011. All the stuff required comes with E-mount lenses.The only correction Sony has built into the 24-70 GM II ARW Raw file, when view with Adobe Camera Raw, is for chromatic aberrations, not distortions and it is stated so in the lens profile footnote.
It's also quite apparent when comparing the GM II Raw file to the SOOC Jpeg (which is distortion corrected). There is no Adobe profile to correct distortions for the GM II, only the GM I profile exists at this time. Applying the GM I profile also changes the GM II distortion pattern but it's an eyeball game...not good.ExIftool or any of the GUI wrappers for it will show you the Sony distortion parameters stored in your ARW files. I've been using them for many years in Capture One. I never have to wait for Phase One to make a profile when I get a just released lens. The Lens Compensation information comes with the lens.
Thanks for that information but I use Adobe Camera Raw, so I don't think that GUI wrapper technique would help me, would it?
p.3 #2What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote: fsi22 wroteI’m in a similar situation and I’ve settled on the 35GM. It does 50/f2 duty as well.But can you really see the difference between in-camera and software crop? Details wise I feel there is no difference in resolution/details with top glass on a7r4. Is there analysis available?
There’s no difference in camera or after. I generally crop after but for some in camera is helpful for composing and it reduces file size. So a time saver rather than IQ benefit.
p.3 #3What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
I'm a little surprised that no one has had a kind word for the Sony f1.8 lenses: the 35/1.8, 55/1.8 and 85/1.8. They are all small, light, and very competent. Perhaps it was the OP's emphasis on rendering, since none of them are famous for that but certainly not bad either.
p.3 #4What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
mark galer has some full res images on flickr in conjunction with his reviews and speaks highly of these for size and sharpness but i don’t recall if he discusses rendering. for me, among other things, i prefer the ergonomics and handling of the sigmas
i know the OP states AF which i primarily use but at times i use the AF/MF switch to check if me hyperfocal distance selection is correct
p.3 #6What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote:
I'm a little surprised that no one has had a kind word for the Sony f1.8 lenses: the 35/1.8, 55/1.8 and 85/1.8. They are all small, light, and very competent. Perhaps it was the OP's emphasis on rendering, since none of them are famous for that but certainly not bad either.
That's because you mentioned "travel" and "renders" in the same post. It looked to me like the thread was geared towards re-affirming the CV 40 or Sigma 45 as the best lens ever.
Otherwise all three are fine lenses and will perform no different in "renders" for travel photos, at typical distances and ~f/8, than any other lenses of similar focal length.
p.3 #7What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
The FE 35mm F1.8 has a lot of vignette at F8 and even at F16. That's one of its unique characteristics. It is either something you like or don't like, but it is not like other lenses of similar focal length.
p.3 #8What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
QuietOC wrote:
The FE 35mm F1.8 has a lot of vignette at F8 and even at F16. That's one of its unique characteristics. It is either something you like or don't like, but it is not like other lenses of similar focal length.
Let me quote you here:
"I've been seeing posts like this for years, and I wonder why people continue to put up with it. Sony has been embedding distortion correction parameters in ARW files since 2011. All the stuff required comes with E-mount lenses."
They also embed light fall-off parameters, aka vignette correction.
p.3 #9What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
vdo1 wrote: QuietOC wroteThe FE 35mm F1.8 has a lot of vignette at F8 and even at F16. That's one of its unique characteristics. It is either something you like or don't like, but it is not like other lenses of similar focal length.Let me quote you here:
"I've been seeing posts like this for years, and I wonder why people continue to put up with it. Sony has been embedding distortion correction parameters in ARW files since 2011. All the stuff required comes with E-mount lenses."
They also embed light fall-off parameters, aka vignette correction.
Yes, and Sony cameras apply some shading correction to the "raw data", but the vignette still shows as more noise and reduced dynamic range. Those may not be what you want when shooting at F8. These are things to be aware of.
p.3 #11What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
I can see how a small, light and sharp 24-70/4 would cover most travel needs, unfortunately no one seems to be interested in making one. Bazooka f/2.8 zooms is all the rage these days.
p.3 #12What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
vdo1 wrote:
I can see how a small, light and sharp 24-70/4 would cover most travel needs, unfortunately no one seems to be interested in making one. Bazooka f/2.8 zooms is all the rage these days.
