p.2 #1Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Jochenb wrote:
I still believe it's because of Sigma's mediocre AF algorithm, because all the DG DN lenses I own and tried behave more or less the same.
The very first shot in an AF-C burst is perfectly in focus most of the time. The following shots of that burst often go out of focus. Do a new burst and the first shot is great again. Etc...
So the AF motors are certainly speedy enough. IMHO the Sigma AF algorithm just isn't good at tracking a subject, but acquiring focus is not an issue.
I don't have these issues with native Sony lenses (that don't have slow AF motors). ...Show more →
By chance, do you have the 85mm DG DN? Right now, I have the 45mm, 85mm, and 105mm macro DG DN's, shooting with an A9, typically in wide tracking mode/AF-C for everyday shooting purposes. My 45mm is not reliable in AF-C like many others have reported.
My 85mm DG DN, however, is rock solid in AF-C, both around the house and for indoor sports high frame rate stuff. The 85mm almost never misses and gets the same keeper rates as my native Sony lenses.
I've barely used the 105 macro since I got it, and I probably wouldn't use it in wide/AF-C anyway, so I've got nothing to report there. In my experience, the 45mm is not representative of my experience with other DG DN lenses.
p.2 #2Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
tedgoudie wrote: Jochenb wroteI still believe it's because of Sigma's mediocre AF algorithm, because all the DG DN lenses I own and tried behave more or less the same.
The very first shot in an AF-C burst is perfectly in focus most of the time. The following shots of that burst often go out of focus. Do a new burst and the first shot is great again. Etc...
So the AF motors are certainly speedy enough. IMHO the Sigma AF algorithm just isn't good at tracking a subject, but acquiring focus is not an issue.
I don't have these issues with native Sony lenses (that don't have slow AF motors).By chance, do you have the 85mm DG DN? Right now, I have the 45mm, 85mm, and 105mm macro DG DN's, shooting with an A9, typically in wide tracking mode/AF-C for everyday shooting purposes. My 45mm is not reliable in AF-C like many others have reported.
My 85mm DG DN, however, is rock solid in AF-C, both around the house and for indoor sports high frame rate stuff. The 85mm almost never misses and gets the same keeper rates as my native Sony lenses.
I've barely used the 105 macro since I got it, and I probably wouldn't use it in wide/AF-C anyway, so I've got nothing to report there. In my experience, the 45mm is not representative of my experience with other DG DN lenses.
My, really my wife's, experience is exactly the same. She has no problems with the 45 f/2.8 in AF-S, but it doesn't work well close in AF-C. She has no problems with the 85 f/1.4 DG DN at any distance and finds the AF very fast and very snappy with this lens. In fact, she finds the AF in both AF-C and AF-S to be one of the big strengths of that lens.
Whatever the reason, (I suspect Sigma built this lens, the 45 f/2.8, for CDAF performance and not PDAF performance and even the Canon lenses that have spherical aberrations in droves were built for PDAF) what is generally known is that at closer distances the lens works well in AF-S and works fairly poorly in AF-C. At this point I wouldn't get this lens or keep this lens if you feel you have to use AF-C close up. Even people who are happy with the lens, like my wife, are not happy with AF-C performance close up, but they are happy with AF-S performance close up. So, yes you may have to learn a different way of focussing to use the lens, but if that is not something you want to do then the lens isn't for you.
p.2 #3Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Steve Spencer wrote: tedgoudie wroteJochenb wroteI still believe it's because of Sigma's mediocre AF algorithm, because all the DG DN lenses I own and tried behave more or less the same.
The very first shot in an AF-C burst is perfectly in focus most of the time. The following shots of that burst often go out of focus. Do a new burst and the first shot is great again. Etc...
So the AF motors are certainly speedy enough. IMHO the Sigma AF algorithm just isn't good at tracking a subject, but acquiring focus is not an issue.
I don't have these issues with native Sony lenses (that don't have slow AF motors).By chance, do you have the 85mm DG DN? Right now, I have the 45mm, 85mm, and 105mm macro DG DN's, shooting with an A9, typically in wide tracking mode/AF-C for everyday shooting purposes. My 45mm is not reliable in AF-C like many others have reported.
My 85mm DG DN, however, is rock solid in AF-C, both around the house and for indoor sports high frame rate stuff. The 85mm almost never misses and gets the same keeper rates as my native Sony lenses.
I've barely used the 105 macro since I got it, and I probably wouldn't use it in wide/AF-C anyway, so I've got nothing to report there. In my experience, the 45mm is not representative of my experience with other DG DN lenses.My, really my wife's, experience is exactly the same. She has no problems with the 45 f/2.8 in AF-S, but it doesn't work well close in AF-C. She has no problems with the 85 f/1.4 DG DN at any distance and finds the AF very fast and very snappy with this lens. In fact, she finds the AF in both AF-C and AF-S to be one of the big strengths of that lens.
Whatever the reason, (I suspect Sigma built this lens, the 45 f/2.8, for CDAF performance and not PDAF performance and even the Canon lenses that have spherical aberrations in droves were built for PDAF) what is generally known is that at closer distances the lens works well in AF-S and works fairly poorly in AF-C. At this point I wouldn't get this lens or keep this lens if you feel you have to use AF-C close up. Even people who are happy with the lens, like my wife, are not happy with AF-C performance close up, but they are happy with AF-S performance close up. So, yes you may have to learn a different way of focussing to use the lens, but if that is not something you want to do then the lens isn't for you....Show more →
Fred called this lens a 'mini STF' and I think that's right in more ways than just smooth bokeh. I have the 100 STF and it is a lens of context...it retains the context of the OOF areas and it needs to be used in a context. The STF is the furtherest thing from a general purpose lens, but I love it it and use it a lot. Because all of the quirks are obvious up front, though, one makes the decision with full knowledge. Loss of 2 stops of light, generally must be used wide open, slow AF, etc.
With the Sigma at 45mm, there's a lot of promise that it can be a perfect general purpose walk around lens with gorgeous rendering to boot. But the user experience is different, especially for those who have begun to use Sony's great AF-C extensively. So like you said, you have to learn a different way of focussing and using the lens. For me, I 'go back' and use it like I used to use all my lenses. I have a custom button on my 'ancient' A7RII tasked for eye AF so that's what I do, AF-S and lots of tapping the shutter release.
It should be better, it isn't. I still love what the lens delivers, but I totally get the frustration. It's odd that Sigma simply can't fix it, hence the speculation about SA and how it interacts with the AF system. True or not, it still doesn't work. Dang.
p.2 #4Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
chiron wrote:
Experimenting with the autofocus a bit. Some of the things I have tried and noticed.
1. Real Time Tracking in af-c seems to be working well enough. I have tried locking focus and tracking objects in dim light at about 10 feet and at 1.5 feet (at the short distance there was a high contrast target) by moving the camera erratically and quickly. In both cases the, the lens on the A9 maintained focus despite the dim light and the quick erratic movements. When I took a photo at the end of the erratic tracking, the image was sharp within the limits of this slightly soft lens. All this was done at f2.8.
2. I put up an image of Mona Lisa on the screen of my lap top and used eye-af from about 20 or so inches. The eye-af found her eye quickly and stayed locked when I moved the camera erratically. I then dimmed the brightness of the screen quite a bit and the camera still stayed locked. In both cases, the resulting image was sharp (within the sharpness limitations of the lens).
It is probably true that the Mona Lisa on the computer screen, even when dimmed quite a bit, provides more contrast and brightness, because its light is projected, than a real object would provide since the real object is seen in less intense reflected light. It is also a two-dimensional tracking target, which I suspect would be easier for the processor to compute than would be a three-dimensional object. But it was interesting to me that the lens and A9 did well with tracking the the Mona Lisa's eye, even when jittering around and at a close distance.
Some of this makes me think there is a chance the lens will perform better on an A1 because of the increased calculations. Anyone have this combination to try out?...Show more →
I think you're probably seeing good results with Mona because she's two dimensional and not moving.
p.2 #5Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
freaklikeme wrote: chiron wroteExperimenting with the autofocus a bit. Some of the things I have tried and noticed.
1. Real Time Tracking in af-c seems to be working well enough. I have tried locking focus and tracking objects in dim light at about 10 feet and at 1.5 feet (at the short distance there was a high contrast target) by moving the camera erratically and quickly. In both cases the, the lens on the A9 maintained focus despite the dim light and the quick erratic movements. When I took a photo at the end of the erratic tracking, the image was sharp within the limits of this slightly soft lens. All this was done at f2.8.
2. I put up an image of Mona Lisa on the screen of my lap top and used eye-af from about 20 or so inches. The eye-af found her eye quickly and stayed locked when I moved the camera erratically. I then dimmed the brightness of the screen quite a bit and the camera still stayed locked. In both cases, the resulting image was sharp (within the sharpness limitations of the lens).
It is probably true that the Mona Lisa on the computer screen, even when dimmed quite a bit, provides more contrast and brightness, because its light is projected, than a real object would provide since the real object is seen in less intense reflected light. It is also a two-dimensional tracking target, which I suspect would be easier for the processor to compute than would be a three-dimensional object. But it was interesting to me that the lens and A9 did well with tracking the the Mona Lisa's eye, even when jittering around and at a close distance.
Some of this makes me think there is a chance the lens will perform better on an A1 because of the increased calculations. Anyone have this combination to try out?I think you're probably seeing good results with Mona because she's two dimensional and not moving.
Yes, although I did jitter the lens around while focus was locked on her eyes and it seemed to hold and produce a focused image. Still, the screen is two-dimensional and probalably has greater contrast than most reflected light scenes.
But there may be something to the idea that the lens isn't processing movement fast enough or well enough (which I guess doesn't say much since that is the whole point of af-c). itai195 upthread points out that in a series of shots the first is focused and the others are not and if you start a new series the same thing happens. So af-c acquires focus, presumably using pdaf, and then can't track movements while maintaining focus. But since it does acquire focus in the first place it seems like this should be a fixable problem unless their focus motor or data throughput circuitry can't handle the speed required. But it seems more likely to be a bad algorithm.
p.2 #6Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Dave Sanders wrote: Steve Spencer wrotetedgoudie wroteJochenb wroteI still believe it's because of Sigma's mediocre AF algorithm, because all the DG DN lenses I own and tried behave more or less the same.
The very first shot in an AF-C burst is perfectly in focus most of the time. The following shots of that burst often go out of focus. Do a new burst and the first shot is great again. Etc...
So the AF motors are certainly speedy enough. IMHO the Sigma AF algorithm just isn't good at tracking a subject, but acquiring focus is not an issue.
I don't have these issues with native Sony lenses (that don't have slow AF motors).By chance, do you have the 85mm DG DN? Right now, I have the 45mm, 85mm, and 105mm macro DG DN's, shooting with an A9, typically in wide tracking mode/AF-C for everyday shooting purposes. My 45mm is not reliable in AF-C like many others have reported.
My 85mm DG DN, however, is rock solid in AF-C, both around the house and for indoor sports high frame rate stuff. The 85mm almost never misses and gets the same keeper rates as my native Sony lenses.
I've barely used the 105 macro since I got it, and I probably wouldn't use it in wide/AF-C anyway, so I've got nothing to report there. In my experience, the 45mm is not representative of my experience with other DG DN lenses.My, really my wife's, experience is exactly the same. She has no problems with the 45 f/2.8 in AF-S, but it doesn't work well close in AF-C. She has no problems with the 85 f/1.4 DG DN at any distance and finds the AF very fast and very snappy with this lens. In fact, she finds the AF in both AF-C and AF-S to be one of the big strengths of that lens.
Whatever the reason, (I suspect Sigma built this lens, the 45 f/2.8, for CDAF performance and not PDAF performance and even the Canon lenses that have spherical aberrations in droves were built for PDAF) what is generally known is that at closer distances the lens works well in AF-S and works fairly poorly in AF-C. At this point I wouldn't get this lens or keep this lens if you feel you have to use AF-C close up. Even people who are happy with the lens, like my wife, are not happy with AF-C performance close up, but they are happy with AF-S performance close up. So, yes you may have to learn a different way of focussing to use the lens, but if that is not something you want to do then the lens isn't for you.Fred called this lens a 'mini STF' and I think that's right in more ways than just smooth bokeh. I have the 100 STF and it is a lens of context...it retains the context of the OOF areas and it needs to be used in a context. The STF is the furtherest thing from a general purpose lens, but I love it it and use it a lot. Because all of the quirks are obvious up front, though, one makes the decision with full knowledge. Loss of 2 stops of light, generally must be used wide open, slow AF, etc.
With the Sigma at 45mm, there's a lot of promise that it can be a perfect general purpose walk around lens with gorgeous rendering to boot. But the user experience is different, especially for those who have begun to use Sony's great AF-C extensively. So like you said, you have to learn a different way of focussing and using the lens. For me, I 'go back' and use it like I used to use all my lenses. I have a custom button on my 'ancient' A7RII tasked for eye AF so that's what I do, AF-S and lots of tapping the shutter release.
It should be better, it isn't. I still love what the lens delivers, but I totally get the frustration. It's odd that Sigma simply can't fix it, hence the speculation about SA and how it interacts with the AF system. True or not, it still doesn't work. Dang. ...Show more →
You have captured my feelings about the lens very well. My experience is very very similar. The one difference is that I use the lens a lot with manual focus, but my wife uses it just like you do.
Mar 27, 2021 at 02:10 PM
osv2
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.2 #7Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
sigma has unfortunately moved to using stepper motors instead of hsm on their new milc lenses, see the press releases:
if the last firmware update didn't improve the af, it's not a good sign going forward.
there is no scenario where a stepper motor is going to perform like sony xd linear af, or probably not even as well as sigma's own hsm motors, which work well on the 135 art/60-600/a9 combos.
the 105 dg dn macro does still use hsm, but it's well-known for slow af, not on par with fe90 ddssm focus speed.
Two quotes from that slide
« We're told by Sony that these linear motors are very efficient at generating linear motion, as they don't require any translation of rotational motion to linear motion, as ring-type and stepper motors do.»
And
« In comparison, the tiny FE 35mm F1.8 optic takes 0.3s to rack from its minimum focus distance to infinity, while the Nikkor 35mm F1.8 S takes around 1s to do so. That makes the 0.5 - 0.6s figure for the 50mm F1.2 GM nothing short of impressive.»
p.2 #9Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I have several Sigma lenses. While it’s true that generally they don’t focus on AF-C as reliably as Sony lenses, the others I own have a far higher hit rate than the 45 (other than the 105 macro which is really not designed or expected to be a fast focuser).
Two quotes from that slide
« We're told by Sony that these linear motors are very efficient at generating linear motion, as they don't require any translation of rotational motion to linear motion, as ring-type and stepper motors do.»
And
« In comparison, the tiny FE 35mm F1.8 optic takes 0.3s to rack from its minimum focus distance to infinity, while the Nikkor 35mm F1.8 S takes around 1s to do so. That makes the 0.5 - 0.6s figure for the 50mm F1.2 GM nothing short of impressive.»
I'm wondering what's the deal with 35GM... It seems to be fast but nothing to write home about. I guess it's a matter of lens construction, so maybe quad 'extreme dynamic' linear motors setup was not possible and that's why they used twin setup. Or maybe they wanted to keep the price down to compete with the Bigma...
p.2 #11Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
chiron wrote:
Experimenting with the autofocus a bit. Some of the things I have tried and noticed.
1. Real Time Tracking in af-c seems to be working well enough. I have tried locking focus and tracking objects in dim light at about 10 feet and at 1.5 feet (at the short distance there was a high contrast target) by moving the camera erratically and quickly. In both cases the, the lens on the A9 maintained focus despite the dim light and the quick erratic movements. When I took a photo at the end of the erratic tracking, the image was sharp within the limits of this slightly soft lens. All this was done at f2.8.
2. I put up an image of Mona Lisa on the screen of my lap top and used eye-af from about 20 or so inches. The eye-af found her eye quickly and stayed locked when I moved the camera erratically. I then dimmed the brightness of the screen quite a bit and the camera still stayed locked. In both cases, the resulting image was sharp (within the sharpness limitations of the lens).
It is probably true that the Mona Lisa on the computer screen, even when dimmed quite a bit, provides more contrast and brightness, because its light is projected, than a real object would provide since the real object is seen in less intense reflected light. It is also a two-dimensional tracking target, which I suspect would be easier for the processor to compute than would be a three-dimensional object. But it was interesting to me that the lens and A9 did well with tracking the the Mona Lisa's eye, even when jittering around and at a close distance.
Some of this makes me think there is a chance the lens will perform better on an A1 because of the increased calculations. Anyone have this combination to try out?...Show more →
I'm one of those rare people that do not mount super long fast teles on A1 ... Having said that, it's really difficult to judge for me if/how much better the Sigma works in this combo. I'd say it works better (compared to A7III) but I still see some variation in focus in AF-C, so it's definitely not perfect. I posted some examples after recent firmware update in the Sigma 45 thread: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1608234/48#15546350
The thing is even on A7III I had sharp shots with AF-C, it's just that they were rare. I'd have to gather some real statistics to be able to draw any real conlcusions...
I'm also in the rare(?) group of Sigma45 users that think that once you stop down a bit or shoot further away (like a couple of meters), then the inaccuracy of AF-C is hidden by increased depth of field and the problem basically goes away ...
p.2 #12Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
itai195 wrote:
I have several Sigma lenses. While it’s true that generally they don’t focus on AF-C as reliably as Sony lenses, the others I own have a far higher hit rate than the 45 (other than the 105 macro which is really not designed or expected to be a fast focuser).
Which ones do you have and what is your experience with their autofocus? I am working my way through all four of the i series. The 65 is what I am drilling with now. It is better than the 45, certainly, but not near a Sony or Zeiss or Samyang or Nikon or Canon lens's autofocus. And I read that at least one forum member has his 35i up for sale because its autofocus is not good enough to track his children effectively. The problem's with Sigma's AF appear so pervasive that people note which of their lenses do not have autofocus problems.
My sense is that Sigma's autofocus technology is well behind other major makers. Too bad, because some of their lenses are otherwise appealing.
p.2 #13Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
chiron wrote: itai195 wroteI have several Sigma lenses. While it’s true that generally they don’t focus on AF-C as reliably as Sony lenses, the others I own have a far higher hit rate than the 45 (other than the 105 macro which is really not designed or expected to be a fast focuser).Which ones do you have and what is your experience with their autofocus? I am working my way through all four of the i series. The 65 is what I am drilling with now. It is better than the 45, certainly, but not near a Sony or Zeiss or Samyang or Nikon or Canon lens's autofocus. And I read that at least one forum member has his 35i up for sale because its autofocus is not good enough to track his children effectively. The problem's with Sigma's AF appear so pervasive that people note which of their lenses do not have autofocus problems.
My sense is that Sigma's autofocus technology is well behind other major makers. Too bad, because some of their lenses are otherwise appealing....Show more →
In my country, Norway, some Sigma lenses are quite expensive. The I-series lenses are close to some Sony lenses pricewise, so their AF should have matched. These pairs are close enough that one is within 80% of the other in this price comparison:
Sigma 24/3.5 < Sony 24/2.8 G
Sigma 35/2 < Sony 35/1.8
Sigma 45/2.8 < Sony 40/2.5
Sigma 65/2 > Sony 85/1.8
In the last case Sigma is more expensive than Sony, so does the Sigma 65/2 have better AF than the Sony 85/1.8?
p.2 #14Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
chiron wrote: itai195 wroteI have several Sigma lenses. While it’s true that generally they don’t focus on AF-C as reliably as Sony lenses, the others I own have a far higher hit rate than the 45 (other than the 105 macro which is really not designed or expected to be a fast focuser).Which ones do you have and what is your experience with their autofocus? I am working my way through all four of the i series. The 65 is what I am drilling with now. It is better than the 45, certainly, but not near a Sony or Zeiss or Samyang or Nikon or Canon lens's autofocus. And I read that at least one forum member has his 35i up for sale because its autofocus is not good enough to track his children effectively. The problem's with Sigma's AF appear so pervasive that people note which of their lenses do not have autofocus problems.
My sense is that Sigma's autofocus technology is well behind other major makers. Too bad, because some of their lenses are otherwise appealing....Show more →
I have a different impression from those Sigmas I used... Basically I can't find much fault in DN series AF performance (except 45mm of course, but that's a "by design" case):
* 85mm is very fast in regular use, slows down a bit in MFD-to-Infinity transition. I'd still give the edge to FE 85 1.8 but I don't think the difference is tangible (maybe except tracking, which I don't test in detail usually).
* 100-400 I compared to the GM and of course the GM wins, but that is because the GM is lightning fast and Sigma is simply very fast (I've read GM tracks better too).
* 35mm f2 I found fast enough to chase my kids with. Again, I'm talking about more static pics (as during the winter I shoot indoors mostly and keeping the ISO reasonable means SS around 1/125s, so any sudden movement will be blurred anyway).
* 35mm f1.2 I find fast enough too. Apparently, it's actually very close in AF speed to the new GM (but a bit less consistent)...
* 24-70 is super fast, but I haven't used any similar Sony to compare to.
* 14-24 is also very fast, but also I have not used a similar Sony lens to compare to.
So, basically I think the difference mostly comes down to tracking of dynamic targets, where Sony has the edge. If that's not your main use case, I don't think you'll feel the difference (unless we're talking about Sigma's advantage, e.g 85GM vs 85DN ).
p.2 #15Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
tedgoudie wrote: Jochenb wroteI still believe it's because of Sigma's mediocre AF algorithm, because all the DG DN lenses I own and tried behave more or less the same.
The very first shot in an AF-C burst is perfectly in focus most of the time. The following shots of that burst often go out of focus. Do a new burst and the first shot is great again. Etc...
So the AF motors are certainly speedy enough. IMHO the Sigma AF algorithm just isn't good at tracking a subject, but acquiring focus is not an issue.
I don't have these issues with native Sony lenses (that don't have slow AF motors).By chance, do you have the 85mm DG DN? Right now, I have the 45mm, 85mm, and 105mm macro DG DN's, shooting with an A9, typically in wide tracking mode/AF-C for everyday shooting purposes. My 45mm is not reliable in AF-C like many others have reported.
My 85mm DG DN, however, is rock solid in AF-C, both around the house and for indoor sports high frame rate stuff. The 85mm almost never misses and gets the same keeper rates as my native Sony lenses.
I've barely used the 105 macro since I got it, and I probably wouldn't use it in wide/AF-C anyway, so I've got nothing to report there. In my experience, the 45mm is not representative of my experience with other DG DN lenses.
Yes I own the 85 DG DN as well.
I wish I could agree with you, but I really can't.
For slower subjects it's fine, but anything faster/more erratic: really not. Just like all the other DG DN lenses.
Lenses like the Sony FE 85/1.8, 135 GM, 100-400 GM,... keep up with those same subjects much much better.
I tested this numerous times.
Like I said in my previous post: the first shot of every burst is perfectly focused most of the time. So the lens AF motors are indeed really quick. The problem is that when it starts tracking the subject, things often go very wrong. As a result only the first shot of the burst will be in focus. This must be because of a mediocre Sigma AF-C algorithm.
Here is a quick random example of exactly that behavior.
A9 + 85 DG DN. Just me walking towards a lady that was walking to me. So nothing too crazy.
Very first shot of the burst, no problem. Immediately grabs focus:
Second shot of that (AF-C) burst, completely out of focus:
I don't even need to share crops to show just how out of focus the second one already is.
Native Sony lenses (with fast AF motors) really are MUCH better at this.
BTW: It's not my camera or specific copy. I tested multiple copies on multiple bodies. All DG DN lenses so far show this behavior. They don't do the amazing tracking capabilities of the A1/A9 justice.
p.2 #16Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
@chiron - Peter, I just checked that lens on my A1, just a few shots and they seem to focus fine in AF-C from within a 2-foot distance or so indoors. I will try some again tomorrow as the light is winding lower now.
p.2 #17Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
AGeoJO wrote:
@chiron@ - Peter, I just checked that lens on my A1, just a few shots and they seem to focus fine in AF-C from within a 2-foot distance or so indoors. I will try some again tomorrow as the light is winding lower now.
That is good news, Joshua. Thank you for checking that for me. The A1 is a lot of firepower to throw at a lens to make it focus.
p.2 #18Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
bjornthun wrote: chiron wroteitai195 wroteI have several Sigma lenses. While it’s true that generally they don’t focus on AF-C as reliably as Sony lenses, the others I own have a far higher hit rate than the 45 (other than the 105 macro which is really not designed or expected to be a fast focuser).Which ones do you have and what is your experience with their autofocus? I am working my way through all four of the i series. The 65 is what I am drilling with now. It is better than the 45, certainly, but not near a Sony or Zeiss or Samyang or Nikon or Canon lens's autofocus. And I read that at least one forum member has his 35i up for sale because its autofocus is not good enough to track his children effectively. The problem's with Sigma's AF appear so pervasive that people note which of their lenses do not have autofocus problems.
My sense is that Sigma's autofocus technology is well behind other major makers. Too bad, because some of their lenses are otherwise appealing.In my country, Norway, some Sigma lenses are quite expensive. The I-series lenses are close to some Sony lenses pricewise, so their AF should have matched. These pairs are close enough that one is within 80% of the other in this price comparison:
Sigma 24/3.5 < Sony 24/2.8 G
Sigma 35/2 < Sony 35/1.8
Sigma 45/2.8 < Sony 40/2.5
Sigma 65/2 > Sony 85/1.8
In the last case Sigma is more expensive than Sony, so does the Sigma 65/2 have better AF than the Sony 85/1.8?
To answer your question--not nearly. The Sony is faster and more reliable, and doesn't lose focus once it has been acquired.
p.2 #19Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Jochenb wrote: tedgoudie wroteJochenb wroteI still believe it's because of Sigma's mediocre AF algorithm, because all the DG DN lenses I own and tried behave more or less the same.
The very first shot in an AF-C burst is perfectly in focus most of the time. The following shots of that burst often go out of focus. Do a new burst and the first shot is great again. Etc...
So the AF motors are certainly speedy enough. IMHO the Sigma AF algorithm just isn't good at tracking a subject, but acquiring focus is not an issue.
I don't have these issues with native Sony lenses (that don't have slow AF motors).By chance, do you have the 85mm DG DN? Right now, I have the 45mm, 85mm, and 105mm macro DG DN's, shooting with an A9, typically in wide tracking mode/AF-C for everyday shooting purposes. My 45mm is not reliable in AF-C like many others have reported.
My 85mm DG DN, however, is rock solid in AF-C, both around the house and for indoor sports high frame rate stuff. The 85mm almost never misses and gets the same keeper rates as my native Sony lenses.
I've barely used the 105 macro since I got it, and I probably wouldn't use it in wide/AF-C anyway, so I've got nothing to report there. In my experience, the 45mm is not representative of my experience with other DG DN lenses.Yes I own the 85 DG DN as well.
I wish I could agree with you, but I really can't.
For slower subjects it's fine, but anything faster/more erratic: really not. Just like all the other DG DN lenses.
Lenses like the Sony FE 85/1.8, 135 GM, 100-400 GM,... keep up with those same subjects much much better.
I tested this numerous times.
Like I said in my previous post: the first shot of every burst is perfectly focused most of the time. So the lens AF motors are indeed really quick. The problem is that when it starts tracking the subject, things often go very wrong. As a result only the first shot of the burst will be in focus. This must be because of a mediocre Sigma AF-C algorithm.
Here is a quick random example of exactly that behavior.
A9 + 85 DG DN. Just me walking towards a lady that was walking to me. So nothing too crazy.
Very first shot of the burst, no problem. Immediately grabs focus:
I don't even need to share crops to show just how out of focus the second one already is.
Native Sony lenses (with fast AF motors) really are MUCH better at this.
BTW: It's not my camera or specific copy. I tested multiple copies on multiple bodies. All DG DN lenses so far show this behavior. They don't do the amazing tracking capabilities of the A1/A9 justice. ...Show more →
This is a sign of a very poorly implemented autofocus system that is way behind every other maker.
p.2 #20Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Here's another example of the A9 + 85 DG DN.
This time tracking a guy on a (not even very fast) bicycle. These are 100% crops.
First shot of the burst, no issues again:
Fourth shot of the burst, I think my point is clear:
With fast native Sony lenses these things don't happen on the A9. With the Sigma DG DN lenses all the time.
Edit:
And here is a random example of the A9 + Sigma 45 DG DN, stopped down a little bit and at a distance. So no issues with the sperical aberration.
Also a girl on a slow bicycle (crops).
First shot of the burst:
Third shot of the burst:
See... this is exactly the same AF-C behavior like I showed from the 85 DG DN above.