fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO

  
 
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.15 #1RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
nandadevieast wrote:
Can someone explain to me how 600/F11 will be different from the 600/F4 lens in Sony RX10 IV, which is 600/F10.8 full frame equivalent.


The 220mm f/4 lens is the Sony RX10 IV has to resolve 2.7 X more lines per mm than the 600 mm f/11 on a FF sensor, because the image is enlarged more after capture to get to the same output size. When it comes to diffraction, the end result is the same, but when it comes to lens design, it should be easier to design the longer lens with better characteristics.

On the sensor side, if you have enough light, the FF sensor will be able to capture a much wider dynamic range at base ISO, with more tonality, and of course if you are resolution hungry there is no substitute for a real 50'ish MP sensor.
Jul 07, 2020 at 12:27 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.15 #2RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
alundeb wrote:
nandadevieast wroteCan someone explain to me how 600/F11 will be different from the 600/F4 lens in Sony RX10 IV, which is 600/F10.8 full frame equivalent.
The 220mm f/4 lens is the Sony RX10 IV has to resolve 2.7 X more lines per mm than the 600 mm f/11 on a FF sensor, because the image is enlarged more after capture to get to the same output size. When it comes to diffraction, the end result is the same, but when it comes to lens design, it should be easier to design the longer lens with better characteristics.

On the sensor side, if you have enough light, the FF sensor will be able to capture a much wider dynamic range at base ISO, with more tonality, and
...Show more →

Yes, but it still was a good question for much of the target market for these lenses as both provide about 20 MP at 600mm equivalent when using the more affordable R bodies (that are still much more expensive including the lens). Would be interesting to see how big the IQ difference is in practice (given other contraints like light levels, atmospheric distortion etc.) and if it is worth the extra cost, size and weight. Interestingly, while R has a much bigger sensor the weight difference with RX10 IV isn't huge, about 1450 against 1095 gram.
Jul 07, 2020 at 02:54 AM
luminaire
Offline
Details
p.15 #3RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
nandadevieast wrote:
Can someone explain to me how 600/F11 will be different from the 600/F4 lens in Sony RX10 IV, which is 600/F10.8 full frame equivalent.


That 'full frame equivalence' is only in terms of DoF and confuses many photographers.

The '600mm' end of the Sony lens is actually physically 220mm and is indeed f/4; it lets in that amount of light. That's why it takes 72mm filters. There's no 'equivalence', it has a 55mm aperture at that focal length. Basic physics.

The Canon lenses are truly f/11 in terms of exposure.
Jul 07, 2020 at 03:36 AM
koenkooi
Offline
Details
p.15 #4RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Nokishita reports that they will be below GBP 1000, that's a lot cheaper than I expected!
Jul 07, 2020 at 03:49 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.15 #5RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
The leaked UK prices of 699 for the 600DO and 929 for the 800DO are closer to what I thought these would have to come in at to make any sense.

I'm not sure how those prices translate into USD $. I saw that UK price of Canon 100-400II is 1999 pounds and US is $2199 currently. RF70-200/2.8 is $2699 USD and $2599 pounds. So those UK prices are probably really close to the US price.

But those do seem like reasonable prices...



Edited on Jul 07, 2020 at 06:19 AM · View previous versions
Jul 07, 2020 at 05:03 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.15 #6RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
More photos...

If you zoom in you can now clearly see the word "Lock" for that rear most ring. The silver ring being the control ring and thankfully placed in a proper position for handholding a lightweight super-tele.





























Jul 07, 2020 at 05:04 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.15 #7RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
More photos...

If you zoom in you can now clearly see the word "Lock" for that rear most ring. The silver ring being the control ring and thankfully placed in a proper position for handholding a lightweight super-tele.


The focus ring (I guess it is a MF ring) is pretty close to the camera which isn't great with such a long and probably front-heavy lens. I have the same problem with the 100-400II, it is very uncomfortable to do hand-held MF because the MF ring is too close to the lens mount. Older primes like the 2.8/200L and 4/300 IS have much better focus ring position.
Jul 07, 2020 at 07:18 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.15 #8RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
technic wrote:
arbitrage wroteMore photos...

If you zoom in you can now clearly see the word "Lock" for that rear most ring. The silver ring being the control ring and thankfully placed in a proper position for handholding a lightweight super-tele.
The focus ring (I guess it is a MF ring) is pretty close to the camera which isn't great with such a long and probably front-heavy lens. I have the same problem with the 100-400II, it is very uncomfortable to do hand-held MF because the MF ring is too close to the lens mount. Older primes like the 2.8/200L and 4/300 IS have much better focus ring position.


It is not really that close once in extended position for the 600/800. Or were you talking about the 100-500?
I guess the 800 is still not in the best position but the 600 looks pretty good.









Jul 07, 2020 at 07:31 AM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.15 #9RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Even Canon has 54mm aperture so no difference. If we put the Sony lens in front of a hypothetical full frame sensor, it will be 220/4 but right now its on a cropped sensor to give 600mm/10.8 FOV.

RX10 being F4 will take in more light but has a small sensor so that advantage is negated. (You can use higher ISOs on full frame but its F11).

I thought both packages are similar but there may be differences I don’t understand.

luminaire wrote:
nandadevieast wroteCan someone explain to me how 600/F11 will be different from the 600/F4 lens in Sony RX10 IV, which is 600/F10.8 full frame equivalent.
That 'full frame equivalence' is only in terms of DoF and confuses many photographers.

The '600mm' end of the Sony lens is actually physically 220mm and is indeed f/4; it lets in that amount of light. That's why it takes 72mm filters. There's no 'equivalence', it has a 55mm aperture at that focal length. Basic physics.

The Canon lenses are truly f/11 in terms of exposure.

Jul 07, 2020 at 09:18 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.15 #10RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
The leaked UK prices of 699 for the 600DO and 929 for the 800DO are closer to what I thought these would have to come in at to make any sense.

I'm not sure how those prices translate into USD $. I saw that UK price of Canon 100-400II is 1999 pounds and US is $2199 currently. RF70-200/2.8 is $2699 USD and $2599 pounds. So those UK prices are probably really close to the US price.

But those do seem like reasonable prices...



Man! Those are incredibly affordable prices! I hope that's true and if that 800 holds up to reasonable IQ then I'll have a fantastic pocket friendly wildlife lens to go hiking with in the very near future.


Geesh, things are getting exciting in the GAS world. Who would have thought we would have an 800mm lens this tiny just a year ago.
Jul 07, 2020 at 09:48 AM
JaimitoFrog
Offline
Details
p.15 #11RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
I think with STM, this may end up to be a good wildlife movie lens. Damn cheap too. If the AF is fast enough, might pick one up.
Jul 07, 2020 at 09:50 AM
bobbytan
Offline
Details
p.15 #12RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Cheap it certainly is, but remember that you get what you pay for. Some things have to give but we don’t know what yet, aside from the slow aperture and some diffraction penalty. Canon is not being charitable to us! They exist to make money, so those lenses are possibly costing them half as much to make.

lighthound wrote:
arbitrage wroteThe leaked UK prices of 699 for the 600DO and 929 for the 800DO are closer to what I thought these would have to come in at to make any sense.

I'm not sure how those prices translate into USD $. I saw that UK price of Canon 100-400II is 1999 pounds and US is $2199 currently. RF70-200/2.8 is $2699 USD and $2599 pounds. So those UK prices are probably really close to the US price.

But those do seem like reasonable prices...
Man! Those are incredibly affordable prices! I hope that's true and if that 800 holds up to reasonable IQ then I'll have a fantastic pocket friendly wildlife lens to go hiking with in the very near future.

Geesh, things are getting exciting in the GAS world. Who would have thought we would have an 800mm lens this tiny just a year ago.
Jul 07, 2020 at 10:06 AM
JohanEickmeyer
Offline
Details
p.15 #13RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
If the USA prices are lower than rumored, or even equal, those primes are going to sell many, many copies. I can't imagine the image quality of the 600 and 800 will be anything short of excellent. Canon doesn't really make bad primes these days, at any price point.
Jul 07, 2020 at 10:10 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.15 #14RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
technic wrote
arbitrage wroteMore photos...

If you zoom in you can now clearly see the word "Lock" for that rear most ring. The silver ring being the control ring and thankfully placed in a proper position for handholding a lightweight super-tele.
The focus ring (I guess it is a MF ring) is pretty close to the camera which isn't great with such a long and probably front-heavy lens. I have the same problem with the 100-400II, it is very uncomfortable to do hand-held MF because the MF ring is too close to the lens mount. Older primes like the 2.8/200L and 4/300 IS have much better focus ring position.
It is not really that close once in extended position for the 600/800. Or were you talking about the 100-500?
I guess the 800 is still not in the best position but the 600 looks pretty good.


You are right: I only looked at the separate lens pictures: in extended position it looks better (but still not great).
---------------------------------------------

lighthound wrote:
arbitrage wroteThe leaked UK prices of 699 for the 600DO and 929 for the 800DO are closer to what I thought these would have to come in at to make any sense.

I'm not sure how those prices translate into USD $. I saw that UK price of Canon 100-400II is 1999 pounds and US is $2199 currently. RF70-200/2.8 is $2699 USD and $2599 pounds. So those UK prices are probably really close to the US price.

But those do seem like reasonable prices...
Man! Those are incredibly affordable prices! I hope that's true and if that 800 holds up to reasonable IQ then I'll have a fantastic pocket friendly wildlife lens to go hiking with in the very near future.

Geesh, things are getting exciting in the GAS world. Who would have thought we would have an 800mm lens this tiny just a year ago.


Makes you wonder why they are not offering such lens for their EF(S) customers, who number probably 100x more and might be a more suitable audience for such a relatively cheap lens than those who are now rushing to buy into the expensive R system

Obviously Canon wants to lure R customers with these lenses but as they are pretty "niche" it still is weird.
If Canon wants to suggest the EF-M and EF(-S) lines are not yet EOL, they should offer it with at least EF mount as well.
Jul 07, 2020 at 10:30 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.15 #15RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
bobbytan wrote:
Cheap it certainly is, but remember that you get what you pay for. Some things have to give but we don’t know what yet, aside from the slow aperture and some diffraction penalty. Canon is not being charitable to us! They exist to make money, so those lenses are possibly costing them half as much to make.

lighthound wrote
arbitrage wroteThe leaked UK prices of 699 for the 600DO and 929 for the 800DO are closer to what I thought these would have to come in at to make any sense.

I'm not sure how those prices translate into USD $. I saw that UK price of Canon 100-400II is 1999 pounds and US is $2199 currently. RF70-200/2.8 is $2699 USD and $2599 pounds. So those UK prices are probably really close to the US price.

But those do seem like reasonable prices...
Man! Those are incredibly affordable prices! I hope that's true and if that 800 holds up to reasonable IQ then I'll have a fantastic pocket friendly wildlife lens to go hiking with in the very near future.

Geesh, things are getting exciting in the GAS world. Who would have thought we would have an 800mm lens this tiny just a year ago.


Oh there is no doubt these won't be L class lenses and there will certainly be compromises, but at that price I don't really care. I want a long lens to literally stuff into a pocket (albeit a large one) and not have to worry about trashing a $6k - $12k lens. If you accidentally drop it off a cliff 2 years after purchase just run out and grab another one, with only a small tear in your eye.
Most of my weekend hikes involve driving a fair distance with my wife and mutt and then hiking back in a ways. By that time there is usually lots of light so the f/11 wont kill me too much for this type of shooting. If I were to go out specifically for wildlife, leaving the wife and mutt at home and getting up well before dawn, then I'd take my 500II f/4 and leave the slow glass at home.

I view these lenses like the nifty-fifty but with an extra zero in the price.
Jul 07, 2020 at 10:37 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.15 #16RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
technic wrote:
arbitrage wrote
technic wrote
arbitrage wroteMore photos...

If you zoom in you can now clearly see the word "Lock" for that rear most ring. The silver ring being the control ring and thankfully placed in a proper position for handholding a lightweight super-tele.
The focus ring (I guess it is a MF ring) is pretty close to the camera which isn't great with such a long and probably front-heavy lens. I have the same problem with the 100-400II, it is very uncomfortable to do hand-held MF because the MF ring is too close to the lens mount. Older primes like the 2.8/200L and 4/300 IS have much better focus ring position.
It is not really that close once in extended position for the 600/800. Or were you talking about the 100-500?
I guess the 800 is still not in the best position but the 600 looks pretty good.
You are right: I only looked at the separate lens pictures: in extended position it looks better (but still not great).
---------------------------------------------

lighthound wrote
arbitrage wroteThe leaked UK prices of 699 for the 600DO and 929 for the 800DO are closer to what I thought these would have to come in at to make any sense.

