fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.

  
 
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.3 #1The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
200mm f/2 if you work out regularly
105mm f/1.4 if you work out occasionally
85mm f/1.8 if you never work out
Feb 09, 2022 at 10:51 PM
sputnik
Offline
Details
p.3 #2The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Using the term "best" is always tricky. Best sharpness, best character (whatever that is) etc? For me the sweet spot is between 85 and 135-ish. Lately I've become a bit uninspired by the 85/1.4D and tried the 105/1.4, which seem rally promising. I really liked the 135DC when I had it several years back. Right now my go to combo is the 58G and the 105/1.4.

I also had that 200/2 itch, but after having owned it, I realised it really wasn't for me. Way too big and cumbersome and much limited compared to the 70-200. For me I think that it's a lens that really shines for sports, especially since it practically gives you a 300/2.8 when you slap on a TC. I'm constantly amazed by how impressed people are about it's capability to "obliterate" backgrounds. While that is certainly true - I find that the use of minimum amount of dof usually distracts me when it comes to portraits. For sports and wildlife I do not feel the same way.
Feb 10, 2022 at 09:05 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.3 #3The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
For portraits:
Best overall, the 105/1.4 (and IMHO the Nikon version renders better or at least more pleasingly than the Sigma version);
Second best overall if you own the 105/1.4, the 58/1.4;
Second best overall if you do not own the 105/1.4, the 85/1.8S.
Most unique, the 200/2 (but you can get close to that with a 70-200/2.8S at 200/2.8);
Super unique but requires some working distance, the 300/2.8.

>flamesuit_on<
Feb 10, 2022 at 10:43 AM
rico
Online
Details
p.3 #4The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
elkhornsun wrote:
There is a reason why the 70-200mm lens is the single most popular lens for fashion photographers
...
Jeff Ascough, a well known and very successful wedding photographer in the UK stated that he looks for backgrounds first and then waits for something to happen. He recognized how important the background was to the strength of the images he produces for his clients. Look at any fashion magazine and see whether the photographer is relying on bokeh or instead is carefully choosing the backgrounds.


Exactly! The b/g anchors the subject in time and space. It should be present and identifiable. If the dumpster behind the subject cannot be avoided for some bizarre reason then hang a muslin. For some images like fashion a plain b/g is desirable but, even then, I like to see a drop shadow so the subject doesn't look like a cutout. I have no use for one-eyelash-in-focus portraits so am always at f/5.6 or so. A fast lens in this role is just deadweight. Given optical performance these days, I always choose an AF zoom like the kit 55-200 DX or the 70-200/4G FX. My 70-200/2.8E is also nice but heavier than I need.

D500, 17-55/2.8 DX:



D3X, 70-200/4:

Feb 10, 2022 at 01:50 PM
aerospace99
Offline
Details
p.3 #5The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
urbanwild wrote:
aerospace99 wroteAgree with the 58....my favorite Nikon lens by far. I switched from the 105 1.4E to a Zeiss Milvus 85 as I wanted slightly wider field of view. The 105 is superlative though. But for 35 I am using the Tamron 35 1.4. Amazing lens with great bokeh qualities. Does not get enough recognition but very sharp and contrasty images.
Thanks! How does it handle on the Z? My 45mm f1.8 tamron did no go well. The vib control was erratic and the focus was slow. Loved the image though.


It is very good but in low light on the Z7 it can miss once in a while but that would be true even of native lenses. On the Z7 it can create some nice rendering. In DX mode it makes a respectable 50mm image. Its the only wide I need or use. Wide open its very sharp, At 1.6, it is as good as 2.8.
Feb 11, 2022 at 04:29 AM
Lassep
Offline
Details
p.3 #6The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Thank you for all of the amazing suggestions and feedback.


After days of consideration and bargain hunting i have started to narrow down the long list of options to something useable.

I have ordered one lens so far. The 24-70mm 2.8S. I have read that it holds up well in overall image quality, considering its a zoom lens. I could get the whole lineup of primes for the same price, but i do favor the versatility.

My main portrait lens is going to be either the 105mm 1.4 or the 200mm F2. I am still undecided on that account. Though i am leaning towards the 105mm 1.4 for the portability and the considerable lower price. (and i do work out occationally)

My secondary portrait lens will be the Nikon 85mm 1.8S.

If i end up with the lower priced 105mm 1.4 i might also be adding the 58mm 1.4G as well, as i can get that at a pretty decent price.

For anyone curious, i will update this post once i make my final decision and i will post some images from each of the lenses once i receive them.
Feb 11, 2022 at 06:11 AM
sanjayg
Offline
Details
p.3 #7The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
I think you have made an excellent decision. I have 58g/105e and 200f2 myself and I am in awe every time I use these lenses for portraiture or otherwise. Of the 3, I find 58g needs some planning, thinking in terms of getting the best out of it but the 105e and 200f2, you can point them at anything and the pictures are great (yes, I am biased)

Lassep wrote:
Thank you for all of the amazing suggestions and feedback.

After days of consideration and bargain hunting i have started to narrow down the long list of options to something useable.

I have ordered one lens so far. The 24-70mm 2.8S. I have read that it holds up well in overall image quality, considering its a zoom lens. I could get the whole lineup of primes for the same price, but i do favor the versatility.

My main portrait lens is going to be either the 105mm 1.4 or the 200mm F2. I am still undecided on that account. Though i
...Show more →

Feb 11, 2022 at 08:37 AM
sanjayg
Offline
Details
p.3 #8The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
saaketham wrote:
200mm f/2 if you work out regularly
105mm f/1.4 if you work out occasionally
85mm f/1.8 if you never work out


... spot on!
Feb 11, 2022 at 08:39 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.3 #9The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Lassep wrote:
Thank you for all of the amazing suggestions and feedback.

After days of consideration and bargain hunting i have started to narrow down the long list of options to something useable.

I have ordered one lens so far. The 24-70mm 2.8S. I have read that it holds up well in overall image quality, considering its a zoom lens. I could get the whole lineup of primes for the same price, but i do favor the versatility.

My main portrait lens is going to be either the 105mm 1.4 or the 200mm F2. I am still undecided on that account. Though i
...Show more →

I think you've chosen well overall, but I would add two thoughts for you to consider: first is just get the 105/1.4 and 58/1.4 and use them for a bit -- I doubt you'll ever regret either purchase; second is that as nice as the 200/2 is, the Z 70-200/2.8 S is outstanding optically and arguably a lot more versatile assuming you can only do one.

Feb 11, 2022 at 11:00 AM
huddy
Offline
Details
p.3 #10The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Based on advice and your preferences, I think you have chosen well. The 105 is. Fantastic and IMO able to be used in more circumstances than the 200/2. Really for portraits at the 180-200mm length, I would lean towards the flexibility of a 70-200/2.8s or maybe an adapted E mount tamron 70-180 if you want something a bit smaller. That is a lens I really hope ends up in native Z mount at some point.

The 58/1.4 is fantastic. It takes time to master and of course isn't as sharp as the 85S or 105/1.4 but if you like that style of image It can be worth picking up and takig the time to learn.

For full disclosure I have a 58/1.4 but none of the others. I am waiting to see if the 70-180 ever comes into Native Z mount so that I have the versatility of a zoom. The 105/1.4 is on my bucket list of lenses to buy but very low priority just due to my own financial priorities.
Feb 11, 2022 at 05:53 PM
urbanwild
Offline
Details
p.3 #11The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Lassep wrote:
Thank you for all of the amazing suggestions and feedback.

After days of consideration and bargain hunting i have started to narrow down the long list of options to something useable.

I have ordered one lens so far. The 24-70mm 2.8S. I have read that it holds up well in overall image quality, considering its a zoom lens. I could get the whole lineup of primes for the same price, but i do favor the versatility.

My main portrait lens is going to be either the 105mm 1.4 or the 200mm F2. I am still undecided on that account. Though i
...Show more →

I think you'll be happy with these. The only consideration I would suggest is that the 85mm and the 105mm, while different, are not much different in terms of the focal length. You will certainly see a difference but having something a bit wider may serve you well. Now if you're okay with 2.8, the 24-70 f2.8 will cover all of this for you. But a 35mm or 50 / 58mm would be my second choice behind the 105mm in my opinion (in terms of primes). Enjoy - exciting times getting such quality gear!
Feb 12, 2022 at 01:33 PM
kilowhiskey
Offline
Details
p.3 #12The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Perhaps 2 bodies, 6 lenses, best of both worlds:

F body with:
58/1.4
105/1.4 or 100/2 DC
200/2

Z body with
24-70/2.8 Z
70-200/2.8 Z
85/1.8 Z

Lots of options there, not one option that is bad for portraits.
Feb 12, 2022 at 02:09 PM
urbanwild
Offline
Details
p.3 #13The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
The f-mount lenses perform more flawlessly with the mirrorless cameras in my opinion.

kilowhiskey wrote:
Perhaps 2 bodies, 6 lenses, best of both worlds:

F body with:
58/1.4
105/1.4 or 100/2 DC
200/2

Z body with
24-70/2.8 Z
70-200/2.8 Z
85/1.8 Z

Lots of options there, not one option that is bad for portraits.

Feb 13, 2022 at 01:34 AM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.3 #14The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
There is no such thing as a right or wrong answer as to which portrait lens is the "best". The more I see of all lenses, the more I am impressed by so many lenses, whether they be Nikon, Sony, Canon or Sigma or whatever. Personal preferences for the look of the result generally steer me towards Nikon, but that is just me. Having said that, regardless of make, the all make stunning lenses.

Having used a number of Nikon lenses, all I can say is that the 105 f1.4E has the ability to produce some stunning results at certain apertures and camera to subject distances. I would love to show my results, but they are of my grandson and I do not share private photos on the internet. You will just have to take my word for it, but the results are just superb, the bokeh just incredible, the sharpness, color etc is stunning. Is it better than a Sigma, Sony or a Canon? I do not know, but if the others could produce better results, I would be crying with emotion as to how good they must be.

This is by no means a push to sway you towards the Nikon 105 f1.4E, just my thoughts as I own it and having used it as well as a number of other great portrait lense like the 85 f1.4G. It is not without it's (minor) flaws (what lens does not have a few minor flaws), just that it can be a gem. I have no doubt that Sigma and Canon and Sony have superb lenses in specific focal lengths etc. Like I say, there is no right or wrong answer and we must be able to accept that so many other factors can make or break an image ather than who made the lens. We must accept that they all have the ability to make superb images and the end result isn't so much whether the lens is a Sigma, Sony, Canon or Nikon lens in a certain circumstance, but whether the light was right, or the subject matter was right or the correct aperture was used etc.

Feb 13, 2022 at 02:17 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.3 #15The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Unlike most others, let me be the first one to clearly state I am absolutely trying to push you towards owning both the Nikon 105/1.4 AND 58/1.4 as a killer portrait combo

(My other full disclosure comment is a small caveat: you will want to take some time playing with the 58 to learn its idiosyncracies -- once you do, it actually adds a bunch of flexibility to the lens and you'll probably end up using it a lot more than you ever thought you would. OTOH, the 105 will please for portraits right out of the gate.)
Feb 13, 2022 at 09:56 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.3 #16The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Lance B wrote:
... We must accept that they all have the ability to make superb images and the end result isn't so much whether the lens is a Sigma, Sony, Canon or Nikon lens in a certain circumstance, but whether the light was right, or the subject matter was right or the correct aperture was used etc.


I second Lance's comments. But let me add Zeiss too (ZF.2 100/2 & 135/2 lenses)
Feb 13, 2022 at 10:57 AM
Paul_K
Offline
Details
p.3 #17The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Although over the years I have been more then satisfied with the results from shooting withmclassics like
the 2/200VRI
https://a4.pbase.com/g1/20/670620/2/127455094.mNDzD6zA.jpg
(D3 2/200VRI at f2.2 1/800s iso4500 )
and 2/135mm DC (which I can use with AF - with some manual prefocussing for speed and reduced mechanical noise - on my Z bodies with the Megadap MTZ11)
https://a4.pbase.com/g9/20/670620/2/160167132.tQ1Xwqt9.jpg
(D800 2/135mm DC at f3.2 1/125s iso100)
my preferred lens for portraiture is the 1.4/58mm AFS

Love its image rendering and colors.
While the, due relatively short, but not too short, focal length, close distance it forces to shoot/be near the subject, allows a much more intimate closeness and atmosphere compared to shooting with longer lenses.
https://a4.pbase.com/g9/20/670620/2/164046023.N89if4pb.jpg
(D800 1.4 58mm AFS at f/2.2 1/2000s iso400)
https://a4.pbase.com/g9/20/670620/2/163822862.56WQJR86.jpg
(D800 1.4 58mm AFS at f/1.4 1/2000s iso1250)

Feb 13, 2022 at 02:26 PM
Sauseschritt
Offline
Details
p.3 #18The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
urbanwild wrote:
The f-mount lenses perform more flawlessly with the mirrorless cameras in my opinion.

