fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms

  
 
chiron
Online

p.1 #1What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
What are the best-rendering autofocus lenses for travel? Among prime lenses? Among zoom lenses?

The emphasis here is on two qualities that sometimes oppose each other: the best-rendering lenses in terms of all those qualities that make a lens's images appealing (excellent and appealing colors, smoothness generally and in transition zones (no harshness allowed), etc) AND a size and weight that is suitable or at least reasonable for lugging around from place to place while you are also hanging on to your passport, money, a jacket in case it rains, and your traveling companions..

The primary consideration is rendering, with a tolerable weight and size as the secondary consideration. And I am not speaking here of technically best, but rather of rendering best.

My own nominees in primes are three sets of lenses, remembering that the goal is to maximize rendering in a travel-tolerant size and weight:

The Sigma i series lenses: specifically, I am thinking of the 20/2.0, 24/3.5, 35/2.0, 45/2.8, 65/2.0, and 90/2.8.
OR
The Batis lenses; specifically, the 18/2.8, 40/2.0, 85/1.8, and 135/2.8. These are larger but light and still travel-worthy.
OR
The Sony 20/1.8, Sony 24/1.4, Sigma 35/2.0, Sigma 45/2.8, Sigma 65/2.0, and Sigma 90/2.8.

Among zoom lenses, I feel less sure about what I would take. Probably one of the following two sets:

Sony 16-35/4.0 PZ, Sony 24-70/4.0, Tamron 70-180/2.8
OR
Sony 16-35/2.8, Sony 24-70/2.8 II, Tamron 70-180/2.8

I'd be very interested to hear opinions on this.

Edited on Oct 01, 2022 at 07:26 PM · View previous versions
Oct 01, 2022 at 04:35 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.1 #2What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Sigma 28-70DN seems to fit your citeria, it trades a bit of sharpness in exchange for smoother rendering from what I've seen, while being compact & light for a standard 2.8 zoom (well, no 24mm but you can't have it all).
Oct 01, 2022 at 04:54 AM
QuietOC
Offline
Details
p.1 #3What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
It is probably impossible to avoid harshness in all situations without drastic measures like an STF lens. I have seen some rather crunchy images from both the Sigma 45mm and 65mm on occasions. The Sigma i series are not sealed which makes them fair weather lenses maybe best used at home. I am picking 1.8/55 ZA for the normal. The Samyang 50mm F1.4 II is too portrait focused for me.

I just picked up the Sigma 28-70mm F2.8 DN C based on similar criteria. My last F2.8 normal zoom the old Sony 28-75mm F2.8 SAM had rather awful background rendering. I didn't like the rending of the 24-70mm F4 ZA either at least compared to the 28-70mm OSS kit zoom. The F4 ZA is a very appealing size. The 24-105G is bulky.

The Tamron 70-180 rendering is merely ok. That isn't a range I'd use much, so it could be good enough choice. I might bring the 100mm STF GM instead.

Sigma 35/2 is pretty good, but the Tamron 35/2.8 can be a little better and is lighter and sealed.

Samyang 24mm F1.8.

I've only used the Tamron 17-28 in the native ultrawide zooms. Like the 70-180 it is a solid ok with limited range.
Oct 01, 2022 at 05:05 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.1 #4What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
In its essence, 'travel' is just a displacement of geography. Giving you a more informed opinion would require more specifics in exactly what your definition is - the subject matter, the purpose, the time that you can put into the photography.

I'm not being snippy here, but most people whip out their plastic slab and point it in the general direction of some of the greatest sights this world has to offer, places they have paid large sums to reach yet find only ten minutes to view them, jostled by hundreds of similar individuals. But knowing what most mean by the category, you have choices that are all much better than the pocket coms devices:

For no portraits, poor low light, more deep DOF general captures (people see it as this), the zooms are fine.

For the best results both technically and aesthetically in most environments, I favour the Batis line here. The reason to be very cautious about 'artistic' lenses within travel environments is you have no idea about the light, you cannot often return easily to 'get it right' as a pro would, and you tend to be giving up the brilliant contrast and colour that Zeiss lenses give you. 'Versatile' works best.

Max apertures are similar with the Sigma set, but the 135mm is a very satisfying option that will net superb tele images, good enough for 180mm crops unless huge prints are on the agenda. Light is often tough in the hours you find yourself with something compelling to shoot, and APO is very useful here, as is the stabilisation. And not often noted - performance is almost identical at the apertures you will be using. The Batis 85mm is very sound indeed, the 18mm is a great lens.

The middle is critical and I suggest you think hard about it. It's where you have the most choice and flexibility and lens speed etc. 50s are so light and small, I'd take one as well. You might swap the 40/2 for the Sigma 45, for instance. See what I mean about priorities? The gaps are large, but portrait friendly...if you have a wide angle bent, it would be quite different advice. 18-40/45 is a stretch, but we lack a high end 28mm. The Sigmas are rather close, aren't they? 35-45-65, these AOVs give pretty close results in some ways.

There is the concept of 'anchor lenses', the ones you love and love to use - you can build the kit around them because you know they will get most of the action. And spacing comes into it, as well as purpose - so you may want telephoto for distance and some portraits, 85-90 for intimate portraits and some open nature. Then the middle lenses, which need to separate from 85-90 and also (ideally) 28-35, finall your fave wide angle. It is not easy, I have taken a different set for each of 20 trips but I shoot a lot of different material. Know thyself, photographer!
Oct 01, 2022 at 04:17 PM
offtraildog
Offline
Details
p.1 #5What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
One reason I have mostly Sigma lenses right now is because I like the rendering .... as well as the IQ, size, weight, feel while on the camera and during use. I have owned all of the Sigma's you list except the 20/2 and still have the 24/45/90 compact primes.

I have also owned the Batis series. Really like them but they are bulky and I primarily use zooms now.

You list the Sigma 70-180/2.8 but I think you mean the Tamron. I also had the Tamron but after 3 copies, was never lucky enough to get one that lived up to the stellar reviews by others on FM

Just got back from a 3 week trip in IT and took the A74, Sigma 16-28/2.8 and 28-70/2.8. I like the versatility and focal length of these two zooms for my style of travel photos.

While my 24-105 is a more usable focal range, I find I use 2.8 often enough for inside dark buildings to leave the 24-105 at home. I would still need an UWA to pair with the 24-105.

I tried the new 24-70/2.8 II and did some comparison shooting but it is heavier and larger and for my viewing requirements (65" 4k OLED or 27" 5k iMac, and maybe printing 24x36ish, the Sigma IQ is good enough.

The A74 with one lens attached w/ lens hood, along with the other lens, fit easily in a PD Sling 6 with room for my travel wallet (cash, ID, passport, coins), lens cloth, lens wipes, lens brush, spare battery, mask (if required).



Oct 01, 2022 at 04:23 PM
chiron
Online
Details
p.1 #6What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
offtraildog wrote:
One reason I have mostly Sigma lenses right now is because I like the rendering .... as well as the IQ, size, weight, feel while on the camera and during use. I have owned all of the Sigma's you list except the 20/2 and still have the 24/45/90 compact primes.

I have also owned the Batis series. Really like them but they are bulky and I primarily use zooms now.

You list the Sigma 70-180/2.8 but I think you mean the Tamron. I also had the Tamron but after 3 copies, was never lucky enough to get one that lived up to
...Show more →
Yes, I did mean the Tamron 70-180, as recommended by several others. I have edited my original to correct the error.
Oct 01, 2022 at 07:25 PM
chiron
Online
Details
p.1 #7What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Very helpful advice from QuietOC, phillip_pj, and offtraildog that makes sense to me and there are some interesting points to think about. I do like the Batis lenses a lot and I think they are just the right side of portable. The Sigma 45/2.8 is one of my favorite lenses, though I also think the Batis 40 is an excellent lens. The Sigma 45/2.8 is an anchor lens for me, as is the Canon 50/1.2L on an adapter, which I am not thinking of taking. And Phillip is right about what zooms are best used for and when they do you no favors.

Oct 01, 2022 at 07:43 PM
lensfan
Offline
Details
p.1 #8What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Not sure what you are looking for. What do you mean by travel? Is it vacation or photography job thing?
Oct 01, 2022 at 08:29 PM
chiron
Online
Details
p.1 #9What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote:
Not sure what you are looking for. What do you mean by travel? Is it vacation or photography job thing?


A couple of weeks vacation in Rome and Tuscany. Villages, cities, streets, people, interiors, landscapes. Here's one from Venice a few years ago:



© chiron 2022

Oct 01, 2022 at 08:54 PM
lensfan
Offline
Details
p.1 #10What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote:
A couple of weeks vacation in Rome and Tuscany. Villages, cities, streets, people, interiors, landscapes.


In this case its 24-70 2.8 GM II - case closed.

Versatile, lightest (the only lens you need), optimal available image quality for a standard zooms covering most important focal lengths, best performer compared to older and non-sony lenses, bright enough, covers essential 24mm (28mm is not enough in many situations and under time constraints). Will get you those shots you don't want to miss (including action and unexpected stuff) without lugging around extra gear, saving space and weight in your bags, not wasting time zooming with your feet or changing lenses or thinking which lens would be most appropriate or remembering how this one particular operates, etc.

On vacation time is always a factor - so use the best standard zoom in existence. This is especially valid today, when GM II is so good optically, weight and performance wise.
Oct 01, 2022 at 10:24 PM
Frogfish
Offline
Details
p.1 #11What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote:
lensfan wroteNot sure what you are looking for. What do you mean by travel? Is it vacation or photography job thing?
A couple of weeks vacation in Rome and Tuscany. Villages, cities, streets, people, interiors, landscapes. Here's one from Venice a few years ago:


This is important qualifying information missing from the OP (and maybe why responses have been thin). The theme 'Travel' is a wide reaching term and has so much variety contained in that one simple word, that it likely means something different to everyone.

Travel with your partner, children, alone, hiking-camping, Winter/Summer, mountains or towns, staying in hotels or B&Bs, driving-flying, shooting astro or landscapes or cities or people etc. etc. : each can mean a different lens / camera set-up.

And your definition covers a plethora of different situations / subjects that would, for what you are asking, mean a variety of different lenses. Rendering is far less important per se (assuming PP and shooting at typical deep landscape apertures) for landscapes and interiors than shooting for street or people. Most people too, now accept that colour can easily be adjusted in post regardless of camera/lens.

Generally carrying lenses to cover all those subjects means a compromise. Either in rendering, weight or widest aperture etc.

Personally the lenses I use at home to cover those subjects are heavier than those I use for travel (unless staying exclusively in hotels and without the family).

Sorry I realise this isn't going to be of much help but it is a very personal choice. Personally the weight is a priority, so as long as the rendering isn't horrendous that opens up other factors that are of more importance (aperture, sharpness and weight).

For those locations (which I've been to numerous times - having lived close by in Austria for 3 years) I'd take (although this may not address your questions) : Voigt 15mm, SY18, SY 24/1.8 (astro and mountains, + weight, being a priority for me, the stunningly beautiful Dolomites are so close!) if not then replace those 3 with the Sony 16-35 PZ, plus the Voigt 35/1.7 and SY45 and the Tamron 70-180 is an excellent lens overall and has replaced the 100-400 in my bag for 'travel' of any nature. If I was with family then also a fast 50 or 85mm (depending on your preference).
Oct 01, 2022 at 10:51 PM
chiron
Online
Details
p.1 #12What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Frogfish wrote:
chiron wrote
lensfan wroteNot sure what you are looking for. What do you mean by travel? Is it vacation or photography job thing?
A couple of weeks vacation in Rome and Tuscany. Villages, cities, streets, people, interiors, landscapes. Here's one from Venice a few years ago:
This is important qualifying information missing from the OP (and maybe why responses have been thin). The theme 'Travel' is a wide reaching term and has so much variety contained in that one simple word, that it likely means something different to everyone.

Travel with your partner, children, alone, hiking-camping, Winter/Summer, mountains or towns, staying in hotels or B&Bs, driving-flying, shooting astro or landscapes or cities or people etc. etc. : each can mean a different lens / camera set-up.

And your definition covers a plethora of different situations / subjects that would, for what you are asking, mean a variety
...Show more →

I really do think the question is fairly simple. Good rendering, and relatively small and light lenses. I specified AF. Cartier-Bresson covered the entire world for fifty years, usually with only a single 50mm Leitz lens, and only very occasionally a 35 or 135 or a second 50 that was a touch faster than his usual. Your preferred lenses, especially the primes, are a fairly specialized set that works well for you but nothing that says a particular type of travel more than does a set of the Batis or the i series Sigma.
Oct 02, 2022 at 06:38 AM
GoroMajima
Offline
Details
p.1 #13What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Just get the Sigma 28-70 DN, no standart zoom renders as nicely as this one.
Oct 02, 2022 at 06:51 AM
lensfan
Offline
Details
p.1 #14What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
GoroMajima wrote:
Just get the Sigma 28-70 DN, no standart zoom renders as nicely as this one.


But it misses super important 24-28mm range essential for indoors and architecture. I realized vast majority of my travel shots were in this area.
Back in Canon days I shot 24-70 2.8 L II 95%+ of the time. Covered 50+ countries with it including hundreds Italian cities mentioned there. At the same time I also owned 24-104 4 L, 16-35 4 L, 70-200 2.8 L IS II, Sigma 1.4/35 Art, 40mm pankake, first gen nifty fifty with metal bayonet and a couple more but was never tempted to take any of those on my trips.
iPhone was always my best companion to standard zoom. Today it offers even greater images at 3 focal lengths. Even gives you ultra wide which is perfectly usable in good light for your memories.

