realVivek wrote:
I have no idea why you are obsessed with the 35/1.8 that you returned.
Let go if you can.
There are no onion rings from that lens. Not in my use.
It is not what this thread is about, nor what my post was about. I was making a joke-notice the smiley emoji. I do think, however, since you mention it, that those onion rings under the WOW sign are not any worse than a number of examples I have seen with the Sony 35 f/1.8. If that is the worst of it, which it may not be, then I don't think there is any more reason to be worried about onion rings on this lens more than there is to be worried about onion rings on the Sony 35 f/1.8.
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I got mine today and did some shooting at lunch break and after work with my A9. The weather was pretty good. Mostly used f4 and f2. It works very nicely in low light at f2 for long distance shots too. The handling and weight are very nice and the hood is very light even if a bit long. Mine has optimal infinity pretty much at the center of the infinity symbol but hard infinity is further than that so need to pull back.
Thanks for these! The images are remarkable in being technically unremarkable, in respect to the lack of anything obviously bad about its optical performance. Neutral would seem to be the word that comes to mind. Would have been nice to have an M-mount variant of the design. Hopefully it will eventually find its way to other mirrorless mounts, too... Looks like a lens that you just use and not have to think about.
realVivek wrote:
Under the Wow sign there are OOF highlights showing vestiges of onion rings. For me, not too objectionable but there may be some who would list it in their cons.
If I'm seeing what you're seeing, I don't think those are vestiges of onion rings. It's more likely some of the distant point light sources were extremely close together, which resulted in that repeating pattern of the hard edge of the bokeh ball. Looking through the many other photos with OOF specular lights in the background and I didn't see any trace of onion rings where the bokeh ball was clearly from a single point light source.
rscheffler wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI got mine today and did some shooting at lunch break and after work with my A9. The weather was pretty good. Mostly used f4 and f2. It works very nicely in low light at f2 for long distance shots too. The handling and weight are very nice and the hood is very light even if a bit long. Mine has optimal infinity pretty much at the center of the infinity symbol but hard infinity is further than that so need to pull back.
Some SOOC Jpeg samples:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/AN6jEUxMBAMRtKSG9realVivek wroteUnder the Wow sign there are OOF highlights showing vestiges of onion rings. For me, not too objectionable but there may be some who would list it in their cons.If I'm seeing what you're seeing, I don't think those are vestiges of onion rings. It's more likely some of the distant point light sources were extremely close together, which resulted in that repeating pattern of the hard edge of the bokeh ball. Looking through the many other photos with OOF specular lights in the background and I didn't see any trace of onion rings where the bokeh ball was clearly from a single point light source.
Thank you for the long response!
I am increasingly appreciating the MF with the CV65. I quickly found focus peaking annoying and focused more on magnify, but sometimes you miss the event. thanks for sharing your technique i'm going to experiment with it imagesfromobjects wrote:
Thanks! I'm kinda obsessed with this stuff, so please excuse a long response, but since you asked...
I have a standing, bi-weekly gig documenting life at a preschool, as well as a toddler at home, so I've had ample time to practice. This has led to a few other paid gigs, but it's mostly just a labor of love. I love the "sport" of street/candid photography, and I love the unpredictability of kids, so it's all good.
Beyond just "practice, practice, practice" there are a few more technical things that help. Basically, I try to use a single MF lens until I know its haptics without looking. Often, this means knocking against the infinity hard stop and pulling back to pre-specified distances until the throw becomes embedded into muscle memory where 1m and 2m are. Sometimes I lay in bed at night just doing this. That's probably weird, but hey.
When photographing moving subjects, a shutter speed of 1/250s is essential as a bare minimum, unless you want to deliberately show motion blur, or the subjects are getting tired out. >1/500 is ideal. Also, shallow DOF is awesome, but sometimes it's smarter to stop down to f/2.2 or so just to get some wiggle room and still retain OOF backgrounds. Other thing to do is set Creative Style to +1 or 2 Contrast, and *maximum* sharpness. This is faster than focus peaking or engaging focus magnify, because you will see a moire "shimmer" where things are truly in focus. Practice shooting in bursts of 3 to 5 frames without moving, or while tracking a moving subject. Try to pre-focus on a stationary object in a plane of focus where a subject is bound to step. Try to track not only laterally, but also incoming and outgoing subjects. Especially when working with kids, try to anticipate when subjects will be (more) still and devise non-intrusive ways to get them to look up, because nobody wants to see pics of the tops of heads. Most importantly, cull hard and immediately. It's already been proven that HCB's "Decisive Moment" was an ideal of sorts (see: https://erickimphotography.com/blog/debunking-the-myth-of-the-decisive-moment) - that even the guy who was a true master of capturing poignant moments in sublime compositions sometimes felt compelled to stage his results, or direct his subjects into a "re-do" of a shot, so I don't feel too dogmatic about any of this. As long as the results look natural and are reasonably in-focus, I'm happy.
