So I picked up a tc-1.4 iii after seeing so many people having great success with the Z9 and 500mmpf lens. I got it on Thursday and headed straight to my duck spot for some photos. First impressions was that it wasn’t as sharp as I was expecting or what I had seen people pst on here. Here are 2 shots of a duck on the same rock. One with the tc on and one with the bare lens. Both cropped down to relatively the same size so the images look similar. Maybe I am missing the point of the tc but if I can crop the bare lens down to the same crop as I would get with the tc on and the images look the same why use the tc? I would even dare to say that after the bigger crop on the bare lens compared to that of tc that the bare lens photo is still sharper. Is this your experience as well? At this point I am tempted to send the tc back and use my money on something else. I might test it out a little more before making a final decision.
The water droplets in the TC image may indicate that there was subject movement.
Depth of field (with an acceptable circle of confusion for critical sharpness comparisons) is very thin at 500mm f/5.6. Depth of field at 700mm f/8 is even thinner for smaller distances (at 5m, you have about 2/3 of the DOF of the bare lens).
High ISO may invalidate any gains in resolution due to noise.
Shutter shock or camera movement may also invalidate the higher resolution of the TC image.
TC images has more pixels to work with, so sharpening does work better provided that noise is limited.
In my view, at 500mm f/5.6, a valid comparison of the bare lens and the lens with TC can only be done with a tripod and a static subject.
Thanks for the response. There was no subject movement as both photos the duck was resting on the rock. The water droplets in the one photo are from the duck in the BG which is not the main subject. Also, Even if there was subject movement 1/1600 should have been fast enough to stop it. I will try a test with a static subject on a tripod and see what happens. I would imagine it will mirror what I posted in the original post.
AcuteShadows wrote:
As mentioned, heat wave may be an issue.
The water droplets in the TC image may indicate that there was subject movement.
Depth of field (with an acceptable circle of confusion for critical sharpness comparisons) is very thin at 500mm f/5.6. Depth of field at 700mm f/8 is even thinner for smaller distances (at 5m, you have about 2/3 of the DOF of the bare lens).
High ISO may invalidate any gains in resolution due to noise.
Shutter shock or camera movement may also invalidate the higher resolution of the TC image.
TC images has more pixels to work with, so sharpening does work better provided that noise is limited.
In my view, at 500mm f/5.6, a valid comparison of the bare lens and the lens with TC can only be done with a tripod and a static subject....Show more →
A TC is helpful when you do not want to crop. In other words when you need the pixels for printing. If you are just posting on the web, in my opinion, crop away.
in rereading this there is one statement that needs to be dealt with: TC images has more pixels to work with
any image taken with any digital camera will have only the fixed number of pixels available from the sensor itself. A TC magnifies an image but it does not ad “pixels”.
Some more test shots with and without the tc cropped to be close to the same size. Obviously the 500mm shots were cropped a lot more. Not much difference imo. Thoughts?? Tripod used this time. Unfortunately the light cjanged a little in the last 2 shots the sun was setting.
eorlando wrote:
Some more test shots with and without the tc cropped to be close to the same size. Obviously the 500mm shots were cropped a lot more. Not much difference imo. Thoughts?? Tripod used this time. Unfortunately the light cjanged a little in the last 2 shots the sun was setting.
Can you specify whether the 500mm image is scaled up, or the 700mm scaled down? Is the picture that is scaled up presented at 100%, i.e. one pixel of the image equals one pixel on the screen (after looking at the image in a separate window and zooming in with the mouse)?
I honestly don’t know. All I did was import them into Lightroom and then crop them so that they looked similar and then exported them.
AcuteShadows wrote: eorlando wroteSome more test shots with and without the tc cropped to be close to the same size. Obviously the 500mm shots were cropped a lot more. Not much difference imo. Thoughts?? Tripod used this time. Unfortunately the light cjanged a little in the last 2 shots the sun was setting.
6. 700mm https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51949201330_f5e4d7a7e5_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on FlickrCan you specify whether the 500mm image is scaled up, or the 700mm scaled down? Is the picture that is scaled up presented at 100%, i.e. one pixel of the image equals one pixel on the screen (after looking at the image in a separate window and zooming in with the mouse)?
eorlando wrote:
I honestly don’t know. All I did was import them into Lightroom and then crop them so that they looked similar and then exported them.
AcuteShadows wroteeorlando wroteSome more test shots with and without the tc cropped to be close to the same size. Obviously the 500mm shots were cropped a lot more. Not much difference imo. Thoughts?? Tripod used this time. Unfortunately the light cjanged a little in the last 2 shots the sun was setting.
6. 700mm https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51949201330_f5e4d7a7e5_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on FlickrCan you specify whether the 500mm image is scaled up, or the 700mm scaled down? Is the picture that is scaled up presented at 100%, i.e. one pixel of the image equals one pixel on the screen (after looking at the image in a separate window and zooming in with the mouse)?
Without this information, it's difficult, if not impossible, to make any determination with regard to the sharpness of the lens.
It would be best to have the following images, without any sharpening except where specified:
Okay seriously, my true opinion on them is: the apparent sharpness of a bird shot is mainly due to being able to distinguish the basic fine feather detail. Maybe not all the fine feather detail, but the detail of the main feathers. When that is not obstructed by a TC, a TC will look good and get you more pixels on your subject, and so therefore it will be a good way of enlarging a photo compared to without a TC.
However, with that duck photo, due to conditions and other factors, the lens is kind of already at its limit to resolve detail, and therefore adding a TC won't add much apparent detail since it also reduces the lens' resolving power, so it's not like you're using a true 700mm lens with the same sharpness.
I think every bird photographer must know of the following fact: different birds have very different feathers and some feathers have larger strands that look much sharper at longer distances than others. Have you ever compared a Cedar Waxwing to a Grey Catbird? Grey Catbirds look very sharp even with lesser lenses whereas you need a very sharp lens and excellent technique to make a Cedar Waxwing look good. That is another reason why you might see some extreme crops with TC's look good. Some birds just make a lens look better than it really is.
There is no doubt that a TC adds some detail compared to cropping. However, when you compare any two images side by side, I think there won't be much difference between the two. Given the hassle of having to put one on, decide whether it's necessary, and accept the additional glass elements that reduce optical quality, I think it's better just to leave it off and crop.
I also agree that the best case use of TC's is when the bird is closer and the image already would have looked really good without the TC, and you just need a few more pixels for its final output size.
Thanks for the detailed response. I really appreciate it. So far it sounds like I am better off without the tc for my specific needs.
JasonTheBirder wrote:
Here's my opinion on TC's. They're total junk.
Okay seriously, my true opinion on them is: the apparent sharpness of a bird shot is mainly due to being able to distinguish the basic fine feather detail. Maybe not all the fine feather detail, but the detail of the main feathers. When that is not obstructed by a TC, a TC will look good and get you more pixels on your subject, and so therefore it will be a good way of enlarging a photo compared to without a TC.
However, with that duck photo, due to conditions and other factors, the lens is kind of already at its limit to resolve detail, and therefore adding a TC won't add much apparent detail since it also reduces the lens' resolving power, so it's not like you're using a true 700mm lens with the same sharpness.
I think every bird photographer must know of the following fact: different birds have very different feathers and some feathers have larger strands that look much sharper at longer distances than others. Have you ever compared a Cedar Waxwing to a Grey Catbird? Grey Catbirds look very sharp even with lesser lenses whereas you need a very sharp lens and excellent technique to make a Cedar Waxwing look good. That is another reason why you might see some extreme crops with TC's look good. Some birds just make a lens look better than it really is.
There is no doubt that a TC adds some detail compared to cropping. However, when you compare any two images side by side, I think there won't be much difference between the two. Given the hassle of having to put one on, decide whether it's necessary, and accept the additional glass elements that reduce optical quality, I think it's better just to leave it off and crop.
I also agree that the best case use of TC's is when the bird is closer and the image already would have looked really good without the TC, and you just need a few more pixels for its final output size....Show more →
eorlando wrote:
Thanks for the detailed response. I really appreciate it. So far it sounds like I am better off without the tc for my specific needs.
JasonTheBirder wroteHere's my opinion on TC's. They're total junk.
Okay seriously, my true opinion on them is: the apparent sharpness of a bird shot is mainly due to being able to distinguish the basic fine feather detail. Maybe not all the fine feather detail, but the detail of the main feathers. When that is not obstructed by a TC, a TC will look good and get you more pixels on your subject, and so therefore it will be a good way of enlarging a photo compared to without a TC.
However, with that duck photo, due to conditions and other factors, the lens is kind of already at its limit to resolve detail, and therefore adding a TC won't add much apparent detail since it also reduces the lens' resolving power, so it's not like you're using a true 700mm lens with the same sharpness.
I think every bird photographer must know of the following fact: different birds have very different feathers and some feathers have larger strands that look much sharper at longer distances than others. Have you ever compared a Cedar Waxwing to a Grey Catbird? Grey Catbirds look very sharp even with lesser lenses whereas you need a very sharp lens and excellent technique to make a Cedar Waxwing look good. That is another reason why you might see some extreme crops with TC's look good. Some birds just make a lens look better than it really is.
There is no doubt that a TC adds some detail compared to cropping. However, when you compare any two images side by side, I think there won't be much difference between the two. Given the hassle of having to put one on, decide whether it's necessary, and accept the additional glass elements that reduce optical quality, I think it's better just to leave it off and crop.
I also agree that the best case use of TC's is when the bird is closer and the image already would have looked really good without the TC, and you just need a few more pixels for its final output size.
I don't think it's possible to draw conclusions based on the information we have at this moment.
I am not sure how to do any of the things that you requested in light room. I don’t mind sending someone the JPEG’s that can do it and see but I don’t know anything about upscaling and everything else
AcuteShadows wrote: eorlando wroteI honestly don’t know. All I did was import them into Lightroom and then crop them so that they looked similar and then exported them.
AcuteShadows wroteeorlando wroteSome more test shots with and without the tc cropped to be close to the same size. Obviously the 500mm shots were cropped a lot more. Not much difference imo. Thoughts?? Tripod used this time. Unfortunately the light cjanged a little in the last 2 shots the sun was setting.
6. 700mm https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51949201330_f5e4d7a7e5_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on FlickrCan you specify whether the 500mm image is scaled up, or the 700mm scaled down? Is the picture that is scaled up presented at 100%, i.e. one pixel of the image equals one pixel on the screen (after looking at the image in a separate window and zooming in with the mouse)?Without this information, it's difficult, if not impossible, to make any determination with regard to the sharpness of the lens.
It would be best to have the following images, without any sharpening except where specified: