I'm not sure why a person would buy a MF lens over the Sony 55 f1.8 ZA, which is amazing and very close to the same price as this new one. I understand optics can be interesting so I think the 50mm f2 would be interesting as an add-on in the 50 range. But I wouldn't get rid of the 55mm f1.8. I'm curious enough I'd like to review the F2 and compare.
Comes down to it, though, MF is going to be slower and missed shots will result. So, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.
Lots of reasons to buy MF lenses and use in addition to or instead of AF lenses. That’s why they exist, manufacturers make them and people buy them.
Sometimes AF is annoying and not as accurate or fast as MF. Not often but sometimes.
For example if you are shooting street, zone focusing with a real helicoid and aperture ring with a distance scale is far more effective than AF when light permits.
I sold the FE 55 and an FE 50/1.4. I shoot the VC 50/1.2 and like the results a lot more than the FE 55. I have other glass in the normal range with AF when needed. It is easy to manually focus this lens on my a7r4 EVF. I shoot my kids with it all the time. Lots of misses but when I hit focus the results are very satisfying! Even some of the blurry shots are cool!
pasblues wrote:
I'm not sure why a person would buy a MF lens over the Sony 55 f1.8 ZA, which is amazing and very close to the same price as this new one. I understand optics can be interesting so I think the 50mm f2 would be interesting as an add-on in the 50 range. But I wouldn't get rid of the 55mm f1.8. I'm curious enough I'd like to review the F2 and compare.
Comes down to it, though, MF is going to be slower and missed shots will result. So, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects....Show more →
pasblues wrote:
I'm not sure why a person would buy a MF lens over the Sony 55 f1.8 ZA, which is amazing and very close to the same price as this new one. I understand optics can be interesting so I think the 50mm f2 would be interesting as an add-on in the 50 range. But I wouldn't get rid of the 55mm f1.8. I'm curious enough I'd like to review the F2 and compare.
Comes down to it, though, MF is going to be slower and missed shots will result. So, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects....Show more →
Well, I guess mainly it comes down to different points of view and different needs. I have a huge preference for MF lenses, but I don't shoot anything that can move under its own power. I do have a few AF lenses because they have abilities or qualities unique to themselves, but they're used only in MF mode.
On the other hand, I utterly loathe everything about the Zony 55/1.8. Rendering, terrible cyan CA, and worst for me, MF that's close to unusable. So bad that it kept me from trying another FBW lens for a couple of years, until I learned that they had improved a lot in MF usability since that time.
I've already told myself that I don't need the Voigt 50/2 apo-lanthar. I have multiple others that I can use, but I have no doubt that seeing reviews, I'll feel myself compelled to have it anyway.
'Miles...responded when Coltrane admitted difficulty ending his extended improvisations: 'Try taking the saxophone out of your mouth’.
Miles Davis practiced endlessly and blew notes sparingly but perfectly timed and spaced. Coltrane was the guy shooting runs of near-identical frames. Miles was the manual focus guy using his skill to record precious moments. The best MF lenses are a big part of that skill, and that's why they exist.
Near identical is not the same as identical. Minor differences in a fraction of a second can make a big difference, such as facial expressions, open or closed eyes, etc. Sometimes those are very difficult to anticipate while looking through a viewfinder, especially if it is an EVF with very slight lag. In another vein, I just shot a football game yesterday and produced several thousand images. None of the peak action images at 14fps were identical, let alone similar because the high speed motion of the subjects changed so much between frames.
There is a place for both... and tools relevant to each.
It just annoys me slightly, the notion that single-frame decisive moments are the pinnacle of photographic talent.
Steve Spencer wrote:
Given the published MTFs, I am not worried about sharpness. I will be very surprised if it isn't very sharp, but I am very interested in and have much less confidence in whether I will like the rendering so I very much appreciate the samples. It is a beginning of some indication of what the rendering is like.
Wow, I think that's the first time Cosina has actually published MTFs for a lens!
philip_pj wrote:
'Miles...responded when Coltrane admitted difficulty ending his extended improvisations: 'Try taking the saxophone out of your mouth’.