As an owner of AF 60mm f2.8 micro, AF 105mm f2 DC and AF 180mm f2.8 I dont follow.
Feb 14, 2022 at 03:58 AM
stevekphotos
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #19The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Lassep wrote:
Dear friends

Having had a quick flirt with Sony in-between the Nikon D850 and now the Nikon Z9, i owned the 135 1.8GM. A masterpiece of a lens that really blew out the backgrounds, with silky smooth rendering. I adored that lens, but it couldent fit on the Nikon so it had to go.

The entire day i have been picking out my new Nikon kit, but i have yet to settle on the perfect portrait lens.

What is the best Nikon alternative? What would be your prime pick(s) for the best portrait lenses to use on the Z9?



Coming off a very similar debate I'll provide my own thoughts. I was originally considering jumping to Sony as my first mirrorless body (A1) and the 135mm 1.8GM would have been one of my primary lenses. I've had many "discussions" with ill informed people on this forum, who like to provide advice, but are completely clueless.

I ended up picking up the Z9 with the 50mm 1.2 instead, and no other Z mount lenses.

There's no difference between the Nikon 35mm 1.4, 58mm 1.4, 85mm 1.4, or 105mm 1.4 in general rendering.
Only real difference is in the amount of compression of the focal length.
58mm 1.4 is noticeably softer in the center compared to the other three.
58mm and 105mm are both noticeably dark in the center compared to the 35mm / 85mm (almost one full stop difference). I would almost refer to them as 58mm F2, and 105mm F2 because of that.

I only own the 35mm, and 85mm 1.4Gs because I don't think the 58mm/105mm are worth owning. They weren't an upgrade for me when they were released.

Sharpness is equal across the board, particularly on Z9. The newer 1.8 Z lenses do not render nearly as well after having the chance to shoot both side by side. They're dull, consumer grade glass, and focus MUCH slower than their 1.4G counterparts. They shouldn't be called "S" line. They should be called "C" line for consumer grade video lenses.

Bokeh on the 85mm 1.4 is rendered the best. 58mm, and 105mm are harsher by far.

I have a personal dislike for the 105mm after shooting it. The aspherical elements in that lens have a design flaw that green shifts, the lens creates a nauseating circular bokeh effect, as well as weird compression that creates vertical banding in any short distance background. It doesn't compare to the Sony 135mm 1.8, and it's a piss poor comparison to the 200mm F2.

The 200mm F2 is flawless on the Z9, and far out performs any portrait lens. There's a huge difference between F2 and F2.8. If there wasn't, Canon wouldn't have produced the 28-70mm F/2 which is a stellar piece of glass and if Nikon made one I would seriously have to consider buying it. It would be the only zoom I would own at this point.

The 300mm 2.8 is flawless on the Z9, and also a terrific portrait lens despite the length, ironically.

The 50mm 1.2 S is just outstanding all around. It's insanely sharp at F/1.2 (as sharp as the 200mm F2), great color, and the focal length has no distortion even for head shots. It's incredibly bright in the center which makes me think it's more than just a 1/2 stop improvement. If Nikon releases a DS variant of the 85mm 1.2 (like the Canon), I'll buy that also even if the T stop is actually F/2. The 50mm performs so well at 1.2 you don't need both, and the Nikon 85mm 1.2 DS will likely be the best 85mm lens they've ever produced.

I put the 50mm 1.2 as an equal to the 200mm F2.

I wouldn't buy any of the 1.8 lenses. I wouldn't buy the 105mm at all, at any price. I would only buy the 58mm 1.4 if it was $600 USD or less.

I can't comment on the Sigmas, because I've never actually used one.
Feb 14, 2022 at 04:04 AM
vaptre
Offline
Details
p.3 #20The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
stevekphotos wrote:
58mm and 105mm are both noticeably dark in the center compared to the 35mm / 85mm (almost one full stop difference). I would almost refer to them as 58mm F2, and 105mm F2 because of that.

Bokeh on the 85mm 1.4 is rendered the best. 58mm, and 105mm are harsher by far.

I have a personal dislike for the 105mm after shooting it. The aspherical elements in that lens have a design flaw that green shifts, the lens creates a nauseating circular bokeh effect, as well as weird compression that creates vertical banding in any short distance background. It doesn't compare
...Show more →

Very strange to hear that. I couldn't agree with these arguments as I've never seen same issues. Could you please post some examples? It is very interesting to understand where is the problem and what are we talking about.
Feb 14, 2022 at 05:16 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister