Dustin Gent wrote:
Depends on the situation for sure. I know there was a trend for a while when the amazing Canon lenses came out, same as the Loxia and Voightlander lenses.
If a sunstar evokes emotion in an image, I will include it, but obviously personal preference.
This one at Mesa Arch taken with Nikon 14-24 I actually liked. The sunstars from that lens weren't known to be amazing, but they can render sunstars I do like. It isn't in the same league as my Leica 35-70R, and it renders crazy sunstars even wide-open
But most times I like shots w/o sunstars, like the last image. I have a shot of this with the sunstar, but again easily can turn into a distraction ...Show more →
Dustin, my view of your first two images results my eyes focusing onto the sunstars and not onto the nice scenes. Sunstars are typically one of the brightest areas in the image which draws your view and attention...away from what you were trying to capture in the first place. I feel your scenes would be better without the sunstar distractions...like in your 3rd image.
Sunstars in urban night images, not landscapes
Thin over thick rays
Short over long rays
Regular over irregular rays
Many blades over few blades
Odd over even number of blades
chez wrote: Hardcore wroteTo me, it's a tool in your bag. Much like I'd rather have a lens that doesn't flare shooting into the sun, I'd much rather have a lens that produces nice sun stars/effects vs a mess of streaks/globs that reduce contrast and truly do ruin the image because they are way too long.
Not sure what is so gimmicky about shooting into the sun or bright light sources and wanting it to look the best it can.Gimmicky because when looking at that scene with my eyes, I don't see the sunstars. It's an artifact of the lens...just like flare, that is overused or almost forced.
Agree to disagree. I also like highlight bokeh. Also something you can't see with your eyes and is an artifact of the lens but I live on the edge that way.
I like the sunstars in these images. They don’t dominate the scene and emphasize the rising (or setting) sun. Your compositional talent is key here. When a sunstar dominates an image, I’m distracted by it and not usually a fan.
What I find amusing is the Nays being most vocal in opposition whilst the Yays, with the clear majority (easily over all other options put together) have little or nothing to say!
Anyway personally I like them so long as they don't dominate the shot.
p.2 #10What is your preference regarding sunstars?
I will say that I like sun stars mostly with wider angle lenses. After 50mm, I usually don't like them in my own pictures.
They are a bit like a spice. Too much of any one spice will ruin the soup. However, judiciously applied, it can enhance the flavor (or composition). Nice to have the option of including it or not. Too bad no one has come up with a lens where one can change the shape of the aperture blades on the fly.
p.2 #11What is your preference regarding sunstars?
I like well defined sun stars. That’s why the Loxia and Voigtlander lenses are so nice. I don’t shoot into the sun often, but when used judiciously sun stars can add a nice effect when needed. So what if my eyes don’t see them? When has photography ever been about recording stark reality? Your eyes don’t see bokeh either.
p.2 #14What is your preference regarding sunstars?
mudlake wrote:
I like well defined sun stars. That’s why the Loxia and Voigtlander lenses are so nice. I don’t shoot into the sun often, so used judiciously sun stars can add a nice effect when needed. So what if my eyes don’t see them? When has photography ever been about recording stark reality? Your eyes don’t see bokeh either.
Those are my favourite lenses too .. and why I prefer primes, just so I can continue using them, (though Sony is making that decision harder to sustain)
p.2 #15What is your preference regarding sunstars?
A regrettably flawed and biased poll since the absence of a negative option ensures that those of us who hate sunstars have effectively been denied a vote. (And no, “I try to avoid sunstars, I shoot at large apertures with ND filters” isn’t a genuine negative option.)
p.2 #17What is your preference regarding sunstars?
I like them when sun is in the image, prefer 8-12 pointed ones.
They seem natural to me, they somehow represent the fact that you can’t actually look at the sun without damage, and the star somehow gives the feeling of eye skidding around the sun, as it does in reality. A plain round bright but is suitable for the 🌓!
p.2 #18What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Sunstars can add some interest to a well composed image. My all time favorite sunstar lens is the Loxia 21. This lens can't help but to create beautiful sunstars. OTOH I don't think I've ever created an image with intentional sunstar(s) other than a few test shots.
p.2 #19What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Some rather heated opinions here.
I'm in the "like sunstars camp". Love the Loxia and Voigtlander sunstars.
I can understand not liking them, or thinking they are gimmicky, and I certainly get not liking them becoming such a dominating part of the composition that it overpowers an image.
But I also think they can be used to great effect to add a dynamic element to the scene, and I think they look beautiful in certain scenes.
I do NOT get the argument that they are unnatural. Yeah, no crap. You know what else is "unnatural"? Smoothed water/clouds with ND shots, bokeh, seeing the image compression/distortion when shooting at long telephoto FLs or ultrawide FLs, any image of landscape astrophotography, distracting elements of a picture removed in Photoshop, color toning an image to reflect the mood you felt when viewing the scene, focus stacking 36 images with front to back sharpness humanly impossible, and many other things. And yet we often use these other techniques to create an image that tells a story.
p.2 #20What is your preference regarding sunstars?
A photograph should be about the subject, not the equipment used to make the image.
If the lens intrudes into the image, IMO it ruins it.
Sun stars are the worst offense.
Just my opinion. I'm sure its not unanimous.