fredmiranda.com Login

Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review

  
 
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.9 #1Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
fotografur wrote:

If you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.


lukecookphoto wrote:

That's true, from MFD the Sigma is not so great! If you get a bit further back from MFD it sharpens up nicely.

I'll have to look at some f/1.4 vs. f/2 examples on a 35mm and see how I feel. Seems like it'd be better to have a fast 55 or 65 for when I want to blow out backgrounds though as a 35 is still a 35.


chiron wrote:

Good point. I personally don't shoot a 35mm up close because I don't like distortion in my images, but for some people this would be a bit of difficulty. But the Voigtlander 40/1.2 had the same issue, and that didn't stop it becoming a favorite for many people.


Speaking as someone who has had to deal with RSA with the Batis 40 for a few years now, I will say the biggest impact you'll normally have with this is low light shooting indoors. To clarify: outdoors it's possible to distance yourself from a subject enough that f2 is usable—but indoors that isn't an option.

If a location has enough lighting, this won't be an issue. However, in poorly lit indoor conditions I find the glow up close exacerbates noise based image degradation. SA glow might not give a huge reduction in resolution, but the loss of contrast and halation makes things look... extra flat when you have the all-aspects image degradation that noise brings. I often find that within the range of RSA (with my 40—again, but that and the 35i look very similar in this regard) that despite the added noise, images look better stopped down to the point that RSA disappears.

If you have another lens to use in these conditions this won't be a problem at all. Just something I'd keep in mind if I were planning to use this lens in the described circumstances.
Mar 09, 2021 at 07:34 AM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.9 #2Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
JVan_02 wrote:
fotografur wroteIf you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.
lukecookphoto wroteThat's true, from MFD the Sigma is not so great! If you get a bit further back from MFD it sharpens up nicely.

I'll have to look at some f/1.4 vs. f/2 examples on a 35mm and see how I feel. Seems like it'd be better to have a fast 55 or 65 for when I want to blow out backgrounds though as a 35 is still a 35.
chiron wroteGood point. I personally don't shoot a 35mm up close because I don't like distortion in my images, but for some people this would be a bit of difficulty. But the Voigtlander 40/1.2 had the same issue, and that didn't stop it becoming a favorite for many people.
Speaking as someone who has had to deal with RSA with the Batis 40 for a few years now, I will say the biggest impact you'll normally have with this is low light shooting indoors. To clarify: outdoors it's possible to distance yourself from a subject enough that f2 is usable—but indoors that isn't an option.

If a location has enough lighting, this won't be an issue. However, in poorly lit indoor conditions I find the glow up close exacerbates noise based image degradation. SA glow might not give a huge reduction in resolution, but the loss of contrast and
...Show more →

This is a shot indoors in very dim light with the Batis at f2.0 at 5000 ISO and underexposed by 2/3rds of a stop. Focus was on the dog's eyes.



© chiron 2021

Mar 09, 2021 at 07:45 AM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
chiron wrote:
JVan_02 wrote
fotografur wroteIf you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.
lukecookphoto wroteThat's true, from MFD the Sigma is not so great! If you get a bit further back from MFD it sharpens up nicely.

I'll have to look at some f/1.4 vs. f/2 examples on a 35mm and see how I feel. Seems like it'd be better to have a fast 55 or 65 for when I want to blow out backgrounds though as a 35 is still a 35.
chiron wroteGood point. I personally don't shoot a 35mm up close because I don't like distortion in my images, but for some people this would be a bit of difficulty. But the Voigtlander 40/1.2 had the same issue, and that didn't stop it becoming a favorite for many people.
Speaking as someone who has had to deal with RSA with the Batis 40 for a few years now, I will say the biggest impact you'll normally have with this is low light shooting indoors. To clarify: outdoors it's possible to distance yourself from a subject enough that f2 is usable—but indoors that isn't an option.

If a location has enough lighting, this won't be an issue. However, in poorly lit indoor conditions I find the glow up close exacerbates noise based image degradation. SA glow might not give a huge reduction in resolution, but the loss of contrast and halation makes things look... extra flat when you have the all-aspects image degradation that noise brings. I often find that within the range of RSA (with my 40—again, but that and the 35i look very similar in this regard) that despite the added noise, images look better stopped down to the point that RSA disappears.