24-70 GM II paired with latest body has superior IQ and is several hundred grams lighter than DSLR combo - makes it even more attractive option.

Another thing I did not mention - single lens saves you from cleaning lenses and sensor, especially in windy and sandy places.
Oct 02, 2022 at 07:23 AM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.1 #15What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote:
What are the best-rendering autofocus lenses for travel?


What kind of *travel* photos at large apertures and close focus (where "renderz" would be a factor) do you have in mind? Food pics?
Oct 02, 2022 at 11:29 AM
chiron
Online
Details
p.1 #16What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
vdo1 wrote:
chiron wroteWhat are the best-rendering autofocus lenses for travel?
What kind of *travel* photos at large apertures and close focus (where "renderz" would be a factor) do you have in mind? Food pics?


I almost never photograph food. But I find that a lens's rendering is a factor in more than large ap/close focus pics. Above is an example of the kind of picture i frequently take.
Oct 02, 2022 at 11:57 AM
Matt Kerby
Offline
Details
p.1 #17What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
For AF I use an a7c, Tammy 28-200 and my 24GM...The 24GM renders beautifully and the Tammy is a VERY versatile superzoom that's sharp at both ends and starts at 2.8. That said, my actual travel kit (traveling abroad) is my m10r, 35 Summilux, 50 summilux and 75 Summarit that all fits in a Tenba BYOB slim Backpack insert.
Oct 02, 2022 at 12:04 PM
goodbokeh
Offline
Details
p.1 #18What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote:
chiron wroteA couple of weeks vacation in Rome and Tuscany. Villages, cities, streets, people, interiors, landscapes.
In this case its 24-70 2.8 GM II - case closed.

Versatile, lightest (the only lens you need), optimal available image quality for a standard zooms covering most important focal lengths, best performer compared to older and non-sony lenses, bright enough, covers essential 24mm (28mm is not enough in many situations and under time constraints). Will get you those shots you don't want to miss (including action and unexpected stuff) without lugging around extra gear, saving space and weight in your bags, not wasting time zooming with your feet or changing lenses or thinking which lens would be most appropriate
...Show more →

I also have the 24-70 GM II. The huge fly in the ointment for me is it's now 6 months after introduction and the GM II still does not have a full lens profile for distortion corrections from Adobe for use in Adobe Camera Raw and Lightroom. And there is no Adobe lens profile update in sight. That is a Big Deal and disappointment I have with the GM II.

So for now 24-70 GM II owners are stuck either using Jpegs, eyeballing Raw corrections themselves, or trying the 24-70 GM I Adobe profile and eyeballing corrections there also. Not good, not good at all.
Oct 02, 2022 at 12:24 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.1 #19What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Chiron, you know my vote. I travel with my Batis primes ( 25, 40 and 85 ). They are small enough to not be too heavy, yet deliver the type of image quality you are looking at. They are also fast enough to handle lower light conditions. If you want a bit wider, throw in the Sony 20...but to me the 20mm range is something I would not shoot anymore than maybe 5% of the images.

I use neoprene wraps to protect the lenses in a Osprey backpack which also holds my passport, wallet, water, sun lotion and sweater or jacket.
Oct 02, 2022 at 12:36 PM
chiron
Online
Details
p.1 #20What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chez wrote:
Chiron, you know my vote. I travel with my Batis primes ( 25, 40 and 85 ). They are small enough to not be too heavy, yet deliver the type of image quality you are looking at. They are also fast enough to handle lower light conditions. If you want a bit wider, throw in the Sony 20...but to me the 20mm range is something I would not shoot anymore than maybe 5% of the images.

I use neoprene wraps to protect the lenses in a Osprey backpack which also holds my passport, wallet, water, sun lotion and sweater or jacket.
...Show more →

Yes, Chez, I do know your vote and you know I agree on the Batis. I wish they were a hair smaller, but I love the look they give and their colors and graceful rendering. I even have the Batis 18, if I want to take it, which is a wonderful lens. I do also like the Sigma i series, especially the 45/2.8, the 65/2.0, and the 35/2.0, in that order, and they have the advantage of being smaller.

I want to take two cameras with me, each with a lens on. I have two A7C bodies. I am wondering about taking them or buying a second A9 and taking two of those (and selling some of what is left). I'll have to see what actually fits in the bag I want to take.

I like the size of the A7C, its focusing, and its sensor. I like the fast read-out of the A9 so that I have fewer worries about LED and other flickering lighting and its focusing.

Edited on Oct 02, 2022 at 01:08 PM · View previous versions
Oct 02, 2022 at 01:06 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister