p.22 #1New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote:
Has the temperature cooled for this lens? People seemed euphoric at the announcement.
From how downright incredible the Nokton 50mm 1.2 and the Nokton 35mm 1.2 III were, and comparing them to the 50mm 1.0 in terms of size and price at the time of announcement.. I just kinda hoped they had something super extra special in the 50mm 1.0.
p.22 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote:
Has the temperature cooled for this lens? People seemed euphoric at the announcement.
Sharp wide open with a strong possibility of reverse field curvature seems to be the general consensus but I suspect a lot of potential buyers are waiting for Matt to reveal how it deals with the curvature of scantily-clad Eastern European models.
p.22 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
lookert wrote: Desmolicious wroteHas the temperature cooled for this lens? People seemed euphoric at the announcement.From how downright incredible the Nokton 50mm 1.2 and the Nokton 35mm 1.2 III were, and comparing them to the 50mm 1.0 in terms of size and price at the time of announcement.. I just kinda hoped they had something super extra special in the 50mm 1.0.
Since you have the lens, can you post a link to DNG sample files?
p.22 #5New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote:
Has the temperature cooled for this lens? People seemed euphoric at the announcement.
Sugar highs. ; - )
Still interested here...
After a going over a smattering of samples from the older 1.1/50, I'm waiting for some monochromes to showcase any aesthetically meaningful aberrations. I'm still working with the new 1.5/50 Heliar, so I'm in no rush. I figure I'll pick up a mint used copy for probably $1200.
p.22 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
peasant_slave wrote: Desmolicious wrotehighdesertmesa wroteMatt Osborne's video on the CV 50 f/1 is up:I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.I like his simple and to the point vids. ..
I really do like his presentation and pace. Some sites really try to draw it out - I used to like Analog Insights but now trying to watch it is like pounding a mug of Nyquil after a turkey dinner.
p.22 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
zhangyue wrote:
Without knowing lens character you will not use it wisely. Just saying.
The video didn't show anything new other than sharpness and flare that we have known. At 3:05, judging the cat eye size make me estimate this is a f2.5 lens at corner at that distance. Around 4:30, comparing to 50mm F1 Leica, I prefer Leica look a lot more. Judged from samples so far, I believe I prefer TTA 0.95 as well at close distance but I wish I am wrong. So far, nothing changed my view regarding it after initial samples. I am only hoping I can see some good user cases justify it. Ergo wise, it is very lovely. I have no doubt about sharpness.
Don't tell me Alt FMers are more analytical, if we are not talk about that but just photography, you may well just use a nifty fifty and call it a day. A good photo will be good with those. Who care about background if it is really a good photo? IF f1 give you f2.5 corner DOF with strong FC and doesnt offer you something special, why this? VC f1.2 seems have a much lovely bokeh than this IMHO. ...Show more →
I agree the video didn’t show much. We need to see more samples!
Maybe too much is being expected of an f/1, sub-$2K lens that doesn’t completely block the M viewfinder. I was expecting something slightly better than their f/1.1, and so far that look like what this lens will be.
p.22 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I would suggest that out-of-focus blur and/or shallow depth of field isn't the only or main use for this lens - though it is a rather important one, I agree.
For me, shooting on the Leica m10 monochrom, it is primarily for its low light ability that I preordered one.
If one shoots at night or in very low light/available light situations, it can open up new vistas. No, it isn't
essential for what I do, but it helps.
Nevertheless, I appreciate the intense scrutiny of new lenses on all fronts. It is one reason why I am here.
p.22 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote: peasant_slave wroteDesmolicious wrotehighdesertmesa wroteMatt Osborne's video on the CV 50 f/1 is up:I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.I like his simple and to the point vids. ..I really do like his presentation and pace. Some sites really try to draw it out - I used to like Analog Insights but now trying to watch it is like pounding a mug of Nyquil after a turkey dinner.
In addition to Matt’s presentation and pace I also like the fact that he packs plenty of useful information and insights into his relatively short videos. Too many YouTube photo reviewers/pundits come across as loquacious wankers—Hugh Brownstone comes to mind—but Matt is refreshingly down to earth and direct.
p.22 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
So true!
His video is packed without BS.
And his girl models are pretty.
