pasblues wrote:
I stopped putting much stock in opinions here..... but I admit that I tend to be more about content than rendering.
How to win friends and influence people.
Have you thought about spending less time in the gear forums where many actually care about rendering and more time in the content forums where your real interests can be discussed?
genji wrote: pasblues wroteSo, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.---------------------------------------------
pasblues wroteIf you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.
These are so good...
Nah. Yeah, I shoot manual focus primarily and find it lands a more efficient keeper rate for moving subjects than AF, but I use 3-5 frame bursts for toddler events. The "decisive moment" happens in LR *wink wink*
rscheffler wrote:
Near identical is not the same as identical. Minor differences in a fraction of a second can make a big difference, such as facial expressions, open or closed eyes, etc. Sometimes those are very difficult to anticipate while looking through a viewfinder, especially if it is an EVF with very slight lag. In another vein, I just shot a football game yesterday and produced several thousand images. None of the peak action images at 14fps were identical, let alone similar because the high speed motion of the subjects changed so much between frames.
There is a place for both... and tools relevant to each.
It just annoys me slightly, the notion that single-frame decisive moments are the pinnacle of photographic talent.
Wow, I think that's the first time Cosina has actually published MTFs for a lens!...Show more →Steve Spencer wroteGiven the published MTFs, I am not worried about sharpness. I will be very surprised if it isn't very sharp, but I am very interested in and have much less confidence in whether I will like the rendering so I very much appreciate the samples. It is a beginning of some indication of what the rendering is like.
genji wrote: pasblues wroteSo, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.---------------------------------------------
pasblues wroteIf you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.
Well, to be fair. Each one of these images it is obvious to me the zone of focus was set up prior to the action taking place. Which is common for most famous older "action" shots. And if you look at most famous shots that are spontaneous they are rarely "in focus". That said focus is not the determining factor always in a powerful image. In fact blur or lack of focus can benefit an image, but I would have to say that the majority of the time it was not intended. Look, I love the process of using MF lenses. And have used MF lenses to capture many action shots over the years (with alittle planning, skill, and luck). Very satisfying. But AF provides much more consistent results obviously. AF allows you to capture a moment in time you just can't with MF (without relying on being lucky) I mean let's be realistic. The 50 APO is going to be an excellent lens but it is not designed for action. So I think it is fair to state it is for slow or non- moving subjects. That is not a slight on the lens in my opinion.
DannyBurkPhoto wrote: pasblues wroteI'm not sure why a person would buy a MF lens over the Sony 55 f1.8 ZA, which is amazing and very close to the same price as this new one. I understand optics can be interesting so I think the 50mm f2 would be interesting as an add-on in the 50 range. But I wouldn't get rid of the 55mm f1.8. I'm curious enough I'd like to review the F2 and compare.
Comes down to it, though, MF is going to be slower and missed shots will result. So, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.Well, I guess mainly it comes down to different points of view and different needs. I have a huge preference for MF lenses, but I don't shoot anything that can move under its own power. I do have a few AF lenses because they have abilities or qualities unique to themselves, but they're used only in MF mode.
On the other hand, I utterly loathe everything about the Zony 55/1.8. Rendering, terrible cyan CA, and worst for me, MF that's close to unusable. So bad that it kept me from trying another FBW lens for a couple of years, until I learned that they had improved a lot in MF usability since that time.
I've already told myself that I don't need the Voigt 50/2 apo-lanthar. I have multiple others that I can use, but I have no doubt that seeing reviews, I'll feel myself compelled to have it anyway. ...Show more →
Agree I never saw any redeeming factor in the 55mm. Even any AF lens I have it has to manual focus and the 55 is horrendous at MF. As far as this 50 2 I’ll probably get it for a small kit for travel Cv21 3.5 which I just repurchased. Leica 75 1.5 M and this lens would be great. I know the CV 40 may gap better but a really well corrected 50 would be nice to have.
On AF I’m having thoughts of the Sigma 24-70 along with my 12-24 and call it a day with my 85,135. I’m in a downsizing mode.
nhsonyshooter wrote: genji wrotepasblues wroteSo, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.---------------------------------------------
pasblues wroteIf you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.Well, to be fair. Each one of these images it is obvious to me the zone of focus was set up prior to the action taking place. Which is common for most famous older "action" shots. And if you look at most famous shots that are spontaneous they are rarely "in focus". That said focus is not the determining factor always in a powerful image. In fact blur or lack of focus can benefit an image, but I would have to say that the majority of the time it was not intended. Look, I love the process of using MF lenses. And have used MF lenses to capture many action shots over the years (with alittle planning, skill, and luck). Very satisfying. But AF provides much more consistent results obviously. AF allows you to capture a moment in time you just can't with MF (without relying on being lucky) I mean let's be realistic. The 50 APO is going to be an excellent lens but it is not designed for action. So I think it is fair to state it is for slow or non- moving subjects. That is not a slight on the lens in my opinion....Show more →
And I was one of the photographers who "successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented" I hate to burst the romantic bubble but It was a PITA. If any of us had had AF back then, we'd have used it.
pasblues wrote: nhsonyshooter wrotegenji wrotepasblues wroteSo, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.---------------------------------------------
pasblues wroteIf you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.Well, to be fair. Each one of these images it is obvious to me the zone of focus was set up prior to the action taking place. Which is common for most famous older "action" shots. And if you look at most famous shots that are spontaneous they are rarely "in focus". That said focus is not the determining factor always in a powerful image. In fact blur or lack of focus can benefit an image, but I would have to say that the majority of the time it was not intended. Look, I love the process of using MF lenses. And have used MF lenses to capture many action shots over the years (with alittle planning, skill, and luck). Very satisfying. But AF provides much more consistent results obviously. AF allows you to capture a moment in time you just can't with MF (without relying on being lucky) I mean let's be realistic. The 50 APO is going to be an excellent lens but it is not designed for action. So I think it is fair to state it is for slow or non- moving subjects. That is not a slight on the lens in my opinion.And I was one of the photographers who "successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented" I hate to burst the romantic bubble but It was a PITA. If any of us had had AF back then, we'd have used it.
Extrapolating your beliefs across the entire human race is usually a losing argument.
pasblues wrote: nhsonyshooter wrotegenji wrotepasblues wroteSo, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.---------------------------------------------
pasblues wroteIf you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.Well, to be fair. Each one of these images it is obvious to me the zone of focus was set up prior to the action taking place. Which is common for most famous older "action" shots. And if you look at most famous shots that are spontaneous they are rarely "in focus". That said focus is not the determining factor always in a powerful image. In fact blur or lack of focus can benefit an image, but I would have to say that the majority of the time it was not intended. Look, I love the process of using MF lenses. And have used MF lenses to capture many action shots over the years (with alittle planning, skill, and luck). Very satisfying. But AF provides much more consistent results obviously. AF allows you to capture a moment in time you just can't with MF (without relying on being lucky) I mean let's be realistic. The 50 APO is going to be an excellent lens but it is not designed for action. So I think it is fair to state it is for slow or non- moving subjects. That is not a slight on the lens in my opinion.And I was one of the photographers who "successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented" I hate to burst the romantic bubble but It was a PITA. If any of us had had AF back then, we'd have used it.
tsdevine wrote:
Extrapolating your beliefs across the entire human race is usually a losing argument.
pasblues wrotenhsonyshooter wrotegenji wrotepasblues wroteSo, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.---------------------------------------------
pasblues wroteIf you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.Well, to be fair. Each one of these images it is obvious to me the zone of focus was set up prior to the action taking place. Which is common for most famous older "action" shots. And if you look at most famous shots that are spontaneous they are rarely "in focus". That said focus is not the determining factor always in a powerful image. In fact blur or lack of focus can benefit an image, but I would have to say that the majority of the time it was not intended. Look, I love the process of using MF lenses. And have used MF lenses to capture many action shots over the years (with alittle planning, skill, and luck). Very satisfying. But AF provides much more consistent results obviously. AF allows you to capture a moment in time you just can't with MF (without relying on being lucky) I mean let's be realistic. The 50 APO is going to be an excellent lens but it is not designed for action. So I think it is fair to state it is for slow or non- moving subjects. That is not a slight on the lens in my opinion.And I was one of the photographers who "successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented" I hate to burst the romantic bubble but It was a PITA. If any of us had had AF back then, we'd have used it.
You're RIGHT! I'm sure there are some holdovers who loved manually focusing and refused to use AF.
pas blues wrote: If you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.
genji wrote: Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.
nhsonyshooter wrote: Well, to be fair. Each one of these images it is obvious to me the zone of focus was set up prior to the action taking place. Which is common for most famous older "action" shots. And if you look at most famous shots that are spontaneous they are rarely "in focus". That said focus is not the determining factor always in a powerful image. In fact blur or lack of focus can benefit an image, but I would have to say that the majority of the time it was not intended. Look, I love the process of using MF lenses. And have used MF lenses to capture many action shots over the years (with alittle planning, skill, and luck). Very satisfying. But AF provides much more consistent results obviously. AF allows you to capture a moment in time you just can't with MF (without relying on being lucky) I mean let's be realistic. The 50 APO is going to be an excellent lens but it is not designed for action. So I think it is fair to state it is for slow or non- moving subjects. That is not a slight on the lens in my opinion.
pasblues wrote: And I was one of the photographers who "successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented" I hate to burst the romantic bubble but It was a PITA. If any of us had had AF back then, we'd have used it.
nhsonyshooter wrote: Not sure who your quoting but that was not me?
Would you also agree that if you look at the set of people who enjoy photography as a profession or a hobby, only a small subset participates on forums. Within that set, a smaller subset participates on FM forums. Within that set, there is probably a higher percentage of photographers who enjoy manual focus than the percentage would be for the larger set of photographers on a whole. I am going out on a limb here, completely open on that.
Tim
pasblues wrote: tsdevine wroteExtrapolating your beliefs across the entire human race is usually a losing argument.
pasblues wrotenhsonyshooter wrotegenji wrotepasblues wroteSo, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.---------------------------------------------
pasblues wroteIf you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.Well, to be fair. Each one of these images it is obvious to me the zone of focus was set up prior to the action taking place. Which is common for most famous older "action" shots. And if you look at most famous shots that are spontaneous they are rarely "in focus". That said focus is not the determining factor always in a powerful image. In fact blur or lack of focus can benefit an image, but I would have to say that the majority of the time it was not intended. Look, I love the process of using MF lenses. And have used MF lenses to capture many action shots over the years (with alittle planning, skill, and luck). Very satisfying. But AF provides much more consistent results obviously. AF allows you to capture a moment in time you just can't with MF (without relying on being lucky) I mean let's be realistic. The 50 APO is going to be an excellent lens but it is not designed for action. So I think it is fair to state it is for slow or non- moving subjects. That is not a slight on the lens in my opinion.And I was one of the photographers who "successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented" I hate to burst the romantic bubble but It was a PITA. If any of us had had AF back then, we'd have used it.You're RIGHT! I'm sure there are some holdovers who loved manually focusing and refused to use AF.
I only use MF lenses—I find myself to have better control over the images I produce using them, to be more engaged in the process, and to enjoy the whole experience more. I don’t care about “missing” images—I do care about missing moments and being present in them. To me, that’s a foundational element of a great image. I probably don’t produce great images, but I learn a lot and take great pleasure in trying to do so, as part of being present in a moment.
Everything is moving. Hence everything I photograph is moving. Some things move faster than others—that’s where art, composition, and technique come in. Those things may be facilitated by technology, including AF, or undermined by them, depending on the artist, tools, and circumstances.
Use what you like to make images you like in the way you like. I can imagine this being different for each of us, as we all see the world from unique perspectives.
I am a landscape photographer only and so mf is preferred for me. I am coming from a large format camera and still now use a tripod and even a focusing cloth over the LCD. MF is probably funky to some but for me funky is having to push a button on a camera body to lower the aperture and another button to increase the aperture. I am also one of the few perhaps who uses a 50mm lens as my main lens. Many of St. Ansel’s most iconic landscapes were shot with a 50mm lens equivalent. And lastly, I really like and trust Voigtlander. They seem to be a company driven by photographers, this 50mm will give me a lens set of three with the 21mm 3.5 and 110mm. To the earlier poster, I haven’t received an email this AM with shipment info from Cameraquest but they are a California company. I will post here when i get the notice if that will be helpful. All the best everyone, John
Just a guess, but I'm wondering whether the percentage of MF lovers is higher among those who've used it for many years (i.e. back when there were no AF lenses) compared to those who grew up using AF and/or digital from the start.
I'm not typical in that I'm basically a 4x5 shooter who converted to digital only 4 years ago. For the previous 20 years, I'd shot 4x5, 5x7, and a variety of medium format film, but no 35mm since the '90s. Of course all of these were manual focus only. When I converted to digital, I sold all of my film equipment at the same time, and it was quite an adjustment getting used to everything simultaneously! Eventually I did, but I retain many of my old ways. I always say that I treat all of my cameras as little view cameras; no, not viewing upside-down or with a darkcloth, but nearly always on a tripod, cable- or IR release, slow and precise composition, etc.
I've tried AF several times, and simply don't like it. I trust my own MF abilities to get more precise focus (proven multiple times by comparisons...results are close, but my manually focused examples are nearly always a little sharper at the point of focus), it makes so many things easier (such as selecting point of focus, keeping it there without the camera changing it, etc), and although it may not affect the final result, the pleasure and good feel of using a real MF lens such as Voigtlander or Zeiss.
Anyway, all of this really only applies to me. Someone else's needs will be different - maybe a little, maybe a lot. And that's how it should be, I think - variety is good, no?
I VERY rarely shoot with AF, as a landscape shooter. With DSLR's I was 98% magnified liveview at selected hyperfocal distance... While AF can be convenient for people and shooting handheld... I wouldn't have any problem working with a fully MF setup, if meaningfully better IQ. Thankfully, AF lenses (especially in the newer Canon DSLR lineup) have been as good or better than the older (MF or AF) primes (for landscapes). The newer crop of AF offerings by Sigma and Tamron (35mm SP) also incredible.
I'd LOVE an APO Lanthar in 35mm f2, and a VC in an ultrawide with better specs than current (more suitable for astro)...