fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?

  
 
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #1What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
kidtexas wrote
Steve Spencer wroteAll that said, could you say a bit about or even give a picture of the viewfinder blockage of the 28 cron? I have assumed it isn't too bad given the small size of the lens, and thanks again for the very thoughtful description and pictures of blockage of the viewfinder that you have provided.
I can try to get pics with both 28 Summicrons. The v1 hood is pretty massive, though it has a very large cutout for the viewfinder. You get used to it, but it's not ideal. There are a lot of replacement options for it as well - one of the 35mm hoods as mentioned, generic screw-in hoods, or do what I do and use it without a hood. It's a pretty compact lens then.

The v2 hood is much more compact and intrudes into the viewfinder less. It does make the lens longer, and since it is the new special screw in type, it's less convenient to pop on and off quickly.
Thank you. The picture would be great, but just your verbal description is very helpful. I certainly like the size of this new Voigtlander 28 f/2 and I am hopeful I will like the rendering, but I am also cautious about the rendering as I don't really like the rendering of the new 35 f/2 ultron. So far size and price look very good for this new 28 f/2 ultron if the performance is there I may not have to worry about a 28 summicron.


I am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.
Apr 15, 2021 at 08:51 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #2What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Translated to English:




Apr 15, 2021 at 09:56 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #3What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Optical design differences between discontinued CV 28/2 Ultron and newly released versions (Type I and II):

51.2mm length (old) vs 36mm length (new). That's a big deal.
Also the new version's MTF is 0.5m (live view) vs 0.7m. *Rangefinder 0.7m

Weight: 244g (old) vs 190g (Type I) / 230g (Type II)

Old and New are equipped with 10-aperture blades.

The new version AOV is slightly narrower. (75° vs 74.5°)

Filter size: 46mm (old), 39mm (new)






Discontinued version: 10 elements in 8 groups with one (1) anomalous partial dispersion






New version: 10 elements in 7 groups with one (1) double sided aspherical elements, two (2) with anomalous partial dispersion

Apr 15, 2021 at 10:01 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #4What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Fred Miranda wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
kidtexas wrote
Steve Spencer wroteAll that said, could you say a bit about or even give a picture of the viewfinder blockage of the 28 cron? I have assumed it isn't too bad given the small size of the lens, and thanks again for the very thoughtful description and pictures of blockage of the viewfinder that you have provided.
I can try to get pics with both 28 Summicrons. The v1 hood is pretty massive, though it has a very large cutout for the viewfinder. You get used to it, but it's not ideal. There are a lot of replacement options for it as well - one of the 35mm hoods as mentioned, generic screw-in hoods, or do what I do and use it without a hood. It's a pretty compact lens then.

The v2 hood is much more compact and intrudes into the viewfinder less. It does make the lens longer, and since it is the new special screw in type, it's less convenient to pop on and off quickly.
Thank you. The picture would be great, but just your verbal description is very helpful. I certainly like the size of this new Voigtlander 28 f/2 and I am hopeful I will like the rendering, but I am also cautious about the rendering as I don't really like the rendering of the new 35 f/2 ultron. So far size and price look very good for this new 28 f/2 ultron if the performance is there I may not have to worry about a 28 summicron.
I am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.


To be honest, I am not very impressed with either rendering wide-open—though it’s not the intent of either lens. I would be surprised though (and hope), that the 35 APO is better than the 35/2 Ultron till f4. The 35/2 Ultron is a bit of wild lens. If one can keep the background simple though, I really do like the draw colors, contrast, central sharpness and small size. It was better on my m240 than my stock sony’s as you’d expect. It’s a great option for film too.

Also, love the new stylings, smaller size and shorter MFD for the new 28mm. Now let’s see the draw 🤞🏻




Apr 15, 2021 at 10:27 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.5 #5What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?

LBJ2 wrote:
Do I see a Leica like focus tab on this new 28/2 Ultron lens ?


Yes! Also the same with the 35/2 Ultron vII refresh. Finally some decent ergonomics.

mcbroomf wrote:
OK so that is weird. After reading Ron's post I clicked on the link and found the text he referred to (just above the MTF graphs at the bottom) and copied the text I italicized above. NOW however the same link takes me to a modified page. No MTF or any comment about adapting lenses, just as you say. In case I had clicked on the wrong lens I went through EVERY lens, VM and SE and no mention. So they must have changed the page. No idea why ... maybe Ron can chime in to let me know I'm
...Show more →

I didn't see any MTFs. Revisiting the page I see the same thing Juha stated... Yeah, too bad you didn't screen-grab the page.

Maybe future reference for all of us: if you see a non-APO Voigtlander product page with MTFs, save it!

---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote:
... I certainly like the size of this new Voigtlander 28 f/2 and I am hopeful I will like the rendering, but I am also cautious about the rendering as I don't really like the rendering of the new 35 f/2 ultron. So far size and price look very good for this new 28 f/2 ultron if the performance is there I may not have to worry about a 28 summicron.


I agree, rendering TBD. If it's more or less stopped down shooting, then the 35 Ultron actually seems pretty good. While I could live with its background rendering, I found its focus transition zone to be really busy in certain sample images shared by others.
Apr 15, 2021 at 10:45 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.5 #6What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?

Fred Miranda wrote:
I am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.


You mean lesser of two evils?

My guess is the APO but it will depend on camera to subject to background distances. Please also check focus transition areas.

See if you can get the Leica 35 APO on loan. Unfortunately it's so expensive, but thus far, of the recent 35mm M mount releases, I think it has the best balance of optical performance and restrained character.
Apr 15, 2021 at 10:49 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.5 #7What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
rscheffler wrote:
LBJ2 wroteDo I see a Leica like focus tab on this new 28/2 Ultron lens ?
Yes! Also the same with the 35/2 Ultron vII refresh. Finally some decent ergonomics.

mcbroomf wroteOK so that is weird. After reading Ron's post I clicked on the link and found the text he referred to (just above the MTF graphs at the bottom) and copied the text I italicized above. NOW however the same link takes me to a modified page. No MTF or any comment about adapting lenses, just as you say. In case I had clicked on the wrong lens I went through EVERY lens, VM and SE and no mention. So they must have changed the page. No idea why ... maybe Ron can chime in to let me know I'm not going crazy
I didn't see any MTFs. Revisiting the page I see the same thing Juha stated... Yeah, too bad you didn't screen-grab the page.

Maybe future reference for all of us: if you see a non-APO Voigtlander product page with MTFs, save it!

---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote... I certainly like the size of this new Voigtlander 28 f/2 and I am hopeful I will like the rendering, but I am also cautious about the rendering as I don't really like the rendering of the new 35 f/2 ultron. So far size and price look very good for this new 28 f/2 ultron if the performance is there I may not have to worry about a 28 summicron.
I agree, rendering TBD. If it's more or less stopped down shooting, then the 35 Ultron actually seems pretty good. While I could live with its background rendering, I found its focus transition zone to be really busy in certain sample images shared by others.


I really like the Leica lens focus tabs and am very happy to see it on this new Ultron. I am not interested in replacing any of my Leica M lenses with anything else, but I do enjoy the VM 75 1.5 very much ( I never wanted any of the Leica M 75's) and if this new VM 28/2 has the IQ chops AND that focus tab...I'm already breathing heavy as I have been holding out for a 28 for my M10.

Hopefully Fred will get his copy soon for an IQ review and comparison. Absolutely no pressure Fred

P.S. Reading some of the comments about previous Ultron lens IQ, I am however a little hesitant of what to expect...for the new 28/2
Apr 15, 2021 at 11:02 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.5 #8What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Cosina could continue the streak with a tiny 50/2 Ultron with focusing tab...

That said, the new 50/1.5II is a pretty compelling lens for its size and optical quality. It's great that Cosina has at least given us a comprehensive set of Leica-M alternatives. I'd be quite happy to build a kit from VM lenses if I was starting over, or new to the M system. Just needs a couple 90mm options.

Edited on Apr 15, 2021 at 11:14 AM · View previous versions
Apr 15, 2021 at 11:10 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.5 #9What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
rscheffler wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteI am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.
You mean lesser of two evils?

My guess is the APO but it will depend on camera to subject to background distances. Please also check focus transition areas.

See if you can get the Leica 35 APO on loan. Unfortunately it's so expensive, but thus far, of the recent 35mm M mount releases, I think it has the best balance of optical performance and restrained character.


For those of you that have been around Leica M lenses for a while and probably bought and sold more than a few...do you expect the very expensive Leica M 35/2 APO might at least hold close to its current value if one was to purchase today and then sell sometime in very good condition down the road?
Apr 15, 2021 at 11:11 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.5 #10What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Yes. It'll be hard to get for a while. Maybe for the next year or so. But eventually it'll also depreciate. It would at least be cheaper than renting a few times, if it ever becomes available for rental.

From what I recall of the 50AA, secondhand prices were fairly reasonable a while back, but I haven't checked recently.

Leica is consistent with price increases, so if you didn't sell it within a year and held onto it for a while, you'd probably still get back close to what you paid new today. The question is only how long you'd have to hold onto it. That's also not taking into consideration inflation over time and the corresponding loss of per-dollar buying power.

The most expensive Leica M lens I bought was the 21 Lux back in 2011. I think its MSRP now is near double what I paid for it new. However, its secondhand market value, last time I checked, wasn't that great. But I'd probably get back close to what I paid for it.
Apr 15, 2021 at 11:17 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #11What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
kidtexas wrote
Steve Spencer wroteAll that said, could you say a bit about or even give a picture of the viewfinder blockage of the 28 cron? I have assumed it isn't too bad given the small size of the lens, and thanks again for the very thoughtful description and pictures of blockage of the viewfinder that you have provided.
I can try to get pics with both 28 Summicrons. The v1 hood is pretty massive, though it has a very large cutout for the viewfinder. You get used to it, but it's not ideal. There are a lot of replacement options for it as well - one of the 35mm hoods as mentioned, generic screw-in hoods, or do what I do and use it without a hood. It's a pretty compact lens then.

The v2 hood is much more compact and intrudes into the viewfinder less. It does make the lens longer, and since it is the new special screw in type, it's less convenient to pop on and off quickly.
Thank you. The picture would be great, but just your verbal description is very helpful. I certainly like the size of this new Voigtlander 28 f/2 and I am hopeful I will like the rendering, but I am also cautious about the rendering as I don't really like the rendering of the new 35 f/2 ultron. So far size and price look very good for this new 28 f/2 ultron if the performance is there I may not have to worry about a 28 summicron.
I am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.
To be honest, I am not very impressed with either rendering wide-open—though it’s not the intent of either lens. I would be surprised though (and hope), that the 35 APO is better than the 35/2 Ultron till f4. The 35/2 Ultron is a bit of wild lens. If one can keep the background simple though, I really do like the draw colors, contrast, central sharpness and small size. It was better on my m240 than my stock sony’s as you’d expect. It’s a great option for film too.

Also, love the new stylings, smaller size and shorter MFD for the new
...Show more →

The CV 35/2 Ultron is closer in rendering to CV 35/1.4 II Nokton (@f/2) than CV 35/1.7. The latter's draw is more in tune with lenses like the Sigma 35/2 and RX1. Having said that, I do enjoy shooting with lenses with more funky rendering (call it busy, harsh). I see it as just a different look to images.
Apr 15, 2021 at 11:55 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.5 #12What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
rscheffler wrote:
Yes. It'll be hard to get for a while. Maybe for the next year or so. But eventually it'll also depreciate. It would at least be cheaper than renting a few times, if it ever becomes available for rental.

From what I recall of the 50AA, secondhand prices were fairly reasonable a while back, but I haven't checked recently.

Leica is consistent with price increases, so if you didn't sell it within a year and held onto it for a while, you'd probably still get back close to what you paid new today. The question is only how long you'd have
...Show more →

Thank you. I don't mind parking some money for a few truly exceptional pieces that I will use aka my 50 0,95. But if ever I decide to sell any of my Leica glass, just wondering if the forum Leica resale lore is anywhere near accurate.
Apr 15, 2021 at 12:11 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #13What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Fred Miranda wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
kidtexas wrote
Steve Spencer wroteAll that said, could you say a bit about or even give a picture of the viewfinder blockage of the 28 cron? I have assumed it isn't too bad given the small size of the lens, and thanks again for the very thoughtful description and pictures of blockage of the viewfinder that you have provided.
I can try to get pics with both 28 Summicrons. The v1 hood is pretty massive, though it has a very large cutout for the viewfinder. You get used to it, but it's not ideal. There are a lot of replacement options for it as well - one of the 35mm hoods as mentioned, generic screw-in hoods, or do what I do and use it without a hood. It's a pretty compact lens then.

The v2 hood is much more compact and intrudes into the viewfinder less. It does make the lens longer, and since it is the new special screw in type, it's less convenient to pop on and off quickly.
Thank you. The picture would be great, but just your verbal description is very helpful. I certainly like the size of this new Voigtlander 28 f/2 and I am hopeful I will like the rendering, but I am also cautious about the rendering as I don't really like the rendering of the new 35 f/2 ultron. So far size and price look very good for this new 28 f/2 ultron if the performance is there I may not have to worry about a 28 summicron.
I am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.
To be honest, I am not very impressed with either rendering wide-open—though it’s not the intent of either lens. I would be surprised though (and hope), that the 35 APO is better than the 35/2 Ultron till f4. The 35/2 Ultron is a bit of wild lens. If one can keep the background simple though, I really do like the draw colors, contrast, central sharpness and small size. It was better on my m240 than my stock sony’s as you’d expect. It’s a great option for film too.

Also, love the new stylings, smaller size and shorter MFD for the new 28mm. Now let’s see the draw 🤞🏻
The CV 35/2 Ultron is closer in rendering to CV 35/1.4 II Nokton (@f/2) than CV 35/1.7. The latter's draw is more in tune with lenses like the Sigma 35/2 and RX1. Having said that, I do enjoy shooting with lenses with more funky rendering (call it busy, harsh). I see it as just a different look to images.


I agree—I have owned, extensively shot and rendering tested the 35/1.7, RX1 and 35/2 Ultron. I also like different renderings that are less corrected. I always have both smoother and more character rendering lenses at each important FL for me.
Apr 15, 2021 at 12:13 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #14What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
LBJ2 wrote:
rscheffler wrote
Fred Miranda wroteI am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.
You mean lesser of two evils?

My guess is the APO but it will depend on camera to subject to background distances. Please also check focus transition areas.

See if you can get the Leica 35 APO on loan. Unfortunately it's so expensive, but thus far, of the recent 35mm M mount releases, I think it has the best balance of optical performance and restrained character.
For those of you that have been around Leica M lenses for a while and probably bought and sold more than a few...do you expect the very expensive Leica M 35/2 APO might at least hold close to its current value if one was to purchase today and then sell sometime in very good condition down the road?


My expectation would be that on the used market it will settle somewhere between $5,000 and $6,000 and likely decline very slowly from there. So, that is a big hit in depreciation when you look at the overall loss, but not so much when you look at percentage loss. Financially where Leica M lenses make more sense to me is buying them used after they have been released for a couple of years and the used price has settle. Then even for an expensive lens the overall loss is less than you would think and the percentage loss is quite small. You will have a lot of money tied up in such a lens, however, and you have to think of the opportunity cost of what else you could do with that money.
Apr 15, 2021 at 12:29 PM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.5 #15What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
rscheffler wrote
Fred Miranda wroteI am curious which rendering is more pleasant. 35/2 APO vs 35/2 Ultron II. I'm getting the latter today and will post a comparison on the CV 35/2 APO review thread.
You mean lesser of two evils?

My guess is the APO but it will depend on camera to subject to background distances. Please also check focus transition areas.

See if you can get the Leica 35 APO on loan. Unfortunately it's so expensive, but thus far, of the recent 35mm M mount releases, I think it has the best balance of optical performance and restrained character.
For those of you that have been around Leica M lenses for a while and probably bought and sold more than a few...do you expect the very expensive Leica M 35/2 APO might at least hold close to its current value if one was to purchase today and then sell sometime in very good condition down the road?
My expectation would be that on the used market it will settle somewhere between $5,000 and $6,000 and likely decline very slowly from there. So, that is a big hit in depreciation when you look at the overall loss, but not so much when you look at percentage loss. Financially where Leica M lenses make more sense to me is buying them used after they have been released for a couple of years and the used price has settle. Then even for an expensive lens the overall loss is less than you would think and the percentage loss is
...Show more →

"...buying them used after they have been released for a couple of years and the used price has settled" Sage advice and we know these Leica M lenses typically last for a very, very long time.
Apr 15, 2021 at 12:43 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #16What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Do we have any sample galleries or exact release date?

A7c + CV 28/2 ASPH + ZM 50/1.5 will be a very small, capable kit for for me I think.
Apr 15, 2021 at 12:53 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #17What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Do we have any sample galleries or exact release date?

A7c + CV 28/2 ASPH + ZM 50/1.5 will be a very small, capable kit for for me I think.


That would be great if the CV 28 f/2 isn't affected by the Sony sensor stack, but somehow I don't think that will happen. I am guessing the CV 28 f/2 won't be that hot on an unmodified Sony camera.

Apr 15, 2021 at 01:53 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #18What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
nehemiahphoto wroteDo we have any sample galleries or exact release date?

A7c + CV 28/2 ASPH + ZM 50/1.5 will be a very small, capable kit for for me I think.
That would be great if the CV 28 f/2 isn't affected by the Sony sensor stack, but somehow I don't think that will happen. I am guessing the CV 28 f/2 won't be that hot on an unmodified Sony camera.


That’s the big question. I am optimistic. Time will tell.
Apr 15, 2021 at 02:02 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #19What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
I'm 100% sure it will be affected. The question is by how much and what's acceptable.
Apr 15, 2021 at 02:06 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #20What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Fred Miranda wrote:
I'm 100% sure it will be affected. The question is by how much and what's acceptable.


Agree—just hoping it’s like the 35/1.2iii and 21/3.5.
Apr 15, 2021 at 02:24 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister