fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO

  
 
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #1RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
ChrisMak wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
ChrisMak wroteI shot Olympus 4/3 for years, and it was really hard to get decent subject isolation, even with a lens like the 14-35f2. I went from there to Aps-c and things got better, and from there to FF and things got a lot better again.
I would not want a 600mm f11 lens for the rendering alone. It will never be a good wildlife/birders lens due to insufficient subject isolation. Perhaps a good sports lens for beginners?
nandadevieast wroteThese lenses will make them get the customers from 1” and m43 systems. In those systems all the wildlife solutions have effective F11 aperture in full frame terms, and then there is fact that its a full frame sensor so ISO button will work better. So suddenly you have that small sensor capability on reach and equivalent light gathering capability plus in a minute you can attach a F1.2 lens if you so please.

Exception to this is 300 Pro and m43 combination which makes for 600 F8.

RX10 IV = F10.8
Light gathering capability = F4 neutralised by ISO capability of full frame sensor.
F/11 @ 600mm is roughly 5.6 at 300mm, or f/2.8 at 150mm, + the narrow fov lets you isolate against a given bg better.

So subject isolation shouldn't be a big problem.
I am not sure it works that way, as your subjects are going to be much further away and the surroundings will be much closer relatively than when shooting e.g. a portrait with a 150mm lens. I already find 700mm f8 to be a hard combo to get an attractive separation when shooting birds/wildlife further out.
But for sports, which does seem to be Canon's turf, it might work out well, as the subjects will be much larger in the frame and have lots or at least sufficient free space around them. I am betting these are sports oriented lenses,
...Show more →

600mm at f/11, 300/5.6, and 150/2.8 all require the same minimum diameter front element of about 54.5mm. Obviously if you don't like 700mm at f/8, you're not going to like 600 at f/11, but I tested 85/1.4 vs 200/2.8. Pretty similar front element/aperture diameter.

I liked the 200mm better, IIRC, because the narrow field allows you to get a certain bg more easily, for instance oof green instead of being able to see the shape of a tree. Also the green on the tree is spread out more. I really saw this comparing 50mm macro vs 180, although I can't recall if I equalized the apertures. I probably didn't. But I generally prefer the longer 180. Really obliterates the bg , smooths it. I should probably try f/3.5 on the 50 and f/13 on the 180

600mm f/11 is about 54.5mm vs 100/2 being 50mm. Plus the longer FL , so you should be able to eliminate a bg much more easily using 600/11.
Jun 10, 2020 at 03:48 PM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.4 #2RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
A Fresnel style light thrower would be great for these lenses.
Jun 10, 2020 at 04:18 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.4 #3RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Here's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF 1.4TC.
Jun 10, 2020 at 04:55 PM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.4 #4RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
Here's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF
...Show more →

No interest at all for me. Maybe the f8 versions more so the 800 at f8


Jun 10, 2020 at 05:00 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.4 #5RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
The big whites will come. Canon just wants to sell a bunch of low cost zooms first.
Jun 10, 2020 at 05:20 PM
ted1000
Offline
Details
p.4 #6RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
When I first saw these I had no interest in them (I have a 600 f4 II) but as I've been requested to do more video I'm thinking they may work quite well for that.

Ted
Jun 10, 2020 at 05:24 PM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.4 #7RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
Here's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF
...Show more →

If Sony didn't already have a great value 200-600mm with better aperture range, maybe. But Sony does have that lens and a great camera in the A9. Canon isn't going to win that battle with f/11 lenses. Even the Tamron and Sigma 150-600mm are more likely to draw away from an f/11 lens.
Jun 10, 2020 at 06:04 PM
AvianScott
Offline
Details
p.4 #8RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
Here's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF
...Show more →

800 or bust. If I'm buying an f/11 lens, I want all the reach I can get so long as the 600mm is not noticeably sharper.



Jun 10, 2020 at 06:35 PM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.4 #9RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
AvianScott wrote:
arbitrage wroteHere's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF 1.4TC.
800 or bust. If I'm buying an f/11 lens, I want all the reach I can get so long as the 600mm is not noticeably sharper.



+1 on all counts.
If they both performed the same including IQ then the 800 would be the only one I'd even consider being stuck @ f/11.

Perhaps the question should be... If someone offered either one of these to you for free, which would you choose?
f/11 is awful hard to swallow no matter how you slice it.

A run and gun light weight and small hiking wildlife lens is the only appeal these have to me. And only if they perform well at a ridiculously low price.
Golden hour shooting would be completely off the table.

Jun 10, 2020 at 07:38 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.4 #10RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
Here's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF
...Show more →
AvianScott wrote:
800 or bust. If I'm buying an f/11 lens, I want all the reach I can get so long as the 600mm is not noticeably sharper.

lighthound wrote:
+1 on all counts.
If they both performed the same including IQ then the 800 would be the only one I'd even consider being stuck @ f/11.

Perhaps the question should be... If someone offered either one of these to you for free, which would you choose?
f/11 is awful hard to swallow no matter how you slice it.

A run and gun light weight and small hiking wildlife lens is the only appeal these have to me. And only if they perform well at a ridiculously low price.
Golden hour shooting would be completely off the table.


f/11 is just too slow. I'm probably going to use the 200-600 if I can ever use a lens in 2021.

EBH
Jun 10, 2020 at 07:56 PM
2xbass
Offline
Details
p.4 #11RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Ok all you wildlife gurus, how many times do you stop down to f/11. I have it on good authority from someone at Canon rumours it's all the time as they look to justify these lenses.


I shoot almost nothing else except wildlife and shoot probably 99% of my shots wide open unless there is a specific reason I need greater DOF. That's 400 f2.8, 135 f1.8, 24 f1.4, etc. Those apertures are a huge part of the way I shoot, when I shoot, etc. and I can't imagine what it would be like to be forced to shoot at f11 on a 45 MP sensor.

If these f11 lenses become a reality, it will be really interesting to see what the market will be for such lenses. This would be prioritizing reach (and some carryability) above all else.
Jun 10, 2020 at 10:52 PM
Mike_5D
Offline
Details
p.4 #12RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
2xbass wrote:
Pixel Perfect wroteOk all you wildlife gurus, how many times do you stop down to f/11. I have it on good authority from someone at Canon rumours it's all the time as they look to justify these lenses.
I shoot almost nothing else except wildlife and shoot probably 99% of my shots wide open unless there is a specific reason I need greater DOF. That's 400 f2.8, 135 f1.8, 24 f1.4, etc. Those apertures are a huge part of the way I shoot, when I shoot, etc. and I can't imagine what it would be like to be forced to shoot at f11 on a 45 MP sensor.

If these f11 lenses become a reality, it will be really interesting to see what the market will be for such lenses. This would be prioritizing reach (and some carryability) above
...Show more →

There are always going to be people who want big reach but don't have $12k laying around or can't lug a giant lens and tripod up a mountain. Of course they'll never match the look of a Big White, but being newly designed primes, they'll likely be pretty sharp. I look forward to seeing samples.
Jun 11, 2020 at 12:06 AM
Mike_5D
Offline
Details
p.4 #13RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
These could make nice air show lenses. You can never have enough reach and if you're shooting prop planes or helicopters, you're stopped down anyway and panning which blurs the background.
Jun 11, 2020 at 12:25 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #14RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
Here's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF
...Show more →

If the 800 works out very well, and the 600 is dirt cheap and collapsible to 15-20 cm length, I might get the 600 in addition to the 800 as a toy lens / gap filler between a 70-200 and the 800. But never the 600 alone and not the 800.
Jun 11, 2020 at 12:53 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.4 #15RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
Here's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF
...Show more →

Basically - as AmbientMike already mentioned above - the size of the front element indicates the maximum background blur you can obtain; that would make the 600 less attractive to me compared to the 800. The real question is how these lenses compare to alternatives like e.g. a 5.6/400 with TC or in case of the 600 maybe even a cheap 70-300 zoom with TC, both regarding optics quality, size/weight and mechanics like AF speed, IS performance, accurate MF control etc. A long lens is a hassle to carry unless they have a very clever folding design, and such folding designs may increase weight and optical alignment problems (especially in long lenses).

Seems to me that Nikon made a FAR better spec choice with their PF lenses.
Jun 11, 2020 at 01:11 AM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.4 #16RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
lighthound wrote:
arbitrage wrote
alundeb wrote
EB-1 wroteThat's just ridiculous. Suddenly the Sony 20-600/6.3 seems fast by comparison.

EBH
In the big picture, 600 mm f/6.3 is on the fast side of things.

800 mm f/11 is on the slow side of things, but not exceptionally slow.

Let's take a look at the range of equivalent apertures of some 800 mm options:

#1: 800 mm f5.6 is the fastest option you can get for money and practically use. Either as 400/2.8 +2X, 600 + 1.4 or as 800 mm native. It is extremely expensive and only a very few photographers will ever get to touch one.

#2: 800 mm f/8 is very expensive and rather rare, but more manageable than f/5.6. Only availabale by using teleconverters or sensor areas smaller than 36x24mm. It is avaliable in zooms, but they are then again extremely expensive and very heavy for the aperture.

#3: 800 mm f/9 is only slightly slower than option #2, but the fastest realistic option for most enthusiasts and broadly available even as zooms. It is only 1 1/3 stops slower than the fastest option available.

#4: 800 mm f/11 is the most common option for advanced users not dedicated to very long focal lengths. It can be acheived by using a 2X teleconverter on many popular lenses, but still not considered to be for the masses. The Canon RF 800 mm f/11 DO IS STM is targeting to change that.

#5: 800 mm f/16 equivalent with a 1" sensor (Nikkor 70-300 f/5.6 on Nikon 1 cameras or RX10 IV cropped). This is an extremely size effective 800 mm equivalent option, and believe it or not it is possible to take good pictures with it.

#6: 800 mm f/30 equivalent in the Canon PowerShot SX40 HS. This is considered a slow and poor option. Almost 2 stops slower than the acceptable #5.
Beyond f/8 Canon won't even attempt AF
Well then I've had it with the Canon cripple hammer! My lowly 6DII is apparently severely flawed because the AF had no problem in very crappy light at f/22 on this shot last weekend.

6D Mark II
EF100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS II USM +1.4x III
ƒ/22
140mm
1/50
ISO 1600

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/49982244458_c1458ae0c3_h.jpg
Timber Rattler 2

And somehow, the AF worked again on this f/16 shot.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/49982766046_8bae642cc5_h.jpg
Timber Rattler 4

6D Mark II
EF100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS II USM +1.4x III
ƒ/16
560mm
1/80
ISO 1600

Not that any of that matters because the shots are destroyed by the notoriously pathetic DR of the 6DII anyhow.
I wish Canon would get their act together and
...Show more →

Nice shot, but stopping down for close-up is something altogether different to stopping down for subjects at large distances.

Well while R5 may get me back to owning a Canon camera, for the last three years I discovered the joy of using Nikon D500 and Sony A9, both of which are markedly better than any Canon camera I've used including 1DX for AF reliability. Also these long lens RF options aren't giving me confidence. I wish they'd publish a damn lens roadmap so I could see if they actually have something like a 600 f/5.6 DO or 800 f/8 DO down the track not to mention 300 f/2.8 and 500 f/4. I'm not jumping aboard until I know these super slow lenses aren't the only offerings. Currently I have the Nikon 500 f/5.6 PF and if they release a 600 f/5.6 PF I'm never leaving.
Jun 11, 2020 at 01:22 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #17RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
technic wrote:
arbitrage wroteHere's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF 1.4TC.
Basically - as AmbientMike already mentioned above - the size of the front element indicates the maximum background blur you can obtain; that would make the 600 less attractive to me compared to the 800. The real question is how these lenses compare to alternatives like e.g. a 5.6/400 with TC or in case of the 600 maybe even a cheap 70-300 zoom with TC, both regarding optics quality, size/weight and mechanics like AF speed, IS performance, accurate MF control etc. A long lens is a hassle to carry unless they have a very clever folding design, and such folding
...Show more →

I agree that generally a different spec, a bit shorter and brighter for the same lens class, would be more appealing. However these long designs may in theory give better image quality than using a teleconverter on f/5.6 to f/8 lenses. It is not impossible that the image quality of the RF 800 f/11 DO will be better than the 500/5.6 PF with the 1,7X TC or a Sigma 150-600 with 1.4X TC. So for the really long shots these new f/11 DO lenses have the potential to deliver the best image quality to cost or weight ratio. But then the image quality must not be like the 70-300 DO at 300 mm f/5.6.
Jun 11, 2020 at 01:26 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.4 #18RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
alundeb wrote:
technic wrote
arbitrage wroteHere's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF 1.4TC.
Basically - as AmbientMike already mentioned above - the size of the front element indicates the maximum background blur you can obtain; that would make the 600 less attractive to me compared to the 800. The real question is how these lenses compare to alternatives like e.g. a 5.6/400 with TC or in case of the 600 maybe even a cheap 70-300 zoom with TC, both regarding optics quality, size/weight and mechanics like AF speed, IS performance, accurate MF control etc. A long lens is a hassle to carry unless they have a very clever folding design, and such folding designs may increase weight and optical alignment problems (especially in long lenses).

Seems to me that Nikon made a FAR better spec choice with their PF lenses.
I agree that generally a different spec, a bit shorter and brighter for the same lens class, would be more appealing. However these long designs may in theory give better image quality than using a teleconverter on f/5.6 to f/8 lenses. It is not impossible that the image quality of the RF 800 f/11 DO will be better than the 500/5.6 PF with the 1,7X TC or a Sigma 150-600 with 1.4X TC. So for the really long shots these new f/11 DO lenses have the potential to deliver the best image quality to cost or weight ratio. But then
...Show more →

Not impossible that they are better than a traditional tele prime with TC, but it would require a significant jump in DO production technology. DO usually doesn't produce the highest quality optics due to imperfections and stability problems in the diffractive optics element that are almost unavoidable with current production technology for big DO elements. It could possibly be circumvented with technologies like 3D printing, but AFAIK that is still only used for really small DO stuff like microscope lenses. As these seem to be low-cost options (i.e. not like the 4/400DO II) I don't expect competitive IQ, more something for "getting the shot" like with the 55-250STM. And if these are more expensive like $3000 or so, I don't see the market potential with just f/11 aperture.
Jun 11, 2020 at 02:16 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #19RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
technic wrote:
alundeb wrote
technic wrote
arbitrage wroteHere's a question....if one can get past the f/11....would anyone on here opt for the 600 over the 800?

We know from the patent (unless it changed later) that the 600 is about 5.5cm shorter than the 800. And the 600 will have a smaller front element and presumably be lighter and less expensive.

The RF mount to sensor distance is 20mm so from the patent the 800 would be 37cm long and the 600 31.5cm long.

I don't think I'd ever go for the 600 in this class of lens. Certainly would have considered a 600 f/8 that could accept the RF 1.4TC.
Basically - as AmbientMike already mentioned above - the size of the front element indicates the maximum background blur you can obtain; that would make the 600 less attractive to me compared to the 800. The real question is how these lenses compare to alternatives like e.g. a 5.6/400 with TC or in case of the 600 maybe even a cheap 70-300 zoom with TC, both regarding optics quality, size/weight and mechanics like AF speed, IS performance, accurate MF control etc. A long lens is a hassle to carry unless they have a very clever folding design, and such folding designs may increase weight and optical alignment problems (especially in long lenses).

Seems to me that Nikon made a FAR better spec choice with their PF lenses.
I agree that generally a different spec, a bit shorter and brighter for the same lens class, would be more appealing. However these long designs may in theory give better image quality than using a teleconverter on f/5.6 to f/8 lenses. It is not impossible that the image quality of the RF 800 f/11 DO will be better than the 500/5.6 PF with the 1,7X TC or a Sigma 150-600 with 1.4X TC. So for the really long shots these new f/11 DO lenses have the potential to deliver the best image quality to cost or weight ratio. But then the image quality must not be like the 70-300 DO at 300 mm f/5.6.
Not impossible that they are better than a traditional tele prime with TC, but it would require a significant jump in DO production technology. DO usually doesn't produce the highest quality optics due to imperfections and stability problems in the diffractive optics element that are almost unavoidable with current production technology for big DO elements. It could possibly be circumvented with technologies like 3D printing, but AFAIK that is still only used for really small DO stuff like microscope lenses. As these seem to be low-cost options (i.e. not like the 4/400DO II) I don't expect competitive IQ, more something
...Show more →

The 55-250 STM is no slouch, comparable in image quality at 250 mm f/5.6 (wide open) to the 400/4 DO II + 1.4X TC on the 7DII.
Jun 11, 2020 at 02:28 AM
cpe1991
Offline
Details
p.4 #20RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
technic wrote:
cpe1991 wroteFocussing should not be a problem. I put a Kenco 3xTC on a 100-400mm II and found it focuses well at 1200mm f/16.8 using Liveview with a 5DIV and 90D. Diffraction limitation at f/11 is no big deal with 20-24 Mpx sensor on FF. Going from f/8 to f/11 for good lenses on a 50 Mpx 5DSR lowers MTF50 by about 10-15% according to measurements by opticallimits.
Maybe focusing is not a problem for completely static subjects, but moving subjects will be a big problem on almost any body. My 80D with 100-400II and 1.4TCIII is slow to acquire focus and unsuitable for most moving subjects (really big BIFs in perfect light moving in the right direction might work though).


It's your 80D that is the problem. You'd be amazed by a 5DIV and even a 5DSR is better.
Jun 11, 2020 at 04:56 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister