p.18 #1New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote: zhangyue wroteI’d like to. Just nothing so far convince me enough. I don’t like the bokeh so far, hopefully it is the process.After seeing the photos from the temple above, I'm leaning more in your direction. I don't like the rendering in most of those images though IMO the processing for all of those is high contrast, high color saturation, which will make it worse. There's also signs that FC might be noticeable based on the image of the seated people. The wet floor sign behind them is pretty sharp, though unsure if that one was wide open.
I am with you on this one.
I see (maybe record breaking) optical vignetting. And a whole lot of astigmatism towards the corners which leads to (to my eyes) very unsightly bokeh.
I also think there is unfavourable field curvature even when used on a Leica camera.
From all the pictures I have seen so far, I think the floating elements design hurt the bokeh,
as it meant a dual focus cam and that lead to a very small diameter rear element, which rarely means good news for the optical vignetting.
It does look very sharp and contrasty at f/1.0 though, but with such lenses I care way more about the look and what I have seen so far isn't overly convincing.
Due to it being backordered in most places (and me not being ready to put ~2 grand on the table to buy one) might take some time until I get a review sample though.
Until then I enjoy the latest 50mm f/1.1 from China that cost me ~300 bucks and offers nicer bokeh imho
p.18 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
zhangyue wrote:
I want be more specific about my comment about Bokeh. I feel this len's bokeh toward "rich", "thick" or high contrast side, nothing like Leica R water color like bokeh which I hope or love. When I see 50R E60 or Nikon 58G and 80lux at certain cases, first thing come into my mind is pretty. Can't say the same here. It is definitely not on the pretty side nor I can say smooth, not even sure can call it character. Now I just need to see a scenario that it works wonder to justify it. Sharpness and CA are plus, coverage could be too. It is a total package. However, as you said, maybe just get it as that is the only way to find out (which is also my philosophy)
TBF, I don't like TTA 50mm f0.95 render at mid distance too, however it is the first 0.95 Lens I have and It gives me something unique that other lens can't. Now it is just a waiting game. ...Show more →
So far I think I like what I see better at nearer focusing distances or where there is not much content where focus transition can be seen at medium distances.
Based on the images available from the DPR link on the previous page, if you examine his stopped down landscape/cityscape images, there's sign of possibly wavy field curvature or mid-zone weakness that is a fairly tight 'donut' around the center of the image. It didn't help he shot on aperture priority and probably auto ISO with only 2x shutter speed over focal length because some images appear to have a bit of camera movement mixed in to confuse the matter.
These images also show that OOF LoCA is definitely present. The previous photos from the German camera store were definitely tweaked to minimize this IMO.
p.18 #3New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I am less enthused the more I see. I don’t know the realm of ultra fast 50mm’s well, but I think I much prefer the CV 50/1.2.
Seems like they tried to split the difference of a more modern high contrast draw but lost on the rendering side. I will probably have to buy it to really know, but hmmmm…I’ll keep looking at samples.
p.18 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Well, I think it's going to be a really good head & shoulder portrait distance wide open with good sharpness that blows out the background so long as there isn't much transition zone visible kind of a lens.
At near distances there is some SA mixed in which somewhat calms down the look with a little bit of glow, IMO.
Based on the field curvature I'm seeing at far distances, when stopped down, it wouldn't be a multi-purpose lens, for me at least.
p.18 #5New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote: zhangyue wroteI want be more specific about my comment about Bokeh. I feel this len's bokeh toward "rich", "thick" or high contrast side, nothing like Leica R water color like bokeh which I hope or love. When I see 50R E60 or Nikon 58G and 80lux at certain cases, first thing come into my mind is pretty. Can't say the same here. It is definitely not on the pretty side nor I can say smooth, not even sure can call it character. Now I just need to see a scenario that it works wonder to justify it. Sharpness and CA are plus, coverage could be too. It is a total package. However, as you said, maybe just get it as that is the only way to find out (which is also my philosophy)
TBF, I don't like TTA 50mm f0.95 render at mid distance too, however it is the first 0.95 Lens I have and It gives me something unique that other lens can't. Now it is just a waiting game.It sounds like you prefer some spherical aberration. I can't blame you. I love a bit of SA in superfast lenses wide open. Both my Nokton 50mm f/1.2 Asph and Speedmaster 85mm f/1.2 has it (while becoming incredibly sharp when stopped down).
The Nokton f/1.0 appears to be designed for best possible contrast WO.
Yes, I do because there is certain correlation between good bokeh and SA. But not just that, I love 55 OTUS bokeh too and that one has very minimal SA. I think there are lenses have both just not this one based on samples but then this one has speed and sharpness nobody have. I hope I can find some scenario this lens do good. it has to be VC 40mm f1.2 is also have richer bokeh. Its bokeh can be ugly sometimes but at certain condition, it is also wonderful. I just hope I can see 'wonderful cases' soon.
So far, I feel at longer distance, this one do a good job which is a good surprise. But at close distance, it only show me bokeh quantity than quality.
p.18 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote: zhangyue wroteI want be more specific about my comment about Bokeh. I feel this len's bokeh toward "rich", "thick" or high contrast side, nothing like Leica R water color like bokeh which I hope or love. When I see 50R E60 or Nikon 58G and 80lux at certain cases, first thing come into my mind is pretty. Can't say the same here. It is definitely not on the pretty side nor I can say smooth, not even sure can call it character. Now I just need to see a scenario that it works wonder to justify it. Sharpness and CA are plus, coverage could be too. It is a total package. However, as you said, maybe just get it as that is the only way to find out (which is also my philosophy)
TBF, I don't like TTA 50mm f0.95 render at mid distance too, however it is the first 0.95 Lens I have and It gives me something unique that other lens can't. Now it is just a waiting game.So far I think I like what I see better at nearer focusing distances or where there is not much content where focus transition can be seen at medium distances.
Based on the images available from the DPR link on the previous page, if you examine his stopped down landscape/cityscape images, there's sign of possibly wavy field curvature or mid-zone weakness that is a fairly tight 'donut' around the center of the image. It didn't help he shot on aperture priority and probably auto ISO with only 2x shutter speed over focal length because some images appear to have a bit of camera movement mixed in to confuse the matter.
These images also show that OOF LoCA is definitely present. The previous photos from the German camera store were definitely tweaked to minimize this IMO....Show more →
I actually prefer long distance ones. The early samples that turn me off are all near distance. The set from HK actually give me some hope as I feel it did better job than TTA 0.95 for mid distance. TTA is quite good at MFD though, bokeh is softer.
p.18 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
BastianK wrote:
I see (maybe record breaking) optical vignetting
Maybe too early for that, especially these could be processed images.
I was hoping it will be good due to shorter/fatter design. All other 0.95 lenses are long that prone to mechanical vignette.
p.18 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote:
Based on the images available from the DPR link on the previous page, if you examine his stopped down landscape/cityscape images, there's sign of possibly wavy field curvature or mid-zone weakness that is a fairly tight 'donut' around the center of the image.
See this image for an illustration of where I see the mid-zone weakness:
The original image can be downloaded from this link
I believe he stated in one of his posts he either shot at f/1.0 or f/5.6, so I would take the above as being at f/5.6. EXIF kind of agrees with this.
p.18 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote: rscheffler wroteBased on the images available from the DPR link on the previous page, if you examine his stopped down landscape/cityscape images, there's sign of possibly wavy field curvature or mid-zone weakness that is a fairly tight 'donut' around the center of the image.See this image for an illustration of where I see the mid-zone weakness:
p.18 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote: rscheffler wroteBased on the images available from the DPR link on the previous page, if you examine his stopped down landscape/cityscape images, there's sign of possibly wavy field curvature or mid-zone weakness that is a fairly tight 'donut' around the center of the image.See this image for an illustration of where I see the mid-zone weakness:
The original image can be downloaded from this link
I believe he stated in one of his posts he either shot at f/1.0 or f/5.6, so I would take the above as being at f/5.6. EXIF kind of agrees with this.
Clear mid-zone weakness there.
I would not be surprised if the CV 50/1 had a mid-zone weakness (not wavy FC) since it's a characteristic of many successful lenses like the CV 50/1.2 and 50/1.4 Lux. It's hard to analyse images we don't know the processing or even the shooting aperture.
So far, aside from the pronounced optical vignetting, I find rendering pleasant from the images I've seen. My expectations are not super high to begin with as I have never seen a decently sharp f/0.95 or f/1 lens with technically great rendering.
I'm curious to see how the CV 50/1 and 50/1.2 compare in rendering at mid-distance. I will definitely test that next week. The 50/1.4 Lux's rendering is similar to the 50/1.2 Nokton. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1707236/1#15637090
p.18 #11New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I've been testing the lens for a couple hours today and yesterday. I've compared it to my 50mm 1.2 Nokton which I love. Here's the vignette of them both shot wide open against a while wall at around 1 meter of distance. First one is 1.0 and second one is 1.2.
Aside from that, the 50 1.0 seems to take a bit longer to clear up on the heavy vignetting than the 50 1.2 does.
p.18 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
zhangyue wrote:
No way f5.6 behave like this. Something is not right. I hope it is not f5.6.
EXIF is 1/125 at ISO 125 with an estimated aperture of f/4.8.
From this post: "I decided to "walk to town" and take the M10R w/ 50mm Voigtländer with me to see if a photo opportunity present itself. Part I attached - From the Walk. All shots are OOC JPEG, *not* processed from RAW, between F1 and mostly F5.6 (very sharp)."
Based on the lack of vignetting, I would guess it's stopped down somewhat and could be f/5.6 or a bit wider open.
He shot on the M10-R, so 40MP. Sure, when pixel peeping the FC or weakness is noticeable. Really the question would be how noticeable for how each of us would view these images? Lower magnification/enlargement and of course it becomes less noticeable. From a purely technical perspective, mid-zone weakness stopped down this much is undesirable but maybe it's a tradeoff for other considerations, such as nearer distance performance, size, cost, etc.
lookert wrote:
I've been testing the lens for a couple hours today and yesterday. I've compared it to my 50mm 1.2 Nokton which I love. Here's the Vignette of them both shot wide open against a while wall at around 1 meter of distance. First one is 1.0 and second one is 1.2.
Aside from that, the 50 1.0 seems to take a bit longer to clear up on the heavy vignetting than the 50 1.2 does.
Not much difference. I wonder how it looks if focused at infinity instead. This is where vignetting would be the worst - smallest image circle coverage and most oblique off-axis light rays to the corners.
p.18 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Going through BostonBoy's samples (missed focus excepted - and there's a lot of it), the edge to edge sharpness for the plane-of-focus, vignetting and contrast is what I would expect from a new Nokton. Looks like it's going to be great for event coverage.
On the other hand, from some of the comments so far, I'm anticipating the used market is going to be well stocked... ; - )
p.18 #16New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote:
Dan, there are so many fast 50s out there for M or LTM, you'll end up with a few, I'm sure.
mapgraphs wroteOn the other hand, from some of the comments so far, I'm anticipating the used market is going to be well stocked... ; - )I didn't want to mention that so as not to dissuade early adopters from committing and thus ensuring ample secondhand supply.
p.18 #17New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
dancook wrote:
I recently bought a Leica M9 to use 'cheap' vintage lenses on for 'character' - want a fast 50 for low light and dreamy portraits
look forward to more samples, but it might not be what i'm after.
I’ve done just that and bought the TTArtisan 50mm F0.95. I don’t mind the softness, character is great but I dislike the chromatic aberration and bokeh fringing which is extremely apparent on the M9. A super solid lens for black and white though.
p.18 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Well, my enthusiasm has cooled, somewhat, but I will be paying particular attention to black & white images, because a significant role that I have, for this 50/1.0 lens, would be on an M Monochrom 246 camera, in very low light. A faster Nokton lens would be less-costly than buying an M10 Monochrom, or any of the Noctilux lenses.
p.18 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
RexGig0 wrote:
Well, my enthusiasm has cooled, somewhat, but I will be paying particular attention to black & white images, because a significant role that I have, for this 50/1.0 lens, would be on an M Monochrom 246 camera, in very low light. A faster Nokton lens would be less-costly than buying an M10 Monochrom, or any of the Noctilux lenses.
Precisely! And, think of the 50mm f1.0 on the M10 Monochrom. That will be my sole use for this lens. Though, I may fool around on the fuji gfx 100s for a little color.
Waiting on cameraquest receiving it - hopefully - this Sat.
p.18 #20New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Another couple shots. In these ones, especially in the top left corner of the images, I think you can see the reverse field curvature, that everyone has been seeing. If you compare the both of the images, the 50mm 1.2 is very out of focus like I would expect that part of the image to be, while the 50mm 1.0 is a lot sharper in the small little twigs. The plane of focus of the 50mm 1.0 seems to be curved away quite a bit at the edges.
These are exported from C1 with the ProStandard ICC profile (no fixes/edits). Honestly sometimes I wonder why some people choose to fix things like CAs or vignetting for photos that are supposed to give an impression of how a given lens actually does perform. Not to mention the usage of color presets.. Maybe that's just me.