fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses

  
 
Chuck Coyne
Offline
Details
p.70 #1Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
I think the 65mm's both are fantastic. I give a slight edge to the Sigma for overall rendering vs the CV but I wouldn't disappointed in either resulting shot. I guess it may come down to preference in a fully manual focus lens vs an AF lens that has exceptional manual focus capabilities for an AF lens.
Feb 07, 2021 at 07:06 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.70 #2Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Chuck Coyne wrote:
I think the 65mm's both are fantastic. I give a slight to the Sigma for overall rendering vs the CV but I wouldn't disappointed in either resulting shot. I guess it may come down to preference in a fully manual focus lens vs an AF lens that has exceptional manual focus capabilities for an AF lens.


If only the Sigma 65 did 1:2 macro....
Feb 07, 2021 at 08:35 AM
Tonzah78
Offline
Details
p.70 #3Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Interesting is that their 24mm does 1:2 macro. Which makes the lens especially fun and versatile. And on the long end I have the 105mm as well, so this feature missing from the 65mm is not a dealbreaker.

smpetty wrote:
If only the Sigma 65 did 1:2 macro....

Feb 07, 2021 at 11:07 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.70 #4Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Tonzah78 wrote:
Interesting is that their 24mm does 1:2 macro. Which makes the lens especially fun and versatile. And on the long end I have the 105mm as well, so this feature missing from the 65mm is not a dealbreaker.

smpetty wroteIf only the Sigma 65 did 1:2 macro....

What's the difference in macro working distance between the Sigma 24/2.5 and the CV 65/2 at 1:2?

You may have just made my decision easier

.... Google is my friend....

Looks like the working distances at MFD are 12" for the Voigtlander 65/2 and 4" for the Sigma 24/3.5 DG DN.
Feb 07, 2021 at 11:15 AM
ggweci
Offline
Details
p.70 #5Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Thanks very much for putting this together Juha. Much appreciated.

Regarding the 24, that I’m most interested in, the Sigma is definitely narrower. The fact that the Sonys and Minolta all look fairly similar, I would assume that they are closest to 24mm and that the Sigma is more like a 26mm (estimating). Probably pretty close to an incorrectly Sony 28mm f2.

Juha Kannisto wrote:
I compared the field of view between Sigma 24/3.5 DG DN, Sony 24/1.4 GM, Sony 24-105/4 G (at wide end) and Minolta 24/2.8 MD W.Rokkor, and then between Sigma 65/2 and CV 65/2 at near infinity.

I took comparison shots from balcony (handheld but I tried to keep framing identical, I took multiple shots and chose the best matches). Exported from Raw files in C1 Pro 21 to generate distortion-corrected and uncorrected JPEGs (using Manufacturer profile for each lens, which produces identical distortion correction to SOOC JPEGs when applied).

https://photos.app.goo.gl/knzv2ss1PSVcz1VDA

The order of the files in the folder didn't stay as
...Show more →
Feb 07, 2021 at 11:29 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.70 #6Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
tsdevine wrote:
The light was changeable, but it's snowing today and I had to work with what I was given. I tried to shoot in the windows where the lighting was stable. The EXIF is intact, you can verify the aperture. Shutter speed worked out to be the same between each lens (different though in the different framings.) The CV vignettes more.

Not sure it makes sense to stop the lens down to try to make the depth of field more equal. It seems to be apples to oranges to me.

