fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms

  
 
Matt Kerby
Offline
Details
p.2 #1What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
The problem with the Sony 20/1.8 is the flare. Something to think about. Not something I like to deal with when traveling. The Batis lenses are always great choice.
Oct 02, 2022 at 01:08 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.2 #2What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
My travel kit is the Sony FE PZ 16-35/4 and the Samyang AF 75/1.8.
Small, easy to carry, sharp enough, the rendering is easily good enough (both lenses) and they fit easily together with an A7C into a satchel bag together with everything else needed.

I have found I can manage the gap between 35 and 75mm just fine

If you like to work with longer lenses (like in the image you posted) or fast wide lenses you need something else of course. What to use then is beyond my knowledge.

I think the choice of equipment is very personal. In the focal length range between 28 and say 135 or so primes very much make sense to me. Shorter and longer than that zoom lenses are really helpful.

As I in general like to travel light I'm not interested in backpacks and a lot of lenses and other stuff to carry. I have for example never brought two cameras as I think travel and vacation is for mainly experience and not for weight lifting. Should the worst happen one can buy a new camera or settle with the phone.

It is of course another thing if traveling professionally for reportage work or at places far beyond cities.
Oct 02, 2022 at 01:29 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #3What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Jonas B wrote:
As I in general like to travel light I'm not interested in backpacks and a lot of lenses and other stuff to carry. I have for example never brought two cameras as I think travel and vacation is for mainly experience and not for weight lifting. Should the worst happen one can buy a new camera or settle with the phone.

It is of course another thing if traveling professionally for reportage work or at places far beyond cities.


That is where you and I differ. I always take a spare camera for both flexibility in having two different focal lengths ready to be used and more importantly as a camera that is ready if something happens to my main camera. Many places it's just not convenient to go into a store and buy another camera if your camera breaks down...in fact there are many places where this is not possible.

As far as backpacks go, I need it to carry extra clothes and water anyway. Leaving out for the day in the morning it can be quite chilly, but by afternoon, it can become damn hot...so the backpack is very handy to hold your jacket when not needed. It also makes carrying things like passports ( which many countries require you to have the passport on hand with you ) as well as money and other niceties such as a roll of toilet paper ( many countries do not supply toilet paper ).

Maybe if one keeps their travels to well established countries and cities, one can get away with the bare minimums...but once a person's travels venture away from the established is when we need to carry more items with us, including the spare camera. At least this has been my experiences.
Oct 02, 2022 at 01:40 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.2 #4What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
And I take more than Jonas (maybe) and you, use a backpack, like you...but tend to use my 14-24 on the wide end and a zoom on the long end...primes in between, like he does.

We are so lucky to have so many options to tailor to our individual preferences.

chez wrote:
Jonas B wroteAs I in general like to travel light I'm not interested in backpacks and a lot of lenses and other stuff to carry. I have for example never brought two cameras as I think travel and vacation is for mainly experience and not for weight lifting. Should the worst happen one can buy a new camera or settle with the phone.

It is of course another thing if traveling professionally for reportage work or at places far beyond cities.
That is where you and I differ. I always take a spare camera for both flexibility in having two different focal lengths ready to be used and more importantly as a camera that is ready if something happens to my main camera. Many places it's just not convenient to go into a store and buy another camera if your camera breaks down...in fact there are many places where this is not possible.

As far as backpacks go, I need it to carry extra clothes and water anyway. Leaving out for the day in the morning it can be quite chilly, but
...Show more →



Edited on Oct 02, 2022 at 01:46 PM · View previous versions
Oct 02, 2022 at 01:43 PM
chiron
Online
Details
p.2 #5What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Jonas B wrote:
My travel kit is the Sony FE PZ 16-35/4 and the Samyang AF 75/1.8.
Small, easy to carry, sharp enough, the rendering is easily good enough (both lenses) and they fit easily together with an A7C into a satchel bag together with everything else needed.

I have found I can manage the gap between 35 and 75mm just fine

If you like to work with longer lenses (like in the image you posted) or fast wide lenses you need something else of course. What to use then is beyond my knowledge.

I think the choice of equipment is very personal. In the focal
...Show more →

The shot I posted is one that just happened to be on my desktop. It is actually from ten years ago and was shot with a Nex-7 and an 18-200mm Sony zoom at a 35mm equivalent of 166mm. That would be very unusual for me these days when I am generally no longer than 90mm. I do see the appeal of what you are carrying.

Here is another characteristic shot from this trip to Venice in the focal length range I more often shoot. It's the same Nex-7 and 18-200mm lens, but this time at a 35mm equivalent of 28mm.




Oct 02, 2022 at 01:45 PM
lensfan
Offline
Details
p.2 #6What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
goodbokeh wrote:
So for now 24-70 GM II owners are stuck either using Jpegs, eyeballing Raw corrections themselves, or trying the 24-70 GM I Adobe profile and eyeballing corrections there also. Not good, not good at all.

What's going on between Adobe and Sony? Most important flagship lens does not get proper treatment.
I don't own zooms anymore - I chose path of working hard with manual focus lenses so I feel like I earned every shot. But have 24GM and Batis 85 just in case.
Oct 02, 2022 at 07:56 PM
onthebeam
Offline
Details
p.2 #7What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Respectfully, this is too open ended to keep a conversation as helpful as it could be.

You could get most helpful feedback by asking and sharing your choice of best particular lens within a more defined type /category.
Oct 02, 2022 at 08:25 PM
Frogfish
Offline
Details
p.2 #8What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote:
Frogfish wrote
chiron wrote
lensfan wroteNot sure what you are looking for. What do you mean by travel? Is it vacation or photography job thing?
A couple of weeks vacation in Rome and Tuscany. Villages, cities, streets, people, interiors, landscapes. Here's one from Venice a few years ago:
This is important qualifying information missing from the OP (and maybe why responses have been thin). The theme 'Travel' is a wide reaching term and has so much variety contained in that one simple word, that it likely means something different to everyone.

Travel with your partner, children, alone, hiking-camping, Winter/Summer, mountains or towns, staying in hotels or B&Bs, driving-flying, shooting astro or landscapes or cities or people etc. etc. : each can mean a different lens / camera set-up.

And your definition covers a plethora of different situations / subjects that would, for what you are asking, mean a variety of different lenses. Rendering is far less important per se (assuming PP and shooting at typical deep landscape apertures) for landscapes and interiors than shooting for street or people. Most people too, now accept that colour can easily be adjusted in post regardless of camera/lens.

Generally carrying lenses to cover all those subjects means a compromise. Either in rendering, weight or widest aperture etc.

Personally the lenses I use at home to cover those subjects are heavier than those I use for travel (unless staying exclusively in hotels and without the family).

Sorry I realise this isn't going to be of much help but it is a very personal choice. Personally the weight is a priority, so as long as the rendering isn't horrendous that opens up other factors that are of more importance (aperture, sharpness and weight).

For those locations (which I've been to numerous times - having lived close by in Austria for 3 years) I'd take (although this may not address your questions) : Voigt 15mm, SY18, SY 24/1.8 (astro and mountains, + weight, being a priority for me, the stunningly beautiful Dolomites are so close!) if not then replace those 3 with the Sony 16-35 PZ, plus the Voigt 35/1.7 and SY45 and the Tamron 70-180 is an excellent lens overall and has replaced the 100-400 in my bag for 'travel' of any nature. If I was with family then also a fast 50 or 85mm (depending on your preference).
I really do think the question is fairly simple. Good rendering, and relatively small and light lenses. I specified AF. Cartier-Bresson covered the entire world for fifty years, usually with only a single 50mm Leitz lens, and only very occasionally a 35 or 135 or a second 50 that was a touch faster than his usual. Your preferred lenses, especially the primes, are a fairly specialized set that works well for you but nothing that says a particular type of travel more than does a set of the Batis or the i series Sigma.


I've had two Batis (and quite a few other Zeiss & Contax lenses) and sold them both. Most of my photography is 'travel' (often including a lot of hiking and camping) and I've found that other lenses offer me more (either faster or lighter or have some other function I require) more than the Zeiss. But of course this is a purely personal choice.

This is why I found the question not as simplistic as you are picturing (and as Onthebeam also stated). And if you've already tried out all of the Batis and Sigma slower lens ranges then surely you know by now and indeed you seem to have already made your mind up "but I love the look they give and their colors and graceful rendering" !

I'd also agree with the guy above who said rendering doesn't have much impact on landscape / architectural photography at the usual apertures (f8-f16) they are shot at. I find this to be a little bit of a 'geeky' question for those genres when full focus front to back and corner to corner sharpness is usually more important. After processing I doubt 99.9% of people can notice any difference and other factors become more important - especially if selling prints. Of course if you are trying to make a couple of lenses 'do-it-all' including portraits and street, then focus your attention on those lenses, I'm sure there are plenty that will be great at f8-f11 for landscape/architecture too.

Oct 02, 2022 at 11:27 PM
fsi22
Offline
Details
p.2 #9What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms

I’m in a similar situation and I’ve settled on the 35GM. It does 50/f2 duty as well. On the higher MP bodies, you would still get around 20MP after crop and pushing it to 70mm, there’s larger than 4k. I like it’s relative compactness, I think it’s rendering is alright but how cropable it is because of it’s sharpness made it my favoured option for travel.



Edited on Oct 03, 2022 at 03:13 AM · View previous versions
Oct 03, 2022 at 01:02 AM
QuietOC
Offline
Details
p.2 #10What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
goodbokeh wrote:
I also have the 24-70 GM II. The huge fly in the ointment for me is it's now 6 months after introduction and the GM II still does not have a full lens profile for distortion corrections from Adobe for use in Adobe Camera Raw and Lightroom. And there is no Adobe lens profile update in sight. That is a Big Deal and disappointment I have with the GM II.

So for now 24-70 GM II owners are stuck either using Jpegs, eyeballing Raw corrections themselves, or trying the 24-70 GM I Adobe profile and eyeballing corrections there also. Not good,
...Show more →

I've been seeing posts like this for years, and I wonder why people continue to put up with it. Sony has been embedding distortion correction parameters in ARW files since 2011. All the stuff required comes with E-mount lenses.
Oct 03, 2022 at 02:49 AM
Alan Parker
Offline
Details
p.2 #11What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
I'm personally very happy with the Batis 40 and Sigma 24-70 DG DN. I picked out both for their rendering characteristics
Oct 03, 2022 at 02:51 AM
jaybr
Offline
Details
p.2 #12What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote:
What are the best-rendering autofocus lenses for travel? Among prime lenses? Among zoom lenses?

The emphasis here is on two qualities that sometimes oppose each other: the best-rendering lenses in terms of all those qualities that make a lens's images appealing (excellent and appealing colors, smoothness generally and in transition zones (no harshness allowed), etc) AND a size and weight that is suitable or at least reasonable for lugging around from place to place while you are also hanging on to your passport, money, a jacket in case it rains, and your traveling companions..

The primary consideration is rendering, with a tolerable
...Show more →

Travel Zooms:
Tamron FE 17-28mm f2.8 and 28-200mm f2.8-5.6

Travel Primes:
Voigtlander FE 21mm f3.5 and Zony FE 55mm f1.8

Or

Voigtlander FE 15mm f4.5 and Samyang FE 35mm f2.8 and Samyang FE 75mm f1.8

J
Oct 03, 2022 at 04:15 AM
lensfan
Offline
Details
p.2 #13What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
fsi22 wrote:
I’m in a similar situation and I’ve settled on the 35GM. It does 50/f2 duty as well.



But can you really see the difference between in-camera and software crop? Details wise I feel there is no difference in resolution/details with top glass on a7r4. Is there analysis available?
Oct 03, 2022 at 07:34 AM
goodbokeh
Offline
Details
p.2 #14What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
QuietOC wrote:
goodbokeh wroteI also have the 24-70 GM II. The huge fly in the ointment for me is it's now 6 months after introduction and the GM II still does not have a full lens profile for distortion corrections from Adobe for use in Adobe Camera Raw and Lightroom. And there is no Adobe lens profile update in sight. That is a Big Deal and disappointment I have with the GM II.

So for now 24-70 GM II owners are stuck either using Jpegs, eyeballing Raw corrections themselves, or trying the 24-70 GM I Adobe profile and eyeballing corrections there also. Not good, not good at all.
I've been seeing posts like this for years, and I wonder why people continue to put up with it. Sony has been embedding distortion correction parameters in ARW files since 2011. All the stuff required comes with E-mount lenses.


The only correction Sony has built into the 24-70 GM II ARW Raw file, when view with Adobe Camera Raw, is for chromatic aberrations, not distortions and it is stated so in the lens profile footnote.
It's also quite apparent when comparing the GM II Raw file to the SOOC Jpeg (which is distortion corrected). There is no Adobe profile to correct distortions for the GM II, only the GM I profile exists at this time. Applying the GM I profile also changes the GM II distortion pattern but it's an eyeball game...not good.
Oct 03, 2022 at 10:17 AM
Erichimedes
Offline
Details
p.2 #15What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
I can't contribute much from personal experience because much of my glass is MF. But when I go, I tend to take a combination of zooms/primes/MF/AF so it's all across the board. But there are some gems in the world of adapted MF lenses as far as rendering is concerned.

My only thought to contribute is that Samyang has some fast primes whose rendering I really like, and they are LIGHT. I only own the 45mm, but the rendering on that lens is great.

