Which camera did you use for those side-by-side shots with the two Nokton's?
If it's your Z6 and it's unmodified, it means the sensor glass thickness is about 1mm thicker, or almost twice as thick, as it was designed for. This could cause reverse field curvature, which I think we are seeing on the left side of the image, where the f/1.2 lens has more background blur than the f/1.
p.19 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
lookert wrote:
Another couple shots. In these ones, especially in the top left corner of the images, I think you can see the reverse field curvature, that everyone has been seeing.
Very useful post!
Didn't expect it to be:
a) already clearly visible at this focus distance
b) noticeably worse than 50mm 1.2
p.19 #3New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
BastianK wrote:
I see (maybe record breaking) optical vignetting. And a whole lot of astigmatism towards the corners which leads to (to my eyes) very unsightly bokeh.
I also think there is unfavourable field curvature even when used on a Leica camera.
From all the pictures I have seen so far, I think the floating elements design hurt the bokeh,
as it meant a dual focus cam and that lead to a very small diameter rear element, which rarely means good news for the optical vignetting.
It does look very sharp and contrasty at f/1.0 though, but with such lenses I care way more about the look and what I have seen so far isn't overly convincing.
Due to it being backordered in most places (and me not being ready to put ~2 grand on the table to buy one) might take some time until I get a review sample though.
Until then I enjoy the latest 50mm f/1.1 from China that cost me ~300 bucks and offers nicer bokeh imho ...Show more →
Some of those samples from user BostonBoy @ DPR really shows a lot of vignetting. However, the DNG file I downloaded shows a quite mild degree of vignetting. It becomes even more odd when considering both used the same in-camera lens profile.
Which camera did you use for those side-by-side shots with the two Nokton's?
If it's your Z6 and it's unmodified, it means the sensor glass thickness is about 1mm thicker, or almost twice as thick, as it was designed for. This could cause reverse field curvature, which I think we are seeing on the left side of the image, where the f/1.2 lens has more background blur than the f/1.
It is an unmodified Z6. I've only began looking for the reverse field curvature when I've read your observations in the l-camera-forum. The test shots there were done with an M10 I think and you were still able to pick up on that characteristic pretty quickly. I'm curious to see though how much better your modded Z6 does.
---------------------------------------------
BastianK wrote: lookert wroteAnother couple shots. In these ones, especially in the top left corner of the images, I think you can see the reverse field curvature, that everyone has been seeing.Very useful post!
Didn't expect it to be:
a) already clearly visible at this focus distance
b) noticeably worse than 50mm 1.2
So far the Nokton 50mm 1.2 seems to be just an overall insanely good deal.
The most noticeable difference seems to be more (I wouldn't even say creamier.. it's almost more nervous) bokeh and a slight yellow tint in the color rendering for the Nokton 1.0. Oh, and it's very sharp, almost feels sharper than the 1.2 – both shot wide open.. but I'm not sure about that, maybe it's just the high contrast and extreme vignetting that makes it seem that way.
Aside from that the Nokton 1.2 is lightweight, has quite a bit less intrusive vignetting and to me the focus ring feels a lot nicer.
p.19 #5New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
lookert wrote:
It is an unmodified Z6. I've only began looking for the reverse field curvature when I've read your observations in the l-camera-forum. The test shots there were done with an M10 I think and you were still able to pick up on that characteristic pretty quickly. I'm curious to see though how much better your modded Z6 does.
Thanks for posting the images. As Bastian said, they are very helpful, and now that we know the camera is a Z6, we are also getting a better grip on how the two lenses behave on an (unmodified and non-M) mirrorless camera.
Regarding how the f/1.0 does on my Z6UT, I am not sure if I will eventually buy the lens. Since I didn't order it very early and found out I would have to wait to March for it, and on top of that, needed to pre-pay the entire amount, I decided to wait and see sample images and possibly reviews before ordering. As it is, I am inclined to not buying it.
p.19 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
nehemiahphoto wrote: peasant_slave wrotenehemiahphoto wrotepeasant_slave wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroteMore samples here: https://www.foto-video-klein.de/voigtlaender-50mm-nokton-10/In the mirror swirly flower selfie in this gallery, looks like the photog is using an Sony cam, and I highly doubt it’s modded…LoCal does look very good. Thus far, I do like the images.Good catch! Looks like roman numeral 3 next to the 7...so a73...so then 24mp.I meant for FC and non-native sensor stack behavior like bokeh though!Yes, it was a present surprise when hunting that page to see which leica camera he was using that it was in fact a sony.
Is there a definitive answer for what causes swirly bokeh?It’s caused by optical vignetting, which means light is being truncated/distorted as it’s hits the peripheries of the frame. This causes increased DOF in the corners and the uneven elliptical bokeh, and can get swirly depending on how corrected it is. It’s a product of lens design. Some lenses are specifically created to enhance it, while others minimize it.
Thanks for the info. So, if stopping down reduces vignetting it therefore reduces swirly bokeh? I ask because in that dpreview link given above there's a shot with some foreground swirly bokeh. Looks like shot taken at f4 and the swirliness is mitigated to some extent.
p.19 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
peasant_slave wrote: nehemiahphoto wrotepeasant_slave wrotenehemiahphoto wrotepeasant_slave wrotenehemiahphoto wroteIn the mirror swirly flower selfie in this gallery, looks like the photog is using an Sony cam, and I highly doubt it’s modded…LoCal does look very good. Thus far, I do like the images.Good catch! Looks like roman numeral 3 next to the 7...so a73...so then 24mp.I meant for FC and non-native sensor stack behavior like bokeh though!Yes, it was a present surprise when hunting that page to see which leica camera he was using that it was in fact a sony.
Is there a definitive answer for what causes swirly bokeh?It’s caused by optical vignetting, which means light is being truncated/distorted as it’s hits the peripheries of the frame. This causes increased DOF in the corners and the uneven elliptical bokeh, and can get swirly depending on how corrected it is. It’s a product of lens design. Some lenses are specifically created to enhance it, while others minimize it.Thanks for the info. So, if stopping down reduces vignetting it therefore reduces swirly bokeh? I ask because in that dpreview link given above there's a shot with some foreground swirly bokeh. Looks like shot taken at f4 and the swirliness is mitigated to some extent.
Yes, closing down the aperture reduces optical vignetting which in turn mitigates swirling.
p.19 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
lookert wrote:
Another couple shots. In these ones, especially in the top left corner of the images, I think you can see the reverse field curvature, that everyone has been seeing. If you compare the both of the images, the 50mm 1.2 is very out of focus like I would expect that part of the image to be, while the 50mm 1.0 is a lot sharper in the small little twigs. The plane of focus of the 50mm 1.0 seems to be curved away quite a bit at the edges.
These are exported from C1 with the ProStandard ICC profile (no fixes/edits). Honestly sometimes I wonder why some people choose to fix things like CAs or vignetting for photos that are supposed to give an impression of how a given lens actually does perform. Not to mention the usage of color presets.. Maybe that's just me.
Thanks for the samples. In this case, what we are seeing is the effect of using a lens designed for the thin M sensor on a thicker sensor (induced field curvature). However, it also shows that this ill-effect looks worse compared to the 50/1.2 nokton, assuming focus was identical for both lenses.
I wish Voigtlander would pay more attention to optical vignetting which seems to bother many shooters, however, that would likely mean larger lenses.
p.19 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I’ve got one coming next week and intend to compare it to a nice copy of a late 50/1 Noctilux I have here, on an M10-R. Was intending to just use jpgs with the standard in camera settings for sharpening and contrast, so as not to introduce any variances caused by processing. It won’t be the kind of exhaustive testing that Fred does, and will take me a few days, but if anything looks helpful, will post samples here. Any other suggestions, and I’ll see what I can do to accommodate those.
p.19 #11New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Edward Teller wrote:
I’ve got one coming next week and intend to compare it to a nice copy of a late 50/1 Noctilux I have here, on an M10-R.
Will love to see your comparison. If using a coded Noctilux, remember to disable lens detection in order to minimize in-camera processing. Please also compare stopped-down backfocusing.
I am especially interested in portraits wide open.
p.19 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
CheshireCat wrote:
Will love to see your comparison. If using a coded Noctilux, remember to disable lens detection in order to minimize in-camera processing. Please also compare stopped-down backfocusing.
The Noctilux isn’t coded. Was intending to code both lenses as a 50/1 Noctilux since most M users would use them that way (guessing, at this point, they’d code the Nokton that way), though maybe your suggestion is better. I should probably do it both ways, one for pure lens information, one for how they’d perform everyday on an M, which would seem to be more valuable to M users (?). Provided I am thinking correctly.
Thanks for the suggestion, will do that, at least some of the time.
p.19 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Just random walk around shot with different subject and distance will be helpful.
I personally don’t think comparison make much difference given these are all niche lenses not for technical reason. Especially considering the price difference even I am curious.
Edward Teller wrote:
I’ve got one coming next week and intend to compare it to a nice copy of a late 50/1 Noctilux I have here, on an M10-R. Was intending to just use jpgs with the standard in camera settings for sharpening and contrast, so as not to introduce any variances caused by processing. It won’t be the kind of exhaustive testing that Fred does, and will take me a few days, but if anything looks helpful, will post samples here. Any other suggestions, and I’ll see what I can do to accommodate those.
p.19 #14New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Edward Teller wrote
The Noctilux isn’t coded. Was intending to code both lenses as a 50/1 Noctilux since most M users would use them that way (guessing, at this point, they’d code the Nokton that way),
I always disable coding when testing (even for native Leica lenses), so the results are true to the lens. But I am sure I'll appreciate your results any way you decide to test.
p.19 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
zhangyue wrote:
Just random walk around shot with different subject and distance will be helpful.
I personally don’t think comparison make much difference given these are all niche lenses not for technical reason. Especially considering the price difference even I am curious.
Will be doing those and tripod shots, and maybe even a brick wall if I can find one. Books on shelves, women in diners, planning on exhausting all the cliches excepting cats as none available.
What’s the general consensus, using Noctilux 50/1 coding on or off (for both lenses)?
p.19 #16New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Yes, disable code make more sense if you do comparison. Thank you for doing this.
Edward Teller wrote: zhangyue wroteJust random walk around shot with different subject and distance will be helpful.
I personally don’t think comparison make much difference given these are all niche lenses not for technical reason. Especially considering the price difference even I am curious.Will be doing those and tripod shots, and maybe even a brick wall if I can find one. Books on shelves, women in diners, planning on exhausting all the cliches excepting cats as none available.
What’s the general consensus, using Noctilux 50/1 coding on or off (for both lenses)?
p.19 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
Some of those samples from user BostonBoy @ DPR really shows a lot of vignetting. However, the DNG file I downloaded shows a quite mild degree of vignetting. It becomes even more odd when considering both used the same in-camera lens profile.
Just to be clear, a fair number of his images were stopped down rather than wide open, which would account for a significant difference in vignetting.
lookert wrote:
So far the Nokton 50mm 1.2 seems to be just an overall insanely good deal.
The most noticeable difference seems to be more (I wouldn't even say creamier.. it's almost more nervous) bokeh and a slight yellow tint in the color rendering for the Nokton 1.0. Oh, and it's very sharp, almost feels sharper than the 1.2 – both shot wide open.. but I'm not sure about that, maybe it's just the high contrast and extreme vignetting that makes it seem that way.
From what I've seen from others with the 50/1.2 and the limited 50/1 samples available so far, IMO the major difference will be higher sharpness/contrast in the plane of focus for the 50/1 wide open at nearer distances. Is this a good thing? I guess it depends on your priorities because the 50/1.2 certainly has a pleasing look with its higher SA at nearer distances.
I get the feeling this lens is a 'hey look at what we can do' exercise by Cosina to showcase their capabilities. It's one thing to make super sharp f/2 APOs, which I think we all appreciate. But for general market impact and product 'sexiness' nothing can beat a great performing ultra-fast lens. The higher than anticipated initial demand seems to verify this. The 50/1 probably outperforms the Leica 0.95, or at least matches it, in a smaller package (taking another page out of Leica's playbook). And should outclass all of the less expensive Chinese variants, in respect to general sharpness and contrast. So far I haven't seen any sign of onion rings, so the ground aspherical seems to be doing its job, along with retaining better sharpness and contrast than one would expect for such a lens (in combination with the floating element design).
p.19 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
mapgraphs wrote: Edward Teller wrote... Noctilux 50/1 coding on or off (for both lenses)?Off. Always.
Coding/profiles give you how the software decides to render...
I understand this, and will be doing it with the codes off (and on probably, at least until I can evaluate the inter-lens difference that way). So, I’m not arguing here, but I’m assuming most people shoot M bodies using the lens codes. If that’s the case, testing lenses without software correction is of academic interest because it gives the most accurate reading of innate lens characteristics, but that’s not indicative of how the lens will render the way most people will use it, which is with utilizing Leica’s built in codes.
So, testing it without utilizing the correction profiles, will give you the best indicator of how the lens performs if not attached to a camera, but I hardly ever use one that way.I do understand that some people don’t ever use profiles preferring to do any corrections to taste in post processing, but am betting most people use the codes most of the time.
Again, I’m not arguing with the soundness of the premise, and I will test them with the codes off (also understanding that the 50/1 Noctilux code might not be ideal for the Nokton anyway), but will shoot a few with the code selected anyway and post those separately for anyone interested.
Thanks for the input. Will try to make this worthwhile.