RustyBug wrote: genji wroteI’m warming to the Ultron. I’ll pick it up next Tuesday, give it an unprejudiced trial, and report back in this thread.Will be interesting to hear.
I've got the Elmarit 28/2.8 Asph II, and the Ultron catches my eye as I see the images others shoot with it. Simultaneously, I wonder about a Cron. I quite like my Elmarit for its its drawing style, but the haptic does present itself some issues for me that I can't quite seem to "become one" with.
I'm shooting on an M-P 240 (and X-Pro3 or future CL2), so I don't have the quite the same optical concerns as those shooting on FF Sony. Still, will be interesting to hear your take on it, compared to the Cron for both drawing and handling. (And then, there's the prospect of the Q for its 28mm.)...Show more →
I don’t have the same optical concerns as those shooting on FF Sony either since, with the sole exception of a Tele-Elmar-M 135/4, I use my M-mount lenses with various film and digital M bodies. Nor will I be comparing the Ultron to the Cron since I don’t have a copy of the Cron. Yet.
It turns out that, with a couple of caveats, the Ultron VM 28mm f/2 II vastly exceeded my expectations. As an object, it just oozes class. The build quality is superb: heavy brass construction, gorgeous black paint finish, focus ring as smooth as silk, rangefinder focus dead accurate, aperture ring that clicks easily but firmly. It’s as good as any Leica-branded lens I own, apart from the BC Lux 50 ASPH.
As far as the optics are concerned, I couldn't find fault with the Ultron. I normally photograph subjects at close to mid distance—very rarely beyond about five metres—and found the Ultron to be sharp across the frame from f/2.8 with a pleasing rendering of the urban landscape that I like to photograph.
It's a little smaller than I'd prefer but doesn't quite cross over the border into "too small territory" as I feared it would. If CV had designed it to be large enough to require a 43mm filter (instead of 39mm) the Ultron would be close to perfect because that would allow the front element to be bigger which would in turn reduce the vignetting.
"Honestly, it was a surprise to me that the Ultron II was sharper across the frame than my Summicron-M Asph II (both wide open). In terms of bokeh, they both have their strengths and weaknesses; the Ultron smoother in the central area, the Summicron in the sides and corners at medium focus distance. My biggest complaint about the Ultron II is that its vignetting is so strong that I consider it roughly a f/2.4 lens with a small hot spot in the center." https://d1u92k3d1w68j5.cloudfront.net/lens-tests/ultron-28mm-f2-v2/jd-20211106-151337-8493-m246a-copy01-w1200bc.jpg
After using the Ultron II for a while I'm now inclined to regard it as an f/2.8 lens with a hot spot in the center but the lens is so pleasing in every other way that this doesn't trouble me. And on the few occasions when I have used it wide open, the vignetting hasn't ruined the pictures as I thought it might.
For any M user who wants a 28/2 but can’t afford or isn't willing to pay for a Summicron 28 ASPH, I would recommend the Ultron 28 II without hesitation. I, on the other hand, am willing to pay for a (used) Summicron 28 ASPH so I've asked the dealer from whom I buy secondhand Leica equipment to keep an eye out for a Cron 28 v1, which he believes will be easier to find than the more recent v2. The plan then is for me to use the v1 until he finds a copy of the rarer v2 and, if I like that better, to replace the v1 with a v2. But there's no way I'll sell the Ultron 28/2 II.
“The Summicron 28 straddles the transition between two eras of Leica rendering – the more precise, almost clinical look ushered in by current head of the optical department at Leica; Peter Karbe, and the more organic rendering that was the signature of his predecessor – Dr Walter Mandler. The excellent micro-contrast and resolution combined with the vignetting, nice bokeh and highly saturated colors combine to offer the most pleasingly balanced rendering I’ve seen. Sharp without being clinical, lively without being messy.”
and:
"The Summicron 28 is hands down the best lens I’ve used. Technically it’s as close to perfect as can ever be expected. Perfection tends to be boring, but somehow the Summicron 28 still manages a beautiful rendering – sharp, lively, brilliant. While there are cheaper options available the low deprecation of Leica lenses mean that the actual cost of having and shooting the lens for a few years is close to nothing. Considering that I’ve made a significant fraction of my favourite shots using it, I couldn’t be happier about how it has and continues to serve me."
Since I'm no admirer of Peter Karbe's "precise, almost clinical look", most of my Leica lenses are either Mandler designs or they straddle the transition between the two eras of rendering Vogelius describes. (I regard the Lux 50 ASPH as falling into this zone.) I'd be interested to learn from members who've had both versions of the Cron 28 ASPH whether Karbe has managed to eliminate the magic that Vogelius so admires.
When I wrote that I consider the 28mm Ultron II as an f/2.4 lens (with a hot spot in the center), it is because stopping down from f/2 to f/2.4 doesn't change the exposure in the corners. Stopping down to f/2.8 does, so to me, this suggests that it's faster than f/2.8. Regarding vignetting, it's worth noting that while the Ultron II vignettes more than the Summicron-M Asph II in the f/2 - f/2.8 range, it vignettes LESS than the 'cron from f/4 and onwards.
LarsHP wrote:
When I wrote that I consider the 28mm Ultron II as an f/2.4 lens (with a hot spot in the center), it is because stopping down from f/2 to f/2.4 doesn't change the exposure in the corners. Stopping down to f/2.8 does, so to me, this suggests that it's faster than f/2.8. Regarding vignetting, it's worth noting that while the Ultron II vignettes more than the Summicron-M Asph II in the f/2 - f/2.8 range, it vignettes LESS than the 'cron from f/4 and onwards.
I have now sold my Summicron-M Asph II.
Thank you for the clarification! The vignetting behaviour you describe—the Ultron vignetting less than the Cron from f/4 and onwards—is something I’d never have expected.
Jonathon, what 28mm lenses are you working with now? I noticed in the Leica images thread you have images labeled 28 Cron v1, Elmarit v4 and the new Ultron.
If you're currently using all three, do you have any thoughts/observations to share?
Ron, in addition to the three you mention, I have the Biogon ZM 28/2.8 and the 7Artisans 28/1.4.
I’ve retrieved from storage the boxes for the Elmarit v4 and the Biogon ZM and both will be sold. IIRC the ZM 28 has always been regarded as the weakest in the ZM family and it really does need to be stopped right down to perform acceptably. The Elmarit v4 is better than the ZM but not by much and is easily surpassed by the Summicron ASPH v1. Obviously the later Elmarit 28 ASPH lens would be way superior to my v4.
I should say that, for Leica M lenses, I like to have at least two variants of each of the focal lengths from 28mm to 90mm: one modern and one vintage. (I’ve given up entirely on adapting lenses for my Sony A7R4, all my Leica R lenses are gone and the Classic ZEs are up for sale.) The Elmarit v4 was meant to occupy the 28mm vintage slot.
The Ultron 28/2 v2 is noticeably superior to the Cron 28 v1 in that—at the 3 metre distance at which I commonly photograph—it takes f/5.6 for the Cron’s edges to match the Ultron’s wide open. I was neither surprised nor disappointed by this because it has already been mentioned earlier in the thread that the Cron 28 v2 is significantly improved in this regard. When I purchased a used Cron 28 v1, it was with the understanding that it would be a stopgap until the dealer found a used v2 lens for me. But perhaps the Cron v1 can now occupy that vintage slot and I can forget about getting the v2, choosing instead to play to the v1’s strengths, using it close up and near wide open and not worrying about the edges/corners. To sum up, if one is in the market for an inexpensive, technically superb 28mm M-mount lens then the Ultron v2 is the logical choice. But I much prefer the Cron v1’s haptics and gentler rendering. In other words, I admire and respect the Ultron but I love the Cron. I’ll continue to use both, pairing the Ultron 28 v2 with a Planar ZM 50 and the Cron 28 v1 with a Summicron 50 v5.
Which leaves the 7Artisans 28/1.4. I was saying earlier to a friend today that if I was restricted to a single M-mount lens, it would be my BC Lux 50 ASPH which I can use wide open, at 2.8, or at 5.6, at close range or medium distance and always get results that I find pleasing. (I know you regard the Lux 50’s midzone dip as a flaw but that has never impacted negatively on any pictures I’ve made with it.) If I could be sure that the Lux 28 ASPH would be a well behaved companion to the Lux 50 ASPH I might consider paying the still very high price for a used copy. I’ll wait until my dealer can find one for me to try before I buy. In the meantime, the 7A 28/1.4 does an excellent job given its absurdly low price: decently sharp wide open, great build quality, and in terms of overall IQ #3 after the Ultron v2 and the Cron v1.
Thanks! I'm curious, for a vintage 28, would one of the older 28 Elmarits be suitable? At least in respect to having much different technical performance compared to the ASPH lenses. I have not tried any, but have been curious about them.
I'm very tempted to get the new VM28 for the technical performance reasons you mentioned. I would probably use it as my primary 28 for most situations, which often are stopped down urban and natural landscapes where bokeh character is often not a consideration. It sounds like it could be a good match.
I currently use the 28 Lux as an all-purpose lens, given it's my only 28. It's fast yet quite good stopped down - at least close enough to my 28 Cron v1 experience. My typical carry kit philosophy is also to mix faster and slower lenses at various focal lengths so that I have speed if I need it without having to decide ahead of going out whether or not I might need one over the other. Currently it's 21/3.4 (which I can use adequately in low light if I can brace the camera), 28 Lux, LLL 35/2 replica, 50 Lux ASPH and 90/4 Macro. Sometimes I'll swap the macro for the 90AA if it's likely I'll want it for shallow depth of field work.
I used the 28 Lux a lot for people and event type work, but there hasn't been much of that the past couple years. It leaves me wondering a bit, if I get the Ultron, whether I will use the Lux much? Or if it will be worth holding onto it? As many can probably appreciate, I have some reluctance to sell Leica lenses, given the cost of re-entry if I would like to acquire one again.
Regarding the 28 Lux and 50 Lux ASPH pairing: IMO they're a pretty good match. Colour quality is very similar in that nothing obvious, such as WB tint differences, jump out at me (which was the case with the 28 Cron v1). In use I consider the 28 more reliable for off-centre subject placement. This is my complaint about the 50 Lux ASPH's mid-zone weakness; I have difficulty getting results I like with the subject placed in the rule of thirds zones and aperture in the f/2.8-4 range. I generally avoid such compositions with the 50 unless I can stop down enough, but not the 28. So in terms of focus and field curvature, the 28 seems better behaved, more predictable. IMO its weakness is colour fringing. Even the corner areas will show purple fringing well stopped down. But in typical use, I don't often notice it. Wide open purple fringing is quite noticeable in high contrast transition areas. Given that Karbe stated the 50 Lux ASPH is APO, it's not surprising it performs better in this regard and is also a reason I prefer it over many of the fast, less expensive VM options.
As I may have mentioned before, I had a bad experience with two copies of the 28 Cron v2. Both were very early production and exhibited strong field curvature when stopped down, to the point where the image periphery was worse than the v1 and destroyed by the VM 35/1.7. Current user reports are much more promising. I'd just caution you to thoroughly test any v2 your dealer finds because it's uncertain to me how much copy variation exists with this lens, particularly if it's from earlier in the production period.
rscheffler wrote:
Thanks! I'm curious, for a vintage 28, would one of the older 28 Elmarits be suitable? At least in respect to having much different technical performance compared to the ASPH lenses. I have not tried any, but have been curious about them.
Well, I decided that the Pre-ASPH v4 wasn’t suitable so that would leave the Elmarit ASPH v1 but I’d rather have the Cron ASPH v1. Here is a 2018 shootout between five 28mm Leica M lenses: the Lux, two versions of the Cron ASPH, and two versions of the Elmarit ASPH.
His conclusion:
“Overall the five lenses are remarkably similar, and the only significant difference is speed and resolving detail at high resolution. So, if you don't need speed, you don't need the Summilux. And if you don't need to resolve details at high resolution, you can do without the current version updates.”
If money was no object, I’d get the Lux and the Elmarit ASPH v2. But realistically the Cron is the best choice for me unless a reasonably priced Lux turns up. Then I might replace the Cron with an Elmarit.
I'm very tempted to get the new VM28 for the technical performance reasons you mentioned. I would probably use it as my primary 28 for most situations, which often are stopped down urban and natural landscapes where bokeh character is often not a consideration. It sounds like it could be a good match.
I’m pretty sure that you would wind up using the Ultron 28 v2 most of the time—my use case for it is urban/social landscapes where, stopped down to about f/8, it’s perfect for zone focusing.
I currently use the 28 Lux as an all-purpose lens, given it's my only 28. It's fast yet quite good stopped down - at least close enough to my 28 Cron v1 experience. My typical carry kit philosophy is also to mix faster and slower lenses at various focal lengths so that I have speed if I need it without having to decide ahead of going out whether or not I might need one over the other. Currently it's 21/3.4 (which I can use adequately in low light if I can brace the camera), 28 Lux, LLL 35/2 replica, 50 Lux ASPH and 90/4 Macro. Sometimes I'll swap the macro for the 90AA if it's likely I'll want it for shallow depth of field work. ...Show more →
I like to work with two bodies with either 28 & 50 or 35 & 75 lenses of the same speed attached, for example 28 & 50 Summicrons or APO-Lanthar 35/2 & APO-Summicron 75. If I need/want to travel light, I’ll just take the Lux 50 ASPH.
I used the 28 Lux a lot for people and event type work, but there hasn't been much of that the past couple years. It leaves me wondering a bit, if I get the Ultron, whether I will use the Lux much? Or if it will be worth holding onto it? As many can probably appreciate, I have some reluctance to sell Leica lenses, given the cost of re-entry if I would like to acquire one again.
As I suggested above my guess is that you’ll wind up using the 28 Ultron 80% of the time but, that said, you’d still be crazy to sell the 28 Lux for the reason you give.
Regarding the 28 Lux and 50 Lux ASPH pairing: IMO they're a pretty good match. Colour quality is very similar in that nothing obvious, such as WB tint differences, jump out at me (which was the case with the 28 Cron v1). In use I consider the 28 more reliable for off-centre subject placement. This is my complaint about the 50 Lux ASPH's mid-zone weakness; I have difficulty getting results I like with the subject placed in the rule of thirds zones and aperture in the f/2.8-4 range. I generally avoid such compositions with the 50 unless I can stop down enough, but not the 28. So in terms of focus and field curvature, the 28 seems better behaved, more predictable. IMO its weakness is colour fringing. Even the corner areas will show purple fringing well stopped down. But in typical use, I don't often notice it. Wide open purple fringing is quite noticeable in high contrast transition areas. Given that Karbe stated the 50 Lux ASPH is APO, it's not surprising it performs better in this regard and is also a reason I prefer it over many of the fast, less expensive VM options. ...Show more →
It’s the purple fringing that mainly puts me off the 28 Lux. This might be unreasonable given its positive qualities but it does seem inexcusable given the price. I could never justify buying one new.
As I may have mentioned before, I had a bad experience with two copies of the 28 Cron v2. Both were very early production and exhibited strong field curvature when stopped down, to the point where the image periphery was worse than the v1 and destroyed by the VM 35/1.7. Current user reports are much more promising. I'd just caution you to thoroughly test any v2 your dealer finds because it's uncertain to me how much copy variation exists with this lens, particularly if it's from earlier in the production period.
I will thoroughly test any v2 Cron ASPH that my dealer finds. I’m in the fortunate situation of being able to “borrow” a lens for a week or two to see whether or not it suits my needs.
Thanks again. Based on all this I agree one of the Cron versions is probably ideal for you based on a balance of design, haptics, technical image quality and character.
I really liked my Cron v1 a lot. The only reason I looked to the v2 was for the supposedly flatter plane of focus wider than f/5.6 and landed with the Lux because I convinced myself I needed the extra speed for event work (too often I was at or below 1/60 indoor and getting camera shake or subject motion blur). Given the better high ISO performance since the M10, the Cron is IMO the 28mm Goldilocks.
Definitely try 28cron V2. I am not closely following any 28mm threads ( so don’t know how it compare to modern VC glasses) because I am totally satisfied with V2. It is sharp enough for any use I can think of and perform great on SL too.
I don’t use it a lot but only because I don’t use M a lot if I am not traveling to cities. And usually use 50 and 35 a lot more if I am not traveling.
But cronII is a highly recommended lens.
genji wrote: rscheffler wroteThanks! I'm curious, for a vintage 28, would one of the older 28 Elmarits be suitable? At least in respect to having much different technical performance compared to the ASPH lenses. I have not tried any, but have been curious about them.Well, I decided that the Pre-ASPH v4 wasn’t suitable so that would leave the Elmarit ASPH v1 but I’d rather have the Cron ASPH v1. Here is a 2018 shootout between five 28mm Leica M lenses: the Lux, two versions of the Cron ASPH, and two versions of the Elmarit ASPH.
His conclusion:
“Overall the five lenses are remarkably similar, and the only significant difference is speed and resolving detail at high resolution. So, if you don't need speed, you don't need the Summilux. And if you don't need to resolve details at high resolution, you can do without the current version updates.”
If money was no object, I’d get the Lux and the Elmarit ASPH v2. But realistically the Cron is the best choice for me unless a reasonably priced Lux turns up. Then I might replace the Cron with an Elmarit.
I’m pretty sure that you would wind up using the Ultron 28 v2 most of the time—my use case for it is urban/social landscapes where, stopped down to about f/8, it’s perfect for zone focusing.
I like to work with two bodies with either 28 & 50 or 35 & 75 lenses of the same speed attached, for example 28 & 50 Summicrons or APO-Lanthar 35/2 & APO-Summicron 75. If I need/want to travel light, I’ll just take the Lux 50 ASPH.
As I suggested above my guess is that you’ll wind up using the 28 Ultron 80% of the time but, that said, you’d still be crazy to sell the 28 Lux for the reason you give.
It’s the purple fringing that mainly puts me off the 28 Lux. This might be unreasonable given its positive qualities but it does seem inexcusable given the price. I could never justify buying one new.
I will thoroughly test any v2 Cron ASPH that my dealer finds. I’m in the fortunate situation of being able to “borrow” a lens for a week or two to see whether or not it suits my needs....Show more →Earlier quoteI'm very tempted to get the new VM28 for the technical performance reasons you mentioned. I would probably use it as my primary 28 for most situations, which often are stopped down urban and natural landscapes where bokeh character is often not a consideration. It sounds like it could be a good match.Earlier quoteI currently use the 28 Lux as an all-purpose lens, given it's my only 28. It's fast yet quite good stopped down - at least close enough to my 28 Cron v1 experience. My typical carry kit philosophy is also to mix faster and slower lenses at various focal lengths so that I have speed if I need it without having to decide ahead of going out whether or not I might need one over the other. Currently it's 21/3.4 (which I can use adequately in low light if I can brace the camera), 28 Lux, LLL 35/2 replica, 50 Lux ASPH and 90/4 Macro. Sometimes I'll swap the macro for the 90AA if it's likely I'll want it for shallow depth of field work.Earlier quoteI used the 28 Lux a lot for people and event type work, but there hasn't been much of that the past couple years. It leaves me wondering a bit, if I get the Ultron, whether I will use the Lux much? Or if it will be worth holding onto it? As many can probably appreciate, I have some reluctance to sell Leica lenses, given the cost of re-entry if I would like to acquire one again.Earlier quoteRegarding the 28 Lux and 50 Lux ASPH pairing: IMO they're a pretty good match. Colour quality is very similar in that nothing obvious, such as WB tint differences, jump out at me (which was the case with the 28 Cron v1). In use I consider the 28 more reliable for off-centre subject placement. This is my complaint about the 50 Lux ASPH's mid-zone weakness; I have difficulty getting results I like with the subject placed in the rule of thirds zones and aperture in the f/2.8-4 range. I generally avoid such compositions with the 50 unless I can stop down enough, but not the 28. So in terms of focus and field curvature, the 28 seems better behaved, more predictable. IMO its weakness is colour fringing. Even the corner areas will show purple fringing well stopped down. But in typical use, I don't often notice it. Wide open purple fringing is quite noticeable in high contrast transition areas. Given that Karbe stated the 50 Lux ASPH is APO, it's not surprising it performs better in this regard and is also a reason I prefer it over many of the fast, less expensive VM options.Earlier quoteAs I may have mentioned before, I had a bad experience with two copies of the 28 Cron v2. Both were very early production and exhibited strong field curvature when stopped down, to the point where the image periphery was worse than the v1 and destroyed by the VM 35/1.7. Current user reports are much more promising. I'd just caution you to thoroughly test any v2 your dealer finds because it's uncertain to me how much copy variation exists with this lens, particularly if it's from earlier in the production period.
rscheffler wrote:
Thanks! I'm curious, for a vintage 28, would one of the older 28 Elmarits be suitable? At least in respect to having much different technical performance compared to the ASPH lenses. I have not tried any, but have been curious about them.
I'm very tempted to get the new VM28 for the technical performance reasons you mentioned. I would probably use it as my primary 28 for most situations, which often are stopped down urban and natural landscapes where bokeh character is often not a consideration. It sounds like it could be a good match.
I currently use the 28 Lux as an all-purpose lens, given it's my only 28. It's fast yet quite good stopped down - at least close enough to my 28 Cron v1 experience. My typical carry kit philosophy is also to mix faster and slower lenses at various focal lengths so that I have speed if I need it without having to decide ahead of going out whether or not I might need one over the other. Currently it's 21/3.4 (which I can use adequately in low light if I can brace the camera), 28 Lux, LLL 35/2 replica, 50 Lux ASPH and 90/4 Macro. Sometimes I'll swap the macro for the 90AA if it's likely I'll want it for shallow depth of field work.
I used the 28 Lux a lot for people and event type work, but there hasn't been much of that the past couple years. It leaves me wondering a bit, if I get the Ultron, whether I will use the Lux much? Or if it will be worth holding onto it? As many can probably appreciate, I have some reluctance to sell Leica lenses, given the cost of re-entry if I would like to acquire one again.
Regarding the 28 Lux and 50 Lux ASPH pairing: IMO they're a pretty good match. Colour quality is very similar in that nothing obvious, such as WB tint differences, jump out at me (which was the case with the 28 Cron v1). In use I consider the 28 more reliable for off-centre subject placement. This is my complaint about the 50 Lux ASPH's mid-zone weakness; I have difficulty getting results I like with the subject placed in the rule of thirds zones and aperture in the f/2.8-4 range. I generally avoid such compositions with the 50 unless I can stop down enough, but not the 28. So in terms of focus and field curvature, the 28 seems better behaved, more predictable. IMO its weakness is colour fringing. Even the corner areas will show purple fringing well stopped down. But in typical use, I don't often notice it. Wide open purple fringing is quite noticeable in high contrast transition areas. Given that Karbe stated the 50 Lux ASPH is APO, it's not surprising it performs better in this regard and is also a reason I prefer it over many of the fast, less expensive VM options.
As I may have mentioned before, I had a bad experience with two copies of the 28 Cron v2. Both were very early production and exhibited strong field curvature when stopped down, to the point where the image periphery was worse than the v1 and destroyed by the VM 35/1.7. Current user reports are much more promising. I'd just caution you to thoroughly test any v2 your dealer finds because it's uncertain to me how much copy variation exists with this lens, particularly if it's from earlier in the production period....Show more →
I just purchased the 28/1.4 Lux and will compare it to the Voigtlander 28/2 II.
Thanks. All the images are in the same Google docs folder which I linked to in the first of the two posts below.
rscheffler wrote: Fred Miranda wroteAre there side by side rendering comparisons between the 28/2 cron (version I or II) vs the Voigtlander 28/2 Ultron II?Nothing super comprehensive that I have seen, but LarsHP had some:
genji wrote: Fred Miranda wroteAre there side by side rendering comparisons between the 28/2 cron (version I or II) vs the Voigtlander 28/2 Ultron II?---------------------------------------------
rscheffler wroteMaybe Jonathon could indulge us? Sure, as long as it won’t require a huge amount of time.
What kinds of subjects/subject distances/apertures would be useful?
Thanks Jonathon!
I just checked @LarsHP's comparison and saw the difference. It's very small but I see higher contrast for the Voigtlander and slightly smoother rendering in the OOF corners for the Leica.
If you can do a comparison with the subject a mid-distance and some foliage in the background, we may see this more clearly.
My analysis of the bokeh difference is that the Ultron II is smoother in the central era and also in the outer at short focus distance with background a few meter or longer away. The Summicron-M Asph II has less nervous bokeh in the sides and corners at medium to long focus distances though. If I was primarily using the 28mm f/2 lens for group portraits, particularly outside, then I might have preferred the Leica over the Voigtländer. The Leica also has less vignetting wide open. Otherwise, at least in my experience, the Ultron II is the overall better lens both in terms of sharpness and bokeh rendering.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Thanks Jonathon!
I just checked @LarsHP@'s comparison and saw the difference. It's very small but I see higher contrast for the Voigtlander and slightly smoother rendering in the OOF corners for the Leica.
If you can do a comparison with the subject a mid-distance and some foliage in the background, we may see this more clearly.
LarsHP wrote:
My analysis of the bokeh difference is that the Ultron II is smoother in the central era and also in the outer at short focus distance with background a few meter or longer away. The Summicron-M Asph II has less nervous bokeh in the sides and corners at medium to long focus distances though. If I was primarily using the 28mm f/2 lens for group portraits, particularly outside, then I might have preferred the Leica over the Voigtländer. The Leica also has less vignetting wide open. Otherwise, at least in my experience, the Ultron II is the overall better lens both in terms of sharpness and bokeh rendering.
I just checked @LarsHP@@'s comparison and saw the difference. It's very small but I see higher contrast for the Voigtlander and slightly smoother rendering in the OOF corners for the Leica.
If you can do a comparison with the subject a mid-distance and some foliage in the background, we may see this more clearly.
I will test rendering with the 28 Lux @f/2.
I think the off-axis nervousness you refer to is just more DOF towards the corners due to higher optical vignetting. If it's more pleasant around the center area, that means the transition zone is actually smoother compared to the Leica.
I don't know this for sure because I've never tried the 28/2 cron.