I'm not sure how those prices translate into USD $. I saw that UK price of Canon 100-400II is 1999 pounds and US is $2199 currently. RF70-200/2.8 is $2699 USD and $2599 pounds. So those UK prices are probably really close to the US price.

But those do seem like reasonable prices...
Man! Those are incredibly affordable prices! I hope that's true and if that 800 holds up to reasonable IQ then I'll have a fantastic pocket friendly wildlife lens to go hiking with in the very near future.

Geesh, things are getting exciting in the GAS world. Who would have thought we would have an 800mm lens this tiny just a year ago.
Makes you wonder why they are not offering such lens for their EF(S) customers, who number probably 100x more and might be a more suitable audience for such a relatively cheap lens than those who are now rushing to buy into the expensive R system

Obviously Canon wants to lure R customers with these lenses but as they are pretty "niche" it still is weird.
If Canon wants to suggest the EF-M and EF(-S) lines are not yet EOL, they should
...Show more →

With smaller sensors there are equivalent options already, like third party zooms to 400/6.3,. Canon must have something in mind though. There are rumors about EF-M 100-300 mm f/5.6 - f/8 being on the roadmap.
Jul 07, 2020 at 10:45 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.15 #17RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
JohanEickmeyer wrote:
If the USA prices are lower than rumored, or even equal, those primes are going to sell many, many copies. I can't imagine the image quality of the 600 and 800 will be anything short of excellent. Canon doesn't really make bad primes these days, at any price point.


As far as I can tell, they traded on all the "right" things. Don't try to make it physically short. Keep the MFD long. This has been the recipe of the excellent old primes like the 400/5.6 and 300/4 non-IS. Further: Perfect use case for DO element. Make the build quality adequate but not L grade. In theory, they have done nothing that should compromise the image quality. I am a bit anxious about the DO element, but on the positive side it has always meant high resolving power wide open, even field and low CA. All good in my book.
Jul 07, 2020 at 10:52 AM
NonDecaf
Offline
Details
p.15 #18RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Canon always seems to anchor themselves with some kind of bread-and-butter market segment. It was the new-kid/vacationing couple with their rebels, I guess now its.. birders/wild-life enthusiasts? I'm guessing we're going to see some crazy kit pricing with the RP and these lenses. I think Canon did the right thing with these lenses, it doesn't threaten the 1DX and 600 III buyers, and it gives Canon time to deliver a knockout R1 body that can hopefully drive the EF super tele glass like native RF.

bobbytan wrote:
Cheap it certainly is, but remember that you get what you pay for. Some things have to give but we don’t know what yet, aside from the slow aperture and some diffraction penalty. Canon is not being charitable to us! They exist to make money, so those lenses are possibly costing them half as much to make.

lighthound wrote
arbitrage wroteThe leaked UK prices of 699 for the 600DO and 929 for the 800DO are closer to what I thought these would have to come in at to make any sense.

I'm not sure how those prices translate into USD $. I saw that UK price of Canon 100-400II is 1999 pounds and US is $2199 currently. RF70-200/2.8 is $2699 USD and $2599 pounds. So those UK prices are probably really close to the US price.

But those do seem like reasonable prices...
Man! Those are incredibly affordable prices! I hope that's true and if that 800 holds up to reasonable IQ then I'll have a fantastic pocket friendly wildlife lens to go hiking with in the very near future.

Geesh, things are getting exciting in the GAS world. Who would have thought we would have an 800mm lens this tiny just a year ago.
Jul 07, 2020 at 10:56 AM
ilkka_nissila
Offline
Details
p.15 #19RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO

A DSLR cannot autofocus an f/11 lens in the normal way, through the viewfinder. Thus, such lenses are not realistically usable on DSLRs for the typical applications (wildlife).
Jul 07, 2020 at 11:02 AM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.15 #20RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
I expect the IQ to be as good as the long end of a great zoom, say 100-400 or the 100-500 that’s coming. The compromise is in F number, shouldn’t be in IQ.
Jul 07, 2020 at 11:03 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister