p.12 #1New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
DavidBM wrote:
Again, why use LF and not squeeze the most IQ out of it.
Why use any camera and not squeeze the most IQ out of it? The reasons for shallow DOF would be exactly the same on any format, no?
This is probably gonna offend some people but: personally I think it's because those bothering with large format are more often skilled photographers that have realized that shallow DOF doesn't make an image interesting (yes, there are of course many examples of the opposite, but I mean generally).
The current enthusiasm for very wide aperture 35mm FF photography is made possible by accurate autofocus, it was a bit of a niche before.
Umm, this whole thread is about a manual focus lens. Also, large aperture lenses were very common long before AF existed.
I'd love to see a change in the other direction, with manufacturers making high performance slower lenses. Especially with manual focus so that they can be compact and carried everywhere. Seriously, f/1 is more or less a gimmick. Exposure is only gonna get higher in the middle of the frame when you open from f/1.4 to f/1 anyway.
p.12 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Ah I missed that video posted earlier!
Guess that answers my question about using it on GFX, it definitely does not cover the 44x33 format very well, maybe 33x33 would be OK. As such, it is probably better to use the Nokton 50/1.2 if it covers 44x33 better as I've seen reported.
As much as I desire a lens like this and enjoy using my CV40, I think I'd opt for the 50GM for the AF ability at the end of the day over this 50/1.
p.12 #3New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Makten, I dont want quote you as it looks like this become a argument I enjoy more and more small aperture shooting depend on subject and background I want integrate.
It is not shallow or deep DOF make photographs interesting. It is more like is it an interesting photography?
It is also about option and freedom that people can choose use "wider" aperture to have extra control for DOF but at the same time can stop down to get deep DOF if needed.
There is nothing new here that all manufacture produce f1.4 glasses, now more f1.2 glasses and you have 200mm f2, 135 f1.8 etc... I can't use this logic to against people get fast glasses.
In term of shallow DOF, actually, this one is not shallower than traditional 85mm f1.4, or 135mm f2, or 300mmf2.8, 500f4, 600f4. A 600f4 bird will looks way better than 600f11 bird IMHO even with same ISO It is not about shallow DOF but is DOF serve the image.
At 2M, the DOF for 50mm f1 might be more than 0.7m 50mm f2 glass which is nothing fancy.
p.12 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
zhangyue wrote:
Makten, I dont want quote you as it looks like this become a argument I enjoy more and more small aperture shooting depend on subject and background I want integrate.
It is not shallow or deep DOF make photographs interesting. It is more like is it an interesting photography?
It is also about option and freedom that people can choose use "wider" aperture to have extra control for DOF but at the same time can stop down to get deep DOF if needed.
There is nothing new here that all manufacture produce f1.4 glasses, now more f1.2 glasses and you have 200mm f2, 135 f1.8 etc... I can't use this logic to against people get fast glasses.
In term of shallow DOF, actually, this one is not shallower than traditional 85mm f1.4, or 135mm f2, or 300mmf2.8, 500f4, 600f4. A 600f4 bird will looks way better than 600f11 bird IMHO even with same ISO It is not about shallow DOF but is DOF serve the image.
At 2M, the DOF for 50mm f1 might be more than 0.7m 50mm f2 glass which is nothing fancy.
I mostly agree, but I think it's a bit silly to strive for shallower DOF than what you get with f/1.4 or even f/2.
The comparison between focal lengths isn't really meaningful either, because you probably first choose your angle of view and then what DOF you want ("need").
I have the GF 110/2 for GFX and I'm actually often stopping it down even when I want shallow DOF, because it's too shallow. Why would you want to completely wipe out the background? That doesn't make interesting images, in my opinion.
But, it's only an opinion. But maybe food for thought.
p.12 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Makten wrote:
I have the GF 110/2 for GFX and I'm actually often stopping it down even when I want shallow DOF, because it's too shallow. Why would you want to completely wipe out the background? That doesn't make interesting images, in my opinion.
But, it's only an opinion. But maybe food for thought.
No worry. About opinion, me too.
All I want to say is there is no rule on this. I see tons of very interesting images regardless of shallow or not DOF. Plus, in term of background, this is highly related to focal length, subject distance, background to subject ratio etc... It almost impossible to generalize.
I agree people with fast glass tend to shoot WO, me included, I encourage photographer choose aperture based on subject, intention. Fast glass give option which slow one don't if you dont mind cost and size. Plus, most fast glass stop down a stop or two give better rendering than native slow glasses, at least more than not.
p.12 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Makten wrote: DavidBM wroteAgain, why use LF and not squeeze the most IQ out of it.
(1) "Why use any camera and not squeeze the most IQ out of it? The reasons for shallow DOF would be exactly the same on any format, no? "
No I don't think so. There is a tradeoff between portability and IQ improvement. Going from phone to a relatively hapitcally decent camera gives you a lot of benefit even if you don't squeeze very last drop out. Going to 8x10, or even 4x5 is a huge difference in terms of hassle. And everything about your technique and choice of settings and so on has to be spot on if you are to see an improvement over the best smaller formats. I know large format people who use MF or FF for shallow DOF work.
(2) "Umm, this whole thread is about a manual focus lens." Of course. But I'm talking about why shallow DOF photography got to be so mainstream and popular, and I do think that's down in part to AF. Sure there were wide aperture lenses back in the days of film. But there are almost no important images in the history of photography made with them. This is partly, perhaps, because shallow DOF photography is maybe less aesthetically important than its most enthusiastic practitioners think. But it's mainly because those lenses were more rare and expensive compared to other lenses than current fast lenses, and when they were used, were most often used to make focussing easier - at least on SLRs, not of course on rangefinders.
(3) "I'd love to see a change in the other direction, with manufacturers making high performance slower lenses. Especially with manual focus so that they can be compact and carried everywhere." This used to be something I was keen on. To a degree I still am, but less so for the reason that I and others have noted in this thread. To make a slower lens that is just as good in bokeh terms at least (especially in the periphery) as a faster one stopped down to the same aperture, requires it to be about as large and heavy as the faster one.
p.12 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
^^^ "But there are almost no important images in the history of photography made with them."
Please, I'm not flaming here, just contributing to the discussion!
I will have to beg to differ on this point. I have all the readily available books of the photographs of Native Americans taken by Edward Sheriff Curtis, which are iconic (as well as controversial) both photographically and sociologically, and they are some of the most important images ever made in American history. Curtis used large formats (off hand I think 8x10) for his portraits, with a very narrow DOF (and which he exploited to great effect). So, although I myself am not a big fan of overused modern ultra-shallow DOF, it was unavoidable and very effectively used in 19th century portrait photography!
p.12 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
photonoclast wrote:
^^^ "But there are almost no important images in the history of photography made with them."
Please, I'm not flaming here, just contributing to the discussion!
I will have to beg to differ on this point. I have all the readily available books of the photographs of Native Americans taken by Edward Sheriff Curtis, which are iconic (as well as controversial) both photographically and sociologically, and they are some of the most important images ever made in American history. Curtis used large formats (off hand I think 8x10) for his portraits, with a very narrow DOF (and which he exploited to great effect). So, although I myself am not a big fan of overused modern ultra-shallow DOF, it was unavoidable and very effectively used in 19th century portrait photography!...Show more →
You are absolutely right.
I should have been clear I was talking of what me might call the modern era (after the 1930s or so). And even then I have no doubt there are counterexamples if we think hard enough.
But as you yourself have pointed out by saying “unavoidable” the C19 is a very different kettle of fish, with apertures being dictated by exposure times in portraits, rather than chosen for aesthetic effect.
Sometimes I think it looks great, btw, and sometimes not. And it’s hard to know now whether it looks great because it’s the badge of the era (as it were) and iconic, or for more intrinsic reasons. It’s interesting that although with very fast lenses these days that look could be replicated, that’s not typically how they are used. I don’t know why.
p.12 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
So given all the talk about NOT shooting lenses just to elicit the shallow DOF look, I'm curious what the primary appeal of this lens is for people? Stopped-down performance, compared to other lenses at a similar aperture? Nighttime shooting? Or is this kind of lens simply too "exotic" and special-use to ever be a staple?
p.12 #11New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I guess those people aren't in the market for such a lens. They would be much, much better off with the 50mm Apo-Lanthar for instance.
I am considering the Nokton f/1 for using it at it's max aperture. Before we see more (quality) sample images, to me, that's the whole, if not only, point getting it. The price is high (at least for a Voigtländer VM lens) and the lens is very big and heavy for a 50mm in M mount, so the reason to buy it is its max aperture. A more specific use of the lens might be for bokeh nerds that want even degree of blur across the frame when shooting at f/1.4 or f/2, but this requires a moderate degree of vignetting already at f/1.
I just checked the vignetting of the Noctilux-M 50mm f/0.95 Asph. The official vignetting curve from Leica suggests more than three stops wide open (around 12% luminance in the extreme corners). According to OpticalLimits.com (previously know as PhotoZone) it is 4.3 stops down in the corners:
This means I expect and hope that the Nokton f/1 will perform better in this regard. (And to be honest, I am shocked how high the vignetting in the Noctilux Asph is.)
astrobuoy wrote:
So given all the talk about NOT shooting lenses just to elicit the shallow DOF look, I'm curious what the primary appeal of this lens is for people? Stopped-down performance, compared to other lenses at a similar aperture? Nighttime shooting? Or is this kind of lens simply too "exotic" and special-use to ever be a staple?
p.12 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
astrobuoy wrote:
So given all the talk about NOT shooting lenses just to elicit the shallow DOF look, I'm curious what the primary appeal of this lens is for people? Stopped-down performance, compared to other lenses at a similar aperture? Nighttime shooting? Or is this kind of lens simply too "exotic" and special-use to ever be a staple?
Well the problem is with the word "NOT." There is really no rule in art. If it's your intention for that look, why not? People can disagree with you. From my experience, f/1 has plenty of DOF for a full body shot with a blurred background. There are successful photographers out there who specialize in this look. Just another tool in the shed. If size and weight don't matter, I say a faster lens affords you more flexibility to shoot in all kind of light.
p.12 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
On the large format stuff. I shoot 4x5. People don't shoot large format to get shallow depth of field. They shoot large format so that they can get A LOT MORE depth of field than you normally can. Movements let you control DOF and increase it...well you never really increase it you just tilt/rotate it to make it look like you have more. You can also fix perspective etc etc etc. Yes you can move everything the wrong way and get those old school tintype weird photos where just the eye are in focus and everything else is proper ghostly but...whatever.
Now...a 50/1 lens. Great. I don't see the point of this lens for anyone using the rangefinder though unless you are a human tripod. These fast lenses are made either for EVFs or for people who want to just say they have a f/1 lens. Or for low light shooting where getting "a" shot is more important than getting "the" shot.
On the other end of the spectrum, I just got myself a 50 Elmar-M, it is actually liberating shooting at f/2.8 and not worrying about focus as much. Yes you can shoot the 50/1 at f/2.8 too but why carry the weight.
Then again, lots of people make great photos with a 200/1.8. It is good to have choice.
p.12 #14New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
astrobuoy wrote:
So given all the talk about NOT shooting lenses just to elicit the shallow DOF look, I'm curious what the primary appeal of this lens is for people? Stopped-down performance, compared to other lenses at a similar aperture? Nighttime shooting? Or is this kind of lens simply too "exotic" and special-use to ever be a staple?
I would agree with you. If you are buying an f/1 50mm lens for 35mm format, and you aren't planning on using it at the widest apertures regularly, then there is no point in getting the lens. If you will almost always be shooting it at f/2 or smaller, the APO Lanthar is going to be cheaper, sharper, much smaller and lighter and be an overall better corrected optic. If you want fast, but not insane fastness, the 50/1.2 Nokton is probably going to be the better buy..likely better at small apertures, but still fast, and notably smaller and less expensive, plus it focuses closer. Similarly for the 50/1.4 Summilux, if price isn't a concern, but size and other qualities are.
p.12 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Jman13 wrote: astrobuoy wroteSo given all the talk about NOT shooting lenses just to elicit the shallow DOF look, I'm curious what the primary appeal of this lens is for people? Stopped-down performance, compared to other lenses at a similar aperture? Nighttime shooting? Or is this kind of lens simply too "exotic" and special-use to ever be a staple?I would agree with you. If you are buying an f/1 50mm lens for 35mm format, and you aren't planning on using it at the widest apertures regularly, then there is no point in getting the lens. If you will almost always be shooting it at f/2 or smaller, the APO Lanthar is going to be cheaper, sharper, much smaller and lighter and be an overall better corrected optic. If you want fast, but not insane fastness, the 50/1.2 Nokton is probably going to be the better buy..likely better at small apertures, but still fast, and notably smaller and less expensive, plus it focuses closer. Similarly for the 50/1.4 Summilux, if price isn't a concern, but size and other qualities are. ...Show more →
Same here. If I had this lens, I would mostly use it at f/1....otherwise the CV 50/1.2 Nokton or 50/2 APO would be a more sensible choice considering the lower size, weight and price.
p.12 #16New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I have TTartisan that I realize never stop that lens down. I also find I almost only shoot that lens within 2M subject. (Both for a reason) I also don’t like a flat look subject with total blur background( far away). However, most subject we shooting are 3d: portrait, a car, a bike, a tree. There is no such a thing total blur with 3D subject. Many times, I do wish it is even faster.
Bokeh or lens render to me is not just background. Or corner look I talked a lot in this thread. It is also about in focus look, how the focus roll off. Fast glass give different transition look slow glass can’t. It’s purpose is away from reality not other way around the goal many try to achieve so they blame lens
I realize I only combine wide open and stop down a little with certain glass( not talking about deep DOF landscape or product shooting); planar 50, 85, distagon 35f1.4 classic. 35mm summilux ASPH, Nikon 58G.
I almost never stop down 80lux, 50lux ASPH, 50cron APO, 28cron. 35lux preASPH any S glasses any V or contax645 glass on S or GFX. I have good reason to not do that. However, this requires long discussion for each one for the thinking process. The way how I use each lens and why I keep them at all play big part of this decision. I admit many times it has nothing to do with make final image look better but a satisfaction of I get the look I want with the tool I choose.
This is just me. I don’t mind you disagree or agree. This is so personal that no need for justification.
The initial samples look pretty good but this is not the one I want use on GFX. This confirm my thinking that none of M glass I want to use on larger format.
I ordered it from Fred’s link. Hopefully, it can be delivered before my Payboo expire. Finger crossed.
p.12 #17New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
astrobuoy wrote:
So given all the talk about NOT shooting lenses just to elicit the shallow DOF look, I'm curious what the primary appeal of this lens is for people? Stopped-down performance, compared to other lenses at a similar aperture? Nighttime shooting? Or is this kind of lens simply too "exotic" and special-use to ever be a staple?
Jman13 wrote:
I would agree with you. If you are buying an f/1 50mm lens for 35mm format, and you aren't planning on using it at the widest apertures regularly, then there is no point in getting the lens. If you will almost always be shooting it at f/2 or smaller, the APO Lanthar is going to be cheaper, sharper, much smaller and lighter and be an overall better corrected optic. If you want fast, but not insane fastness, the 50/1.2 Nokton is probably going to be the better buy..likely better at small apertures, but still fast, and notably smaller and less expensive, plus it focuses closer. Similarly for the 50/1.4 Summilux, if price isn't a concern, but size and other qualities are. ...Show more →
It will be interesting to see how this lens looks stopped down a little, say at f/1.4 and f/2, compared to other lenses that are either f/1.4 or f/2 wide open. My past experience with other fast 50s has been that stopping those down slightly, like to f/2, still looks nicer, in terms of bokeh blur, than a 50/2 wide open. A lens like the 50/1 gives you some options in the f/1.0-f/2 range to play with. But I agree, if stopped down use is a priority, then it probably doesn't make sense as a first choice from a size, weight and price (relative to other VM options) point of view. I'm interested to see how it performs at f/1.2 vs the VM50/1.2 - I'm guessing it will be sharper/higher contrast at least centrally. And also at f/1.4, and f/2.0 against such lenses.
Michael likes to shoot the 50 Lux ASPH wide open. I like it at f/1.7 and f/2.0 as well. Same with the various 50/1.5 Sonnar flavors from the 50s & 60s. Take the 50/1.4 Nikkor LTM with crazy wide open character that changes dramatically by f/2. Or the Zeiss Opton Sonnar that is a bit tamer wide open and smooths out around f/2-2.5. These lenses offer creative choices.
In theory the VM just expands the envelope more than those lenses for wider than f/2 creative options. But from the few sample photos so far, it appears it might be rather well corrected wide open, which isn't necessarily the case for some of the other 50/0.95s currently on the market. It's possible its character doesn't change a lot on stopping down. This could be good or bad, depending on your preferences. I have the feeling Cosina is looking to better the 50/0.95 Noctilux, possibly taking a page out of Karbe's playbook of 'stopping down only for more depth of field.' At least to the degree that's possible with current technology in a $2000 50/1.0 lens.
p.12 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Certain lenses suggest a method of use, and have a sweet spot: The Distagon 35/1.4 ZM is definitely unique wide open, as is my Konishiroku Hexanon 50/1.9 LTM lens from the 1950’s. Stop both of those lenses down, even a stop, and the magic disappears. Wide open, all the flaws combine into something special.
Some lenses, like my Nikkor 55/1.2 are just too crazy for me at full aperture, but are really lovely, and maintain their special look, even at f1.4 or f2. Same with the 58/1.4G, when I owned one - it was best (for me) at about f1.6-f2.2.
It will be interesting to see how this Nokton (Noktolux?) behaves. I am hoping for something unique wide open. So far, none of the sample photos show this, but manufacturer samples are always meant to be “non-controversial”. Hopefully, there’s some weirdness in this lens, too!
p.12 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Oldwino wrote..
Some lenses, like my Nikkor 55/1.2 are just too crazy for me at full aperture, but are really lovely, and maintain their special look, even at f1.4 or f2. ..
What craziness? My Nikkor 55 1.2 @ 1.2:
Now my Nikkor 35 1.4 AIS is all sorts of dreamy deliciousness wide open.
I think that perhaps with all these lenses how close to the subject really influences/emphasizes these behaviours.
p.12 #20New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Oldwino wrote:
It will be interesting to see how this Nokton (Noktolux?) behaves. I am hoping for something unique wide open. So far, none of the sample photos show this, but manufacturer samples are always meant to be “non-controversial”. Hopefully, there’s some weirdness in this lens, too!
If there was wide open weirdness (think Canon 50/0.95 Dream Lens) it would have been evident in the samples we’ve already seen. I agree all of the samples look well corrected and that’s what I expect from this lens, including ‘modern’ clean rendering.