But it will still be not bright enough (they typically make them ~4.5 T-stops) and not enough shallow DOF at 70mm. I would need another lens to accompany 2470@4 (likely two - wide for low light and standard to mid telephoto for shallow DOF) - still making f2.8 my preferred choice.
p.3 #13What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
"Best rendering" for me are the Batis lenses I own (25 and 85) and the 55ZA. The 35 GM rendering is more neutral. For travel it is wonderful for night shots but on the heavy side for carrying during the day when smaller apertures will suffice. And a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.
p.3 #14What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
16-35 f4 pz, probably the my defacto travel lens and lens in general.
for longer focal lengths, it's a tossup
24-70 f4 zony
28-70 f2.8 sigma
28-60 sony
35 f2.8 zony
50 f1.8 sony
I have a very hard time picking the normal lenses for a few reasons, I want the bokeh, yet I want the range, and I dont want anything large (the two constant aperture lenses are slightly in that category)
p.3 #16What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
For AF, small(ish) and nice rendering out of what I’ve owned, my subjective take:
RX1, Sigma 45/2.8, Sigma 35/2, Sigma 65/2, 24 GM. On other platforms, I really liked the PL 25/1.4 in m4/3.
Maybe FE 55/1.8 but isn’t as consistent as the above lenses
I have FE 20/1.8 which is sharp, excellent lens but I wouldn’t say it has great rendering
FE 35/1.8 was too harsh, didn’t care for rendering. But magnificent AF and great choice if you like the look.
Batis 40 was too punchy, not cartoonish like the FE 35/1.8 but my preference is for smoother rendering like RX1 and some GMs.
If you can deal with MF, VC 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 have great rendering, the Loxia 21 is great (haven’t owned, but the 25/85 also seem consistently great from images I’ve seen), VC 50/2 is an incredible lens - not so much characterful as totally transparent.
p.3 #17What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote: rob_ww wroteAnd a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.I'm late for the party - what would be the selling points of this lens, optically?
It has a good amount of under corrected spherical aberration which does some good things to the background out-of-focus. It both smooths and somewhat reduces the amount of background blur. And unlike STF lenses there's no transmission penalty. Unfortunately, it causes the opposite effects with out-of-focus foregrounds. It also causes some glow especially with close focus. The Lensbaby Velvets and Soft Focus lenses have higher amounts of spherical aberration. It also causes some focus shift and affects phase-detection.
Normal primes historically have had under-corrected spherical aberration. But often they would also have bright outlining wide-open which didn't smooth out until stopped down a bit. Think old Zeiss Planars, Canon F1.4 and F1.8, Minoltas. The old Sigma 50mm F1.4 EX DG HSM didn't have that issue. The Sony FE 50mm F1.8 and Samyang AF 50mm F1.4 don't either.
The Sony 2.5/40G is a good contrast. It is very sharp wide-open and has decent neutral rendering. If there is any amount of somewhat out-of-focus background transition--images from the Sigma 45 images will look better. Most will probably be happy with the Sony's rendering.
p.3 #18What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote: QuietOC wroteExIftool or any of the GUI wrappers for it will show you the Sony distortion parameters stored in your ARW files. I've been using them for many years in Capture One. I never have to wait for Phase One to make a profile when I get a just released lens. The Lens Compensation information comes with the lens.Is there an instruction to seamlessly incorporate in Capture One and Lightroom workflows?
Capture One reads them. If Phase One has their own profile for the lens, that one gets applied by default, but you can manually switch to the embedded "Manufacturer Profile". The Manufacturer Profile is applied by default otherwise. I've never used Lightroom.
p.3 #19What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
QuietOC wrote: vdo1 wroteQuietOC wroteThe FE 35mm F1.8 has a lot of vignette at F8 and even at F16. That's one of its unique characteristics. It is either something you like or don't like, but it is not like other lenses of similar focal length.Let me quote you here:
"I've been seeing posts like this for years, and I wonder why people continue to put up with it. Sony has been embedding distortion correction parameters in ARW files since 2011. All the stuff required comes with E-mount lenses."
They also embed light fall-off parameters, aka vignette correction.Yes, and Sony cameras apply some shading correction to the "raw data", but the vignette still shows as more noise and reduced dynamic range. Those may not be what you want when shooting at F8. These are things to be aware of.
Yeah, it ruined my sky's texture and dynamic range
p.3 #20What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote: rob_ww wroteAnd a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.I'm late for the party - what would be the selling points of this lens, optically?