Miles Davis practiced endlessly and blew notes sparingly but perfectly timed and spaced. Coltrane was the guy shooting runs of near-identical frames. Miles was the manual focus guy using his skill to record precious moments. The best MF lenses are a big part of that skill, and that's why they exist.
Miles also believed the space between the notes were more important than the notes themselves.
DannyBurkPhoto wrote: pasblues wroteI'm not sure why a person would buy a MF lens over the Sony 55 f1.8 ZA, which is amazing and very close to the same price as this new one. I understand optics can be interesting so I think the 50mm f2 would be interesting as an add-on in the 50 range. But I wouldn't get rid of the 55mm f1.8. I'm curious enough I'd like to review the F2 and compare.
Comes down to it, though, MF is going to be slower and missed shots will result. So, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.Well, I guess mainly it comes down to different points of view and different needs. I have a huge preference for MF lenses, but I don't shoot anything that can move under its own power. I do have a few AF lenses because they have abilities or qualities unique to themselves, but they're used only in MF mode.
On the other hand, I utterly loathe everything about the Zony 55/1.8. Rendering, terrible cyan CA, and worst for me, MF that's close to unusable. So bad that it kept me from trying another FBW lens for a couple of years, until I learned that they had improved a lot in MF usability since that time.
I've already told myself that I don't need the Voigt 50/2 apo-lanthar. I have multiple others that I can use, but I have no doubt that seeing reviews, I'll feel myself compelled to have it anyway. ...Show more →
I haven't noticed "terrible cyan CA" and this is fixable in post anyway. If you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.
FM cracks me up a lot - just watching and reading the discussions. This or that piece of gear will be the darling for a few months or so and then two years later, it's a piece of crap. OTOH, there will be some gear that is trashed like the A7R3 when it came out and now that its price has dropped due to a new model, it's suddenly AMAZING and better than the new model.
I stopped putting much stock in opinions here. My 55 1.8 is a great lens but I admit that I tend to be more about content than rendering. For photographers who depend heavily on extremely precise rendering of static subjects, the excitement may be higher when a 50mm MF lens comes out. The specs on the new Voight do look really impressive.
pasblues wrote:
If you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.
FM cracks me up a lot - just watching and reading the discussions. This or that piece of gear will be the darling for a few months or so and then two years later, it's a piece of crap. OTOH, there will be some gear that is trashed like the A7R3 when it came out and now that its price has dropped due to a new model, it's suddenly AMAZING and better than the new model.
I stopped putting much stock in opinions here. My 55 1.8 is a great lens but I admit that I tend to be more about content than rendering. For photographers who depend heavily on extremely precise rendering of static subjects, the excitement may be higher when a 50mm MF lens comes out. The specs on the new Voight do look really impressive. ...Show more →
Thanks for your contribution to this thread. As you've stopped putting much stock in opinions here, do you mind sharing what sites, if any, where opinions you value are shared? Always looking for the most valuable forums with highest signal to noise ratio and that's been FM so far but would love to discover other places to frequent.
pasblues wrote:
So, the application for the 50mm f2 is going to be non-moving or very slow moving subjects.
---------------------------------------------
pasblues wrote:
If you are a MF photographer who doesn't shoot moving subjects, it makes sense to have MF lenses.
Jacques-Henri Lartigue, who photographed in the early part of the 20th century, would certainly have disagreed with you as would countless other photographers who successfully photographed moving subjects in the decades before autofocus was invented.
What's interesting about MF lenses is that they are fabulous at portraits, and it's a specialty with a rich history right up the present, that is actually hard to imagine without MF lenses from many makers. All FLs from 28mm to however long.
AF lenses have their place of course, but if you go through all of the portraits in the dedicated thread here, how many of them could be efficiently taken with a manual focus lens. 99%, and I'm not sure about where the 1% might be hiding - only looked through a hundred or so. They are much more staged and prepared (which is understandable) than anything I shoot.
You hear endlessly about people not being able to keep up with their kids, etc. But so very few high quality portraits are of people on the move, now and true of the past. You don't see the real person if they are moving much, it seems.
This is the kind of image the new Apo-Lanthar should excel at. I am happy with how the 55/1.8 lens took it, but it required 10 minutes of careful brushing to remove the LoCA from her hair. It's a common issue in bright light.