I think those that like sun stars, like myself, have a preference for them in wide angle to normal glass most often used for landscape/cityscape type pics. However, for longer focal lengths and especially lenses used most often for portraits, I like rounded aperture blades which avoid sun stars and produce rounder OOF highlights. Thus, I think the preference really depends upon usage.
I find sunstars to be distracting. Beautiful landscapes become dominated by this unnatural lens effect. To me, sunstars often feel contrived and out of place in images meant to convey natural beauty.
There are some blue hour and night scenes, IMO, where sunstars from artificial lights add interest without becoming the star of the show, pun intended.
Ultimately the value of sunstars is in the eye of the beholder.
I prefer the natural look of an odd number of blades myself. The sharp, defined stars that the Loxia 21 lens produces were cool at first but got kinda repetitive.
I prefer an even number of blades, producing few but large and well defined sunrays
I prefer an odd number of blades, producing many subdued sunrays
Even or odd number of blades does not dictate how well defined or subdued sunstars can be.
This is a function of the shape of the aperture blades, being straight or curved, plus the size of the aperture opening.
I try to avoid sunstars, I shoot at large apertures with ND filters
Some lenses are capable of well-defined sunstars even at large apertures. Using a ND filter won't avoid sunstars...
_________
In my opinion, well-defined sunstars can be aesthetic pleasant for night shooting and landscapes.
I like the one with Batis 18, maybe a bit too large, I think f/8 would had been better
Oct 05, 2019 at 10:24 AM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #11What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Usually I couldn't care less.
Besides, I live in St. Petersburg - the original one, not the one down in FL. For us here, the sun is like the Holy Grail: lots of people talk about it but few can prove to have really seen it.
p.1 #12What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Fred Miranda wrote: Earlier quoteI prefer an even number of blades, producing few but large and well defined sunrays
I prefer an odd number of blades, producing many subdued sunraysEven or odd number of blades does not dictate how well defined or subdued sunstars can be.
This is a function of the shape of the aperture blades, being straight or curved, plus the size of the aperture opening.
Earlier quoteI try to avoid sunstars, I shoot at large apertures with ND filtersSome lenses are capable of well-defined sunstars even at large apertures. Using a ND filter won't avoid sunstars...
_________
In my opinion, well-defined sunstars can be aesthetic pleasant for night shooting and landscapes.
Well there are many subtleties to it, in Phillip’s examples page one can see that some lenses will make sharper, thinner rays, while others will make broader, imprecise ones, although they share the same number and type of blades. What is 100% reproducible though is that even bladed lens will produce lesser, but more clearly defined rays - one per blade. While the odd bladed ones will produce twice as many rays as number of blades, and they tend to also create a light ball in the center that make the rays appear shorter and subdued.
p.1 #13What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Depends on the situation for sure. I know there was a trend for a while when the amazing Canon lenses came out, same as the Loxia and Voightlander lenses.
If a sunstar evokes emotion in an image, I will include it, but obviously personal preference.
This one at Mesa Arch taken with Nikon 14-24 I actually liked. The sunstars from that lens weren't known to be amazing, but they can render sunstars I do like. It isn't in the same league as my Leica 35-70R, and it renders crazy sunstars even wide-open
But most times I like shots w/o sunstars, like the last image. I have a shot of this with the sunstar, but again easily can turn into a distraction
p.1 #15What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Funny, for daytime shooting it's not something I usually consider/care about, but I like the effect when shooting scenes at night that have street lights, etc.
p.1 #17What is your preference regarding sunstars?
To me, it's a tool in your bag. Much like I'd rather have a lens that doesn't flare shooting into the sun, I'd much rather have a lens that produces nice sun stars/effects vs a mess of streaks/globs that reduce contrast and truly do ruin the image because they are way too long.
Not sure what is so gimmicky about shooting into the sun or bright light sources and wanting it to look the best it can.
Oct 06, 2019 at 08:40 AM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #18What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Jesting aside, I get a bit of sunstars shooting stopped down (way down...) nightscapes in the city, but I never looked upon them as a quantifiable lens parameter. Let alone the one that might, for someone, make or break a lens choice / purchase. O_o
p.1 #20What is your preference regarding sunstars?
Hardcore wrote:
To me, it's a tool in your bag. Much like I'd rather have a lens that doesn't flare shooting into the sun, I'd much rather have a lens that produces nice sun stars/effects vs a mess of streaks/globs that reduce contrast and truly do ruin the image because they are way too long.
Not sure what is so gimmicky about shooting into the sun or bright light sources and wanting it to look the best it can.
Gimmicky because when looking at that scene with my eyes, I don't see the sunstars. It's an artifact of the lens...just like flare, that is overused or almost forced.