If you have another lens to use in these conditions this won't be a problem at all. Just something I'd keep in mind if I were planning to use this lens in the described circumstances.
This is a shot indoors in very dim light with the Batis at f2.0 at 5000 ISO and underexposed by 2/3rds of a stop. Focus was on the dog's eyes.


Great image, saw it in the 40 image thread

To be even more pedantic, this is what Zeiss' forced aperture values (f2→2.5 at 0.6→.25m) are aimed at correcting and its a little difficult to get f2 RSA issues to manifest. I'd say that I've found at ~0.6-0.8m you can get the RSA-based image degradation to manifest under the right conditions... and it looks much better in black and white as you've shown. To be fair, I don't have a proper setup to do scientific testing. This is just observations from continued use, so I expect I'm a little off on the exact details.

If interested, I can try to dig up some photos that demonstrate the RSA issues using flash. It isn't exactly equivalent to this issue in bad lighting, but logically it should follow as I've described and I've observed as much. I just don't have as clear as of a RSA/no RSA (stopping down the lens on the same subject at same distance) that I do with the flash image.

Mar 09, 2021 at 08:31 AM
lukecookphoto
Offline
Details
p.9 #4Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
With the Sigma I haven't really noticed a loss in contrast or anything drastic when shooting up close at f/2, definitely a reduction in resolution though. The A7R III is so good in low light that I'm happy to bump that ISO up to 12,800 or maybe even a touch beyond if need be!

Mar 09, 2021 at 08:35 AM
Mystik
Offline
Details
p.9 #5Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
fotografur wrote:
lukecookphoto wrote
chiron wrote
lukecookphoto wrote
2ndviolinman wrote@lukecoookphoto:
The first picture is a TOTALLY cool picture, especially being owned by a calico cat, as I am.
Thank you!

chiron wroteThese are all very beautiful. I love the compositions, the colors, and the post-processing. Just lovely.
Thanks very much! The last one has almost no post processing so I was very surprised by how well it turned out.
I like them all, but I especially like the first and the fourth. They have a sense of deep space and dark colors and variation rather than uniformity which makes them complex to look at. In the first picture especially, the sense of space is so cut up and varied that I kept thinking that I was looking at a collage. I had to make myself see that it was a single photograph. It really works.
One might be tempted to say... 3D pop

The results from this lens are so good that I am really second guessing whether I should go for the 35 GM, as f/1.4 won't blur the background significantly more than the f/2 and I could instead pick up the Sigma 65 f/2 or Zony 55 f/1.8 and keep the Sigma 35 all for the same price (roughly) as the GM... And those longer lenses will supply more DOF control than the 35 GM.
If you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.


Just about every lens get sharper a couple stops down from wide open...just the nature of lens design.

The question to consider is if the 35 F2 is competently sharp enough wide open at F2 given real world use cases. The 35GM will undoubtedly be sharper at F2, but realistically most lenses releases these days are so competently sharp wide open that it isn't the first consideration anymore. i.e. the 85GM is not as sharp as the 135GM, but the superior rendering and easier to work with focal length take priority for me and I never feel the 85GM isn't sufficiently sharp. It has tons of RSA wide open and this contributes to the rendering that it is beloved for.

I doubt anyone will ever say the 35 F2 is soft wide open. If you want test chart killing sharpness, get the 35GM. Looking at things comprehensively including the shooting experience....if you want a more compact option that renders well and is more that competent optically, then the 35i might be the better option and its cheaper to boot.




Edited on Mar 09, 2021 at 09:36 AM · View previous versions
Mar 09, 2021 at 09:30 AM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.9 #6Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Decided to dig up the photos anyway. Here's the f2 version first:



And the close up. @lukecookphoto I'd say there is a bit of resolution loss along with the loss in contrast, again—not the same lens but it should translate.



By contrast, here's the f2.8 version:



Corresponding close up:



In any case, unless proven otherwise I'd still expect the 35i to perform worse than a lens without RSA in poor lighting conditions.
Mar 09, 2021 at 09:33 AM
fotografur
Offline
Details
p.9 #7Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Mystik wrote:
fotografur wrote
lukecookphoto wrote
chiron wrote
lukecookphoto wrote
2ndviolinman wrote@lukecoookphoto:
The first picture is a TOTALLY cool picture, especially being owned by a calico cat, as I am.
Thank you!

chiron wroteThese are all very beautiful. I love the compositions, the colors, and the post-processing. Just lovely.
Thanks very much! The last one has almost no post processing so I was very surprised by how well it turned out.
I like them all, but I especially like the first and the fourth. They have a sense of deep space and dark colors and variation rather than uniformity which makes them complex to look at. In the first picture especially, the sense of space is so cut up and varied that I kept thinking that I was looking at a collage. I had to make myself see that it was a single photograph. It really works.
One might be tempted to say... 3D pop

The results from this lens are so good that I am really second guessing whether I should go for the 35 GM, as f/1.4 won't blur the background significantly more than the f/2 and I could instead pick up the Sigma 65 f/2 or Zony 55 f/1.8 and keep the Sigma 35 all for the same price (roughly) as the GM... And those longer lenses will supply more DOF control than the 35 GM.
If you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.
Just about every lens get sharper a couple stops down from wide open...just the nature of lens design.

The question to consider is if the 35 F2 is competently sharp enough wide open at F2 given real world use cases. The 35GM will undoubtedly be sharper at F2, but realistically most lenses releases these days are so competently sharp wide open that it isn't the first consideration anymore. i.e. the 85GM is not as sharp as the 135GM, but the superior rendering and easier to work with focal length take priority for me and I never feel the 85GM isn't sufficiently
...Show more →

I'm aware most lenses are sharper closed down a few stops. I'm talking about close up.

As in Fed's reveiw

"Close-up performance, SA and Focus Shift

The Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN focuses as close as 0.27m and at around this distance, there is noticeable spherical aberration (SA).
This optical design provides a great balance between ultimate resolution and pleasant rendering. At close distance, the lens performs best at f/3.2 where residual SA goes away."
Mar 09, 2021 at 09:44 AM
Mystik
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
fotografur wrote:
Mystik wrote
fotografur wrote
lukecookphoto wrote
chiron wrote
lukecookphoto wroteThank you!

Thanks very much! The last one has almost no post processing so I was very surprised by how well it turned out.
I like them all, but I especially like the first and the fourth. They have a sense of deep space and dark colors and variation rather than uniformity which makes them complex to look at. In the first picture especially, the sense of space is so cut up and varied that I kept thinking that I was looking at a collage. I had to make myself see that it was a single photograph. It really works.
One might be tempted to say... 3D pop

The results from this lens are so good that I am really second guessing whether I should go for the 35 GM, as f/1.4 won't blur the background significantly more than the f/2 and I could instead pick up the Sigma 65 f/2 or Zony 55 f/1.8 and keep the Sigma 35 all for the same price (roughly) as the GM... And those longer lenses will supply more DOF control than the 35 GM.
If you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.
Just about every lens get sharper a couple stops down from wide open...just the nature of lens design.

The question to consider is if the 35 F2 is competently sharp enough wide open at F2 given real world use cases. The 35GM will undoubtedly be sharper at F2, but realistically most lenses releases these days are so competently sharp wide open that it isn't the first consideration anymore. i.e. the 85GM is not as sharp as the 135GM, but the superior rendering and easier to work with focal length take priority for me and I never feel the 85GM isn't sufficiently sharp. It has tons of RSA wide open and this contributes to the rendering that it is beloved for.

I doubt anyone will ever say the 35 F2 is soft wide open. If you want test chart killing sharpness, get the 35GM. Looking at things comprehensively including the shooting experience....if you want a more compact option that renders well and is more that competent optically, then the 35i might be the better option and its cheaper to boot.
I'm aware most lenses are sharper closed down a few stops. I'm talking about close up.

As in Fed's reveiw

"Close-up performance, SA and Focus Shift

The Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN focuses as close as 0.27m and at around this distance, there is noticeable spherical aberration (SA).
This optical design provides a great balance between ultimate resolution and pleasant rendering. At close distance, the lens performs best at f/3.2 where residual SA goes away."


Ah ok apologies mis-read.

Yes its similar to the 85GM in this regard. If the RSA becomes problematic, then stop down even 1/3 stop and things improve, or frame a bit looser.

RSA isn't always a negative though. The reason the 35 tends to have more pleasing samples than the 65 is the slight glow wide open. Again similar to the 85GM
Mar 09, 2021 at 09:52 AM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.9 #9Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
JVan_02 wrote:
chiron wrote
JVan_02 wrote
fotografur wroteIf you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.
lukecookphoto wroteThat's true, from MFD the Sigma is not so great! If you get a bit further back from MFD it sharpens up nicely.

I'll have to look at some f/1.4 vs. f/2 examples on a 35mm and see how I feel. Seems like it'd be better to have a fast 55 or 65 for when I want to blow out backgrounds though as a 35 is still a 35.
chiron wroteGood point. I personally don't shoot a 35mm up close because I don't like distortion in my images, but for some people this would be a bit of difficulty. But the Voigtlander 40/1.2 had the same issue, and that didn't stop it becoming a favorite for many people.
Speaking as someone who has had to deal with RSA with the Batis 40 for a few years now, I will say the biggest impact you'll normally have with this is low light shooting indoors. To clarify: outdoors it's possible to distance yourself from a subject enough that f2 is usable—but indoors that isn't an option.

If a location has enough lighting, this won't be an issue. However, in poorly lit indoor conditions I find the glow up close exacerbates noise based image degradation. SA glow might not give a huge reduction in resolution, but the loss of contrast and halation makes things look... extra flat when you have the all-aspects image degradation that noise brings. I often find that within the range of RSA (with my 40—again, but that and the 35i look very similar in this regard) that despite the added noise, images look better stopped down to the point that RSA disappears.

If you have another lens to use in these conditions this won't be a problem at all. Just something I'd keep in mind if I were planning to use this lens in the described circumstances.
This is a shot indoors in very dim light with the Batis at f2.0 at 5000 ISO and underexposed by 2/3rds of a stop. Focus was on the dog's eyes.
Great image, saw it in the 40 image thread

To be even more pedantic, this is what Zeiss' forced aperture values (f2→2.5 at 0.6→.25m) are aimed at correcting and its a little difficult to get f2 RSA issues to manifest. I'd say that I've found at ~0.6-0.8m you can get the RSA-based image degradation to manifest under the right conditions... and it looks much better in black and white as you've shown. To be fair, I don't have a proper setup to do scientific testing. This is just observations from continued use, so I expect I'm a little off
...Show more →

I'd be very interested in seeing your examples with explanations/annotations if you can dig them up. Good way to learn about optical issues.

Ha! I just went up-thread and saw that you had decided to post the examples already! Well done!
Mar 09, 2021 at 10:02 AM
Dave Sanders
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
fotografur wrote:
Mystik wrote
fotografur wrote
lukecookphoto wrote
chiron wrote
lukecookphoto wroteThank you!

Thanks very much! The last one has almost no post processing so I was very surprised by how well it turned out.
I like them all, but I especially like the first and the fourth. They have a sense of deep space and dark colors and variation rather than uniformity which makes them complex to look at. In the first picture especially, the sense of space is so cut up and varied that I kept thinking that I was looking at a collage. I had to make myself see that it was a single photograph. It really works.
One might be tempted to say... 3D pop

The results from this lens are so good that I am really second guessing whether I should go for the 35 GM, as f/1.4 won't blur the background significantly more than the f/2 and I could instead pick up the Sigma 65 f/2 or Zony 55 f/1.8 and keep the Sigma 35 all for the same price (roughly) as the GM... And those longer lenses will supply more DOF control than the 35 GM.
If you shoot close though the GM looks to be the better lens. I read the Sigma f2 doesn't get very sharp up close unless you stop it down a few clicks.
Just about every lens get sharper a couple stops down from wide open...just the nature of lens design.

The question to consider is if the 35 F2 is competently sharp enough wide open at F2 given real world use cases. The 35GM will undoubtedly be sharper at F2, but realistically most lenses releases these days are so competently sharp wide open that it isn't the first consideration anymore. i.e. the 85GM is not as sharp as the 135GM, but the superior rendering and easier to work with focal length take priority for me and I never feel the 85GM isn't sufficiently sharp. It has tons of RSA wide open and this contributes to the rendering that it is beloved for.

I doubt anyone will ever say the 35 F2 is soft wide open. If you want test chart killing sharpness, get the 35GM. Looking at things comprehensively including the shooting experience....if you want a more compact option that renders well and is more that competent optically, then the 35i might be the better option and its cheaper to boot.
I'm aware most lenses are sharper closed down a few stops. I'm talking about close up.

As in Fed's reveiw

"Close-up performance, SA and Focus Shift

The Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN focuses as close as 0.27m and at around this distance, there is noticeable spherical aberration (SA).
This optical design provides a great balance between ultimate resolution and pleasant rendering. At close distance, the lens performs best at f/3.2 where residual SA goes away."


The 45/2.8 behaves this way as well, only worse. In the real world, it's very unusual that I'm close to MFD wide open as DOF is too shallow. But it is one of the tradeoffs the designers chose, so it's worth being aware of. Both the Sigma I and the Sony GM look excellent.
Mar 09, 2021 at 10:04 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

wolfloid
Offline
Details
p.9 #11Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
In the above examples of the boy, the sharpness and contrast in both examples looks excellent. If I keep looking from one to another, the second may be a very little sharper, and a tiny bit more contrasty. Nothing there that I would not expect as the difference between f2 and f2.8 (given slight differences in depth of field) in a very well corrected lens. How could you be even slightly dissatisfied? I'm baffled.
Mar 09, 2021 at 12:40 PM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.9 #12Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
wolfloid wrote:
In the above examples of the boy, the sharpness and contrast in both examples looks excellent. If I keep looking from one to another, the second may be a very little sharper, and a tiny bit more contrasty. Nothing there that I would not expect as the difference between f2 and f2.8 (given slight differences in depth of field) in a very well corrected lens. How could you be even slightly dissatisfied? I'm baffled.


What are you viewing this on? Just curious.

Anyway, like it if you want. No one is forcing you to have an opinion. But SA glow is a pretty divisive topic and to me the first picture (especially with the close up) looks like vaseline has been smeared over the front element.
Mar 09, 2021 at 01:19 PM
wolfloid
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
I'm viewing on an ipad pro. Depth of focus seems to cover most of the small difference. You really don't think your vaseline simile is simply excessive?
Mar 09, 2021 at 01:40 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.9 #14Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Might want to be very explicit about what lens was used when posting samples. Just to avoid misinterpretation/confusion.

Are these from the Batis 40, or Sigma 35i? I realize there is enough comment in the post to infer it's not the 35i, but I wonder how many people would just scan through and miss that.

JVan_02 wrote:
Decided to dig up the photos anyway. Here's the f2 version first:

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51019623146_07142d686b_h.jpg

And the close up. @lukecookphoto@ I'd say there is a bit of resolution loss along with the loss in contrast, again—not the same lens but it should translate.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51018894663_adca9e2f64_h.jpg

By contrast, here's the f2.8 version:

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51019719822_10e6e887bf_h.jpg

Corresponding close up:

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51018894853_418f4d22ae_h.jpg

In any case, unless proven otherwise I'd still expect the 35i to perform worse than a lens without RSA in poor lighting conditions.


Mar 09, 2021 at 01:42 PM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.9 #15Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
tsdevine wrote:
Might want to be very explicit about what lens was used when posting samples. Just to avoid misinterpretation/confusion.

Are these from the Batis 40, or Sigma 35i? I realize there is enough comment in the post to infer it's not the 35i, but I wonder how many people would just scan through and miss that.


The 40, and I actually say this in post (admittedly not at the header). However, from all I've seen in this way these two lenses fare similar (RSA wide open until ~1m). The 35i may be slightly better, but this is meant to be a broad strokes comparison.

wolfloid wrote:
I'm viewing on an ipad pro. Depth of focus seems to cover most of the small difference. You really don't think your vaseline simile is simply excessive?


No. Dunno if there is a difference between a good dedicated monitor and the pro, but I wouldn't call that excessive at all from what I'm seeing.
Mar 09, 2021 at 01:59 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.9 #16Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review

No argument for the reasoning for posting those. Just wasn’t clear what lens was involved:

JVan_02 wrote:
tsdevine wroteMight want to be very explicit about what lens was used when posting samples. Just to avoid misinterpretation/confusion.

Are these from the Batis 40, or Sigma 35i? I realize there is enough comment in the post to infer it's not the 35i, but I wonder how many people would just scan through and miss that.
The 40, and I actually say this in post (admittedly not at the header). However, from all I've seen in this way these two lenses fare similar (RSA wide open until ~1m). The 35i may be slightly better, but this is meant to be a broad strokes comparison.

wolfloid wroteI'm viewing on an ipad pro. Depth of focus seems to cover most of the small difference. You really don't think your vaseline simile is simply excessive?
No. Dunno if there is a difference between a good dedicated monitor and the pro, but I wouldn't call that excessive at all from what I'm seeing.

Mar 09, 2021 at 02:26 PM
moyang_mm
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
I am so excited to see these comparisons:


  1. Infinity Performance compared to Voigtlander 35mm f/2 APO-Lanthar
  2. Infinity Performance compared to Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM


Will they have their own dedicated FM Reviews?
Mar 09, 2021 at 02:36 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #18Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
moyang_mm wrote:
I am so excited to see these comparisons:


  1. Infinity Performance compared to Voigtlander 35mm f/2 APO-Lanthar
  2. Infinity Performance compared to Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM


Will they have their own dedicated FM Reviews?


Yes!
Mar 10, 2021 at 01:59 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #19Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Final Thoughts

The Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN is the lens Sony shooters were waiting for.

Besides being small, light and extremely well built, it has a balanced optical design capable of high resolution and contrast, without neglecting rendering. Landscape photographers take note: The Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN is flat-field at infinity distance. Axial and lateral chromatic aberration are both well corrected and above average for a 35mm lens. Some residual spherical aberration is visible which contributes to smooth rendering at transition zone in exchange for a slight resolution/contrast loss at close distance, especially MFD.

The only negative is noticeable optical vignetting which not only affects the specular highlights' shape off-axis (cat-eyes) but also affects rendering uniformity. Flare resistance and distortion are average compared to other 35mm lenses.

Pros:
  1. High resolution/contrast at infinity even wide open
  2. Smooth rendering at close and mid-distance
  3. Very low field curvature at infinity. Flat-field design
  4. Even resolution across the field without a mid-zone dip
  5. High tolerance metal build including features like aperture ring and AF-MF button
  6. Linear manual focus response
  7. Low axial and lateral color error
  8. Quick and accurate AF-S (CDAF) and AF-C (PDAF) modes.
  9. Well defined 18-point sunstar at f/20-22

Average:
  1. Moderate Barrel Distortion
  2. Flare resistance

Cons:
  1. Noticeable optical vignetting wide open which unfortunately is common with modern 35mm lenses
_________

Order the Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN: B&H Photo | Adorama

Mar 10, 2021 at 02:00 PM
nehemiahphoto
Online
Details
p.9 #20Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
Final Thoughts

The Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN could be the lens many Sony shooters were waiting for.

Besides being small, light and extremely well built, it has a balanced optical design capable of high resolution and contrast, without neglecting rendering. Axial and lateral chromatic aberration are both well corrected and above average for a 35mm lens. Some residual spherical aberration is visible which contributes to smooth rendering at transition zone in exchange for a slight resolution/contrast loss at close distance, especially MFD. Landscape photographer take note: The Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN is flat-field at infinity distance.

The main negative
...Show more →

Good summary list and thanks for the testing! 2 things which I find notable which you have not mentioned: it vignettes somewhat heavily all over the frame, and the coma correction is very good for 35, and much better than the FE 35/1.8
Mar 10, 2021 at 02:20 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister