p.2 #1The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
The 58mm f1.4g vs the 50mm f1.2S is where there's a real debate for me. Both are phenomenal and if the 1.2S was smaller, lighter and less expensive like the 58, I would have leaned in that direction. The 58 is not reliably sharp but it sure paints a beautiful picture, is very light and a used one is easier to find for a much better price.....similar out-of-focus but with some differences in transition from my perspective.
Curious what others suggest with a 35mm option. I'm still using the Sigma art. The 1.8S doesn't do much for me and I really liked the 1.4 over the 1.8 despite having less contrast.
Agree with the 58....my favorite Nikon lens by far. I switched from the 105 1.4E to a Zeiss Milvus 85 as I wanted slightly wider field of view. The 105 is superlative though. But for 35 I am using the Tamron 35 1.4. Amazing lens with great bokeh qualities. Does not get enough recognition but very sharp and contrasty images.
p.2 #2The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
aerospace99 wrote:
Agree with the 58....my favorite Nikon lens by far. I switched from the 105 1.4E to a Zeiss Milvus 85 as I wanted slightly wider field of view. The 105 is superlative though. But for 35 I am using the Tamron 35 1.4. Amazing lens with great bokeh qualities. Does not get enough recognition but very sharp and contrasty images.
Thanks! How does it handle on the Z? My 45mm f1.8 tamron did no go well. The vib control was erratic and the focus was slow. Loved the image though.
p.2 #4The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Wow so many replies!
I apologize for my late pop-in here, but we are all sick with COVID currently and i have been sleeping/taking care of the family most of the day.
Those Sigma 135 images looks very nice, it is not bad at all!
That 200 F2 is just crazy. Coincidentally i found one for sale locally, a well kept VRII version for about $2800. But seeing it compared to the 105 1.4 it seems to me, in all my ignorance, that the rendering is pretty much on par. Compression being the biggest difference between the two. What is you guys thought on that?
That 58 1.4 does look good. I get what you are saying about the rendering, but also about the sharpness. It does seem a bit bland compared sharpness wise, but the rendering is nuts. I bet you can do so some very artsy things with that lens.
So many interesting choices! I have not looked at the 85 1.4G yet, but i do like the aperture size. However i did look at some of the images bernardl posted on his flickr profile, among them a lot of superb images. I especially fell for one shot with the 85 1.8 S. That rendering looks amazing. So that went on my list of must-haves.
In regards to the 50mm nocht, i dont do manual focus but if i could afford one i am sure i could manage :P Unfortunately its out of my reach currently.
So to sum up the total recommendations are: Nikon 200mm F2, Nikon 105 1.4E, Nikon 58 1.4G, Nikon 50 1.2S, Nikon 85 1.8S and Nikon 85 1.4G.
I have been thinking about some different combinations of these, as i want to stretch my budget as far as possible. While still being able to do most things.
So far i have settled on the Nikon 85 1.8S, the rendering looks spectacular on that for a relatively low price.
I have looked at the 105 1.4E as my main portrait lens, while i have also not completely forgotten about the 70-200 2.8 S for its versatility. The Nikon 200mm F2, while very very tempting leaves me pretty dry, budget wise.
As for the lower focal lengths i have been debating the 24-70 2.8S, as it supposedly is very sharp and has some really nice rendering, i also like the fact that it covers a wide range of focal lengths with a pretty good performance in a single lens.
The opposite to the 24-70 2.8S is going all primes. Here i was contemplating the 24 1.8, 50 1.8 (or 1.2) and then the 85 1.8 obviously.
I was contemplating adding the 58 1.4G as per your recommendation, as i found a pretty cheap used copy, it would not hurt my budget much getting it.
So options.
1#
24-70mm 2.8 S
85mm 1.8 S
105mm 1.4 E
2#
24-70mm 2.8S
85mm 1.8S
70-200mm 2.8S
3#
24mm 1.8S
50mm 1.2S
85mm 1.8S
105mm 1.4E
#4
24mm 1.8S
58mm 1.4G
85mm 1.8S
200mm F2 VRII.
I am still completely undecided about these options, but that's what i have come down to for now. I wish i could add a kit with both the 105 and the 200F2 but that's simply not an option budget wise. I would have to settle for a F4 zoom and that would not suit me much.
Thank you all for helping steering me in the right direction and thank you for your recommendations so far!
p.2 #6The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
While I have suggested the 200f2 above, if you can wait, wait for the new 85mm f1.2S. Can't be much longer. Maybe end of 2022.
The 200f2 is a very special lens. You need working distance and you need to hit the gym before you can use it for half a day shoot. The 85mm however, can be picked up anytime and will give you images you want as well.
p.2 #9The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
As much as I love the 50/1.2S I would find it a little wide for a portrait lens. Perhaps group shots.
If I shot portraits seriously I'd probably get the Sigma 105/1.4 ART. Or perhaps the Nikon. The Sigma 135/1.4 seems sharper, but lacks the portrait look (IMO). The 105 DC is also a classic, but AF-D.
If manual focus is acceptable consider the aforementioned 105 DC, or a plain old 105/2.5 AI-S. The latter optic holds its own even on the Z7, with a sharp central area even wide open and with lovely color, bokeh and rendering. Heck, given the modest money you can get one for you should go buy one right away! Mine's a gem.
Longer, I'd look at the 200/2 or 200/4 Micro - although the latter is an AF-D lens so can't AF on Z bodies.
It's not just about maximum aperture, but about lens character even when stopped down for adequate DoF.
p.2 #10The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
If you like softer or more forgiving skin / detail rendering, go for the 58 / 85mm.
If you shoot people with flawless skin or post process a lot, the newer 105mm 1.4 or Z 85mm 1.8s are great.
p.2 #11The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Personally I am not much impressed with Z lenses. Sorry! I agree all of them are great in sharpness perspective. But at the same time most of them are clinically not inspiring and boring!
I had 24/35/50/85/24-70 (both version) and just one lens I can say that I really love - it is 24/1.8 which most of other reviewers hate so much. Because of it imperfections it gives really pleasant rendering and inspiration.
Everything else is like mortuary. Clean, quiet, perfect!
So I suggest revising and buying 28/1.4E, 58/1.4G, 105/1.4E
p.2 #12The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
I have seen so many distorted bodies and faces shot by people using shorter than normal focal length lenses. They post the images proudly so evidently cannot see the distortion that to me is quite obvious.
There is a reason why the 70-200mm lens is the single most popular lens for fashion photographers and they are working with beautiful women. Longer is better but indoors a 135mm focal length does not provide adequate working space and in many situations it is impossible to do full body pictures but need to crop the person. 85mm to 105mm works well indoors and outdoors and provides a natural amount of perspective compression for people's faces.
For street photography 85mm or longer focal lengths provides not only better perspective but also greater comfort for subjects. We all have a level of personal space which if violated makes us uncomfortable. I made the mistake of using the 70-200mm lens on the streets of cities in Italy and quickly saw how uncomfortable it made the people who would visibly tense up when this large lens was pointed in their direction.
The fad of using wide angle lenses with SLR cameras grew out of people not understanding that people like Cartier-Bresson had no choice but to use 35mm and 50mm lenses with their Leica rangefinder cameras with manual focusing. Anything past 50mm was slow and awkward and required a special viewfinder attachment on the camera.
I feel that anything in a picture of the subject that distracts from the viewers' attention is not a good element and with shorter focal length lenses that have a much wider field of view there is going to be more clutter in the images.
Background blurring is something I fell back on when photographing weddings with terrible backgrounds where I had few options for most situations I have control of the backgrounds and bokeh is of no importance. Jeff Ascough, a well known and very successful wedding photographer in the UK stated that he looks for backgrounds first and then waits for something to happen. He recognized how important the background was to the strength of the images he produces for his clients. Look at any fashion magazine and see whether the photographer is relying on bokeh or instead is carefully choosing the backgrounds.
p.2 #13The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
I tend to like the longer lengths unless seeking to do an environmental type portrait. If nothing else, a longer focal length and the longer shooting distance allows easier control of the background in the shot, perhaps making super creamy bokeh a little less important. I'd rather have rougher bokeh on a simple background that I can isolate with a longer focal length than more background area to tame / control with smoother bokeh lenses. Moving your feet 18 inches to one side can change the background dramatically with longer focal lengths.
p.2 #14The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Lassep wrote:
That 200 F2 is just crazy. Coincidentally i found one for sale locally, a well kept VRII version for about $2800. But seeing it compared to the 105 1.4 it seems to me, in all my ignorance, that the rendering is pretty much on par. Compression being the biggest difference between the two. What is you guys thought on that?
I don't have either of those but I want both of those.
I'd recommend the 105mm first just because the focal length, weight, price, working space and attracting unwanted attention is less than the 200mm.
Lassep wrote:
So many interesting choices! I have not looked at the 85 1.4G yet, but i do like the aperture size. However i did look at some of the images bernardl posted on his flickr profile, among them a lot of superb images. I especially fell for one shot with the 85 1.8 S. That rendering looks amazing. So that went on my list of must-haves.
I have the 85mm 1.4G, its great. As indicated by another poster you might want to wait for the rumored 85mm 1.2 S / Z mount which will hopefully be officially announced soon. I had the 85mm 1.8G and while it was perfectly fine it wasn't getting used enough versus my 105 DC to justify keeping it so I eventually upgraded to the 1.4G , you may feel similarly (against the 105 1.4E ) if there a 1.2 S/Z released in the future.
Of the option groupings you listed # 3 is probably the closest that would work for me.
Where we're different is I have no interest in the 24-70mm F2.8S and I'm quite interested in the 24-120mm F4 S.
p.2 #15The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
this is me wrote:
While I have suggested the 200f2 above, if you can wait, wait for the new 85mm f1.2S. Can't be much longer. Maybe end of 2022.
The 200f2 is a very special lens. You need working distance and you need to hit the gym before you can use it for half a day shoot. The 85mm however, can be picked up anytime and will give you images you want as well.
The 85mm f1.2 may be announced in the coming 2 weeks.
Now, reacting to other comments, as far as the Z lenses feeling clinical I couldn’t disagree more. To me the 85mm f1.8 S has one of the nicest look of any portrait lens I have used. Certainly much more appealing to me than the Sony 135mm f1.8 for instance that is incredibly sharp but flat as hell. So perceptions can differ widely.
As far as the 24mm f1.8 S goes I agree it’s very nice but it’s also overall the best 24mm ever released, equaling the Sony 24mm f1.8 in terms of technical qualities while having IMHO a nicer look and less focus breathing. The only thing that reviewers didn’t like about it is its bulk compared to the Sony.
p.2 #16The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
bernardl wrote: this is me wroteWhile I have suggested the 200f2 above, if you can wait, wait for the new 85mm f1.2S. Can't be much longer. Maybe end of 2022.
The 200f2 is a very special lens. You need working distance and you need to hit the gym before you can use it for half a day shoot. The 85mm however, can be picked up anytime and will give you images you want as well.The 85mm f1.2 may be announced in the coming 2 weeks.
Now, reacting to other comments, as far as the Z lenses feeling clinical I couldn’t disagree more. To me the 85mm f1.8 S has one of the nicest look of any portrait lens I have used. Certainly much more appealing to me than the Sony 135mm f1.8 for instance that is incredibly sharp but flat as hell. So perceptions can differ widely.
As far as the 24mm f1.8 S goes I agree it’s very nice but it’s also overall the best 24mm ever released, equaling the Sony 24mm f1.8 in terms of technical qualities while having IMHO a nicer look and less focus breathing. The only thing that reviewers didn’t like about it is its bulk compared to the Sony.
The Sony 24 GM, however, is an f/1.4 lens (not f/1.8 as you suggest above) and is actually a little smaller than the Nikon Z 24 f/1.8. Two thirds of a stop faster and smaller with a quite nice rendering is a nice achievement for the Sony lens. Not saying that the Nikon Z 24 f/1.8 is a very good lens--it is--but it is has a notably narrower aperture than the Sony.
p.2 #17The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Oh, and I don't think I have weighed in on the original question. IMO, the 200 f/2 VR is the best portrait lens for Nikon, but in practice I use the 105 f/1.4 about 5 times as often. I have both. The difference is size is a huge difference. I also very much like the Nikon Z 85 f/1.8S. I think it is the best 85 f/1.8 I have ever used and I have used a lot of them (Canon EF 85 f/1.8; Zeiss Batis 85 f/1.8; Pentax K 85 f/1.8). Nikon has a fantastic set of portrait lenses and you really can't go wrong with any of these three.
p.2 #18The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
elkhornsun wrote:
There is a reason why the 70-200mm lens is the single most popular lens for fashion photographers and they are working with beautiful women. Longer is better but indoors a 135mm focal length does not provide adequate working space and in many situations it is impossible to do full body pictures but need to crop the person. 85mm to 105mm works well indoors and outdoors and provides a natural amount of perspective compression for people's faces.
For street photography 85mm or longer focal lengths provides not only better perspective but also greater comfort for subjects. We all have a level of personal space which if violated makes us uncomfortable. I made the mistake of using the 70-200mm lens on the streets of cities in Italy and quickly saw how uncomfortable it made the people who would visibly tense up when this large lens was pointed in their direction. ...Show more →
I love the 70-200 for portraits for headshots, but I find it busy in many circumstances when doing full body shots. I also find some people just don't like being photographed with a longer lens. I show them what the images look like and then they're good but sometimes the odd person is still camera shy with that lens. Tough to beat a good prime when the workflow allows.
p.2 #19The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
Lassep wrote:
So options.
1#
24-70mm 2.8 S
85mm 1.8 S
105mm 1.4 E
2#
24-70mm 2.8S
85mm 1.8S
70-200mm 2.8S
3#
24mm 1.8S
50mm 1.2S
85mm 1.8S
105mm 1.4E
#4
24mm 1.8S
58mm 1.4G
85mm 1.8S
200mm F2 VRII.
I think you first need to decide if you want a zoom. The 24-70 f2.8S is everything you'd need for f2.8 and up. I think the versatility is worth having and perfect for mixed shooting (landscapes + portraits).
If you're keeping to a tighter budget, I would leave the 200mm f2 for later (unless your shooting style will depend on that but I would suggest that's a specialty lens). It's awesome, but the 105 will get you close and give you more money and room in your bag for other lenses too.
Looking at your patterns above, I'd suggest:
24-70 f2.8S
70-200 f2.8S.....both of these will provide you with full versatility for landscapes and portraits
58mm f1.4G or 50mm f1.2S depending on your budget
105mm f1.4e
If you have room in your budget, add the 28mm f1.4e and you won't look back! If you go with an 85 instead, consider a 35mm.
The 85mm f1.8S is great, but the 105mm f1.4e makes more magic and I'm sure the 85mm f1.2S will be in the same league. The 105 will be had for less cost though.
p.2 #20The best portrait lenses for Nikon F/Z Mount.
pbraymond wrote:
I tend to like the longer lengths unless seeking to do an environmental type portrait. If nothing else, a longer focal length and the longer shooting distance allows easier control of the background in the shot, perhaps making super creamy bokeh a little less important. I'd rather have rougher bokeh on a simple background that I can isolate with a longer focal length than more background area to tame / control with smoother bokeh lenses. Moving your feet 18 inches to one side can change the background dramatically with longer focal lengths.
Changing your height above the ground also changes the background. Standing on a bench or kneeling changes the perspective. During a weddings I must have kneeled more than 100 times to get a better background and my legs would be sore the following day.