fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread

  
 
CKrueger
Offline
Details
p.14 #1Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
cvrle59 wrote:
It's hard to know what kind of processing happened here, but this looks pretty good.
I'm wondering what everyone here thinks about it?
According to EXIF, 400mm wide open.
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51766545565_f9a0eb4806_k.jpgWhite-crowned sparrow in the rain by Doug Greenberg, on Flickr


I'd be very happy with that from my 500PF, to say nothing of my 100-400!
Dec 23, 2021 at 05:03 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #2Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
If I can’t produce a sharp pic at 400mm at 1/500 I have a problem and it’s not me

George DeCamp wrote:
Just noticed you're shooting tbe 100-400@ 1/500 hand held.

You're shooring the 24-120@ 1/400 hand held which means you must be much closer and much better shutter speed for that lens. Probably enough to produce a sharper image.

Dec 23, 2021 at 05:05 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #3Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Is Ego charger sharpness testing the new hotness on FM?!

CKrueger wrote:
Hey Scott, I have the same Ego charger, so I can give you some apples-to-apples! Unfortunately it was already getting dark at 4:15pm here, but I was able to shoot outside with a tripod at ISO100 on my Z6.

Here's my results!

First shot is my 105 MC at f/5.6 a couple feet from the target. I'd call that an "ideal case"!

Second shot is my 100-400 at 100mm f/5.6 at the same distance.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51771169549_2b53319213_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770528966_f6cf063cea_o.jpg

Next test!

First shot is my 100-400 at 400mm f/5.6 perhaps six feet from the target.

Second shot is my 500PF at f/5.6 at the same distance. As close to an "ideal
...Show more →
Dec 23, 2021 at 05:05 PM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.14 #4Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Seeing pics above and on the 100-400 pic thread you likely have a bad copy. The lens itself can be very sharp and yours is less so. Not horrible but noticeable. But what is strange is how similar your copy is to your Sony lens. So if one is soft, both are. Strange indeed.

Good luck.

Edited on Dec 23, 2021 at 06:01 PM · View previous versions
Dec 23, 2021 at 06:01 PM
CKrueger
Offline
Details
p.14 #5Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
They tend to move less than ducks. Much more uniform, too!

RoamingScott wrote:
Is Ego charger sharpness testing the new hotness on FM?!

CKrueger wroteHey Scott, I have the same Ego charger, so I can give you some apples-to-apples! Unfortunately it was already getting dark at 4:15pm here, but I was able to shoot outside with a tripod at ISO100 on my Z6.

Here's my results!

First shot is my 105 MC at f/5.6 a couple feet from the target. I'd call that an "ideal case"!

Second shot is my 100-400 at 100mm f/5.6 at the same distance.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51771169549_2b53319213_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770528966_f6cf063cea_o.jpg

Next test!

First shot is my 100-400 at 400mm f/5.6 perhaps six feet from the target.

Second shot is my 500PF at f/5.6 at the same distance. As close to an "ideal case" as I can muster with my equipment. Note I did NOT correct for distance, cause I was running out of light!

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770529146_752917ff57_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51771410815_1c3a857837_o.jpg

Dec 23, 2021 at 06:01 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.14 #6Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
CKrueger wrote:
Hey Scott, I have the same Ego charger, so I can give you some apples-to-apples! Unfortunately it was already getting dark at 4:15pm here, but I was able to shoot outside with a tripod at ISO100 on my Z6.

Here's my results!

First shot is my 105 MC at f/5.6 a couple feet from the target. I'd call that an "ideal case"!

Second shot is my 100-400 at 100mm f/5.6 at the same distance.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51771169549_2b53319213_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770528966_f6cf063cea_o.jpg

Next test!

First shot is my 100-400 at 400mm f/5.6 perhaps six feet from the target.

Second shot is my 500PF at f/5.6 at the same distance. As close to an "ideal
...Show more →

What a lucky coincidence you have the same charger. These look great and are in close accord with Brad HIll's findings. Certainly plenty sharp enough for all practical uses to the point where other design objectives such as fringing, OOF transitions, colour, contrast, handling etc. become way more interesting.
Dec 23, 2021 at 06:14 PM
westsdad
Offline
Details
p.14 #7Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
@RoamingScott

This is one of the Z lenses (others being DX, MC lenses, and those with VR) that Nikon has limited mechanical shutter from being selected.

IIRC, in Auto shutter mode it uses EFCS up to 1/250s.

Maybe your specific body copy and lens copy combination requires EFCS in the 1/320s and 1/400s range to avoid the effects from the EFC.

You did turn off VR and use a timer (but it would still be a mechanical shutter above 1/250s) during your testing.

It would be interesting to see the initial testing re-performed (tripod and handheld) with d5 set to EFCS.

Favorable results could indicate that the Auto setting may need to be updated to have a selectable shutter speed other than 1/250s when using EFCS.

And damn you, now I have to get a different EGO charger (have 2 already, but neither are the new FM Forum standard) in order to do lens testing!
Dec 23, 2021 at 06:45 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #8Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Interesting to see the same style of softness here, even if not so obvious. I would estimate my range was closer to 10-15’.

CKrueger wrote:
Hey Scott, I have the same Ego charger, so I can give you some apples-to-apples! Unfortunately it was already getting dark at 4:15pm here, but I was able to shoot outside with a tripod at ISO100 on my Z6.

Here's my results!

First shot is my 105 MC at f/5.6 a couple feet from the target. I'd call that an "ideal case"!

Second shot is my 100-400 at 100mm f/5.6 at the same distance.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51771169549_2b53319213_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770528966_f6cf063cea_o.jpg

Next test!

First shot is my 100-400 at 400mm f/5.6 perhaps six feet from the target.

Second shot is my 500PF at f/5.6 at the same distance. As close to an "ideal
...Show more →
Dec 23, 2021 at 08:08 PM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.14 #9Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Not that I disagree, but adjustments are there for a reason, and it’s still worth knowing if you have an AF issue, a glass issue or the lens is just inferior. It’s probably 5-15-80 but still good to know the real source.

RoamingScott wrote:
AdaptedLenses wroteHave you checked for front or back focus? It’s much more rare, but it does happen and the cameras have the ability to adjust focus. Kind of looks to me like it’s slightly missed. Or maybe try manual focus with a tripod, sorry I haven’t heard the whole thread if you’ve already addressed this apologies.

RoamingScott wroteLast post about this. I'll be contacting my vendor to see what my options are...it's a return for sure if nothing else.

Left is Nikon 100-400, 400mm, 1/500, f5.6 handheld
Right is Nikon 24-120, 120mm, 1/400, f4 handheld

Note how much sharper the shorter zoom is. This is the behavior I expect to see from all my lenses. If you can't see a clear difference, and understand why I feel the lens that costs 3x more is quite disappointing, well...I dunno.

Anyways, thanks for humoring me, hopefully my tests were helpful to some degree. Y'all have a very merry christmas, and may Santa bring you only the sharpest copies of your favorite lenses.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770683358_ed05f0d3a4_3k.jpg
I didn't try these things because 1) i shoot mirrorless to avoid having to deal with micro adjustments and 2) it should just work.

Dec 23, 2021 at 09:32 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #10Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Are the adjustments saved per lens in the camera?

AdaptedLenses wrote:
Not that I disagree, but adjustments are there for a reason, and it’s still worth knowing if you have an AF issue, a glass issue or the lens is just inferior. It’s probably 5-15-80 but still good to know the real source.

RoamingScott wrote
AdaptedLenses wroteHave you checked for front or back focus? It’s much more rare, but it does happen and the cameras have the ability to adjust focus. Kind of looks to me like it’s slightly missed. Or maybe try manual focus with a tripod, sorry I haven’t heard the whole thread if you’ve already addressed this apologies.

RoamingScott wroteLast post about this. I'll be contacting my vendor to see what my options are...it's a return for sure if nothing else.

Left is Nikon 100-400, 400mm, 1/500, f5.6 handheld
Right is Nikon 24-120, 120mm, 1/400, f4 handheld

Note how much sharper the shorter zoom is. This is the behavior I expect to see from all my lenses. If you can't see a clear difference, and understand why I feel the lens that costs 3x more is quite disappointing, well...I dunno.

Anyways, thanks for humoring me, hopefully my tests were helpful to some degree. Y'all have a very merry christmas, and may Santa bring you only the sharpest copies of your favorite lenses.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770683358_ed05f0d3a4_3k.jpg
I didn't try these things because 1) i shoot mirrorless to avoid having to deal with micro adjustments and 2) it should just work.

Dec 23, 2021 at 09:40 PM
CKrueger
Offline
Details
p.14 #11Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Don’t forget that I’m on a Z6, so my resolution will be lower than yours overall.

Personally, I was impressed with how close the lens came to my “better” lenses. The differences here wouldn’t be visible in a 20x30 print unless the file were heavily cropped.

I definitely need to get some more real-world testing in, cause plastic doesn’t really stand in well for feathers and fur. I have a bunch of goose and seagull photos so far, and the results have been pretty good, but I often shoot my 500PF with a 1.4x, and I still have a hard time believing the 100-400 can handle that. I guess I’m skeptical because my Canon 100-400 absolutely fell apart (AF included) with a 1.4x. Probably not a fair prejudice…
Dec 23, 2021 at 09:47 PM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.14 #12Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Good question and to be honest I don’t know. Only one I’ve done it on was a Tamron 70-210, but that was done with their TAP Console. Thinking through it, I wonder if it might not be saved in the lens itself since the camera, basically by definition can’t be out of focus. But the lenses calibration can. Ie focus is plane X but lens is going X+1.

RoamingScott wrote:
Are the adjustments saved per lens in the camera?

AdaptedLenses wroteNot that I disagree, but adjustments are there for a reason, and it’s still worth knowing if you have an AF issue, a glass issue or the lens is just inferior. It’s probably 5-15-80 but still good to know the real source.

RoamingScott wrote
AdaptedLenses wroteHave you checked for front or back focus? It’s much more rare, but it does happen and the cameras have the ability to adjust focus. Kind of looks to me like it’s slightly missed. Or maybe try manual focus with a tripod, sorry I haven’t heard the whole thread if you’ve already addressed this apologies.

RoamingScott wroteLast post about this. I'll be contacting my vendor to see what my options are...it's a return for sure if nothing else.

Left is Nikon 100-400, 400mm, 1/500, f5.6 handheld
Right is Nikon 24-120, 120mm, 1/400, f4 handheld

Note how much sharper the shorter zoom is. This is the behavior I expect to see from all my lenses. If you can't see a clear difference, and understand why I feel the lens that costs 3x more is quite disappointing, well...I dunno.

Anyways, thanks for humoring me, hopefully my tests were helpful to some degree. Y'all have a very merry christmas, and may Santa bring you only the sharpest copies of your favorite lenses.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51770683358_ed05f0d3a4_3k.jpg
I didn't try these things because 1) i shoot mirrorless to avoid having to deal with micro adjustments and 2) it should just work.

Dec 23, 2021 at 10:44 PM
cvrle59
Offline
Details
p.14 #13Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Scott may have bad copy, the image from Flickr I posted here, and one Lance posted in the other thread are good examples that lens can produce great level of sharpness at 400/f5.6.
This makes me relaxed, but I have to think about strategy to be prepared to be able to swap it if I don't get good results.
My local store I'm inline at isn't the best at it, I may go to Henry's instead.
Dec 24, 2021 at 07:17 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #14Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
I’m both heartened and mightily annoyed looking at the other folks’ examples wide open.
Dec 24, 2021 at 08:48 AM
cvrle59
Offline
Details
p.14 #15Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread

RoamingScott wrote:
I’m both heartened and mightily annoyed looking at the other folks’ examples wide open.

Fully understood, I went through similar with Fuji 100-400, first copy was pretty sharp in the center, but badly decentered in one corner, second copy was almost useless at 400/f5.6, I had to go at least to f7.1.
Looking to others, who could get amazingly sharp images made me very frustrated.
I dumped Fuji waiting for this to happen, but we still need to open our eyes, not every copy is perfect.
Dec 24, 2021 at 09:21 AM
ilkka_nissila
Offline
Details
p.14 #16Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
I would highly recommend making any sharpness tests on tripod and with EFCS (except of course Z9 which only has e-shutter) so that the influence of vibrations can be minimized. This allows any optical issues that might exist to be identified from other factors that might cause blur. Also with a lightweight 400 mm lens, wind can cause problems.

There is some sample variability in zoom lenses and one sample might be better in a specific part of the frame than another and it may be different depending on focal length (one lens copy may be better at a specific FL than another lens which may be better at another). However, Nikon seem to have put a great deal of effort into designing the 100-400 lens, its manufacture and testing to minimize such differences between copies (according to their web page).

I think the images shown from this lens are quite pleasing including RoamingScott's. I think the sharpness differences shown seem subtle. I quite like the contrast, colour, out of focus rendering make it very attractive. If someone is concerned about the sharpness of one's copy, testing against another copy may be helpful (with tripod, VR off and EFCS on). If the results still indicate subpar sharpness then it is best to either return the lens or take it to service. However, I haven't really seen anything that I would consider a red flag indicating a faulty lens.

It's good to be aware that in addition to focal length and aperture, distance can also influence the relative merits of different lenses.

If I get this lens it would be for landscape (high contrast desirable), outdoor concerts at large stages, and some wildlife. I would not be using it for subjects that require longer than 400mm focal length or deep cropping as it is best to choose a long prime lens for that for several reasons. Printing (or displaying in other ways) cropped shots makes noise more obvious and f/5.6 isn't the best starting point. Also for distant subjects separating the subject from background can benefit for a larger aperture (and shooting longer distance shots and then cropping then makes this even more important).

Dec 24, 2021 at 09:22 AM
CKrueger
Offline
Details
p.14 #17Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
It’s a crappy situation, I agree. When I was shooting Canon EF, I’d generally buy two copies and keep the better one. There was often a considerable difference between copies. And I still remember testing a half dozen different TCs before ending up with a cracker of a Kenko 1.4x and Canon 2x.

Lens testing really sucks! I think many of us here are your samples and think “might not have a problem, needs more testing”, but that’s easy to say when you’re not the one staring down the barrel of a hundred frames of A/B testing.

Bottom line, if you’re not happy with it, swap it out. Cause even if it is actually a good copy, every not-quite-sharp image you ever get with it, you’ll blame on the lens, and you’ll come to hate it.

RoamingScott wrote:
I’m both heartened and mightily annoyed looking at the other folks’ examples wide open.

Dec 24, 2021 at 09:56 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.14 #18Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
I would recommend taking as much time before your return window ends. Forget tests. Go take some real world shots and have fun. Then look at those. Don’t compare against anything, just look at them and see if you are happy with the results. If yes, you have a keeper. If not, try another one or return it.

There is nothing wrong with lens tests. I do them in a pinch. But you already did tests and they were somewhat inconclusive. More will be learned by using the lens. And you don’t NEED to post images here for everyone to tell you about your lens. You know what you are doing.

Off to make Christmas Eve dinner.
Dec 24, 2021 at 10:06 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #19Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread
Swapped my copy. Will see if any improvement soon. I appreciate all the feedback.
Dec 24, 2021 at 12:44 PM
cvrle59
Offline
Details
p.14 #20Nikon Z 100-400S discussion thread


RoamingScott wrote:
Swapped my copy. Will see if any improvement soon. I appreciate all the feedback.

Wow, Texas is the best, they've got so many...
Dec 24, 2021 at 12:57 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister