p.2 #2Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Astro and waterfalls are two ends of that spectrum...
vdo1 wrote: ftllens wroteImagine if all new GM lenses had built-in electronic variable ND. Imagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND
OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.
p.2 #3Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
tsdevine wrote:
Astro and waterfalls are two ends of that spectrum...
vdo1 wroteftllens wroteImagine if all new GM lenses had built-in electronic variable ND. Imagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND
OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.
Astro pictures with waterfalls in the frame? yay, would you take them with or without ND?
p.2 #4Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
vdo1 wrote: ftllens wroteImagine if all new GM lenses had built-in electronic variable ND. Imagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND
Plus a novel shutter with variable speed across the frame as to simulate graduated NDs.
OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.
It would be amazing if A7Sx had it. Fast UWA Zoom with NDs is for video usage, where shutter speed except specific situations allow you to change that.
p.2 #5Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
12 is notably wider than 14, but 14 is still very, very wide, and a lot of people don't need the extra width. I used to have a CV 12 and the Tamron 17-28, but sold both when I got the Sigma. I just didn't use the 12 enough to make too much of a difference. I did pick up a TTArtisan 11mm fisheye, which is a great lens, for when I need extreme width. (it also defishes very well for an ~11-12mm rectilinear view, or a ~9mm FOV on a partial defish).
shadow9d9 wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteWas anybody really asking for this? The Sigma 14-24 already kill its range...how about Sony releases a compact-ish 15 f2?12 is much wider than 14. I'd never consider the sigma because of this.
p.2 #6Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....
vdo1 wrote: tsdevine wroteAstro and waterfalls are two ends of that spectrum...
vdo1 wroteftllens wroteImagine if all new GM lenses had built-in electronic variable ND. Imagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND
OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.Astro pictures with waterfalls in the frame? yay, would you take them with or without ND?
p.2 #7Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
tsdevine wrote:
I was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteAstro and waterfalls are two ends of that spectrum...
vdo1 wroteftllens wroteImagine if all new GM lenses had built-in electronic variable ND. Imagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND
OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.Astro pictures with waterfalls in the frame? yay, would you take them with or without ND?
I got that, however I'm not sure that every lens has to address all possible photographic endeavors. If I were big time into waterfalls I would probably get a 16-35, they tend to accept round screw-in filters and an f/4 would be perfectly fine. And the focal range might be even better suited to it than 12-24.
Astro, although frequently quoted here as the reason why a particular lens fails the standards of the "connoisseurs", is not such a widely pursued purpose as to warrant the criticism - outside, of course, the astro dedicated forums. Those really into astro ended up anyway with some specialty lens and gear (including trackers and whatnot) and have their particular ways with the hobby.
p.2 #8Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I value the extra 2mm, similar to those who wouldn't consider the Sigma over the GM. But there are other areas that having the speed is useful, such as shooting indoors.
In any event, usefulness is more subjective to an individual and their priorities, so I understand where you are coming from.
Actually there are some waterfalls I like to shoot where 16mm is a little tight. But I probably wouldn't need 12mm that often, at least in my experience for what I shoot.
vdo1 wrote: tsdevine wroteI was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteAstro and waterfalls are two ends of that spectrum...
vdo1 wroteftllens wroteImagine if all new GM lenses had built-in electronic variable ND. Imagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND
OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.Astro pictures with waterfalls in the frame? yay, would you take them with or without ND? I got that, however I'm not sure that every lens has to address all possible photographic endeavors. If I were big time into waterfalls I would probably get a 16-35, they tend to accept round screw-in filters and an f/4 would be perfectly fine. Astro, although frequently quoted here as the reason why a particular lens fails the standards of the connoisseur, is not such a widely pursued purpose as to warrant the criticism - outside, of course, the astro dedicated forums. Those really into astro ended up anyway with some specialty lens and gear (including trackers and whatnot) and have their particular ways with the hobby.
p.2 #9Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I have the Sigma 14-24 and love it, but there were shots I got with the 12-24G in Paris that I couldn't have gotten with the 14-24 because 12mm is much wider than 14mm and it also gives a somewhat different creative perspective in some situations. There were shots I couldn't get handheld with the 12-24G indoors without getting lots of noise as I had to raise the ISO pretty high. I do love the image quality of the Sigma 14-24, but I would have to imagine this GM lens will be right up there and maybe not cause the sensor flare I sometimes get with the Sigma.
p.2 #10Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
tsdevine wrote:
I value the extra 2mm, similar to those who wouldn't consider the Sigma over the GM. But there are other areas that having the speed is useful, such as shooting indoors.
In any event, usefulness is more subjective to an individual and their priorities, so I understand where you are coming from.
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteAstro and waterfalls are two ends of that spectrum...
vdo1 wroteImagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND
OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.Astro pictures with waterfalls in the frame? yay, would you take them with or without ND? I got that, however I'm not sure that every lens has to address all possible photographic endeavors. If I were big time into waterfalls I would probably get a 16-35, they tend to accept round screw-in filters and an f/4 would be perfectly fine. Astro, although frequently quoted here as the reason why a particular lens fails the standards of the connoisseur, is not such a widely pursued purpose as to warrant the criticism - outside, of course, the astro dedicated forums. Those really into astro ended up anyway with some specialty lens and gear (including trackers and whatnot) and have their particular ways with the hobby.
Well I'm actually into "tourism" photo including hand held, dimly lit interiors. Not so much into waterfalls and practically zero astro. From the 12-24 G version experience, I can tell that, for my purpose, the GM would have indeed a lot of value with the interiors. And little drawbacks for my purpose except weight.
I suggested the 16-35 in the context of waterfalls and frequent use of ND, not interiors and dense cities.
p.2 #11Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
At first, the filter aspect of the Sigma really put me off, but I have to admit the Nisi setup is really nice. Being able to leave the filter mounted and having caps on both sides means it's very packable. Also having the rear slot for NDs will make it less painful than I had expected. I'm waiting for the Aurora rear NDs to ship.
Having so many options is a great thing. I remember back in the day there was all this noise around how the E mount may not be able to support a high quality UWA lens. Now we have primes covering 9, 10, 12, 14, 15, 18, 20, and 21 (maybe I missed one.) For zooms we have the 12-24/2.8, 12-24/4, 14-24/2.8, 16-35/2.8, 16-35/4 and 17-28/2.8. If you can't find a general solution, or one more suited to certain types of shooting you do, then it seems it's not due to lack of choices (except maybe for T/S, but you can adapt in a bind.)
Great time to be an E mount shooter.
-Tim
vdo1 wrote: tsdevine wroteI value the extra 2mm, similar to those who wouldn't consider the Sigma over the GM. But there are other areas that having the speed is useful, such as shooting indoors.
In any event, usefulness is more subjective to an individual and their priorities, so I understand where you are coming from.
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteAstro and waterfalls are two ends of that spectrum...Astro pictures with waterfalls in the frame? yay, would you take them with or without ND? I got that, however I'm not sure that every lens has to address all possible photographic endeavors. If I were big time into waterfalls I would probably get a 16-35, they tend to accept round screw-in filters and an f/4 would be perfectly fine. Astro, although frequently quoted here as the reason why a particular lens fails the standards of the connoisseur, is not such a widely pursued purpose as to warrant the criticism - outside, of course, the astro dedicated forums. Those really into astro ended up anyway with some specialty lens and gear (including trackers and whatnot) and have their particular ways with the hobby.Well I'm actually into "tourism" photo including hand held, dimly lit interiors. Not so much into waterfalls and practically zero astro. From the 12-24 G version experience, I can tell that, for my purpose, the GM would have indeed a lot of value with the interiors. And little drawbacks for my purpose except weight.
I suggested the 16-35 in the context of waterfalls and frequent use of ND, not interiors and dense cities.
p.2 #12Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
tsdevine wrote:
At first, the filter aspect of the Sigma really put me off, but I have to admit the Nisi setup is really nice. Being able to leave the filter mounted and having caps on both sides means it's very packable. Also having the rear slot for NDs will make it less painful than I had expected. I'm waiting for the Aurora rear NDs to ship.
Having so many options is a great thing. I remember back in the day there was all this noise around how the E mount may not be able to support a high quality UWA lens. Now we have primes covering 9, 10, 12, 14, 15, 18, 20, and 21 (maybe I missed one.) For zooms we have the 12-24/2.8, 12-24/4, 14-24/2.8, 16-35/2.8, 16-35/4 and 17-28/2.8. If you can't find a general solution, or one more suited to certain types of shooting you do, then it seems it's not due to lack of choices (except maybe for T/S, but you can adapt in a bind.)
Great time to be an E mount shooter.
-Tim
...Show more →vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI value the extra 2mm, similar to those who wouldn't consider the Sigma over the GM. But there are other areas that having the speed is useful, such as shooting indoors.
In any event, usefulness is more subjective to an individual and their priorities, so I understand where you are coming from.
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....
vdo1 wroteAstro pictures with waterfalls in the frame? yay, would you take them with or without ND? I got that, however I'm not sure that every lens has to address all possible photographic endeavors. If I were big time into waterfalls I would probably get a 16-35, they tend to accept round screw-in filters and an f/4 would be perfectly fine. Astro, although frequently quoted here as the reason why a particular lens fails the standards of the connoisseur, is not such a widely pursued purpose as to warrant the criticism - outside, of course, the astro dedicated forums. Those really into astro ended up anyway with some specialty lens and gear (including trackers and whatnot) and have their particular ways with the hobby.Well I'm actually into "tourism" photo including hand held, dimly lit interiors. Not so much into waterfalls and practically zero astro. From the 12-24 G version experience, I can tell that, for my purpose, the GM would have indeed a lot of value with the interiors. And little drawbacks for my purpose except weight.
I suggested the 16-35 in the context of waterfalls and frequent use of ND, not interiors and dense cities.
My problem with rear filters is that they still don't address the issue of water sprayed on that expensive, bulbous front element - from waterfalls, city fountains, ocean waves or whatever your water source is. Not to mention other sources of sticky dirt like kids with icecreams. Go Nisi.
p.2 #13Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
For waterfalls I always have a CPL mounted. If I were to shoot long exposures where I didn't want to remove reflections, I'd still have the CPL mounted, but I'd turn it to where it's opposite of where it would be for removing reflections. I often do that when shooting where I want reflections.
If I absolutely had to have a solution in a UWA zoom where it took screw in filters, I'd definitely look at the GM 16-35 or Tamron 17-28.
Anyway, I guess I'm really OT now. Hope the new GM is a killer lens.
vdo1 wrote: tsdevine wroteAt first, the filter aspect of the Sigma really put me off, but I have to admit the Nisi setup is really nice. Being able to leave the filter mounted and having caps on both sides means it's very packable. Also having the rear slot for NDs will make it less painful than I had expected. I'm waiting for the Aurora rear NDs to ship.
Having so many options is a great thing. I remember back in the day there was all this noise around how the E mount may not be able to support a high quality UWA lens. Now we have primes covering 9, 10, 12, 14, 15, 18, 20, and 21 (maybe I missed one.) For zooms we have the 12-24/2.8, 12-24/4, 14-24/2.8, 16-35/2.8, 16-35/4 and 17-28/2.8. If you can't find a general solution, or one more suited to certain types of shooting you do, then it seems it's not due to lack of choices (except maybe for T/S, but you can adapt in a bind.)
Great time to be an E mount shooter.
-Tim
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI value the extra 2mm, similar to those who wouldn't consider the Sigma over the GM. But there are other areas that having the speed is useful, such as shooting indoors.
In any event, usefulness is more subjective to an individual and their priorities, so I understand where you are coming from.
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....I got that, however I'm not sure that every lens has to address all possible photographic endeavors. If I were big time into waterfalls I would probably get a 16-35, they tend to accept round screw-in filters and an f/4 would be perfectly fine. Astro, although frequently quoted here as the reason why a particular lens fails the standards of the connoisseur, is not such a widely pursued purpose as to warrant the criticism - outside, of course, the astro dedicated forums. Those really into astro ended up anyway with some specialty lens and gear (including trackers and whatnot) and have their particular ways with the hobby.Well I'm actually into "tourism" photo including hand held, dimly lit interiors. Not so much into waterfalls and practically zero astro. From the 12-24 G version experience, I can tell that, for my purpose, the GM would have indeed a lot of value with the interiors. And little drawbacks for my purpose except weight.
I suggested the 16-35 in the context of waterfalls and frequent use of ND, not interiors and dense cities.My problem with rear filters is that they still don't address the issue of water sprayed on that expensive, bulbous front element - from waterfalls, city fountains, ocean waves or whatever your water source is. Not to mention other sources of sticky dirt like kids with icecreams. Go Nisi.
p.2 #18Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
vdo1 wrote: tsdevine wroteAt first, the filter aspect of the Sigma really put me off, but I have to admit the Nisi setup is really nice. Being able to leave the filter mounted and having caps on both sides means it's very packable. Also having the rear slot for NDs will make it less painful than I had expected. I'm waiting for the Aurora rear NDs to ship.
Having so many options is a great thing. I remember back in the day there was all this noise around how the E mount may not be able to support a high quality UWA lens. Now we have primes covering 9, 10, 12, 14, 15, 18, 20, and 21 (maybe I missed one.) For zooms we have the 12-24/2.8, 12-24/4, 14-24/2.8, 16-35/2.8, 16-35/4 and 17-28/2.8. If you can't find a general solution, or one more suited to certain types of shooting you do, then it seems it's not due to lack of choices (except maybe for T/S, but you can adapt in a bind.)
Great time to be an E mount shooter.
-Tim
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI value the extra 2mm, similar to those who wouldn't consider the Sigma over the GM. But there are other areas that having the speed is useful, such as shooting indoors.
In any event, usefulness is more subjective to an individual and their priorities, so I understand where you are coming from.
vdo1 wrotetsdevine wroteI was suggesting that this one lens could be used for both purposes. Would it make sense to have a 12-24/2.8 and 12-24/4 so you could take one when you were shooting astro....and then take the other when shooting waterfalls?
Just trying to point out the versatility that might have escaped you.
But maybe it didn't...as there is a smiley on the end of your post....I got that, however I'm not sure that every lens has to address all possible photographic endeavors. If I were big time into waterfalls I would probably get a 16-35, they tend to accept round screw-in filters and an f/4 would be perfectly fine. Astro, although frequently quoted here as the reason why a particular lens fails the standards of the connoisseur, is not such a widely pursued purpose as to warrant the criticism - outside, of course, the astro dedicated forums. Those really into astro ended up anyway with some specialty lens and gear (including trackers and whatnot) and have their particular ways with the hobby.Well I'm actually into "tourism" photo including hand held, dimly lit interiors. Not so much into waterfalls and practically zero astro. From the 12-24 G version experience, I can tell that, for my purpose, the GM would have indeed a lot of value with the interiors. And little drawbacks for my purpose except weight.
I suggested the 16-35 in the context of waterfalls and frequent use of ND, not interiors and dense cities.My problem with rear filters is that they still don't address the issue of water sprayed on that expensive, bulbous front element - from waterfalls, city fountains, ocean waves or whatever your water source is. Not to mention other sources of sticky dirt like kids with icecreams. Go Nisi.
My problem with rear filters is you expose both the camera innards and rear lens elements when you want to change the filter. Shooting at the ocean edge with blowing salt spray, this is not a good thing. On my 16-35 f4, I use a UV filter so I can quickly change out the filter for a clean one rather than taking the time to clean the filter...it can get so much spray that I rotate 3 different UV filters as I shoot.
p.2 #20Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
What's really impressive is how they managed to create a new technology that can forge camera lenses out of entire boat anchors. RIP any Sony a6xxx camera someone mounts this monster to without a tripod collar.