p.6 #1Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
ReleaseDrive wrote:
I can't recall where I read it, probably somewhere buried on this website. That the M mount Voigtlander lenses sell far more than E mount versions. Which, I mean...makes sense to me. The ability to adapt to any camera is pretty appealing. Only native I've owned is 65mm but the rest have all been M mount.
I saw that comment too, it was from one forum member from Singapore. I don't think that was correct sales info though at least for Japan market where CV still has majority of their sales. In the sales rankings data in Japan that I frequently keep an eye on the E-mount APO-Lanthars have been consistently ranking higher than their VM counterparts and several other CV E-mount lenses were also bestsellers for a long time. In the last 2 years the E-mount are not dominating the CV lens rankings anymore like they used to but the E-mount APO-Lanthars are still holding strong.
Today's top 10 sales rankings from kakaku.com for Cosina Voigtländer lenses:
1) 35/1.2 for X-mount
2) 40/1.4 Nokton classic S.C. VM
3) 50/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
4) 50/1.5 Heliar classic VM
5) 35/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
6) 40/1.4 Nokton classic M.C. VM
7) 40/2 SL II for Nikon F
8) 28/2.8 SL II for Nikon F
9) 28/2 II VM
10) 65/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
VM version of 50/2 APO-Lanthar is at #37 and VM 35/2 APO-Lanthar is at #49 on the same rankings so they are not selling quite as well as the E-mount versions... They have been consistently ranking lower.
The optical design shown for both lenses on their pages is identical so it seems like they should be pretty much the same thing...
But the aperture blades are different. 10 blades for VM and 9 for F-mount, and only VM seems to have the "special shape that makes them circular not only in the open F2.8 but also in F4 and F22".
Maybe the F-mount version still has circular aperture blade design, as I think many of the CV SLR lenses didn't have straight blades and sunstars like most of CV M-mount and E-mount lenses. I used to own CV 40/2 (1st generation) in Minolta SLR mount and it had circular blades and it was not possible to get any decent sunstars.
The Nikon F mount version has attractive pricing and I like the small dome hood (not included in the box, sold separately). I have no Nikon mount adapter anymore so not really considering it though.
But the aperture blades are different. 10 blades for VM and 9 for F-mount, and only VM seems to have the "special shape that makes them circular not only in the open F2.8 but also in F4 and F22".
Maybe the F-mount version still has circular aperture blade design, as I think many of the CV SLR lenses didn't have straight blades and sunstars like most of CV M-mount and E-mount lenses. I used to own CV 40/2 (1st generation) in Minolta SLR mount and it had circular blades and it was not possible to get any decent sunstars.
The Nikon F mount version has attractive pricing and I like the small dome hood (not included in the box, sold separately). I have no Nikon mount adapter anymore so not really considering it though....Show more →
Hm wow seems I was wrong about the lens layout not fitting F mount.
F mount vs M mount for me:
+ compatible with all my cameras including 3 Nikon SLRs
+ electronic communication if used with FTZ
+ 52mm filters
+ price
- longer / slightly awkward adapter
- slightly heavier (with adapter)
- probably worse sunstars
p.6 #4Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Assuming the performance is as I expect, the Nikon's the one for me. I can live with the nine blades. Plus it will fit in with the rest of my Nikon lenses, will be usable on my F100, and I'll get EXIF on my rII, though it should just be three-axis IBIS. I don't think these AI-S lenses with the ROM chip report distance. I like the larger filter in a standard Nikon size, too. It'll make me more comfortable using a UV/IR cut filter and color filters without worrying about mechanical vignetting. The hood... we'll see. I'll have to use it before I believe it actually works.
Now I just need Fred or someone from the phillipreeve team to get one and confirm or refute my suspicions about the performance.
p.6 #6Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Juha Kannisto wrote: ReleaseDrive wroteI can't recall where I read it, probably somewhere buried on this website. That the M mount Voigtlander lenses sell far more than E mount versions. Which, I mean...makes sense to me. The ability to adapt to any camera is pretty appealing. Only native I've owned is 65mm but the rest have all been M mount.I saw that comment too, it was from one forum member from Singapore. I don't think that was correct sales info though at least for Japan market where CV still has majority of their sales. In the sales rankings data in Japan that I frequently keep an eye on the E-mount APO-Lanthars have been consistently ranking higher than their VM counterparts and several other CV E-mount lenses were also bestsellers for a long time. In the last 2 years the E-mount are not dominating the CV lens rankings anymore like they used to but the E-mount APO-Lanthars are still holding strong.
Today's top 10 sales rankings from kakaku.com for Cosina Voigtländer lenses:
1) 35/1.2 for X-mount
2) 40/1.4 Nokton classic S.C. VM
3) 50/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
4) 50/1.5 Heliar classic VM
5) 35/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
6) 40/1.4 Nokton classic M.C. VM
7) 40/2 SL II for Nikon F
8) 28/2.8 SL II for Nikon F
9) 28/2 II VM
10) 65/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
VM version of 50/2 APO-Lanthar is at #37 and VM 35/2 APO-Lanthar is at #49 on the same rankings so they are not selling quite as well as the E-mount versions... They have been consistently ranking lower....Show more →
The new 50/1.5 Heliar Classic VM is the biggest surprise here for me. I didn't get much love here in the US, at least not at FM.
p.6 #7Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Fred Miranda wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteReleaseDrive wroteI can't recall where I read it, probably somewhere buried on this website. That the M mount Voigtlander lenses sell far more than E mount versions. Which, I mean...makes sense to me. The ability to adapt to any camera is pretty appealing. Only native I've owned is 65mm but the rest have all been M mount.I saw that comment too, it was from one forum member from Singapore. I don't think that was correct sales info though at least for Japan market where CV still has majority of their sales. In the sales rankings data in Japan that I frequently keep an eye on the E-mount APO-Lanthars have been consistently ranking higher than their VM counterparts and several other CV E-mount lenses were also bestsellers for a long time. In the last 2 years the E-mount are not dominating the CV lens rankings anymore like they used to but the E-mount APO-Lanthars are still holding strong.
Today's top 10 sales rankings from kakaku.com for Cosina Voigtländer lenses:
1) 35/1.2 for X-mount
2) 40/1.4 Nokton classic S.C. VM
3) 50/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
4) 50/1.5 Heliar classic VM
5) 35/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
6) 40/1.4 Nokton classic M.C. VM
7) 40/2 SL II for Nikon F
8) 28/2.8 SL II for Nikon F
9) 28/2 II VM
10) 65/2 APO-Lanthar for E-mount
VM version of 50/2 APO-Lanthar is at #37 and VM 35/2 APO-Lanthar is at #49 on the same rankings so they are not selling quite as well as the E-mount versions... They have been consistently ranking lower.The new 50/1.5 Heliar Classic VM is the biggest surprise here for me. I didn't get much love here in the US, at least not at FM.
It was #1 in Japan for some time but the stocks seemed quite limited and it's been sold out in most places since launch day, even now. It seems to be relatively popular in Japan. I've been shooting with mine again this week
p.6 #8Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
What a beautiful looking lens. It reminds me of my 1960s short Tele-Elmarit that gave me such joy in the 1980s. All these excellent 3rd party M-mount lenses makes me want to get a digital M myself. Leica must be sweating at all these great Leica lens ripoffs from VC, TT artisans etc.
p.6 #9Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
In two sections of the lens description, Voigtlander mentions low vignetting for the CV 90/2.8 APO. Usually that translates to better controlled optical vignetting as well. (cats-eye bokeh toward the corners)
From translation:
"We have secured a generous image circle that supports full-frame 35mm format."
"It has excellent portability and vignetting of the shooting frame when using the optical rangefinder is suppressed."
p.6 #10Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Fred Miranda wrote:
In two sections of the lens description, Voigtlander mentions the CV 90/2.8 APO has low vignetting. Usually that translates to better controlled optical vignetting as well. (cats-eye bokeh toward the corners)
"A generous image circle" sounds promising, but suppression of vignetting when using the optical rangefinder sounds more like a comment on viewfinder blockage on a Leica M camera than on suppression of the sort of vignetting that would affect the image.
p.6 #11Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
This lens is indeed pretty. It remind me 50mm summilux pre ASPH e43.
Fred, the coverage is nice to know. This is one of few times lens description mention this as a feature which I begin to care more and more with modern introductions. Not only for rendering but potential coverage for bigger format
I might go with M version if I get this though I can predict I won’t use it much on M due to long focal length. M version offers the focus direction I prefer and will fit most MILC out there.
p.6 #12Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
zugzwang2 wrote: Fred Miranda wroteIn two sections of the lens description, Voigtlander mentions the CV 90/2.8 APO has low vignetting. Usually that translates to better controlled optical vignetting as well. (cats-eye bokeh toward the corners)"A generous image circle" sounds promising, but suppression of vignetting when using the optical rangefinder sounds more like a comment on viewfinder blockage on a Leica M camera than on suppression of the sort of vignetting that would affect the image.
p.6 #13Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
zugzwang2 wrote:
"A generous image circle" sounds promising, but suppression of vignetting when using the optical rangefinder sounds more like a comment on viewfinder blockage on a Leica M camera than on suppression of the sort of vignetting that would affect the image.
Ah, that makes a lot of sense. I was trying to figure out why they kept mentioning the optical rangefinder. It seemed unnecessary to specify that. I wonder why they used the word "vignetting" for that though, as opposed to blockage or something, when vignetting is more so a lens property (which they know)?
p.6 #14Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
astrobuoy wrote: zugzwang2 wrote"A generous image circle" sounds promising, but suppression of vignetting when using the optical rangefinder sounds more like a comment on viewfinder blockage on a Leica M camera than on suppression of the sort of vignetting that would affect the image.Ah, that makes a lot of sense. I was trying to figure out why they kept mentioning the optical rangefinder. It seemed unnecessary to specify that. I wonder why they used the word "vignetting" for that though, as opposed to blockage or something, when vignetting is more so a lens property (which they know)?
The simple answer is that they didn't use the word 'vignetting' because that's an English word and the description is Japanese. I don't speak the language, but my regular job is in minority language documentation & description. It's possible that there two words that can both be translated as 'vignetting' and the machine (I presume) translation made the error of using the one English word for both. Or there's one Japanese word that has two distinct senses with and those two senses got lost in its translation into 'vignetting'.
p.6 #15Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
MAubrey wrote:
The simple answer is that they didn't use the word 'vignetting' because that's an English word and the description is Japanese. I don't speak the language, but my regular job is in minority language documentation & description. It's possible that there two words that can both be translated as 'vignetting' and the machine (I presume) translation made the error of using the one English word for both. Or there's one Japanese word that has two distinct senses with and those two senses got lost in its translation into 'vignetting'.
That makes sense. I figured it was either translation error or else a disconnect between the lens designers and the marketing department. It's just unfortunate I suppose since it carries the suggestion that vignetting has been suppressed, though that may not be the case. We'll have to see!
But the aperture blades are different. 10 blades for VM and 9 for F-mount, and only VM seems to have the "special shape that makes them circular not only in the open F2.8 but also in F4 and F22".
Maybe the F-mount version still has circular aperture blade design, as I think many of the CV SLR lenses didn't have straight blades and sunstars like most of CV M-mount and E-mount lenses. I used to own CV 40/2 (1st generation) in Minolta SLR mount and it had circular blades and it was not possible to get any decent sunstars.
The Nikon F mount version has attractive pricing and I like the small dome hood (not included in the box, sold separately). I have no Nikon mount adapter anymore so not really considering it though....Show more →
I don't recall Sigma doing aperture blades by lens mount. Any idea why certain lens manufacturers would vary the aperture blade design by mount? That seems to fundamentally change the lens.
p.6 #17Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
MAubrey wrote: astrobuoy wrotezugzwang2 wrote"A generous image circle" sounds promising, but suppression of vignetting when using the optical rangefinder sounds more like a comment on viewfinder blockage on a Leica M camera than on suppression of the sort of vignetting that would affect the image.Ah, that makes a lot of sense. I was trying to figure out why they kept mentioning the optical rangefinder. It seemed unnecessary to specify that. I wonder why they used the word "vignetting" for that though, as opposed to blockage or something, when vignetting is more so a lens property (which they know)?The simple answer is that they didn't use the word 'vignetting' because that's an English word and the description is Japanese. I don't speak the language, but my regular job is in minority language documentation & description. It's possible that there two words that can both be translated as 'vignetting' and the machine (I presume) translation made the error of using the one English word for both. Or there's one Japanese word that has two distinct senses with and those two senses got lost in its translation into 'vignetting'.
Yes, that got lost in translation. They really meant frameline blockage which makes sense since the lens is 60mm in length.
Hopefully we can see some samples images soon.
But the aperture blades are different. 10 blades for VM and 9 for F-mount, and only VM seems to have the "special shape that makes them circular not only in the open F2.8 but also in F4 and F22".
Maybe the F-mount version still has circular aperture blade design, as I think many of the CV SLR lenses didn't have straight blades and sunstars like most of CV M-mount and E-mount lenses. I used to own CV 40/2 (1st generation) in Minolta SLR mount and it had circular blades and it was not possible to get any decent sunstars.
The Nikon F mount version has attractive pricing and I like the small dome hood (not included in the box, sold separately). I have no Nikon mount adapter anymore so not really considering it though.I don't recall Sigma doing aperture blades by lens mount. Any idea why certain lens manufacturers would vary the aperture blade design by mount? That seems to fundamentally change the lens.
In case of the F-mount, the aperture is spring loaded, in order to stop down and then open quickly for viewing through the optical SLR/DSLR finder. Nine blades is about as much as has been common with F-mount lenses in general.
p.6 #19Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Compared to my 90/2.4 Summarit, a descendent of the 90/2 Pre ASPH Summicron, it'll have better aberration control and is 6mm shorter (the Leica starts to touch the 90mm frame at 1.2m without a hood). Tough call.