We can only hope the new Tamron 20-40 has good rendering. For my uses at least it's nearly the perfect travel zoom on paper. Some of Tamron's zooms have nice rendering, at least from examples I've seen online, so hopefully this one does too.

Edited to add:
As others have already said, the Batis lenses are really hard to beat for rendering. They do unbelievable things in low light, but also in particular I like how Zeiss lenses render in bright, top-down sunshine, which you see a lot of in vacation photos. The 25, 40 and 85 are a kit that would do great in so many situations, although I've only owned the 40 and 85.

Edited on Oct 03, 2022 at 11:03 AM · View previous versions
Oct 03, 2022 at 10:54 AM
rob_ww
Offline
Details
p.2 #16What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
While this is a great topic it's likely to fly off in different directions based on personal preferences -- zooms vs primes, weight vs quality etc. These are all well rehearsed.

So to focus in (as it were) I will talk about a couple of actual photographic situations. As I am a prime user, I usually select two primes from five for most of my trips. Recently I visited the Amalfi coast. I brought along a 24mm and the Sony 35mm 1.4 GM. The 35 was splendid, including for night photos of cities and scenes (think Sorrento evenings) which are great to tour after dark. Love that lens! The 24mm added almost nothing. What I lacked was a longer lens, say my Batis 85/1.8 for photos of objects at a greater distance, out at sea or from the shore. Lesson learned.

Next week I am visiting Brussels and will take the Batis 25mm because I expect to do a lot of interiors -- churches, historic buildings and museums. I can also crop the lens to ~35mm equivalent on my A7R4 for contextual photos of people.

Different strokes for different circumstances. In both cases I would need a lens with an aperture of f2.0 or wider IMHO. In summer, in bright sunshine, I might take a zoom and shoot at f8. But even in summer the best picture may well be in a shaded corner where that light gathering needs to be good.
Oct 03, 2022 at 10:59 AM
lensfan
Offline
Details
p.2 #17What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
rob_ww wrote:
Sony 35mm 1.4 GM


Magnificent lens. But as a primarily travel shooter I'm never at 35mm - it is always too wide or too narrow. That said - I now own four 35mm primes but don't think I will ever be taking any of those for my trips (except for maybe tiny CZ 2.8/35 which is only 120g, takes no space and has autofocus - but still I doubt it will leave my bag while on a trip).
Oct 03, 2022 at 11:18 AM
QuietOC
Offline
Details
p.2 #18What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
goodbokeh wrote:
QuietOC wrote
goodbokeh wroteI also have the 24-70 GM II. The huge fly in the ointment for me is it's now 6 months after introduction and the GM II still does not have a full lens profile for distortion corrections from Adobe for use in Adobe Camera Raw and Lightroom. And there is no Adobe lens profile update in sight. That is a Big Deal and disappointment I have with the GM II.

So for now 24-70 GM II owners are stuck either using Jpegs, eyeballing Raw corrections themselves, or trying the 24-70 GM I Adobe profile and eyeballing corrections there also. Not good, not good at all.
I've been seeing posts like this for years, and I wonder why people continue to put up with it. Sony has been embedding distortion correction parameters in ARW files since 2011. All the stuff required comes with E-mount lenses.
The only correction Sony has built into the 24-70 GM II ARW Raw file, when view with Adobe Camera Raw, is for chromatic aberrations, not distortions and it is stated so in the lens profile footnote.
It's also quite apparent when comparing the GM II Raw file to the SOOC Jpeg (which is distortion corrected). There is no Adobe profile to correct distortions for the GM II, only the GM I profile exists at this time. Applying the GM I profile also changes the GM II distortion pattern but it's an eyeball game...not good.


ExIftool or any of the GUI wrappers for it will show you the Sony distortion parameters stored in your ARW files. I've been using them for many years in Capture One. I never have to wait for Phase One to make a profile when I get a just released lens. The Lens Compensation information comes with the lens.
Oct 03, 2022 at 12:09 PM
lensfan
Offline
Details
p.2 #19What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
QuietOC wrote:
ExIftool or any of the GUI wrappers for it will show you the Sony distortion parameters stored in your ARW files. I've been using them for many years in Capture One. I never have to wait for Phase One to make a profile when I get a just released lens. The Lens Compensation information comes with the lens.


Is there an instruction to seamlessly incorporate in Capture One and Lightroom workflows?
Oct 03, 2022 at 12:18 PM
offtraildog
Offline
Details
p.2 #20What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
I found the Sigma 16-28/2.8 was just wide enough for my purposes for inside historic buildings.

Just highlights how people compose differently

Love the silent shutter for this scenario .. it is on my FN menu
Oct 03, 2022 at 12:24 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister