Really appreciate these comparisons - I’ve always been looking over the fence at Nikon, but have mostly stuck with Sony for the AF.
RoamingScott wrote:
Are you me? I moved from the Fuji X-H1 when I realized the Sony package was the same size with a way bigger punch.
wdshuck wroteI can understand that - I switched to Sony for the 24-105, when I realized it gave me better image quality than my Fuji 16-55 in a similar size with stabilization.
Mister-Mr wroteTo clarify, your interest in the Z system was triggered by the upcoming 24-120 S lens ?
Was that the only reason ? Just curious...
.
RoamingScott wroteHey all, I'm trying Nikon for the first time in my 20+ years of shooting, have a Z7ii on the way.
I primarily hike and shoot zooms, and the upcoming 24-120 is highly appealing for a do it all hiking lens, so figured I'd give the Z7ii a shot until that lens releases. My main kit is a 20/1.8, 24-105/4, and 100-400.
I'd be curious to know any general tips/tricks to the Z7ii that might not be obvious, especially in the context of landscape/astro. I don't do a bunch of AF-C type shooting. Any tips relating to the best AF modes or settings are much appreciated, though.
I'd also be interested in feedback on the 20 1/8 and 14-30/4, both seem like great lenses that have a lot of appeal to me for the stuff I shoot.
RoamingScott wrote: ChrisMak wrotefeel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7Definitely noticing this with auto WB, the Sony is shooting 700-1000k higher in the same exact scene. Once you make them even, they are almost identical, however. Sony files aren't inherently "warmer", except by virtue of Sony pumping a bit more red into their raw files and Nikon more green. It's interesting, given that they both have Sony sensors.
You can match these pretty easily by setting an auto white balance offset.
On the Canon R5 I dial in +2G +1B because it’s too warm and magenta for me by default.
Yep, essentially my point…when shooting RAW, “color science” goes out the window. That only applies to JPG rendering in body.
Jesse Evans wrote: RoamingScott wroteChrisMak wrotefeel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7Definitely noticing this with auto WB, the Sony is shooting 700-1000k higher in the same exact scene. Once you make them even, they are almost identical, however. Sony files aren't inherently "warmer", except by virtue of Sony pumping a bit more red into their raw files and Nikon more green. It's interesting, given that they both have Sony sensors.You can match these pretty easily by setting an auto white balance offset.
On the Canon R5 I dial in +2G +1B because it’s too warm and magenta for me by default.
wdshuck wrote:
XT2 for me - but basically the same reasoning!
Really appreciate these comparisons - I’ve always been looking over the fence at Nikon, but have mostly stuck with Sony for the AF.
RoamingScott wroteAre you me? I moved from the Fuji X-H1 when I realized the Sony package was the same size with a way bigger punch.
wdshuck wroteI can understand that - I switched to Sony for the 24-105, when I realized it gave me better image quality than my Fuji 16-55 in a similar size with stabilization.
Mister-Mr wroteTo clarify, your interest in the Z system was triggered by the upcoming 24-120 S lens ?
Was that the only reason ? Just curious...
.
RoamingScott wroteHey all, I'm trying Nikon for the first time in my 20+ years of shooting, have a Z7ii on the way.
I primarily hike and shoot zooms, and the upcoming 24-120 is highly appealing for a do it all hiking lens, so figured I'd give the Z7ii a shot until that lens releases. My main kit is a 20/1.8, 24-105/4, and 100-400.
I'd be curious to know any general tips/tricks to the Z7ii that might not be obvious, especially in the context of landscape/astro. I don't do a bunch of AF-C type shooting. Any tips relating to the best AF modes or settings are much appreciated, though.
I'd also be interested in feedback on the 20 1/8 and 14-30/4, both seem like great lenses that have a lot of appeal to me for the stuff I shoot.
Technically you're right but for me I found it a bit more time consuming to get the Sony images to where I wanted vs working with RAW Canon or Fuji images.
RoamingScott wrote:
Yep, essentially my point…when shooting RAW, “color science” goes out the window. That only applies to JPG rendering in body.
Jesse Evans wroteRoamingScott wroteChrisMak wrotefeel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7Definitely noticing this with auto WB, the Sony is shooting 700-1000k higher in the same exact scene. Once you make them even, they are almost identical, however. Sony files aren't inherently "warmer", except by virtue of Sony pumping a bit more red into their raw files and Nikon more green. It's interesting, given that they both have Sony sensors.You can match these pretty easily by setting an auto white balance offset.
On the Canon R5 I dial in +2G +1B because it’s too warm and magenta for me by default.
I don’t disagree, Sony files need the most massaging for sure.
robert_in_ca wrote:
Technically you're right but for me I found it a bit more time consuming to get the Sony images to where I wanted vs working with RAW Canon or Fuji images.
RoamingScott wroteYep, essentially my point…when shooting RAW, “color science” goes out the window. That only applies to JPG rendering in body.
Jesse Evans wroteRoamingScott wroteChrisMak wrotefeel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7Definitely noticing this with auto WB, the Sony is shooting 700-1000k higher in the same exact scene. Once you make them even, they are almost identical, however. Sony files aren't inherently "warmer", except by virtue of Sony pumping a bit more red into their raw files and Nikon more green. It's interesting, given that they both have Sony sensors.You can match these pretty easily by setting an auto white balance offset.
On the Canon R5 I dial in +2G +1B because it’s too warm and magenta for me by default.
Just sent you an IG message... have to say that I am shocked to see you possibly moving on from your Sony!
RoamingScott wrote:
I don’t disagree, Sony files need the most massaging for sure.
robert_in_ca wroteTechnically you're right but for me I found it a bit more time consuming to get the Sony images to where I wanted vs working with RAW Canon or Fuji images.
RoamingScott wroteYep, essentially my point…when shooting RAW, “color science” goes out the window. That only applies to JPG rendering in body.
Jesse Evans wroteRoamingScott wroteChrisMak wrotefeel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7Definitely noticing this with auto WB, the Sony is shooting 700-1000k higher in the same exact scene. Once you make them even, they are almost identical, however. Sony files aren't inherently "warmer", except by virtue of Sony pumping a bit more red into their raw files and Nikon more green. It's interesting, given that they both have Sony sensors.You can match these pretty easily by setting an auto white balance offset.
On the Canon R5 I dial in +2G +1B because it’s too warm and magenta for me by default.
Holger wrote: ChrisMak wrotenandadevieast wroteI moved to Nikon from Sony for landscapes and wildlife. (Most seem to take opposite route when it comes to wildlife). I assess my lenses informally from real pictures and here are 3 casual observations i would like to share.
1) My 14-30 is way sharper than my Sony 16-35 F4. I read a comment here which said the opposite so i actually sat down and compared images on my laptop @f4 and f8 of dense wood that i had clicked previously. Sony has more CA, corners are softer and there is less acuity generally speaking. I don’t want to generalise these findings though as different people/reviews have contradictory reports.
2) My 300 and 500mm Nikon’s are equally sharp at great distances. This is a precious quality in a tele lens which can only be appreciated after buying and selling many lenses.
3) I like Z7II better than Sony a7rIII for landscapes for many relevant features that the camera has for that kind of work. I have not owned an a7rIV. For people, i found the Sony better, again because of certain features that they have for portraiture. My a7C is particularly good at that.Both the Nikon Z7II and the Sony A7RIV are great cameras, and it is down to personal preference which one is the right one to get. I went from the Sony A7RII to the Nikon Z7 and back to the Sony A7RIVA, and feel that the images from the Sony are warmer and simply please me more visually than the images from the Z7. But I can see that objectively the Z7 is as good as the Sony cameras (better than the A7RII regarding DR btw, the A7RII had real problems with high contrast scenes).
The Nikon colors are just not my thing, but in no way is color reproduction bad with the Nikon Z bodies.
Regarding the lenses: Sony obviously needed some time to get into their own, and only their recent lenses are as good or better than the Nikon Z lenses. The new 35GM was an eye opener for me as to where Sony now is with their new lenses. The fact that they will already be replacing their 24-70GM lens, which is only five years old, with a second version this year is telling.
I think that at present you can not say that either Nikon or Sony is better overall, but you can fairly safely say that each new mirrorless product will set new standards, so I expect the Nikon 100-400 to be better than the Sony version. In the same fashion, each mirroless body can be expected to be better than previous generations. Sony has improved their colors a lot, and Nikon will get better with each generation AF wise etc."better than the A7RII regarding DR btw,"
No. https://www.photonstophotos.net/Charts/PDR.htm#Nikon%20Z%207,Sony%20ILCE-7RM2
"Sony has improved their colors a lot"
Subjective. I found them nice all the time. Of course that is a personal opinion, too, but you make it sound as if it were scientifically proven.
Sorry if that comes across wrong. The thing is that I used the Sony A7RII for years with various lenses, and got to know it inside out. After getting the A7RIV, I get color variety, nuances and a much more natural look to landscapes but also city photography with the same lenses, that I never experienced with the A7RII. It is a striking difference, not a small one that can be within the scope of preference.
I chose my words carefully, but if I could simply say what I subjectively think, then I would say the A7RIV is streets ahead of the A7RII regarding natural and rich color rendering.
The same goes for the amount of contrast that can be captured in a single exposure without either the bright skies blowing out and very hard to get to look right, or the blacks blocking up beyond reasonable repair. If you have worked on raw images from a camera for four years, then you have a sense of what amount of post processing can be expected with certain type of shots. The A7RIV is much easier to get to look right.
I waited for a long time to upgrade the A7RII, because I was not sure what improvement to expect in real life shooting, but the difference is far beyond what I expected, and top lenses like the Loxia 25 or the Sony 35GM may well augment the progression that Sony made between the A7RII and the A7RIV. Also, I use a calibrated 4K Eizo display, that may well also augment the difference and I use CO1 for raw processing, so that is my frame of reference.
Interesting (and good!) to know as I've been on an A7Rii since its release, and have been eyeing the A7Riv as an upgrade. Of course, when I do, the A7Rv will be announced :P
noohoggin1 wrote:
Interesting (and good!) to know as I've been on an A7Rii since its release, and have been eyeing the A7Riv as an upgrade. Of course, when I do, the A7Rv will be announced :P
The A7Rv was already announced, it's called the A1
Alright, here we go, diagnostic comparison images as discussed in the image thread. Nikon images on the left, Sony on the right for the 100% crop comparisons. In all shots, AF-S was used and focused on the battery charge percentage indicators.
At no point wide open does the Nikon appear to approach the Sony's level of critical detail. That said, the Nikon images look fine to me at normal viewing size.
The Nikon gets markedly sharper at f8 in all scenarios, no point to post the full so here are crops. Nikon left, Sony right. quick analysis is that the Nikon is just significantly softer wide open in all applications. This appears to simply be an aperture based behavior, and the Sony results also prove it's not technique based. So far, I don't see $3000 worth of sharpness wide open. If anyone can replicate this basic test (even without another camera/lens to use as a control) it would be helpful.
- Z7ii produces considerably cleaner files than the R4 across the board.
- Z lenses are better at bokeh transition and handling CA than even Sony GM lenses.
- Z lenses are better at handling harsh light transitions without creating halo-ing effects.
- NEF files are generally far closer to the final product than ARW files and take a lot less tweaking. They are also far less red than Sony files, which was always my biggest heartburn.
- The Z IBIS is better than Sony's, however Sony tends to put OIS on more lenses than Nikon.
- Z battery life isn't horribly worse than Sony, was pleasantly surprised.
- Z AF indicator is hard as hell to see vs Sony (much thinner and not as bright of a red color).
- Z burst mode is definitely worse/less usable than Sony, much more blackout.
- Z EFV is nice, and I honestly like it better than the Sony EVF even though Sony is "better".
- Z7ii AF-C is not bad when used with smaller AF points but will quickly refocus if you happen to wander. Wide mode for AF-C is not usable IMO, very very unreliable vs Sony.
- Z 100-400 is just overall better to use than the GM. Feels lighter, shorter zoom throw. Main bummer here is the reversed lens cap blocks the zoom ring completely.
- Z 24-120 is a world beater "kit" zoom.
Overall looking forward to shooting with this kit and sharing my results. See ya round the bend, Sony folks!
- Z7ii produces considerably cleaner files than the R4 across the board.
- Z lenses are better at bokeh transition and handling CA than even Sony GM lenses.
- Z lenses are better at handling harsh light transitions without creating halo-ing effects.
- NEF files are generally far closer to the final product than ARW files and take a lot less tweaking. They are also far less red than Sony files, which was always my biggest heartburn.
- The Z IBIS is better than Sony's, however Sony tends to put OIS on more lenses than Nikon.
- Z battery life isn't horribly worse than Sony, was pleasantly surprised.
- Z AF indicator is hard as hell to see vs Sony (much thinner and not as bright of a red color).
- Z burst mode is definitely worse/less usable than Sony, much more blackout.
- Z EFV is nice, and I honestly like it better than the Sony EVF even though Sony is "better".
- Z7ii AF-C is not bad when used with smaller AF points but will quickly refocus if you happen to wander. Wide mode for AF-C is not usable IMO, very very unreliable vs Sony.
- Z 100-400 is just overall better to use than the GM. Feels lighter, shorter zoom throw. Main bummer here is the reversed lens cap blocks the zoom ring completely.
- Z 24-120 is a world beater "kit" zoom.
Overall looking forward to shooting with this kit and sharing my results. See ya round the bend, Sony folks!...Show more →
Big decision, but you haven't based it on anyone's opinion than yours,
you spent some time comparing two systems against each other.
I'm playing with my new baby, 24-120s, I haven't had a chance to take it out yet,
but so far playing around the house and my backyard, I am very impressed, I think, I'm gonna love it.