nandadevieast wrote:
I moved to Nikon from Sony for landscapes and wildlife. (Most seem to take opposite route when it comes to wildlife). I don’t test lenses and assess them casually from real pictures so here are 3 observations i would like to share.
1) My 14-30 is way sharper than my Sony 16-35 F4. I read a comment here which said the opposite so i actually sat down and compared images on my laptop @f4 and f8 of dense wood that i had clicked previously. Sony has more CA, corners are softer and there is less acuity generally speaking. I don’t want to generalise these findings though as different people/reviews have contradictory reports.
2) My 300 and 500mm Nikon’s are equally sharp at great distances. This is a precious quality in a tele lens which can only be appreciated after buying and selling many lenses.
3) I like Z7II better than Sony a7rIII for landscapes for many relevant features that the camera has for that kind of work. I have not owned an a7rIV....Show more →
You're not wrong about 3, and the R4 has no extra features relevant to landscape, save for some improved timelapse options, but those are still bested by the Z7ii.
nandadevieast wrote:
I moved to Nikon from Sony for landscapes and wildlife. (Most seem to take opposite route when it comes to wildlife). I assess my lenses informally from real pictures and here are 3 casual observations i would like to share.
1) My 14-30 is way sharper than my Sony 16-35 F4. I read a comment here which said the opposite so i actually sat down and compared images on my laptop @f4 and f8 of dense wood that i had clicked previously. Sony has more CA, corners are softer and there is less acuity generally speaking. I don’t want to generalise these findings though as different people/reviews have contradictory reports.
2) My 300 and 500mm Nikon’s are equally sharp at great distances. This is a precious quality in a tele lens which can only be appreciated after buying and selling many lenses.
3) I like Z7II better than Sony a7rIII for landscapes for many relevant features that the camera has for that kind of work. I have not owned an a7rIV. For people, i found the Sony better, again because of certain features that they have for portraiture. My a7C is particularly good at that. ...Show more →
Both the Nikon Z7II and the Sony A7RIV are great cameras, and it is down to personal preference which one is the right one to get. I went from the Sony A7RII to the Nikon Z7 and back to the Sony A7RIVA, and feel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7. But I can see that objectively the Z7 is as good as the Sony cameras (better than the A7RII regarding DR btw, the A7RII had real problems with high contrast scenes).
The Nikon colors are just not my thing, but in no way is color reproduction bad with the Nikon Z bodies.
Regarding the lenses: Sony obviously needed some time to get into their own, and only their recent lenses are as good or better than the Nikon Z lenses. The new 35GM was an eye opener for me as to where Sony now is with their new lenses. The fact that they will already be replacing their 24-70GM lens, which is only five years old, with a second version this year is telling.
I think that at present you can not say that either Nikon or Sony is better overall, but you can fairly safely say that each new mirrorless product will set new standards, so I expect the Nikon 100-400 to be better than the Sony version. In the same fashion, each mirroless body can be expected to be better than previous generations. Sony has improved their colors a lot, and Nikon will get better with each generation AF wise etc.
ChrisMak wrote:
feel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7
Definitely noticing this with auto WB, the Sony is shooting 700-1000k higher in the same exact scene. Once you make them even, they are almost identical, however. Sony files aren't inherently "warmer", except by virtue of Sony pumping a bit more red into their raw files and Nikon more green. It's interesting, given that they both have Sony sensors.
Thanks, this is very informative!
I don't know how to put this with no intention to flame, but to me the difference in perceived sharpness between the 400s might also be caused by slight focus difference or some additional sharpening happening for the Sony file. If these are not the case, then it seems the Sony gets that additional bit of sharpness/contrast at the cost of less smooth background rendering...
As for the 24s comparison, it seems that the Nikon is both a bit sharper (maybe due to higher contrast?) and also smoother in background rendering. I guess you trade +15mm for that OIS on the Sony . Btw, did you try to check how effective stabilization is? I mean OIS+IBIS on Sony vs IBIS-only on Nikon. I guess you'd have to normalize to the same resolution then for a fair comparison...
j4nu wrote:
Thanks, this is very informative!
I don't know how to put this with no intention to flame, but to me the difference in perceived sharpness between the 400s might also be caused by slight focus difference or some additional sharpening happening for the Sony file. If these are not the case, then it seems the Sony gets that additional bit of sharpness/contrast at the cost of less smooth background rendering...
As for the 24s comparison, it seems that the Nikon is both a bit sharper (maybe due to higher contrast?) and also smoother in background rendering. I guess you trade +15mm for that OIS on the Sony . Btw, did you try to check how effective stabilization is? I mean OIS+IBIS on Sony vs IBIS-only on Nikon. I guess you'd have to normalize to the same resolution then for a fair comparison......Show more →
Believe me, no offense taken. I'm standing in my yard in 30 degree temps, handholding two bodies with 100-400s on them
Hopefully I got close enough on these to give you some ideas about the strengths and weaknesses of each...I think we arrived at roughly the same conclusions.
Interestingly regarding IBIS and OIS...the Nikon 100-400 doesn't have an OIS/VR switch, nor modes...I assume it's either IBIS+OIS automatically, or nothing at all.
I don't feel that the 24-120 Z is suffering with a lack of OIS, but I honestly am not a scientific enough tester to tell the difference...and like you say, you'd want to normalize the res, would be more appropriate to do that kind of test on the Sony R3.
ChrisMak wrote: nandadevieast wroteI moved to Nikon from Sony for landscapes and wildlife. (Most seem to take opposite route when it comes to wildlife). I assess my lenses informally from real pictures and here are 3 casual observations i would like to share.
1) My 14-30 is way sharper than my Sony 16-35 F4. I read a comment here which said the opposite so i actually sat down and compared images on my laptop @f4 and f8 of dense wood that i had clicked previously. Sony has more CA, corners are softer and there is less acuity generally speaking. I don’t want to generalise these findings though as different people/reviews have contradictory reports.
2) My 300 and 500mm Nikon’s are equally sharp at great distances. This is a precious quality in a tele lens which can only be appreciated after buying and selling many lenses.
3) I like Z7II better than Sony a7rIII for landscapes for many relevant features that the camera has for that kind of work. I have not owned an a7rIV. For people, i found the Sony better, again because of certain features that they have for portraiture. My a7C is particularly good at that.Both the Nikon Z7II and the Sony A7RIV are great cameras, and it is down to personal preference which one is the right one to get. I went from the Sony A7RII to the Nikon Z7 and back to the Sony A7RIVA, and feel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7. But I can see that objectively the Z7 is as good as the Sony cameras (better than the A7RII regarding DR btw, the A7RII had real problems with high contrast scenes).
The Nikon colors are just not my thing, but in no way is color reproduction bad with the Nikon Z bodies.
Regarding the lenses: Sony obviously needed some time to get into their own, and only their recent lenses are as good or better than the Nikon Z lenses. The new 35GM was an eye opener for me as to where Sony now is with their new lenses. The fact that they will already be replacing their 24-70GM lens, which is only five years old, with a second version this year is telling.
I think that at present you can not say that either Nikon or Sony is better overall, but you can fairly safely say that each new mirrorless product will set new standards, so I expect the Nikon 100-400 to be better than the Sony version. In the same fashion, each mirroless body can be expected to be better than previous generations. Sony has improved their colors a lot, and Nikon will get better with each generation AF wise etc....Show more →
I disagree regarding lenses. The 100-400, 100 STF, 90 macro, and 12-24 F4 were brilliant from the start. Then, as you say, everything from the 24 and 135GM onward have been excellent.
Here's a brick wall test used more to see texture/sharpness at max FL of each lens wide open.
Downright shocking result on this one. Sony either missed focus or the 105 end is just that much weaker than the 120 end. Both cams used AF-S to focus on the star. You can see the Sony is actually better focused on the other half of the picture.
The other big takeaway from this particular shot was that moire was FAR worse in the higher res Sony EVF for some reason while composing.
shadow9d9 wrote: ChrisMak wrotenandadevieast wroteI moved to Nikon from Sony for landscapes and wildlife. (Most seem to take opposite route when it comes to wildlife). I assess my lenses informally from real pictures and here are 3 casual observations i would like to share.
1) My 14-30 is way sharper than my Sony 16-35 F4. I read a comment here which said the opposite so i actually sat down and compared images on my laptop @f4 and f8 of dense wood that i had clicked previously. Sony has more CA, corners are softer and there is less acuity generally speaking. I don’t want to generalise these findings though as different people/reviews have contradictory reports.
2) My 300 and 500mm Nikon’s are equally sharp at great distances. This is a precious quality in a tele lens which can only be appreciated after buying and selling many lenses.
3) I like Z7II better than Sony a7rIII for landscapes for many relevant features that the camera has for that kind of work. I have not owned an a7rIV. For people, i found the Sony better, again because of certain features that they have for portraiture. My a7C is particularly good at that.Both the Nikon Z7II and the Sony A7RIV are great cameras, and it is down to personal preference which one is the right one to get. I went from the Sony A7RII to the Nikon Z7 and back to the Sony A7RIVA, and feel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7. But I can see that objectively the Z7 is as good as the Sony cameras (better than the A7RII regarding DR btw, the A7RII had real problems with high contrast scenes).
The Nikon colors are just not my thing, but in no way is color reproduction bad with the Nikon Z bodies.
Regarding the lenses: Sony obviously needed some time to get into their own, and only their recent lenses are as good or better than the Nikon Z lenses. The new 35GM was an eye opener for me as to where Sony now is with their new lenses. The fact that they will already be replacing their 24-70GM lens, which is only five years old, with a second version this year is telling.
I think that at present you can not say that either Nikon or Sony is better overall, but you can fairly safely say that each new mirrorless product will set new standards, so I expect the Nikon 100-400 to be better than the Sony version. In the same fashion, each mirroless body can be expected to be better than previous generations. Sony has improved their colors a lot, and Nikon will get better with each generation AF wise etc.I disagree regarding lenses. The 100-400, 100 STF, 90 macro, and 12-24 F4 were brilliant from the start. Then, as you say, everything from the 24 and 135GM onward have been excellent.
I will take your word for it without hesitation, I am meaning to refer to lenses like the 16-35GM (also the f4 version) and 24-70GM, which are simply older generation lenses than the Nikon counterparts, and also the Sony-Zeiss lenses were not up there regarding eg. chromatic abberations. The early Sony lenses were also not that great color wise, which is why the manual focus Zeiss Loxia lenses were very popular for a few years.
lukemeup wrote:
That's amazing how much better the 24-120 looks. They're both in similar price bracket when Sony is on sale?
Yep, both around 1100ish. At this point in testing, the Nikon is more reliable, sharper, and has better edges, with the main shortcoming being near MFD at both ends.
I have yet to do much wide angle testing on the 24s, sunstars, etc. So far though, the Nikon version seems like the clear winner.
I've said a few times the 100-400 Z is the clear winner to me as well. My issues stem from the Z7ii AF system, in that it's R3-era in terms of AF-C abilities. However, single point is worlds better than Sony, and that's about 90% of my use cases.
Gut feeling right now is probably keeping the Nikon setup. Wife will kill me if I pick up the 20 Z to compare against the Sony 20, but I have a feeling they'd be neck and neck by all accounts.
ChrisMak wrote: nandadevieast wroteI moved to Nikon from Sony for landscapes and wildlife. (Most seem to take opposite route when it comes to wildlife). I assess my lenses informally from real pictures and here are 3 casual observations i would like to share.
1) My 14-30 is way sharper than my Sony 16-35 F4. I read a comment here which said the opposite so i actually sat down and compared images on my laptop @f4 and f8 of dense wood that i had clicked previously. Sony has more CA, corners are softer and there is less acuity generally speaking. I don’t want to generalise these findings though as different people/reviews have contradictory reports.
2) My 300 and 500mm Nikon’s are equally sharp at great distances. This is a precious quality in a tele lens which can only be appreciated after buying and selling many lenses.
3) I like Z7II better than Sony a7rIII for landscapes for many relevant features that the camera has for that kind of work. I have not owned an a7rIV. For people, i found the Sony better, again because of certain features that they have for portraiture. My a7C is particularly good at that.Both the Nikon Z7II and the Sony A7RIV are great cameras, and it is down to personal preference which one is the right one to get. I went from the Sony A7RII to the Nikon Z7 and back to the Sony A7RIVA, and feel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7. But I can see that objectively the Z7 is as good as the Sony cameras (better than the A7RII regarding DR btw, the A7RII had real problems with high contrast scenes).
The Nikon colors are just not my thing, but in no way is color reproduction bad with the Nikon Z bodies.
Regarding the lenses: Sony obviously needed some time to get into their own, and only their recent lenses are as good or better than the Nikon Z lenses. The new 35GM was an eye opener for me as to where Sony now is with their new lenses. The fact that they will already be replacing their 24-70GM lens, which is only five years old, with a second version this year is telling.
I think that at present you can not say that either Nikon or Sony is better overall, but you can fairly safely say that each new mirrorless product will set new standards, so I expect the Nikon 100-400 to be better than the Sony version. In the same fashion, each mirroless body can be expected to be better than previous generations. Sony has improved their colors a lot, and Nikon will get better with each generation AF wise etc....Show more →
"Sony has improved their colors a lot"
Subjective. I found them nice all the time. Of course that is a personal opinion, too, but you make it sound as if it were scientifically proven.
This isn’t a thread for bickering about “color science”.
Holger wrote: ChrisMak wrotenandadevieast wroteI moved to Nikon from Sony for landscapes and wildlife. (Most seem to take opposite route when it comes to wildlife). I assess my lenses informally from real pictures and here are 3 casual observations i would like to share.
1) My 14-30 is way sharper than my Sony 16-35 F4. I read a comment here which said the opposite so i actually sat down and compared images on my laptop @f4 and f8 of dense wood that i had clicked previously. Sony has more CA, corners are softer and there is less acuity generally speaking. I don’t want to generalise these findings though as different people/reviews have contradictory reports.
2) My 300 and 500mm Nikon’s are equally sharp at great distances. This is a precious quality in a tele lens which can only be appreciated after buying and selling many lenses.
3) I like Z7II better than Sony a7rIII for landscapes for many relevant features that the camera has for that kind of work. I have not owned an a7rIV. For people, i found the Sony better, again because of certain features that they have for portraiture. My a7C is particularly good at that.Both the Nikon Z7II and the Sony A7RIV are great cameras, and it is down to personal preference which one is the right one to get. I went from the Sony A7RII to the Nikon Z7 and back to the Sony A7RIVA, and feel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7. But I can see that objectively the Z7 is as good as the Sony cameras (better than the A7RII regarding DR btw, the A7RII had real problems with high contrast scenes).
The Nikon colors are just not my thing, but in no way is color reproduction bad with the Nikon Z bodies.
Regarding the lenses: Sony obviously needed some time to get into their own, and only their recent lenses are as good or better than the Nikon Z lenses. The new 35GM was an eye opener for me as to where Sony now is with their new lenses. The fact that they will already be replacing their 24-70GM lens, which is only five years old, with a second version this year is telling.
I think that at present you can not say that either Nikon or Sony is better overall, but you can fairly safely say that each new mirrorless product will set new standards, so I expect the Nikon 100-400 to be better than the Sony version. In the same fashion, each mirroless body can be expected to be better than previous generations. Sony has improved their colors a lot, and Nikon will get better with each generation AF wise etc."better than the A7RII regarding DR btw,"
No. https://www.photonstophotos.net/Charts/PDR.htm#Nikon%20Z%207,Sony%20ILCE-7RM2
"Sony has improved their colors a lot"
Subjective. I found them nice all the time. Of course that is a personal opinion, too, but you make it sound as if it were scientifically proven.
To clarify, your interest in the Z system was triggered by the upcoming 24-120 S lens ?
Was that the only reason ? Just curious...
.
RoamingScott wrote:
Hey all, I'm trying Nikon for the first time in my 20+ years of shooting, have a Z7ii on the way.
I primarily hike and shoot zooms, and the upcoming 24-120 is highly appealing for a do it all hiking lens, so figured I'd give the Z7ii a shot until that lens releases. My main kit is a 20/1.8, 24-105/4, and 100-400.
I'd be curious to know any general tips/tricks to the Z7ii that might not be obvious, especially in the context of landscape/astro. I don't do a bunch of AF-C type shooting. Any tips relating to the best AF modes or settings are much appreciated, though.
I'd also be interested in feedback on the 20 1/8 and 14-30/4, both seem like great lenses that have a lot of appeal to me for the stuff I shoot....Show more →
Primarily, yes, in addition to the sensor being largely similar to the fantastic Sony R3 sensor.
Mister-Mr wrote:
To clarify, your interest in the Z system was triggered by the upcoming 24-120 S lens ?
Was that the only reason ? Just curious...
.
RoamingScott wroteHey all, I'm trying Nikon for the first time in my 20+ years of shooting, have a Z7ii on the way.
I primarily hike and shoot zooms, and the upcoming 24-120 is highly appealing for a do it all hiking lens, so figured I'd give the Z7ii a shot until that lens releases. My main kit is a 20/1.8, 24-105/4, and 100-400.
I'd be curious to know any general tips/tricks to the Z7ii that might not be obvious, especially in the context of landscape/astro. I don't do a bunch of AF-C type shooting. Any tips relating to the best AF modes or settings are much appreciated, though.
I'd also be interested in feedback on the 20 1/8 and 14-30/4, both seem like great lenses that have a lot of appeal to me for the stuff I shoot.
I can understand that - I switched to Sony for the 24-105, when I realized it gave me better image quality than my Fuji 16-55 in a similar size with stabilization.
Mister-Mr wrote:
To clarify, your interest in the Z system was triggered by the upcoming 24-120 S lens ?
Was that the only reason ? Just curious...
.
RoamingScott wroteHey all, I'm trying Nikon for the first time in my 20+ years of shooting, have a Z7ii on the way.
I primarily hike and shoot zooms, and the upcoming 24-120 is highly appealing for a do it all hiking lens, so figured I'd give the Z7ii a shot until that lens releases. My main kit is a 20/1.8, 24-105/4, and 100-400.
I'd be curious to know any general tips/tricks to the Z7ii that might not be obvious, especially in the context of landscape/astro. I don't do a bunch of AF-C type shooting. Any tips relating to the best AF modes or settings are much appreciated, though.
I'd also be interested in feedback on the 20 1/8 and 14-30/4, both seem like great lenses that have a lot of appeal to me for the stuff I shoot.
Are you me? I moved from the Fuji X-H1 when I realized the Sony package was the same size with a way bigger punch.
wdshuck wrote:
I can understand that - I switched to Sony for the 24-105, when I realized it gave me better image quality than my Fuji 16-55 in a similar size with stabilization.
Mister-Mr wroteTo clarify, your interest in the Z system was triggered by the upcoming 24-120 S lens ?
Was that the only reason ? Just curious...
.
RoamingScott wroteHey all, I'm trying Nikon for the first time in my 20+ years of shooting, have a Z7ii on the way.
I primarily hike and shoot zooms, and the upcoming 24-120 is highly appealing for a do it all hiking lens, so figured I'd give the Z7ii a shot until that lens releases. My main kit is a 20/1.8, 24-105/4, and 100-400.
I'd be curious to know any general tips/tricks to the Z7ii that might not be obvious, especially in the context of landscape/astro. I don't do a bunch of AF-C type shooting. Any tips relating to the best AF modes or settings are much appreciated, though.
I'd also be interested in feedback on the 20 1/8 and 14-30/4, both seem like great lenses that have a lot of appeal to me for the stuff I shoot.