What else are you people complaining??!!
genji wrote: Desmolicious wrotepeasant_slave wroteDesmolicious wrotehighdesertmesa wroteMatt Osborne's video on the CV 50 f/1 is up:I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.I like his simple and to the point vids. ..I really do like his presentation and pace. Some sites really try to draw it out - I used to like Analog Insights but now trying to watch it is like pounding a mug of Nyquil after a turkey dinner.In addition to Matt’s presentation and pace I also like the fact that he packs plenty of useful information and insights into his relatively short videos. Too many YouTube photo reviewers/pundits come across as loquacious wankers—Hugh Brownstone comes to mind—but Matt is refreshingly down to earth and direct.
p.22 #11New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Rarified air up in here indeed
highdesertmesa wrote: rscheffler wroteI agree this lens is geared towards "portraiture" of subjects in the MFD-1.5m, maybe 2m range. And I do generally like the images I have seen from it at nearer distances. However that is not the only way in which the lens is being showcased in other forums, which obviously present scenarios that reveal some less desirable characteristics.
The discussion here IMO is about finding and knowing the technical capabilities of the lens across a broad range of uses, which each photographer can then weigh according to their own requirements and expectations.I think all the photographers on the planet concerned with mid-distance bokeh, mid-frame sharpness, and field curvature impacting bokeh at the edges of the frame – they are all here in this one Alt forum
p.22 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Justin Stone wrote:
Rarified air up in here indeed
highdesertmesa wroterscheffler wroteI agree this lens is geared towards "portraiture" of subjects in the MFD-1.5m, maybe 2m range. And I do generally like the images I have seen from it at nearer distances. However that is not the only way in which the lens is being showcased in other forums, which obviously present scenarios that reveal some less desirable characteristics.
The discussion here IMO is about finding and knowing the technical capabilities of the lens across a broad range of uses, which each photographer can then weigh according to their own requirements and expectations.I think all the photographers on the planet concerned with mid-distance bokeh, mid-frame sharpness, and field curvature impacting bokeh at the edges of the frame – they are all here in this one Alt forum
It's been a learning opportunity for me since my wide-open shots are usually close to MFD, where even close backgrounds get blurred pretty well. It's interesting to see all the use cases for wide-aperture lenses.
I do like how CV seems to realize there are so many ways to succeed or disappoint with a new lens, they just do whatever the flip they want to. Makes it really exciting to see how the next new one will perform and how it will draw.
p.22 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Thanks Desmolicious (I've pulled apart a few 70s Ducati singles, big ends) for Matt's latest, which is chock full of fast delivery info in his hot takes. A lovely bloke he is, old school from the Old Dart; good at his style of work and very analytical.
I've enjoyed his videos for years, and he is one of the few reviewers to recognise the balance needed in this class of lens. And he likes the 75/1.5 as a potential preference for some users: 'Is this the perfect portrait lens? I would still recommend checking out..'.
Impressive center sharpness at - presumably - MFD. If scrutinizing the stack in the right-hand side, we see minor signs of reverse field curvature.
Camera: M10-R
Lens profile: Noctilux f/1
At close distance (near MFD), it seems superior to the Voigtlander 50mm f/1.2 Nokton in terms of resolution and contrast due to FLE.
It's also a strength for the Leica 50/1.4 Lux compared to the F1.2 Nokton.
p.22 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
It seems like there is a lot of interested on the new SYOPTIC 50mm f/1.1, so I have started a new thread for it and moved all the posts related to this lens there: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1740891
p.22 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote:
Has the temperature cooled for this lens? People seemed euphoric at the announcement.
Just answering for myself, I was already looking into the Nokton 50mm f/1.1, and how it compares to vintage Noctilux f/1 lenses, at the time I became aware of the introduction of the Nokton 50mm f/1.0, so, obviously, my initial attention level was high. Evidence of significant field curvature has cooled my level of anticipation, though I may well still find a niche for this newest 50mm Nokton. The extra stop of light could be really useful, in extremely low light, a tool to keep my “older” M cameras relevant. Or, I may simply direct financial resources elsewhere.
I am not without a very good fast 50mm M-mount lens, as I started M shooting with a Summilux-M 50mm ASPH; it was the one lens that compelled me to add the Leica M system. A 50mm Nokton, of any max aperture, would not dethrone my Summilux.