p.4 #1The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
stevekphotos wrote:
There's no difference between the Nikon 35mm 1.4, 58mm 1.4, 85mm 1.4, or 105mm 1.4 in general rendering.
[...]
I have a personal dislike for the 105mm after shooting it. The aspherical elements in that lens have a design flaw that green shifts, the lens creates a nauseating circular bokeh effect, as well as weird compression that creates vertical banding in any short distance background.
Okay, what exactly do you mean with "general rendering", anyway ?
stevekphotos wrote:
I would only buy the 58mm 1.4 if it was $600 USD or less.
What about the Voigtländer Nokton 58mm f1.4 then ?
Feb 14, 2022 at 07:09 AM
stevekphotos
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.4 #2The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Sauseschritt wrote: stevekphotos wroteThere's no difference between the Nikon 35mm 1.4, 58mm 1.4, 85mm 1.4, or 105mm 1.4 in general rendering.
[...]
I have a personal dislike for the 105mm after shooting it. The aspherical elements in that lens have a design flaw that green shifts, the lens creates a nauseating circular bokeh effect, as well as weird compression that creates vertical banding in any short distance background.Okay, what exactly do you mean with "general rendering", anyway ?
stevekphotos wroteI would only buy the 58mm 1.4 if it was $600 USD or less.What about the Voigtländer Nokton 58mm f1.4 then ?
Light transmission (or what I refer to as color rendering), sharpness (and resolution on 36mp/45mp sensors), microcontrast, general bokeh.
If you took all six of the 1.4G images and shot them side by side on a white background you could only tell the difference by the compression. They'll all look generally the same except for what I mentioned above.
As far as the manual lens: I had a Leica Noctilux 50mm f/1.2 for a few months. I didn't enjoy it. I'm not one to ask about manual focus lenses.
p.4 #3The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
stevekphotos wrote:
Bokeh on the 85mm 1.4 is rendered the best. 58mm, and 105mm are harsher by far.
I have a personal dislike for the 105mm after shooting it. The aspherical elements in that lens have a design flaw that green shifts, the lens creates a nauseating circular bokeh effect, as well as weird compression that creates vertical banding in any short distance background.
Proof, out of thousands of posts about the 105mm 1.4 you are the only one who keeps claimin that without any comparison / proof.
However I agree that the 85mm 1.4g renders lovely, while I had it I used it more than my 58mm 1.4g.
p.4 #4The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
The 85mm f/1.4G renders lovely. But 58/1.4G renders lovely with their own character. The personal character that is able to tell a story not only being just the lovely rendering lens. ))
p.4 #5The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Right you are! I was referring to the portrait lenses that were listed in the message I replied to although the 100/2 dc won’t perform better! Thanks for the clarification.
Sauseschritt wrote: urbanwild wroteThe f-mount lenses perform more flawlessly with the mirrorless cameras in my opinion.As an owner of AF 60mm f2.8 micro, AF 105mm f2 DC and AF 180mm f2.8 I dont follow.
p.4 #6The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
When those of us that own and love it discuss the merits of the 58/1.4, I am reminded of a couple quotes...
The first by Henri Cartier-Bresson:
“Sharpness is a bourgeois concept.”
Then this one by Edgar Degas:
“Art is not what you see, but what you make others see.”
EDIT: I want to add a couple comments specifically re the 58/1.4 and 105/1.4's:
1) *Most* folks selling these after owning them for a bit and not being particularly impressed with them, probably did not take the time to learn their ins and outs...
2) Again most likely never used them on a mirrorless body either -- both of these lenses exhibit focus shift (the 58 more so than the 105), and mirrorless on-sensor AF virtually negates missed focus with either of these lenses. Obviously correct focus renders far more pleasing results with both as opposed to when focus is not nailed. The main point here is whenever I hear a comment like, "the lens works well in some situations with certain combinations of aperture and subject distance, blah, blah, blah" I can virtually guarantee that individual never shot with them on a mirrorless body...
3) A Pro tip for portraits with the 105 at max aperture: this lens focuses so well and is so sharp on my Z7ii, if I focus on an eyball iris it will be in perfect focus, but due to such limited DoF at f1.4 the eyebrows and eyelashes are often out of the focus plane and a touch soft. Hence, by adding a minus 1 or minus 2 to the AF fine-tune for this lens, I can keep iris inside the rear of the focus plane and have now brought the plane far enough forward the eyebrows and lashes are sharp. If you own the lens, play with this a bit and you will be rewarded. Not something I use all the time, but will dial it in for a dedicated portrait session. FWIW only...
p.4 #7The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
I would wait for the Nikon 24-120mm lens to start shipping. It provides the optimum range of 85mm to 105mm for portrait work as these focal lengths provide the most pleasing and natural perspective for faces and are not too long to use indoors. You should be able to get your hands on one within the next 60 days if you place an order now to get into the queue with a Nikon reseller.
At this time the only alternative is the Sigma 24-105mm f/4 IS lens which is compatible with the FTZ and the Nikon Z cameras per Sigma.
You could buy the Nikon 105mm macro lens and have a good portrait lens as well as a macro lens. The 105mm focal length is one that I have found the best as it is short enough to be usable indoors and still provides sufficient perspective compression to be good for faces.
The 105mm focal length also provides the most natural perspective for street and outdoor photography in general. Shooting with a 50mm lens is what results in pictures with lots of clutter in the scene for most images made with this lens. In the days of 35mm film rangefinder cameras the 50mm or a wide angle lens was the only option but people have fixated on this as a good choice. A 50mm with a crop camera is OK as you get the view angle of a 75mm lens but on a full frame camera it is not a lens I would bother with at all.
Feb 14, 2022 at 01:46 PM
stevekphotos
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.4 #8The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
GoroMajima wrote: stevekphotos wroteBokeh on the 85mm 1.4 is rendered the best. 58mm, and 105mm are harsher by far.
I have a personal dislike for the 105mm after shooting it. The aspherical elements in that lens have a design flaw that green shifts, the lens creates a nauseating circular bokeh effect, as well as weird compression that creates vertical banding in any short distance background.Proof, out of thousands of posts about the 105mm 1.4 you are the only one who keeps claimin that without any comparison / proof.
However I agree that the 85mm 1.4g renders lovely, while I had it I used it more than my 58mm 1.4g.
All you have to do is go scroll through vaptre's flickr page, and you'll see exactly what I describe. Anytime he shoots at F/1.4 you'll find it.
There's certain lenses that render much, much better than others. It's just a fact. If you like the 58 or 105, then by all means shoot with it. I prefer lenses that accurately represent colors and contrast consistently, and having 1 lens that produces visibly worse results means there's something fundamentally wrong with the optics.
I could make the same comparison about the 400mm 2.8, 300mm 2.8, and 200mm 2.0. All three of these super tele's should produce identical results. Except they don't.
If you shoot all three of these lenses side by side (and fill the frame the same way) you'll see something interesting.
Neither the 400mm 2.8 VR, the 400mm 2.8 FL produce as sharp of results, render colors, or have the same contrast as the 200mm F2, or the 300mm 2.8. The image is dull, the colors are lacking, and the sharpness is not equal.
When you see the images side by side they look terribly wrong. For that reason I won't own a 400mm. I put it in the same category as the 105mm, and 58mm. There's something off about it.
Feb 15, 2022 at 05:04 AM
stevekphotos
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.4 #9The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
gear-nut wrote:
When those of us that own and love it discuss the merits of the 58/1.4, I am reminded of a couple quotes...
The first by Henri Cartier-Bresson:
“Sharpness is a bourgeois concept.”
Then this one by Edgar Degas:
“Art is not what you see, but what you make others see.”
There is the profit that a man may find in the ignorance of others. Some people are just too ignorant to be educated, and I've learned to never argue with an idiot on the internet.
Allow me to demonstrate my point with a visual aid:
On the left is a 3 quart copper pan made by Mauviel in France. On the right is some Brooklyn steel pan for $5.93 USD.
They both can cook, but one will do a much better job than the other.
The 200mm F2 is the Mauviel. The 105mm 1.4 is the piece of crap on the right.
p.4 #10The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
It’s the poor chef that blames their kitchen…
Neither of those pans will do braised lamb shank very well. But the one on the right will do a better omelet than the one on the left.
Horses for courses.
p.4 #11The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
stevekphotos wrote: gear-nut wroteWhen those of us that own and love it discuss the merits of the 58/1.4, I am reminded of a couple quotes...
The first by Henri Cartier-Bresson:
“Sharpness is a bourgeois concept.”
Then this one by Edgar Degas:
“Art is not what you see, but what you make others see.” There is the profit that a man may find in the ignorance of others. Some people are just too ignorant to be educated, and I've learned to never argue with an idiot on the internet.
Allow me to demonstrate my point with a visual aid:
p.4 #12The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
stevekphotos wrote:
All you have to do is go scroll through vaptre's flickr page, and you'll see exactly what I describe. Anytime he shoots at F/1.4 you'll find it.
I'm so sorry! But I don't catch what do you mean still. Could you please use any of my photos to show what's wrong? I really want to understand because I'm always wanting to study something new. But I don't catch! Sorry!
p.4 #13The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
elkhornsun wrote:
Jeff Ascough, a well known and very successful wedding photographer in the UK stated that he looks for backgrounds first and then waits for something to happen. He recognized how important the background was to the strength of the images he produces for his clients. Look at any fashion magazine and see whether the photographer is relying on bokeh or instead is carefully choosing the backgrounds.
This is true but even more important are lighting, composition and in the case of people photography, posing, and the king of all elements in people photography, expression. Expression beats perfection, perfect lighting, perfect composition, perfect background. In the case of people photography if the expression is killer the photo can even be out of focus and still be a keeper. All this business about lens rendering and bokeh is for pixel peepers. Your background is not your subject. Learn to light, pose, compose and timing. Those things will take your photography to a whole other level not obtainable by simply owning a fast lens with creamy bokeh or some stoic lens rendering. New photographers and even some experienced get swindled into believing that if they can just buy, beg or barrow one of these super fast, super expensive lenses that will now achieve 'professional photographer' status. Save yourself some money and master those other elements of a photograph that make a photograph great.
p.4 #14The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
I've gotten some spectacular portraits with my Nikkor AF 300/2.8 lens on a D800e. Beautifully sharp eyes that sparkle with subject isolation that has hard to define "magic" look to it.
p.4 #15The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
I really enjoy my 58 f/1.4G on Nikon mirrorless. It's sharp enough at F1.4 and with the help of mirrorless, no more playing around with AF micro adjustment and missing focus on DSLR. It's also a good for both environmental portrait and close up and good 1 lens solution for walking around.
p.4 #16The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Best is subjective, for me the lenses that work well are:
1) Nikon 50 f1.2S
2) Nikon 105mm f1.4E
3) Nikon 70-200mm f2.8S
4) Nikon 58mm f1.4G is also a gem
p.4 #18The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
This thread has taken on a life of its own
Thanks for all the helpful input and advise. I just wanted to put up a small update on my choices.
So far i have gotten my long lens (Sigma 500 F4) and the 24-70 2.8S. Both are amazing, sharp and fast with good rendering for each of their own purposes.
I have decided to put a hold on the rest of my buying until the upcoming CP+ announcement from Nikon. If they release the 85mm 1.2S i will be prioritising buying that. If they do not announce it, or it is incredibly expensive. I will be getting the 105 1.4 and the 58 1.4 along with the 85. 1.8S.
I have decided to forego the 200 F2 for now. It will eat almost my entire budget for portrait lenses, and i am not entirely convinced its worth it over other options.
p.4 #19The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
This thread was pretty informational Read through all 4 pages (right now). I'm on a similar boat about deciding between lenses people have recommended on here. Also, thanks to those that shared sample images from the lenses!
p.4 #20The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Interesting thread indeed. So many great native and FTZ adapted Nikon options.
I personally prefer the rendering of the Voigtlander Nokton 75mm f1.5 and 50mm f1.2, especially for creative portraits. Used with the Megadap MTZ11 autofocus works well in my experience, and manual focus with focus confirmation is also an option. The Leica R 135 f2.8 is also wonderful - wide open it gives a nice, smooth and forgiving skin rendering. Stopped down it becomes tack sharp.