fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022Teleconverter questions w/ pics

  
 
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Teleconverter questions w/ pics
eorlando wrote:
I am not sure how to do any of the things that you requested in light room. I don’t mind sending someone the JPEG’s that can do it and see but I don’t know anything about upscaling and everything else

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI honestly don’t know. All I did was import them into Lightroom and then crop them so that they looked similar and then exported them.

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteSome more test shots with and without the tc cropped to be close to the same size. Obviously the 500mm shots were cropped a lot more. Not much difference imo. Thoughts?? Tripod used this time. Unfortunately the light cjanged a little in the last 2 shots the sun was setting.

1. 500mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51948906894_8c9ce5b070_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

2. 700mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51948942079_24153516a4_k.jpgA5575AE8-3C85-4E5E-A5AE-66A3F9A2AF81 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

3. 500mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51948695758_97ea18fb5b_k.jpg955DD0AB-E02A-4A52-8283-D594726D1456 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

4. 700mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51949201390_299e7e8af9_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

5. 500mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51947611982_4d2eca621c_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

6. 700mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51949201330_f5e4d7a7e5_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr
Can you specify whether the 500mm image is scaled up, or the 700mm scaled down? Is the picture that is scaled up presented at 100%, i.e. one pixel of the image equals one pixel on the screen (after looking at the image in a separate window and zooming in with the mouse)?
Without this information, it's difficult, if not impossible, to make any determination with regard to the sharpness of the lens.

It would be best to have the following images, without any sharpening except where specified:

* 500mm at 100%

* 700mm at 100%

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4

* 700mm scaled down by 1.4

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4, with best sharpening

* 700mm at 100%, with best sharpening


I'm using CaptureOne and can't give you detailed information on Lightroom.

Generally, when exporting an image (converting it into JPG), you specify the size of the resulting image (or you are using whatever default size the program uses).

If these images are not 100% (i.e. at pixel level), then many different things can happen during the conversion from the RAW image to the JPG file: a default size may be set that causes scaling of the image, scaling can be done with very different algorithms, different sharpening algorithms may be applied to the image by default etc.

Thus, it is crucially important that all these extraneous factors are removed, in order to evaluate the lens or the lens/TC combination.
Mar 20, 2022 at 10:28 AM
eorlando
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Teleconverter questions w/ pics
Ok. When I exported them from Lightroom they were all exported at 100%. Not sure if that helps.

AcuteShadows wrote:
eorlando wroteI am not sure how to do any of the things that you requested in light room. I don’t mind sending someone the JPEG’s that can do it and see but I don’t know anything about upscaling and everything else

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI honestly don’t know. All I did was import them into Lightroom and then crop them so that they looked similar and then exported them.

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteSome more test shots with and without the tc cropped to be close to the same size. Obviously the 500mm shots were cropped a lot more. Not much difference imo. Thoughts?? Tripod used this time. Unfortunately the light cjanged a little in the last 2 shots the sun was setting.

1. 500mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51948906894_8c9ce5b070_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

2. 700mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51948942079_24153516a4_k.jpgA5575AE8-3C85-4E5E-A5AE-66A3F9A2AF81 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

3. 500mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51948695758_97ea18fb5b_k.jpg955DD0AB-E02A-4A52-8283-D594726D1456 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

4. 700mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51949201390_299e7e8af9_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

5. 500mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51947611982_4d2eca621c_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

6. 700mm
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51949201330_f5e4d7a7e5_k.jpgUntitled by Eric Orlando, on Flickr
Can you specify whether the 500mm image is scaled up, or the 700mm scaled down? Is the picture that is scaled up presented at 100%, i.e. one pixel of the image equals one pixel on the screen (after looking at the image in a separate window and zooming in with the mouse)?
Without this information, it's difficult, if not impossible, to make any determination with regard to the sharpness of the lens.

It would be best to have the following images, without any sharpening except where specified:

* 500mm at 100%

* 700mm at 100%

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4

* 700mm scaled down by 1.4

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4, with best sharpening

* 700mm at 100%, with best sharpening
I'm using CaptureOne and can't give you detailed information on Lightroom.

Generally, when exporting an image (converting it into JPG), you specify the size of the resulting image (or you are using whatever default size the program uses).

If these images are not 100% (i.e. at pixel level), then many different things can happen during the conversion from the RAW image to the JPG file: a default size may be set that causes scaling of the image, scaling can be done with very different algorithms, different sharpening algorithms may be applied to the image by default etc.

Thus, it is crucially important that
...Show more →
Mar 20, 2022 at 11:27 AM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Teleconverter questions w/ pics
eorlando wrote:
Ok. When I exported them from Lightroom they were all exported at 100%. Not sure if that helps.

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI am not sure how to do any of the things that you requested in light room. I don’t mind sending someone the JPEG’s that can do it and see but I don’t know anything about upscaling and everything else

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI honestly don’t know. All I did was import them into Lightroom and then crop them so that they looked similar and then exported them.

AcuteShadows wroteCan you specify whether the 500mm image is scaled up, or the 700mm scaled down? Is the picture that is scaled up presented at 100%, i.e. one pixel of the image equals one pixel on the screen (after looking at the image in a separate window and zooming in with the mouse)?
Without this information, it's difficult, if not impossible, to make any determination with regard to the sharpness of the lens.

It would be best to have the following images, without any sharpening except where specified:

* 500mm at 100%

* 700mm at 100%

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4

* 700mm scaled down by 1.4

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4, with best sharpening

* 700mm at 100%, with best sharpening
I'm using CaptureOne and can't give you detailed information on Lightroom.

Generally, when exporting an image (converting it into JPG), you specify the size of the resulting image (or you are using whatever default size the program uses).

If these images are not 100% (i.e. at pixel level), then many different things can happen during the conversion from the RAW image to the JPG file: a default size may be set that causes scaling of the image, scaling can be done with very different algorithms, different sharpening algorithms may be applied to the image by default etc.

Thus, it is crucially important that all these extraneous factors are removed, in order to evaluate the lens or the lens/TC combination.


The size of the duck is the same in both images. Unless you took the photo with TC from a greater distance, it is not possible that both images have been exported at 100%.

Another factor that may impact the image is JPG compression, which needs to be set at 100% when exporting (the default value may be less than 100%).
Mar 20, 2022 at 11:41 AM
eorlando
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Teleconverter questions w/ pics
Like I said in the original post both images were cropped down so that they looked similar. Then when I export them from Lightroom they were exported at 100% quality. I guess that does not correlate to the hundred percent that you are talking about. Sorry for the confusion. They were also shot in JPEG not raw

AcuteShadows wrote:
eorlando wroteOk. When I exported them from Lightroom they were all exported at 100%. Not sure if that helps.

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI am not sure how to do any of the things that you requested in light room. I don’t mind sending someone the JPEG’s that can do it and see but I don’t know anything about upscaling and everything else

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI honestly don’t know. All I did was import them into Lightroom and then crop them so that they looked similar and then exported them.
Without this information, it's difficult, if not impossible, to make any determination with regard to the sharpness of the lens.

It would be best to have the following images, without any sharpening except where specified:

* 500mm at 100%

* 700mm at 100%

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4

* 700mm scaled down by 1.4

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4, with best sharpening

* 700mm at 100%, with best sharpening
I'm using CaptureOne and can't give you detailed information on Lightroom.

Generally, when exporting an image (converting it into JPG), you specify the size of the resulting image (or you are using whatever default size the program uses).

If these images are not 100% (i.e. at pixel level), then many different things can happen during the conversion from the RAW image to the JPG file: a default size may be set that causes scaling of the image, scaling can be done with very different algorithms, different sharpening algorithms may be applied to the image by default etc.

Thus, it is crucially important that all these extraneous factors are removed, in order to evaluate the lens or the lens/TC combination.
The size of the duck is the same in both images. Unless you took the photo with TC from a greater distance, it is not possible that both images have been exported at 100%.

Another factor that may impact the image is JPG compression, which needs to be set at 100% when exporting (the default value may be less than 100%).

Mar 20, 2022 at 12:02 PM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Teleconverter questions w/ pics
eorlando wrote:
Like I said in the original post both images were cropped down so that they looked similar. Then when I export them from Lightroom they were exported at 100% quality. I guess that does not correlate to the hundred percent that you are talking about. Sorry for the confusion. They were also shot in JPEG not raw

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteOk. When I exported them from Lightroom they were all exported at 100%. Not sure if that helps.

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI am not sure how to do any of the things that you requested in light room. I don’t mind sending someone the JPEG’s that can do it and see but I don’t know anything about upscaling and everything else

AcuteShadows wroteWithout this information, it's difficult, if not impossible, to make any determination with regard to the sharpness of the lens.

It would be best to have the following images, without any sharpening except where specified:

* 500mm at 100%

* 700mm at 100%

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4

* 700mm scaled down by 1.4

* 500mm scaled up by 1.4, with best sharpening

* 700mm at 100%, with best sharpening
I'm using CaptureOne and can't give you detailed information on Lightroom.

Generally, when exporting an image (converting it into JPG), you specify the size of the resulting image (or you are using whatever default size the program uses).

If these images are not 100% (i.e. at pixel level), then many different things can happen during the conversion from the RAW image to the JPG file: a default size may be set that causes scaling of the image, scaling can be done with very different algorithms, different sharpening algorithms may be applied to the image by default etc.

Thus, it is crucially important that all these extraneous factors are removed, in order to evaluate the lens or the lens/TC combination.
The size of the duck is the same in both images. Unless you took the photo with TC from a greater distance, it is not possible that both images have been exported at 100%.

Another factor that may impact the image is JPG compression, which needs to be set at 100% when exporting (the default value may be less than 100%).


When cropping an image, you are removing parts of the image, leaving the rest of the image unchanged. Thus, cropping does not change the size of objects in the image, measured in pixels. I'm not sure what you describe as "cropping down". If you have taken both images at the same distance, then, at some point in the workflow, one or both of the images have been scaled up or down, not just cropped.
Mar 20, 2022 at 12:09 PM
eorlando
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Teleconverter questions w/ pics
Gotcha. Both images were taken from the same distance. Both cropped in Lightroom to make the duck or turkey look the same size. Then I exported them at 100% quality to my phone. Then uploaded to Flickr and posted here. Unless one of those actions made them upscaled I’m not sure how it would have happened. Clearly I am a novice when it comes to this. Sorry.

AcuteShadows wrote:
eorlando wroteLike I said in the original post both images were cropped down so that they looked similar. Then when I export them from Lightroom they were exported at 100% quality. I guess that does not correlate to the hundred percent that you are talking about. Sorry for the confusion. They were also shot in JPEG not raw

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteOk. When I exported them from Lightroom they were all exported at 100%. Not sure if that helps.

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteI am not sure how to do any of the things that you requested in light room. I don’t mind sending someone the JPEG’s that can do it and see but I don’t know anything about upscaling and everything else
I'm using CaptureOne and can't give you detailed information on Lightroom.

Generally, when exporting an image (converting it into JPG), you specify the size of the resulting image (or you are using whatever default size the program uses).

If these images are not 100% (i.e. at pixel level), then many different things can happen during the conversion from the RAW image to the JPG file: a default size may be set that causes scaling of the image, scaling can be done with very different algorithms, different sharpening algorithms may be applied to the image by default etc.

Thus, it is crucially important that all these extraneous factors are removed, in order to evaluate the lens or the lens/TC combination.
The size of the duck is the same in both images. Unless you took the photo with TC from a greater distance, it is not possible that both images have been exported at 100%.

Another factor that may impact the image is JPG compression, which needs to be set at 100% when exporting (the default value may be less than 100%).
When cropping an image, you are removing parts of the image, leaving the rest of the image unchanged. Thus, cropping does not change the size of objects in the image, measured in pixels. I'm not sure what you describe as "cropping down". If you have taken both images at the same distance, then, at some point in the workflow, one or both of the images have been scaled up or down, not just cropped.

Mar 20, 2022 at 12:13 PM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Teleconverter questions w/ pics
eorlando wrote:
Gotcha. Both images were taken from the same distance. Both cropped in Lightroom to make the duck or turkey look the same size. Then I exported them at 100% quality to my phone. Then uploaded to Flickr and posted here. Unless one of those actions made them upscaled I’m not sure how it would have happened. Clearly I am a novice when it comes to this. Sorry.

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteLike I said in the original post both images were cropped down so that they looked similar. Then when I export them from Lightroom they were exported at 100% quality. I guess that does not correlate to the hundred percent that you are talking about. Sorry for the confusion. They were also shot in JPEG not raw

AcuteShadows wrote
eorlando wroteOk. When I exported them from Lightroom they were all exported at 100%. Not sure if that helps.

AcuteShadows wroteI'm using CaptureOne and can't give you detailed information on Lightroom.

Generally, when exporting an image (converting it into JPG), you specify the size of the resulting image (or you are using whatever default size the program uses).

If these images are not 100% (i.e. at pixel level), then many different things can happen during the conversion from the RAW image to the JPG file: a default size may be set that causes scaling of the image, scaling can be done with very different algorithms, different sharpening algorithms may be applied to the image by default etc.

Thus, it is crucially important that all these extraneous factors are removed, in order to evaluate the lens or the lens/TC combination.
The size of the duck is the same in both images. Unless you took the photo with TC from a greater distance, it is not possible that both images have been exported at 100%.

Another factor that may impact the image is JPG compression, which needs to be set at 100% when exporting (the default value may be less than 100%).
When cropping an image, you are removing parts of the image, leaving the rest of the image unchanged. Thus, cropping does not change the size of objects in the image, measured in pixels. I'm not sure what you describe as "cropping down". If you have taken both images at the same distance, then, at some point in the workflow, one or both of the images have been scaled up or down, not just cropped.


Again, if the size of an object is different in two images, you cannot make it look the same size by cropping. Thus, somewhere in your workflow, there is a scaling operation with unknown properties.

The images are fine, and you certainly do not need to understand the details of post-processing in order to produce excellent images. Without those details, however, it's not possible to evaluate the TC/lens combination.
Mar 20, 2022 at 12:20 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister