The resolution and lack of nearly any aberrations is close to Otus 85 levels, and not at all surprising considering the many Cosina lenses that have inherited the Otus technology over the past few years.
The color palate is modern and quite pleasing, the bokeh smooth and luscious.
The modern Leica M offerings are also of stunning resolution, sharpness and color-correctness, but hüte dich, herr Karbe, Cosina is closing in fast.
p.7 #2Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
I'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.
p.7 #3Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
A few metrics for Sony users.
The VM is 60mm in length plus (est) 35mm hood plus 10mm adapter = 105mm ready to go (field users). The F vsn is 41mm long plus 27mm adapter plus (est) 5mm hood, for an all up of 73mm. Without hoods, it's 70mm (VM) -vs- 68mm (F vsn).
Weight of the VM is 250g plus 36g adapter plus (est) 15g hood = 300 grams. The F vsn is 260g plus hood (est) 5g plus (est) 80g adapter = 345 grams. rough figures but quite close, most likely.
Price we have dealt with. Instead of the VM lens/hood, you can afford a high end adapter inside the F deal. The F scales are easier to read and the adapter provides a finger hold to locate the aperture ring more easily. And safe all-of-frame performance, as with all (D)SLR lenses.
p.7 #4Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Jman13 wrote:
I'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.
Yes, not much can be said about that image, except that it shows good level of detail. We don't know which aperture was used but it was likely wide open just by looking at the cats-eye shape specular highlights...
I'm sure that in November, @Juha Kannisto will take it for a spin around the street of Tokyo and share initial samples with us.
I do intend to write a review on it as well. I have two great copies of the Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN and Leica 90/2 APO lenses to compare it to.
But the aperture blades are different. 10 blades for VM and 9 for F-mount, and only VM seems to have the "special shape that makes them circular not only in the open F2.8 but also in F4 and F22".
Maybe the F-mount version still has circular aperture blade design, as I think many of the CV SLR lenses didn't have straight blades and sunstars like most of CV M-mount and E-mount lenses. I used to own CV 40/2 (1st generation) in Minolta SLR mount and it had circular blades and it was not possible to get any decent sunstars.
The Nikon F mount version has attractive pricing and I like the small dome hood (not included in the box, sold separately). I have no Nikon mount adapter anymore so not really considering it though.I don't recall Sigma doing aperture blades by lens mount. Any idea why certain lens manufacturers would vary the aperture blade design by mount? That seems to fundamentally change the lens.In case of the F-mount, the aperture is spring loaded, in order to stop down and then open quickly for viewing through the optical SLR/DSLR finder. Nine blades is about as much as has been common with F-mount lenses in general.
It's great that people now have the option of a chipped version, but if F mount has issues, I wonder why they didn't release a chipped version in another DSLR mount that wouldn't have necessitated this change in aperture blade design.
But the aperture blades are different. 10 blades for VM and 9 for F-mount, and only VM seems to have the "special shape that makes them circular not only in the open F2.8 but also in F4 and F22".
Maybe the F-mount version still has circular aperture blade design, as I think many of the CV SLR lenses didn't have straight blades and sunstars like most of CV M-mount and E-mount lenses. I used to own CV 40/2 (1st generation) in Minolta SLR mount and it had circular blades and it was not possible to get any decent sunstars.
The Nikon F mount version has attractive pricing and I like the small dome hood (not included in the box, sold separately). I have no Nikon mount adapter anymore so not really considering it though.I don't recall Sigma doing aperture blades by lens mount. Any idea why certain lens manufacturers would vary the aperture blade design by mount? That seems to fundamentally change the lens.In case of the F-mount, the aperture is spring loaded, in order to stop down and then open quickly for viewing through the optical SLR/DSLR finder. Nine blades is about as much as has been common with F-mount lenses in general.It's great that people now have the option of a chipped version, but if F mount has issues, I wonder why they didn't release a chipped version in another DSLR mount that wouldn't have necessitated this change in aperture blade design.
It’s not an issue particular to the F-mount. If you’re going to release a manual focus lens with an aperture ring, then F-mount is hands down the obvious choice for that. It’s the rapid opening and closing of the aperture that imparts the changes to the aperture mechanism as opposed to a rangefinder lens. Nine aperture blades is not bad by any reasonable meassure.
E-mount Voigtländer and Zeiss Loxia lenses all have apertures that stop down the same way as Leica M rangefinder lenses, that is they stop down as you turn the aperture ring.
Among DSLR mounts Nikon F, Canon EF, Pentax K and Sony A, Nikon F is the one which is both common and supports lenses with mechanical aperture rings. Pentax K has a minuscle market share and Canon EF and Sony A don’t support mechanical aperture rings. So Nikon F is the only viable choice Cosina could make, when issuing a DSLR version of the Voigtländer 90/2.8 Apo Skopar, and a great choice despite Nikon’s recent misfortunes. There is no other way Cosina could come up with DSLR lenses with such excellent styling. The front decal on the lens could just as well have said «Nippon Kogaku» and «Nikkor», such is the semblance of 1960ies MF Nikkors.
p.7 #7Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Fred Miranda wrote: Jman13 wroteI'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.Yes, not much can be said about that image, except that it shows good level of detail. We don't know which aperture was used but it was likely wide open just by looking at the cats-eye shape specular highlights...
I'm sure that in November, @Juha Kannisto@ will take it for a spin around the street of Tokyo and share initial samples with us.
I do intend to write a review on it as well. I have two great copies of the Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN and Leica 90/2 APO lenses to compare it to.
p.7 #8Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
bjornthun wrote: teddoman wrotebjornthun wroteteddoman wroteJuha Kannisto wroteJuha Kannisto wroteThe lenses have been announced officially at 3pm today as expected:
But the aperture blades are different. 10 blades for VM and 9 for F-mount, and only VM seems to have the "special shape that makes them circular not only in the open F2.8 but also in F4 and F22".
Maybe the F-mount version still has circular aperture blade design, as I think many of the CV SLR lenses didn't have straight blades and sunstars like most of CV M-mount and E-mount lenses. I used to own CV 40/2 (1st generation) in Minolta SLR mount and it had circular blades and it was not possible to get any decent sunstars.
The Nikon F mount version has attractive pricing and I like the small dome hood (not included in the box, sold separately). I have no Nikon mount adapter anymore so not really considering it though.I don't recall Sigma doing aperture blades by lens mount. Any idea why certain lens manufacturers would vary the aperture blade design by mount? That seems to fundamentally change the lens.In case of the F-mount, the aperture is spring loaded, in order to stop down and then open quickly for viewing through the optical SLR/DSLR finder. Nine blades is about as much as has been common with F-mount lenses in general.It's great that people now have the option of a chipped version, but if F mount has issues, I wonder why they didn't release a chipped version in another DSLR mount that wouldn't have necessitated this change in aperture blade design.It’s not an issue particular to the F-mount. If you’re going to release a manual focus lens with an aperture ring, then F-mount is hands down the obvious choice for that. It’s the rapid opening and closing of the aperture that imparts the changes to the aperture mechanism as opposed to a rangefinder lens. Nine aperture blades is not bad by any reasonable meassure.
E-mount Voigtländer and Zeiss Loxia lenses all have apertures that stop down the same way as Leica M rangefinder lenses, that is they stop down as you turn the aperture ring.
Among DSLR mounts Nikon F, Canon EF, Pentax K and Sony A, Nikon F is the one which is both common and supports lenses with mechanical aperture rings. Pentax K has a minuscle market share and Canon EF and Sony A don’t support mechanical aperture rings. So Nikon F is the only viable choice Cosina could make, when issuing a DSLR version of the Voigtländer 90/2.8 Apo Skopar, and a great choice despite Nikon’s recent misfortunes. There is no other way Cosina could come up with DSLR lenses with such excellent styling. The front decal on the lens could just as well have said «Nippon Kogaku» and «Nikkor», such is the semblance of 1960ies MF Nikkors. ...Show more →
The F is also the one mount that can adapt to almost anything because of the 46.5mm flange distance.
p.7 #9Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteJman13 wroteI'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.Yes, not much can be said about that image, except that it shows good level of detail. We don't know which aperture was used but it was likely wide open just by looking at the cats-eye shape specular highlights...
I'm sure that in November, @Juha Kannisto@@ will take it for a spin around the street of Tokyo and share initial samples with us.
I do intend to write a review on it as well. I have two great copies of the Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN and Leica 90/2 APO lenses to compare it to.How’s the sigma shaping up?
I did a quick test today right after it arrived. It's flat field and sharp from wide open to the very corners. It's not capable of resolving high frequency detail like the Leica 90mm f/2 APO but it's not that far behind.
p.7 #10Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteJman13 wroteI'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.Yes, not much can be said about that image, except that it shows good level of detail. We don't know which aperture was used but it was likely wide open just by looking at the cats-eye shape specular highlights...
I'm sure that in November, @Juha Kannisto@@@ will take it for a spin around the street of Tokyo and share initial samples with us.
I do intend to write a review on it as well. I have two great copies of the Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN and Leica 90/2 APO lenses to compare it to.How’s the sigma shaping up?I did a quick test today right after it arrived. It's flat field and sharp from wide open to the very corners. It's not capable of resolving high frequency detail like the Leica 90mm f/2 APO but it's not that far behind.
So it must have the non discretionary manufacturer profile turned on for distortion. More usual for just LaCA. In a way that’s a good sign….that sharpness across the field is after correction! Promising!
Some Sony lenses for APS have had non-discretionary manufacturer profiles in LR for distortion if I recall….maybe also the 2/28? But I’m not sure…
p.7 #13Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteJman13 wroteI'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.Yes, not much can be said about that image, except that it shows good level of detail. We don't know which aperture was used but it was likely wide open just by looking at the cats-eye shape specular highlights...
I'm sure that in November, @Juha Kannisto@@@@ will take it for a spin around the street of Tokyo and share initial samples with us.
I do intend to write a review on it as well. I have two great copies of the Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN and Leica 90/2 APO lenses to compare it to.How’s the sigma shaping up?I did a quick test today right after it arrived. It's flat field and sharp from wide open to the very corners. It's not capable of resolving high frequency detail like the Leica 90mm f/2 APO but it's not that far behind.
This was surprising to me as I saw zero distortion: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1715801/25#15736675So it must have the non discretionary manufacturer profile turned on for distortion. More usual for just LaCA. In a way that’s a good sign….that sharpness across the field is after correction! Promising!
Some Sony lenses for APS have had non-discretionary manufacturer profiles in LR for distortion if I recall….maybe also the 2/28? But I’m not sure…
This is the first time I see distortion included in a LR built-in profile. With Sony full frame lenses, there is only automated correction for "lateral CA" and that includes the Sony 28mm f/2.
Yes, both 24mm and 90mm DG DN are sharp to the edges and improve slightly stopping down. They are not the sharpest I've seen but perform at very high level. The 23-year-old Leica APO-Summicron-M 90 f/2 ASPH @f/2.8 beats it with only 5 elements. However, when comparing both lenses wide open (f/2 vs f/2.8), they are very similar at infinity.
Also similar stopped down to At f/4-5.6 across the field. The Leica is still a tad better even at f/8 at pixel level but it would be hard to differentiate them in real world images. Great value for a well-built $650 compact lens with AF!
All this with distortion correction already applied for the Sigma.
p.7 #14Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
philip_pj wrote:
A few metrics for Sony users.
The VM is 60mm in length plus (est) 35mm hood plus 10mm adapter = 105mm ready to go (field users). The F vsn is 41mm long plus 27mm adapter plus (est) 5mm hood, for an all up of 73mm. Without hoods, it's 70mm (VM) -vs- 68mm (F vsn).
Weight of the VM is 250g plus 36g adapter plus (est) 15g hood = 300 grams. The F vsn is 260g plus hood (est) 5g plus (est) 80g adapter = 345 grams. rough figures but quite close, most likely.
Price we have dealt with. Instead of the VM lens/hood, you can afford a high end adapter inside the F deal. The F scales are easier to read and the adapter provides a finger hold to locate the aperture ring more easily. And safe all-of-frame performance, as with all (D)SLR lenses....Show more →
Thanks Philip. What do people think is the best EXIF-transferring adapter for Nikon F?
p.7 #15Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteJman13 wroteI'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.Yes, not much can be said about that image, except that it shows good level of detail. We don't know which aperture was used but it was likely wide open just by looking at the cats-eye shape specular highlights...
I'm sure that in November, @Juha Kannisto@@@@@ will take it for a spin around the street of Tokyo and share initial samples with us.
I do intend to write a review on it as well. I have two great copies of the Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN and Leica 90/2 APO lenses to compare it to.How’s the sigma shaping up?I did a quick test today right after it arrived. It's flat field and sharp from wide open to the very corners. It's not capable of resolving high frequency detail like the Leica 90mm f/2 APO but it's not that far behind.
This was surprising to me as I saw zero distortion: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1715801/25#15736675So it must have the non discretionary manufacturer profile turned on for distortion. More usual for just LaCA. In a way that’s a good sign….that sharpness across the field is after correction! Promising!
Some Sony lenses for APS have had non-discretionary manufacturer profiles in LR for distortion if I recall….maybe also the 2/28? But I’m not sure…This is the first time I see distortion included in a LR built-in profile. With Sony full frame lenses, there is only automated correction for "lateral CA" and that includes the Sony 28mm f/2.
Yes, both 24mm and 90mm DG DN are sharp to the edges and improve slightly stopping down. They are not the sharpest I've seen but perform at very high level. The 23-year-old Leica APO-Summicron-M 90 f/2 ASPH @f/2.8 beats it with only 5 elements. However, when comparing both lenses wide open (f/2 vs f/2.8), they are very similar at infinity.
Also similar stopped down to At f/4-5.6 across the field. The Leica is still a tad better even at f/8 at pixel level but it would be hard to differentiate them in real world images. Great value for a well-built $650 compact lens with AF!
All this with distortion correction already applied for the Sigma....Show more →
Ah, sorry, must have misremembered about compulsory distortion correction on the 2/28! It needed it!
p.7 #16Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteYes, not much can be said about that image, except that it shows good level of detail. We don't know which aperture was used but it was likely wide open just by looking at the cats-eye shape specular highlights...
I'm sure that in November, @Juha Kannisto@@@@@@ will take it for a spin around the street of Tokyo and share initial samples with us.
I do intend to write a review on it as well. I have two great copies of the Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN and Leica 90/2 APO lenses to compare it to.How’s the sigma shaping up?I did a quick test today right after it arrived. It's flat field and sharp from wide open to the very corners. It's not capable of resolving high frequency detail like the Leica 90mm f/2 APO but it's not that far behind.
This was surprising to me as I saw zero distortion: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1715801/25#15736675So it must have the non discretionary manufacturer profile turned on for distortion. More usual for just LaCA. In a way that’s a good sign….that sharpness across the field is after correction! Promising!
Some Sony lenses for APS have had non-discretionary manufacturer profiles in LR for distortion if I recall….maybe also the 2/28? But I’m not sure…This is the first time I see distortion included in a LR built-in profile. With Sony full frame lenses, there is only automated correction for "lateral CA" and that includes the Sony 28mm f/2.
Yes, both 24mm and 90mm DG DN are sharp to the edges and improve slightly stopping down. They are not the sharpest I've seen but perform at very high level. The 23-year-old Leica APO-Summicron-M 90 f/2 ASPH @f/2.8 beats it with only 5 elements. However, when comparing both lenses wide open (f/2 vs f/2.8), they are very similar at infinity.
Also similar stopped down to At f/4-5.6 across the field. The Leica is still a tad better even at f/8 at pixel level but it would be hard to differentiate them in real world images. Great value for a well-built $650 compact lens with AF!
All this with distortion correction already applied for the Sigma.Ah, sorry, must have misremembered about compulsory distortion correction on the 2/28! It needed it!
This is OT for this thread but I'm shocked by the level of distortion from the new 24/2 DG DN and 90/2.8 lenses.
However, this could be a blessing in disguise. Read on...
Whenever the correction is "barrel", it requires image cropping and in the case of the Sigma 24/2 and Sony 28/2 lenses, it requires a lot of cropping. The difference between the two is that the Sigma is uber sharp before "distortion correction + crop" and the Sony is not.
So, what Sigma did was to basically design a 22mm FL lens and let distortion go crazy relying on auto-correction in-camera to remove the barrel distortion and match the 24mm FL. However, in the process, a sharp and usable section of the image is set to be cropped to allow for the big barrel correction but some images do not require distortion correction and therefore could benefit from that extra range. It's almost like having a 21mm lens with high distortion and a 24mm lens with no distortion in one. The former is actually sharper at the very corners!
This is all hidden and done behind the scenes for the Leica SL2 and I have not checked the Sony yet. On the Leica, there is no way to turn distortion correction off in-camera or in-post (with LR or CaptureOne). So, to gather this information, I used the "DNG Cleaner" app which strips "cooked" lens correction + crop from DNG files, which in turn, allows me to see the real uncorrected RAW image.
p.7 #17Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Petegh wrote: philip_pj wroteA few metrics for Sony users.
The VM is 60mm in length plus (est) 35mm hood plus 10mm adapter = 105mm ready to go (field users). The F vsn is 41mm long plus 27mm adapter plus (est) 5mm hood, for an all up of 73mm. Without hoods, it's 70mm (VM) -vs- 68mm (F vsn).
Weight of the VM is 250g plus 36g adapter plus (est) 15g hood = 300 grams. The F vsn is 260g plus hood (est) 5g plus (est) 80g adapter = 345 grams. rough figures but quite close, most likely.
Price we have dealt with. Instead of the VM lens/hood, you can afford a high end adapter inside the F deal. The F scales are easier to read and the adapter provides a finger hold to locate the aperture ring more easily. And safe all-of-frame performance, as with all (D)SLR lenses.Thanks Philip. What do people think is the best EXIF-transferring adapter for Nikon F?
I've only used the Commlite v1 and pro (they're heavy at 250g) and the Viltrox (much lighter at 100g) on an rII and rIII. The Viltrox didn't work with anything but AF-S lenses, and even there, it's hit and miss. It wouldn't recognize my AF-D or AI-S with ROM chip lenses and froze the camera up after start-up with one them attached. So I've stuck with the Commlite pro, though it's not without its problems. It doesn't play well with non-chipped lenses, it doesn't like it when you control the aperture via the ring on the lens, and the tripod mount is integrated and non-removable (which I prefer, but many don't).
Monster also has an adapter that I haven't used. The tripod mount's removable and it's much lighter than the Commlite (105g without the mount, 153g with). From reviews, it seems to work as well as the Commlite, but it's more expensive by about $100.
Fotodiox offers one, but it appears to be a rebrand of the Commlite.
p.7 #18Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Jman13 wrote:
I'm sure the lens is fantastic, but that image, from what we can see, does not say 'Otus level' to me at all, especially with regards to resolution and contrast. I'm not saying it looks bad...it doesn't, it looks very good, but I don't think we can say anything regarding resolution when we have no idea at what magnification that image is from.
It's difficult to tell whether the lack of contrast is a result from the glass surface that's actually in the image or from the lens.
p.7 #19Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
freaklikeme wrote: Petegh wrotephilip_pj wroteA few metrics for Sony users.
The VM is 60mm in length plus (est) 35mm hood plus 10mm adapter = 105mm ready to go (field users). The F vsn is 41mm long plus 27mm adapter plus (est) 5mm hood, for an all up of 73mm. Without hoods, it's 70mm (VM) -vs- 68mm (F vsn).
Weight of the VM is 250g plus 36g adapter plus (est) 15g hood = 300 grams. The F vsn is 260g plus hood (est) 5g plus (est) 80g adapter = 345 grams. rough figures but quite close, most likely.
Price we have dealt with. Instead of the VM lens/hood, you can afford a high end adapter inside the F deal. The F scales are easier to read and the adapter provides a finger hold to locate the aperture ring more easily. And safe all-of-frame performance, as with all (D)SLR lenses.Thanks Philip. What do people think is the best EXIF-transferring adapter for Nikon F?I've only used the Commlite v1 and pro (they're heavy at 250g) and the Viltrox (much lighter at 100g) on an rII and rIII. The Viltrox didn't work with anything but AF-S lenses, and even there, it's hit and miss. It wouldn't recognize my AF-D or AI-S with ROM chip lenses and froze the camera up after start-up with one them attached. So I've stuck with the Commlite pro, though it's not without its problems. It doesn't play well with non-chipped lenses, it doesn't like it when you control the aperture via the ring on the lens, and the tripod mount is integrated and non-removable (which I prefer, but many don't).
Monster also has an adapter that I haven't used. The tripod mount's removable and it's much lighter than the Commlite (105g without the mount, 153g with). From reviews, it seems to work as well as the Commlite, but it's more expensive by about $100.
Fotodiox offers one, but it appears to be a rebrand of the Commlite....Show more →
«Ai-S with ROM chip», is this a Dandelion chip?
An Ai-P or Ai-S/Ai with a ROM chip should be the easiest to support, because the chip isn’t really needed to control the lens in these cases. Merely information about FL, aperture range and position of exit pupil needs to be communicated. Aperture is mechanical. If you operate an Ai lens with the aperture ring in M or A mode a chip is perfectly fine. Ai have non-linear movement of the aperture lever, Ai-S linear. Thus Ai-S lenses will work correctly in S and P modes with the aperture ring set to the smallest aperture, i.e. highest value, while Ai won’t.
Nikon 500/4P, 1200-1700/5.6-8 and 45/2.8P have ROM chips factory installed and are MF with Ai-S type aperture. This fact has been exploited by Dandelion to make chips to retrofit Ai-S lenses to behave as Ai-P. If you have custom CPUs (not Dandelion) and Nikon contact block assemblies, and Dremel, old Ai-S and even Zeiss ZF, Voigtländer Ai-S can be upgraded to Ai-P. All Zeiss ZF.2 and chipped Voigtländer F-mount lenses are of the Ai-P type in Nikon’s nomenclature.
Corollary: Voigtländer 90/2.8 SL-II F-mount is of the Ai-P type, essentially not too different from an AF lens switched permanently from AF to MF.
Sorry, this is way off topic, but it explains a bit about the CV 90/2.8 F-mount lens.
p.7 #20Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Thanks for the info, Nikon is incomprehensible to any outsider. Being at the other end of the spectrum from Sigma's concept of modern photography, I'll check out the Novoflex for a 'dumb' adapter. Don't care about exif after all these happy years of CY/R/M lenses on Sony. Suspiciously, no one lists their adapter weights. Just need to be able to set the aperture by hand and I'm fine.