Motion blur is a creative choice. I'm not in the camp that everything needs to be sharp, all the time. Some blur implies movement and things move. It often feels more natural if there's some blur in an image, to me.
flash wrote:
Motion blur is a creative choice. I'm not in the camp that everything needs to be sharp, all the time. Some blur implies movement and things move. It often feels more natural if there's some blur in an image, to me.
Gordon
+1
Imo, it depends on whether the motion is pertinent (by intent) to the message being conveyed. If it is going to be perceived as an obvious technical error (e.g. motion blur from an eye blink in a sitting portrait), then it might not be as prudent as seeing the intentional effect of capturing motion (wheel blur on a race car, etc.). But, then again, if it is your intent to convey the motion of a wink ...
Always a decision whether to freeze or allow motion. Then, the trickier part of "how much" motion do you allow ... just another element in the creative decisions.
I did notice a small dust spot on yesterday's images. So, before I went to the Winery this afternoon I used the Sensor Clean Function and my Rocket blower to try an get it off the sensor. It is just a simple function that opens the shutter to provide access to the sensor. Easy and uncomplicated. Since the camera doesn't have IBIS there is no shaking/vibration function available, and you don't have to lock the sensor down.
There are no dust spots on this afternoon's images, so it must have worked.
It is amusing to read the big deal some of the manufactures are making about having the shutter closed to protect the sensor from dust when changing lenses. Since the Leica Range Finders don't read anything off the sensor unless in live view, it has had this function probably since the beginning.
It was an enjoyable afternoon out at the Winery with friends. But photographically I wasn't that interested. I didn't want to just take pictures of the statues in bad light. There were no leaves on the vines, and frankly the whole place was uninspiring. I thought I may get skunked today, and have to show a boring image of a less than magnificent sculpture. Of course there was still a chance that I would see something on the way home.
Most of the group had already left. I stopped to go to the bathroom before the drive home. After that I stopped by the tasting bar to thank our servers. The Ashley walked in for the later shift. She shares her time I think between being a server and a singer. The minute I saw her I knew I wanted to do a portrait of here. I am usually very shy of asking young women to take their picture. But I was desperate for a subject so gave it a swing. She said yes. She was dressed a bit too provocatively for me to feel comfortable taking a full body portrait. So I decided to just do one of her face and make up.
I also instantly felt that the right lens for this was my CV 75mm f/1.5 Nokton. Even though in practice I had found this a difficult lens to shoot I decided to go with it. I had a concept that I though this lens could help me create. I wanted a dreamy look to the portrait, so knew I had to shoot close to wide. open to blur out the ugly background I had to work with. However, in my testing I that found that wide open at f/1.5 was too soft and glowing for my taste. I would stop down a bit to reduce this effect. It was an enjoyable afternoon out at the Winery with friends. But photographically I wasn't that interested. I didn't want to just take pictures of the statues in bad light. There were no leaves on the vines, and frankly the whole place was uninspiring. I thought I may get skunked today, and have to show a boring image of a less than magnificent sculpture. Of course there was still a chance that I would see something on the way home.
Most of the group had already left. I stopped to go to the bathroom before the drive home. After that I stopped by the tasting bar to thank our servers. The Ashley walked in for the later shift. She shares her time I think between being a server and a singer. The minute I saw her I knew I wanted to do a portrait of here. I am usually very shy of asking young women to take their picture. But I was desperate for a subject so gave it a swing. She said yes. She was dressed a bit too provocatively for me to feel comfortable taking a full body portrait. So I decided to just do one of her face and make up.
I also instantly felt that the right lens for this was my CV 75mm f/1.5 Nokton. Even though in practice I had found this a difficult lens to shoot I decided to go with it. I had a concept that I though this lens could help me create. I wanted a dreamy look to the portrait, so knew I had to shoot close to wide. open to blur out the ugly background I had to work with. However, in my testing I that found that wide open at f/1.5 was too soft and glowing for my taste. I would stop down a bit to reduce this effect.
The tasting bar was under a large tent. The tent was positioned on a large white cement patio. This provided very nice "Open Shade Lighting" that is one of my favorite natural light setups for portraits. The bar surface itself was a very light tan color. I decided I could use that as a reflector to make even nicer light. So that is where I wanted to take the image.
I am very tall, and Ashley is a small woman. I knew to get the image I wanted I would have to get squared up with her face and at the same level. I brought up chairs for both of us, and had her pose with her arms crossed on the bar and lower her face to rest on the tops of here hand. I and the camera were now level with her face. This worked well for the lighting, because she was right up against the reflecting bar surface. It also allowed her to easily hold her face squared up the the camera. This was very important because I wanted to get both her eyes square with the sensor so they both would be in focus. The setup and the pose was now established. It took much longer to type this than actually do it.
Now to take the image. Exposure was easy with the beautiful even light we had. I used the range finder to focus. I firmly pressed my back up against the chair back so I could hold my range. This was critical with the shallow depth of field I would have. I then gently rocked back and forth very slightly will I shot images to make sure I would get one in focus. I shot a total of 11 frames of Ashely including the test exposure frames. I hoped I had gotten a good one, and second guessed myself all the way home.
In the end I am very pleased with the results. If I want to be critical I would say that my favorite frame (the one posted) is very slightly front focused. I think this can be verified looking at her hands, nose, and eyes. However, I think this is more than made up for with the color and rendering of the image. I don't know what is in the Leica sauce, but once again this image took almost no post processing. I love the color, the rendering, and the "look" right out of the camera. The posted image has just normal Light Room adjustments that took literally a few quick minutes. A small crop to remove a distraction from the left side, and position the arms at the bottom of the frame. Some typical exposure sliders. Absolute no work to the eyes. Yes they were that white. Once again zero vibrancy or saturation. I added the lightest of vignettes as well.
I am not sure where the magic of the "Leica Look" resides in the system. They seem to be able to maintain it through may iterations of various sensors. That leads me to believe it is in the maestro Image Processor. Whatever, I am drinking the Cool Aid and loving it. I need to make using this setup a natural thing for me. Right now I am having to work very hard to get good results.
It is only fair to say that I probably could also have gotten a very nice image with my Sony a1 under these conditions. For sure focus would be technically better. The Sony Eye AF would have ensured I got perfect focus on the pupil of the eye in every frame. But my experience also tells me that I would have had much more work to do in post.
Here is the portrait of Ashely from this afternoon's trip to the Vineyard. Comments, suggestions, and criticism welcome as always. I think I will also post this one in the People/Portrait Forum.
Enjoy,
-Steve-
PS I hand added the image/camera/lens data in the comments area under the image since the EXIF will be wrong as usual. An interesting aside, I think you can see me in the highlights in her eyes.
Leica M10-P CV 75mm f/1.5 Nokton - f/2, 1/1500 sec, ISO 200, Auto White Balance, Hand Held
1bwana1 wrote:
It was an enjoyable afternoon out at the Winery with friends. But photographically I wasn't that interested. I didn't want to just take pictures of the statues in bad light. There were no leaves on the vines, and frankly the whole place was uninspiring. I thought I may get skunked today, and have to show a boring image of a less than magnificent sculpture. Of course there was still a chance that I would see something on the way home.
Most of the group had already left. I stopped to go to the bathroom before the drive home. After that I stopped by the tasting bar to thank our servers. The Ashley walked in for the later shift. She shares her time I think between being a server and a singer. The minute I saw her I knew I wanted to do a portrait of here. I am usually very shy of asking young women to take their picture. But I was desperate for a subject so gave it a swing. She said yes. She was dressed a bit too provocatively for me to feel comfortable taking a full body portrait. So I decided to just do one of her face and make up.
I also instantly felt that the right lens for this was my CV 75mm f/1.5 Nokton. Even though in practice I had found this a difficult lens to shoot I decided to go with it. I had a concept that I though this lens could help me create. I wanted a dreamy look to the portrait, so knew I had to shoot close to wide. open to blur out the ugly background I had to work with. However, in my testing I that found that wide open at f/1.5 was too soft and glowing for my taste. I would stop down a bit to reduce this effect. It was an enjoyable afternoon out at the Winery with friends. But photographically I wasn't that interested. I didn't want to just take pictures of the statues in bad light. There were no leaves on the vines, and frankly the whole place was uninspiring. I thought I may get skunked today, and have to show a boring image of a less than magnificent sculpture. Of course there was still a chance that I would see something on the way home.
Most of the group had already left. I stopped to go to the bathroom before the drive home. After that I stopped by the tasting bar to thank our servers. The Ashley walked in for the later shift. She shares her time I think between being a server and a singer. The minute I saw her I knew I wanted to do a portrait of here. I am usually very shy of asking young women to take their picture. But I was desperate for a subject so gave it a swing. She said yes. She was dressed a bit too provocatively for me to feel comfortable taking a full body portrait. So I decided to just do one of her face and make up.
I also instantly felt that the right lens for this was my CV 75mm f/1.5 Nokton. Even though in practice I had found this a difficult lens to shoot I decided to go with it. I had a concept that I though this lens could help me create. I wanted a dreamy look to the portrait, so knew I had to shoot close to wide. open to blur out the ugly background I had to work with. However, in my testing I that found that wide open at f/1.5 was too soft and glowing for my taste. I would stop down a bit to reduce this effect.
The tasting bar was under a large tent. The tent was positioned on a large white cement patio. This provided very nice "Open Shade Lighting" that is one of my favorite natural light setups for portraits. The bar surface itself was a very light tan color. I decided I could use that as a reflector to make even nicer light. So that is where I wanted to take the image.
I am very tall, and Ashley is a small woman. I knew to get the image I wanted I would have to get squared up with her face and at the same level. I brought up chairs for both of us, and had her pose with her arms crossed on the bar and lower her face to rest on the tops of here hand. I and the camera were now level with her face. This worked well for the lighting, because she was right up against the reflecting bar surface. It also allowed her to easily hold her face squared up the the camera. This was very important because I wanted to get both her eyes square with the sensor so they both would be in focus. The setup and the pose was now established. It took much longer to type this than actually do it.
Now to take the image. Exposure was easy with the beautiful even light we had. I used the range finder to focus. I firmly pressed my back up against the chair back so I could hold my range. This was critical with the shallow depth of field I would have. I then gently rocked back and forth very slightly will I shot images to make sure I would get one in focus. I shot a total of 11 frames of Ashely including the test exposure frames. I hoped I had gotten a good one, and second guessed myself all the way home.
In the end I am very pleased with the results. If I want to be critical I would say that my favorite frame (the one posted) is very slightly front focused. I think this can be verified looking at her hands, nose, and eyes. However, I think this is more than made up for with the color and rendering of the image. I don't know what is in the Leica sauce, but once again this image took almost no post processing. I love the color, the rendering, and the "look" right out of the camera. The posted image has just normal Light Room adjustments that took literally a few quick minutes. A small crop to remove a distraction from the left side, and position the arms at the bottom of the frame. Some typical exposure sliders. Absolute no work to the eyes. Yes they were that white. Once again zero vibrancy or saturation. I added the lightest of vignettes as well.
I am not sure where the magic of the "Leica Look" resides in the system. They seem to be able to maintain it through may iterations of various sensors. That leads me to believe it is in the maestro Image Processor. Whatever, I am drinking the Cool Aid and loving it. I need to make using this setup a natural thing for me. Right now I am having to work very hard to get good results.
It is only fair to say that I probably could also have gotten a very nice image with my Sony a1 under these conditions. For sure focus would be technically better. The Sony Eye AF would have ensured I got perfect focus on the pupil of the eye in every frame. But my experience also tells me that I would have had much more work to do in post.
Here is the portrait of Ashely from this afternoon's trip to the Vineyard. Comments, suggestions, and criticism welcome as always. I think I will also post this one in the People/Portrait Forum.
Enjoy,
-Steve-
PS I hand added the image/camera/lens data in the comments area under the image since the EXIF will be wrong as usual. An interesting aside, I think you can see me in the highlights in her eyes....Show more →
Lovely shot captured very well. I actually like the slight front focus and sort of reject that focus on the Iris is the ideal in all portraits. The iris is sharp in this shot, but the focus plain seems to fall on her lips, which I think works extremely well for this shot. Her eyes are lovely, but I think the slightly different focus really makes this shot work and emphasizing her lips and her brow both of which are striking certainly is not a bad thing. I find focussing exactly on the iris can often work well, but sometimes leaves the noise out of focus and is sort of formulaic and although almost always a good choice just simply isn't always the best choice. I think with the advent of eye AF, that look with focus on the iris will become more standard and sort of trite. I like this better. My only suggestion is to consider a 4 X 5 crop. I love a 4 X 5 aspect ratio for portraits and you have the room to crop. Once again very nice shot.
Steve Spencer wrote: 1bwana1 wroteIt was an enjoyable afternoon out at the Winery with friends. But photographically I wasn't that interested. I didn't want to just take pictures of the statues in bad light. There were no leaves on the vines, and frankly the whole place was uninspiring. I thought I may get skunked today, and have to show a boring image of a less than magnificent sculpture. Of course there was still a chance that I would see something on the way home.
Most of the group had already left. I stopped to go to the bathroom before the drive home. After that I stopped by the tasting bar to thank our servers. The Ashley walked in for the later shift. She shares her time I think between being a server and a singer. The minute I saw her I knew I wanted to do a portrait of here. I am usually very shy of asking young women to take their picture. But I was desperate for a subject so gave it a swing. She said yes. She was dressed a bit too provocatively for me to feel comfortable taking a full body portrait. So I decided to just do one of her face and make up.
I also instantly felt that the right lens for this was my CV 75mm f/1.5 Nokton. Even though in practice I had found this a difficult lens to shoot I decided to go with it. I had a concept that I though this lens could help me create. I wanted a dreamy look to the portrait, so knew I had to shoot close to wide. open to blur out the ugly background I had to work with. However, in my testing I that found that wide open at f/1.5 was too soft and glowing for my taste. I would stop down a bit to reduce this effect. It was an enjoyable afternoon out at the Winery with friends. But photographically I wasn't that interested. I didn't want to just take pictures of the statues in bad light. There were no leaves on the vines, and frankly the whole place was uninspiring. I thought I may get skunked today, and have to show a boring image of a less than magnificent sculpture. Of course there was still a chance that I would see something on the way home.
Most of the group had already left. I stopped to go to the bathroom before the drive home. After that I stopped by the tasting bar to thank our servers. The Ashley walked in for the later shift. She shares her time I think between being a server and a singer. The minute I saw her I knew I wanted to do a portrait of here. I am usually very shy of asking young women to take their picture. But I was desperate for a subject so gave it a swing. She said yes. She was dressed a bit too provocatively for me to feel comfortable taking a full body portrait. So I decided to just do one of her face and make up.
I also instantly felt that the right lens for this was my CV 75mm f/1.5 Nokton. Even though in practice I had found this a difficult lens to shoot I decided to go with it. I had a concept that I though this lens could help me create. I wanted a dreamy look to the portrait, so knew I had to shoot close to wide. open to blur out the ugly background I had to work with. However, in my testing I that found that wide open at f/1.5 was too soft and glowing for my taste. I would stop down a bit to reduce this effect.
The tasting bar was under a large tent. The tent was positioned on a large white cement patio. This provided very nice "Open Shade Lighting" that is one of my favorite natural light setups for portraits. The bar surface itself was a very light tan color. I decided I could use that as a reflector to make even nicer light. So that is where I wanted to take the image.
I am very tall, and Ashley is a small woman. I knew to get the image I wanted I would have to get squared up with her face and at the same level. I brought up chairs for both of us, and had her pose with her arms crossed on the bar and lower her face to rest on the tops of here hand. I and the camera were now level with her face. This worked well for the lighting, because she was right up against the reflecting bar surface. It also allowed her to easily hold her face squared up the the camera. This was very important because I wanted to get both her eyes square with the sensor so they both would be in focus. The setup and the pose was now established. It took much longer to type this than actually do it.
Now to take the image. Exposure was easy with the beautiful even light we had. I used the range finder to focus. I firmly pressed my back up against the chair back so I could hold my range. This was critical with the shallow depth of field I would have. I then gently rocked back and forth very slightly will I shot images to make sure I would get one in focus. I shot a total of 11 frames of Ashely including the test exposure frames. I hoped I had gotten a good one, and second guessed myself all the way home.
In the end I am very pleased with the results. If I want to be critical I would say that my favorite frame (the one posted) is very slightly front focused. I think this can be verified looking at her hands, nose, and eyes. However, I think this is more than made up for with the color and rendering of the image. I don't know what is in the Leica sauce, but once again this image took almost no post processing. I love the color, the rendering, and the "look" right out of the camera. The posted image has just normal Light Room adjustments that took literally a few quick minutes. A small crop to remove a distraction from the left side, and position the arms at the bottom of the frame. Some typical exposure sliders. Absolute no work to the eyes. Yes they were that white. Once again zero vibrancy or saturation. I added the lightest of vignettes as well.
I am not sure where the magic of the "Leica Look" resides in the system. They seem to be able to maintain it through may iterations of various sensors. That leads me to believe it is in the maestro Image Processor. Whatever, I am drinking the Cool Aid and loving it. I need to make using this setup a natural thing for me. Right now I am having to work very hard to get good results.
It is only fair to say that I probably could also have gotten a very nice image with my Sony a1 under these conditions. For sure focus would be technically better. The Sony Eye AF would have ensured I got perfect focus on the pupil of the eye in every frame. But my experience also tells me that I would have had much more work to do in post.
Here is the portrait of Ashely from this afternoon's trip to the Vineyard. Comments, suggestions, and criticism welcome as always. I think I will also post this one in the People/Portrait Forum.
Enjoy,
-Steve-
PS I hand added the image/camera/lens data in the comments area under the image since the EXIF will be wrong as usual. An interesting aside, I think you can see me in the highlights in her eyes.Lovely shot captured very well. I actually like the slight front focus and sort of reject that focus on the Iris is the ideal in all portraits. The iris is sharp in this shot, but the focus plain seems to fall on her lips, which I think works extremely well for this shot. Her eyes are lovely, but I think the slightly different focus really makes this shot work and emphasizing her lips and her brow both of which are striking certainly is not a bad thing. I find focussing exactly on the iris can often work well, but sometimes leaves the noise out of focus and is sort of formulaic and although almost always a good choice just simply isn't always the best choice. I think with the advent of eye AF, that look with focus on the iris will become more standard and sort of trite. I like this better. My only suggestion is to consider a 4 X 5 crop. I love a 4 X 5 aspect ratio for portraits and you have the room to crop. Once again very nice shot....Show more →
+1
Sometimes, I think the concept of "acceptable DOF" is a concept that is not well understood, particularly wrt how the plane of focus transitions.
Imo, this (even if inadvertent) is a fine example of how the transition is working to not only an "acceptable DOF", but also a pleasing one. I think the elements of mass vs. focus are working together to give really nice balance to this ... as part of the key to why something that has "missed focus" can still look so nice. Could go more into the techno / physio aspect ... but, I'll spare us that for now.
I'm old enough to remember when portrait photographers (yeah I was guilty to) would put softar filters on our blad lenses when doing portraits of women to cut the sharpness of lenses like the 150 Sonnar or 180 Sonnars.
"Sharpness is a bourgeois concept."
Henri Cartier-Bresson
"I’m always amused by the idea that certain people have about technique, which translate into an immoderate taste for the sharpness of the image. It is a passion for detail, for perfection, or do they hope to get closer to reality with this trompe I’oeil? They are, by the way, as far away from the real issues as other generations of photographers were when they obscured their subject in soft-focus effects."
Henri Cartier-Bresson
Thanks for all the nice comments. They did cause me to take a detailed look at each of the 11 exposures. Despite my doubts regarding using this lens so wide open, I am happy to report that all but 3 are in what I would consider the "acceptable" range of focus. Similar to the one I posted. I did manage to nail it perfectly on three of those. Exposure is good on all of them. So, picking a favorite is a matter of expression, and gesture. I end up being torn between the posted one, and one that is perfect on the eyes. For that one I tried a 4 X5 crop, perfectly centered as suggest by Steven Spencer. It woks great. That is the version I sent to Ashley for her use.
Going forward I will be trying to use this lens more for this project.
I find it enjoyable and useful that this experiment is bringing up discussions about broader issues in photography. Thanks for the contributions with that.
Nice one to see. The colour is in the lens, though - I shoot this 75/1.5 on several Sonys, it always shines out-of-camera and balances very easily.
I'm curious as to why you feel it is 'a difficult lens to shoot'? I find the exact opposite. And quick focus acquisition is very important for found portraits like this one, to be able to verify focus at a moment's notice. The 'decisive moment', indeed depends on this. No one cares about slight misses if the image is strong.
PS BH lists it an a 'top seller'. At $900 that's no surprise.
philip_pj wrote:
Nice one to see. The colour is in the lens, though - I shoot this 75/1.5 on several Sonys, it always shines out-of-camera and balances very easily.
I'm curious as to why you feel it is 'a difficult lens to shoot'? I find the exact opposite. And quick focus acquisition is very important for found portraits like this one, to be able to verify focus at a moment's notice. The 'decisive moment', indeed depends on this. No one cares about slight misses if the image is strong.
PS BH lists it an a 'top seller'. At $900 that's no surprise.
Philip,
Welcome to the thread.
I have just started using a range finder camera. With the 75mm focal length I am usually after a shallow depth of field so am shooting it with wide apertures. Focus is critical. When I do decide to use Live View for the shot, I have the camera set up to zoom in when I move the focus ring. Zoomed in every tiny wiggle of the camera causes big swings in the rear screen. I have tremors in my hand that can make this really difficult. Finally, is the view in the range finder. Composition with the small box is harder.
It takes me a lot of work to shoot this lens with my current skill level. But when I do, I really love the results. I will make the effort to get good with it.
I hope that clarifies what I was saying.
Thanks for taking the time to contribute. I always appreciate the effort.