Granted, I've never used an a9 with eye-af or anything, but I stand by MF, even for kids.
*Edit - oops, sorry should have re-sized those.
DannyBurkPhoto wroteJust a guess, but I'm wondering whether the percentage of MF lovers is higher among those who've used it for many years (i.e. back when there were no AF lenses) compared to those who grew up using AF and/or digital from the start.
I'm not typical in that I'm basically a 4x5 shooter who converted to digital only 4 years ago. For the previous 20 years, I'd shot 4x5, 5x7, and a variety of medium format film, but no 35mm since the '90s. Of course all of these were manual focus only. When I converted to digital, I sold all of my film equipment at the same time, and it was quite an adjustment getting used to everything simultaneously! Eventually I did, but I retain many of my old ways. I always say that I treat all of my cameras as little view cameras; no, not viewing upside-down or with a darkcloth, but nearly always on a tripod, cable- or IR release, slow and precise composition, etc.
I've tried AF several times, and simply don't like it. I trust my own MF abilities to get more precise focus (proven multiple times by comparisons...results are close, but my manually focused examples are nearly always a little sharper at the point of focus), it makes so many things easier (such as selecting point of focus, keeping it there without the camera changing it, etc), and although it may not affect the final result, the pleasure and good feel of using a real MF lens such as Voigtlander or Zeiss.
Anyway, all of this really only applies to me. Someone else's needs will be different - maybe a little, maybe a lot. And that's how it should be, I think - variety is good, no?
Great that I have received notice from Cameraquest that they have shipped the lens. Hopefully, all others who preordered from the first batch will have a similar email. All the best, John
Vivek, it's mostly residual busy-ness with a more emphatic outline, you see it in the distinctive outer frame cats eyes too. Doesn't occur often for me so may be easy to say, and it's very high up the scale of 'unnecessary noticing', IMO.
Juha's Xmas trees (and other images, thank you!) tell the tale, very impressive contrast/colour indeed and note: low-medium ISO. It loves low light. How about that light column, second last image. OOC.
High ISO flattens colour tonality, a good demo above, where red-orange separation suffers. Agree with Ron, you supply the creativity but be prepared to be punished for transgressions, like driving a high-powered car with poor tyres. Inside its envelope, it's a 'stand and deliver' lens. It won't like flat light, but CV's colour model will save the day.
'What impressed me at the assembly site was the lens adjustment using the MTF measuring device installed in parallel with the world of craftsmanship. The APO-Lanthar 50mm f2...is not simply assembled, but is constructed while measuring and adjusting the optical axis and lens spacing.'
'Design and manufacturing have continued to evolve little by little due to the accumulation of technology and know-how over the past 20 years. I think we couldn't make the APO-Lanthar 50mm f2 20 years ago.'
I really really like the colour and rendition from this lens. I have a feeling it will do some really nice things with B&W also. Pop and 3D but without the much harsher look of a zeiss.
You may glimmer some more insight from the lenses character.
Bokeh ball tests... shape (centre and corners)/array/content/bokeh rendering + Table Top...bokeh rendering/colours
Vignette f2 test WYSIWYG (No Profile)
Vignette f2.8 test (Dissipates quickly on 1 stop)
Thanks all for the informative photo's! I just heard I missed out on the first batch by one 😢. So now I can look forward to the lens for a bit longer. 😕😁
It is a long story... bottom line is they never refunded my payment 10 days ago due to a misunderstanding and held onto my order.
I got it today.
Thanks, Daniel!
If you visit here (The Hague)in the weekend, you can check it out yourself! Drop me a line.
DanielBB wrote:
Thanks all for the informative photo's! I just heard I missed out on the first batch by one 😢. So now I can look forward to the lens for a bit longer. 😕😁
This is just a note on the declicking feature. Probably too obvious a thing for most on this forum, particularly video people but since I just figured it out I thought I would detail how it works. Apologies if this has been previously described.
We are all familiar with the red green and blue diagonal bars on the front of the lens. On the rear side of the lens, there is a single yellow line. To engage the declicking feature you push down on the two small raised grips at the top of the lens and then turn until the yellow line replaces the white dot. The feature seems as well engineered as the rest of the lens. All the best, John