For landscape sharpness, I think the CV wins. But for bokeh and rendering,
...Show more →
Petegh wrote
tsdevine wroteYes, you can definitely see he expanded depth of field. Notice that on the 50 APO too.

philip_pj wroteThx, Tim. One of the things I absolutely love about the mid FL Voigtlander APOs is the extended DOF wide open, the smooth context front to back. And the highlight sparkle. And the tonal separation. And the resulting image depth conveyed.
I'm having a hard time believing those were both shot at the same aperture: the Voigt looks like it has an extra stop of depth-of-field! I spose there might have been a slight change in light between shots, so you can't really use the shutter speed as a guide to the lenses' real T-stop; that said, did they have the same shutter speed Tim?
The Sigma has the smoother bokeh, but how much of that is due to the extra defocus? It might be worth stopping down the Sigma a bit Tim until we get equivalent depth of field - would make the comparison more apples-to-apples.
Overall though, to be able to trade blows with a reference lens like the Voit 65, the Sigma 65 does very, very well here.
At the very least, this comparison is a stark reminder of how real-world depth-of-field can vary between lenses: perhaps great rendering requires some sacrifice in depth-of-field?


At wide apertures, my copy of the 65/2 DG DN is definitely not as sharp as the CV 65/2 APO off-axis but I would not be surprised if they performed similarly at center.
The extreme edges need some stopping down to be excellent while the CV is already there at f/2 and f/2.8. For landscapes at f/4 and smaller, I don't think they would be too different at infinity.

So, I'd say both are great for landscapes but for everything else, it will depend if you prefer the option of 1:2 macro with visually no axial CA or AF with better rendering in a more compact and lighter lens.
Feb 07, 2021 at 11:42 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.70 #7Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
I was also giving a slight nod to the CV 65 (for landscapes) for broader depth of field at the same aperture (for those that don't focus stack like me), I think it gives you about a stop advantage. Also I would imagine it has better sunstars, although I haven't tested.

I didn't mean to apply that there was a huge difference in application. The macro capability of the CV is nice.

But I've sort have become enamored with the Sigma at wider apertures. And I often second guess taking the CV along due to its weight.

Fred Miranda wrote:
tsdevine wroteThe light was changeable, but it's snowing today and I had to work with what I was given. I tried to shoot in the windows where the lighting was stable. The EXIF is intact, you can verify the aperture. Shutter speed worked out to be the same between each lens (different though in the different framings.) The CV vignettes more.

Not sure it makes sense to stop the lens down to try to make the depth of field more equal. It seems to be apples to oranges to me.

For landscape sharpness, I think the CV wins. But for bokeh and rendering, I like the Sigma.

Petegh wrote
tsdevine wroteYes, you can definitely see he expanded depth of field. Notice that on the 50 APO too.

philip_pj wroteThx, Tim. One of the things I absolutely love about the mid FL Voigtlander APOs is the extended DOF wide open, the smooth context front to back. And the highlight sparkle. And the tonal separation. And the resulting image depth conveyed.
I'm having a hard time believing those were both shot at the same aperture: the Voigt looks like it has an extra stop of depth-of-field! I spose there might have been a slight change in light between shots, so you can't really use the shutter speed as a guide to the lenses' real T-stop; that said, did they have the same shutter speed Tim?
The Sigma has the smoother bokeh, but how much of that is due to the extra defocus? It might be worth stopping down the Sigma a bit Tim until we get equivalent depth of field - would make the comparison more apples-to-apples.
Overall though, to be able to trade blows with a reference lens like the Voit 65, the Sigma 65 does very, very well here.
At the very least, this comparison is a stark reminder of how real-world depth-of-field can vary between lenses: perhaps great rendering requires some sacrifice in depth-of-field?
At wide apertures, my copy of the 65/2 DG DN is definitely not as sharp as the CV 65/2 APO off-axis but I would not be surprised if they performed similarly at center.
The extreme edges need some stopping down to be excellent while the CV is already there at f/2 and f/2.8. For landscapes at f/4 and smaller, I don't think they would be too different at infinity.

So, I'd say both are great for landscapes but for everything else, it will depend if you prefer the option of 1:2 macro with visually no axial CA or AF with
...Show more →



Edited on Feb 07, 2021 at 06:10 PM · View previous versions
Feb 07, 2021 at 01:31 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.70 #8Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Given the well-earned warm reception to these lenses, it may not be long before they build out the range wider and longer. It turns out that 'slow'-small-light-machined metal lenses at the right price was a winning formula, provided aberration control was well-balanced with an attractive drawing style. It need not be either/or.

Feb 07, 2021 at 05:14 PM
itai195
Offline
Details
p.70 #9Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Yep. These seem like the lenses many of us have been wanting for ages. Love my CV lenses, but similarly impressive IQ and rendering in a similarly sized and well built package, with AF, is pretty compelling.
Feb 07, 2021 at 05:47 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.70 #10Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
And in a way, they might even act as gateway drugs to the manual focus lenses that already exist in the Sony ecosystem. It's a shorter step from the I lenses than from say, from the ART series. Soon, we may see these as very different lenses, in materials, utility, portability, even end usage like shooting locations and subject matter.

The Sigma page is worth a look for anyone interested in how a lens maker goes about developing their guiding principles and key concepts. They are a good company and many are delighted they are on board the Sony train.

https://www.sigma-global.com/en/lenses/cas/special/i-series/

Feb 07, 2021 at 06:49 PM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.70 #11Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Haha Sony knows it’s one of those focal lengths which everyone keeps asking for but if they bring it, nobody will buy

nehemiahphoto wrote:
No one loves 28mm...

And I just purchased the Samy 35 1.8–came yesterday. And now a Sigma and Gm 35. Lol. When I buy those, Sony will announce an RX1R3

Feb 08, 2021 at 07:38 AM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.70 #12Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Those who have had Sony 35/1.8 and this Sigma, which one will you take and why?
Sony focusses close and is 1.8, spec wise.
Feb 08, 2021 at 07:46 AM
Mystik
Offline
Details
p.70 #13Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
nandadevieast wrote:
Those who have had Sony 35/1.8 and this Sigma, which one will you take and why?
Sony focusses close and is 1.8, spec wise.


Sigma hands down. Rendering and build quality.

Think of the Sigma like an F2 GM caliber lens.

Feb 08, 2021 at 08:06 AM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.70 #14Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Mystik wrote:
Think of the Sigma like an F2 GM caliber lens.


Maybe I'm being super pedantic, but I feel like this is a little misleading. If I were going to equate it to anything, it would be the CV 35mm 1.7 Ultron. If we follow the latest G/GM primes we see a few themes in design that I feel would disqualify the Sigma from that comparison:
  1. Sealing
  2. Dual AF motors & utilization of said motors to achieve better MFDs/magnification than other lenses of their FL & spec
  3. No flaws (except CA) inside the plane of focus at any point in the focus range (Sigma has glow close up)
  4. Near maximum resolution wide open (Sigma is certainly good, but look at the graph from this post to see how they compare wide open)


Now, I don't mean to say the Sigma is a bad lens—far from it. But its design themes seem to take more cues from classical high quality manual mid-speeds than what Sony is doing with their G/GM primes as of late.

Edited on Feb 08, 2021 at 09:18 AM · View previous versions
Feb 08, 2021 at 09:02 AM
TakenWild
Offline
Details
p.70 #15Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
I’m really happy with the Tamron 35/2.8 for landscape. Though I don’t like it for people. Its AF isn’t great. I’m thinking if I should go with this sigma 35/2 to go with my Tamron. Would prefer the GM 35, but don’t know if I can justify the GM35. I could also sell my FE 55 and pick up a sigma 65/2 to make a sigma combo.

Landscape- Tamron 35/2.8 and VC APO 50/2
People- Sigma 35/2 and Sigma 65/2
Feb 08, 2021 at 09:07 AM
Alex W
Offline
Details
p.70 #16Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
nandadevieast wrote:
Those who have had Sony 35/1.8 and this Sigma, which one will you take and why?
Sony focusses close and is 1.8, spec wise.


I had one day left in my 30 day return period to return the Sony 35mm 1.8. The same day my Sigma 35mm F2 was to arrive at the house. That morning I took the risk and returned the Sony before the Sigma showed up. I already had the Sigma 65 and was very happy with it so unless there was a huge surprise I knew I would like the Sigma 35mm. Well I was right. The build quality compared to the Sony is way better. I already knew that. As soon as I unboxed and held the Sigma I knew I was dealing with top notch build quality. If you do any manual focusing the Sigma is a joy to manual focus with too. Personally I like the overall rendering a lot better on the Sigma. The Sony was plenty sharp enough but the images always were kind of boring and lifeless to me. It left me wanting more. Just my opinion.

Feb 08, 2021 at 09:15 AM
Mystik
Offline
Details
p.70 #17Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
JVan_02 wrote:
Mystik wroteThink of the Sigma like an F2 GM caliber lens.
Maybe I'm being super pedantic, but I feel like this is a little misleading. If I were going to equate it to anything, it would be the CV 35mm 1.7 Ultron. If we follow the latest G/GM primes we see a few themes in design that I feel would disqualify the Sigma from that comparison:
  1. Sealing
  2. Dual AF motors & utilization of said motors to achieve better MFDs/magnification than other lenses of their FL & spec
  3. No flaws (except CA) inside the plane of focus at any point in the focus range (Sigma has glow close up)
  4. Near maximum


Now, I don't mean to say the Sigma is a bad lens—far from it. But its design themes seem to take more ques from classical high quality manual mid-speeds than what Sony is doing with their G/GM primes as of late.
...Show more →

Fair point, but not all GM lenses fit all of those criteria either aside from being weather sealed. i.e. most do not have dual motors....35GM does not as far as I know. 85GM has a glow and CA wide open....not necessarily a bad thing as it lends to the character of the lens vs the more analytical rendering of the 135GM


Feb 08, 2021 at 09:25 AM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.70 #18Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Mystik wrote:
Fair point, but not all GM lenses fit all of those criteria either aside from being weather sealed. i.e. most do not have dual motors....35GM does not as far as I know. 85GM has a glow and CA wide open....not necessarily a bad thing as it lends to the character of the lens vs the more analytical rendering of the 135GM


I did qualify this statement as the latest G/GM primes. Arbitrarily, I'd make this distinction from the 24 GM, so this includes the 135 GM, the 20 G, and the 35 GM. Also, yes, the 35 has dual motors.

Rendering is a bit scattershot, which is why I didn't include this on the list, but I feel like if Sony's lens team has to make the choice between including an optical flaw and allowing better rendering (like with the 85 GM) or making sure the lens is eminently usable at every point in the range they go with the latter (135 GM). While the 20 G and 24 GM render similarly to the 85, they don't have glow in their plane of focus at any point. We'll have to wait for more reviews to come out and more copies to get in the wild, but at this point it seems the 35 is somewhere between the 24 and 135 GM.
Feb 08, 2021 at 09:34 AM
lifeandmylens
Online
Details
p.70 #19Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Alex W wrote:
nandadevieast wroteThose who have had Sony 35/1.8 and this Sigma, which one will you take and why?
Sony focusses close and is 1.8, spec wise.
I had one day left in my 30 day return period to return the Sony 35mm 1.8. The same day my Sigma 35mm F2 was to arrive at the house. That morning I took the risk and returned the Sony before the Sigma showed up. I already had the Sigma 65 and was very happy with it so unless there was a huge surprise I knew I would like the Sigma 35mm. Well I was right. The build quality compared to the Sony is way better. I already knew that. As soon as I unboxed and held the
...Show more →

I had an almost exact experience, agree completely.
Feb 08, 2021 at 09:35 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.70 #20Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Mystik wrote:
nandadevieast wroteThose who have had Sony 35/1.8 and this Sigma, which one will you take and why?
Sony focusses close and is 1.8, spec wise.
Sigma hands down. Rendering and build quality.

Think of the Sigma like an F2 GM caliber lens.


Agree 100%. Had the 35/1.8, kept the Sigma 35/2, Superior in every meaningful way.
Feb 08, 2021 at 09:44 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister