GMPhotography wrote: d.s. wroteGMPhotography wroteIt’s like pick your focal 40 or 50.Not even. It's 41.55 vs 49.15mm.Did not realize the 40 is more like a 42. Very little difference really
Even the Cosina's official diagonal angle of view is 55 degrees which translates to ~41.5mm.
Fred Miranda wrote: GMPhotography wroted.s. wroteGMPhotography wroteIt’s like pick your focal 40 or 50.Not even. It's 41.55 vs 49.15mm.Did not realize the 40 is more like a 42. Very little difference reallyEven the Cosina's official diagonal angle of view is 55 degrees which translates to 41.5mm.
If you look at the Zeiss spec sheets for old Contax Yashica mount and Contax G mount Zeiss lenses the real as well as the nominal focal lengths are stated. It's not uncommon that there are slight discrepancies between real and nominal focal lengths of lenses sometimes by 1-2mm.
Modern Zeiss spec sheets no longer have these data.
bjornthun wrote:
If you look at the Zeiss spec sheets for old Contax Yashica mount and Contax G mount Zeiss lenses the real as well as the nominal focal lengths are stated. It's not uncommon that there are slight discrepancies between real and nominal focal lengths of lenses sometimes by 1-2mm.
Modern Zeiss spec sheets no longer have these data.
I remeber the CY 35 1.4 is actually 37 or 37.5. Too bad they no longer explicitly specify.
It's a general trend by Zeiss to provide even less design info to users. If I had my way, CV and CZ would place a 500 word *design* commentary on each PR page for each lens, old and new. There are so many lenses being released now, and no one knows them better. At the same time, many online reviews have degenerated into short blurbs (with our well-known exceptions such as Phillip Reeve and Viktor, a few others).
Some CY lenses just state the FL with a decimal point, like '21.0 mm' for the CY 21/2.8, but the 35/1.4 is shown as '36.5 mm'. Strange when weights are approximate, like 'approx. 600 g' or 'approx. 530 g'.
Fred, it may not matter to many but the PDF page linked to on page 1 of this thread by Juha and yourself no longer points to the correct page, instead it reports as 'invalid link'.
But it's a valuable page as it shows all their lens designs with asph and APD glass, plus other data among the Japanese text.
They have done a very nice job of it all (we just need MTF now). I think Phillip was asking about whether the designs of the 21/3.5 in E as compared with the Vintage line lens of the same configuration are the same. These pages answer those kinds of questions. They also show the massive use of APD glass in the 65/110 macros, for example. CV would of course be up to date on glass formulas and it shows! How they do it at their price levels is an interesting topic in itself.
I believe the question posed was whether the configurations and corrections are identical in the M mount 21/3.5 and the E mount 21/3.5 as with 10mm, 12mm and 15mm lenses.
The lens diagrams on Cosina’s pages do not answer that question.
Thanks for the new links.
philip_pj wrote:
It's a general trend by Zeiss to provide even less design info to users. If II think Phillip was asking about whether the designs of the 21/3.5 in E as compared with the Vintage line lens of the same configuration are the same. These pages answer those kinds of questions.
philip_pj wrote:
...
Fred, it may not matter to many but the PDF page linked to on page 1 of this thread by Juha and yourself no longer points to the correct page, instead it reports as 'invalid link'.
But it's a valuable page as it shows all their lens designs with asph and APD glass, plus other data among the Japanese text.
They have done a very nice job of it all (we just need MTF now). I think Phillip was asking about whether the designs of the 21/3.5 in E as compared with the Vintage line lens of the same configuration are the same. These pages answer those kinds of questions. They also show the massive use of APD glass in the 65/110 macros, for example. CV would of course be up to date on glass formulas and it shows! How they do it at their price levels is an interesting topic in itself....Show more →
It seems Cosina has removed the CP+ related page they had and the original PDF showing the new lenses announced at CP+ is no longer available at the original location. I had a copy of the PDF saved locally so I share it in another location and I updated the original post with a new link. They also handed out paper copies of the same at CP+.
Since I've pre-ordered the 21/1.4 for E-mount which is going to be released on 6/27, I might not go for this one at least right away (lens budget is spent for the time being) and I'd rather get an E-mount version if there is going to be one in the future.
Juha Kannisto wrote: Beni wroteAm I the only one seeing a big empty gap at the 24mm focal length in the CV lineup? Cummon CV! Many of us think the gap is at 28mm FL instead, right in the middle between 21mm and 35mm
They make a 28mm in other mounts but there is no 24mm at all.
Since I've pre-ordered the 21/1.4 for E-mount which is going to be released on 6/27, I might not go for this one at least right away (lens budget is spent for the time being) and I'd rather get an E-mount version if there is going to be one in the future....Show more →
Would love to hear your take when it arrives. I believe CV is putting out purpose built lenses for photographers who value rendering and utility, instead of all out edge to edge resolution wide open.
First, From the 50/1.2 CV I learned that Cosina is not scared to release a lens with a soft wide open aperture (f1.2). It makes the lens so much more usable for me to get that special rendering at f1.2, like a Noctilux’s unique look but just a little softer. Then at f2 it all tightens up and is sharp as a tack. I wish the 50 Summilux had this extra “portrait” stop. Maybe (hopefully) that’s how the CV 75/1.5 will be. Leica used to do this, e.g. the 75 Summilux.
If Cosina stays on this track, the 75 CV will be very enticing for me and a whole lot less expensive and smaller than the 75 Lux. By labeling it “vintage” I think Cosina will take this liberty.
Second, Also, they don’t release mtf charts, thus again it seems wide open resolving power is not the major concern, instead it’s the special look and rendering which seem to be valued by Cosina wide open.
Third, From the 35/2 Ultron vintage, they aimed at making a tiny lens that kills at center frame, and softens up outside of that. I heard it was a close copy of the version 1 35 Summicron (which also is sharp as a tack on center). Cosina thus put out a lens that did not prioritize edge to edge resolution but instead size and utility. By utility I mean a lens that serves the job of street photography or environmental portraiture, both which may not need the edge resolution.
Since I've pre-ordered the 21/1.4 for E-mount which is going to be released on 6/27, I might not go for this one at least right away (lens budget is spent for the time being) and I'd rather get an E-mount version if there is going to be one in the future.Would love to hear your take when it arrives. I believe CV is putting out purpose built lenses for photographers who value rendering and utility, instead of all out edge to edge resolution wide open.
First, From the 50/1.2 CV I learned that Cosina is not scared to release a lens with a soft wide open aperture (f1.2). It makes the lens so much more usable for me to get that special rendering at f1.2, like a Noctilux’s unique look but just a little softer. Then at f2 it all tightens up and is sharp as a tack. I wish the 50 Summilux had this extra “portrait” stop. Maybe (hopefully) that’s how the CV 75/1.5 will be. Leica used to do this, e.g. the 75 Summilux.
If Cosina stays on this track, the 75 CV will be very enticing for me and a whole lot less expensive and smaller than the 75 Lux. By labeling it “vintage” I think Cosina will take this liberty.
Second, Also, they don’t release mtf charts, thus again it seems wide open resolving power is not the major concern, instead it’s the special look and rendering which seem to be valued by Cosina wide open.
Third, From the 35/2 Ultron vintage, they aimed at making a tiny lens that kills at center frame, and softens up outside of that. I heard it was a close copy of the version 1 35 Summicron (which also is sharp as a tack on center). Cosina thus put out a lens that did not prioritize edge to edge resolution but instead size and utility. By utility I mean a lens that serves the job of street photography or environmental portraiture, both which may not need the edge resolution. ...Show more →
I'll certainly share my impressions and some samples when I get the new CV Nokton 21/1.4 (E-mount) lens next week. I'm not sure if/when I'll get the 75/1.5 VM yet since I'll be running low on lens budget after getting the 21/1.4. Would be keen to get it but I'm also thinking that there might be an e-mount version coming in the near future which I'd rather wait for if it happens.
This year I've already acquired CV 50/1.2 and 15/4.5 III in e-mount and the 35/2 Ultron and Heliar classic 50/2 (from 2006) in VM mount (+ Avenon 28/3.5 MC (1997 10 blade version)). I've been a big fan of CV lenses since 2012 or so when I first got the 35/1.2 Nokton v1 and they've been releasing more and more exciting new lenses these last few years I really like the current E-mount lineup (I'll have 8 of those once 21/1.4 gets released, only missing the widest end 10mm and 12mm).
In the middle I have the CV 28 Ultron F 2 with a PCX 5000 attached to a Hawk adapter for perfect infinity focus. Was thinking of maybe selling it . It’s a new lens I bought in April. My only issue is timing and not really a issue. I’m driving to NY which I leave the 1st get there around the 6th. So maybe not in time to drive with but I love shooting NY with a 12 and 21 lenses
I am CV12, 21, 40 & 65 and any new lens by Cosina is definitely in my radar. The 1.4 use case for a 21mm is for me astro stuff so it better be a great coma performer to compete with the lightweight tiny & amazingly good 21/3.5. Even with that milkyway with 21mm would mean a lot of pano and stitching which is not really my preference as it complicates an already long process for night shots.
For me, I am really interested in the 75 f/1.5. I would love a short tele that is that fast and that small. I also think the 3 big APD elements bode well for nice CA control. I will wait to see how the lens performs, but I am quite hopeful.
GMPhotography wrote:
Well I listed the Ultron 28mm. If it sells I will join the party
Love this little but powerful lens both attached with adapter on my A7R and on my M cameras. Just wish it would also have a 39 mm filter ring diameter as most Leica M lenses. I personally would never sell it. But this is just me
NRKStudio wrote:
Would love to hear your take when it arrives. I believe CV is putting out purpose built lenses for photographers who value rendering and utility, instead of all out edge to edge resolution wide open.
First, From the 50/1.2 CV I learned that Cosina is not scared to release a lens with a soft wide open aperture (f1.2). It makes the lens so much more usable for me to get that special rendering at f1.2, like a Noctilux’s unique look but just a little softer. Then at f2 it all tightens up and is sharp as a tack. I wish the 50 Summilux had this extra “portrait” stop. Maybe (hopefully) that’s how the CV 75/1.5 will be. Leica used to do this, e.g. the 75 Summilux.
If Cosina stays on this track, the 75 CV will be very enticing for me and a whole lot less expensive and smaller than the 75 Lux. By labeling it “vintage” I think Cosina will take this liberty.
Second, Also, they don’t release mtf charts, thus again it seems wide open resolving power is not the major concern, instead it’s the special look and rendering which seem to be valued by Cosina wide open.
Third, From the 35/2 Ultron vintage, they aimed at making a tiny lens that kills at center frame, and softens up outside of that. I heard it was a close copy of the version 1 35 Summicron (which also is sharp as a tack on center). Cosina thus put out a lens that did not prioritize edge to edge resolution but instead size and utility. By utility I mean a lens that serves the job of street photography or environmental portraiture, both which may not need the edge resolution. ...Show more →
There are samples from the 75 shot by Juha at CP+ earlier in this thread that will give you some idea about how the lens performs wide open. I don't have the 50/1.2 so not sure how soft it gets wide open, but the 75 to me does not look like the 'glow' of the 75 Lux wide open. I think there is a bit of SA wide open, but it's not that much. My feeling is this new 75 is fairly modern in terms of performance and rendering.
Not sure if it's copy variation with my 50 Lux, but wide open and at nearer distances, my copy is definitely softer due to SA glow than at f/2 where contrast increases considerably. I've always considered it a 'dual character' lens for this reason.
From other user tests I've seen from the new CV 35/2, on a digital Leica M it's sharp across the frame by f/4. Again thanks to Juha's test photos here in other threads, that lens on Sony exhibits some field curvature that requires off center focusing to optimize across-frame performance, which is achievable by around f/5.6.
FWIW, Cosina never releases MTF charts. I've asked Roger at Lensrentals whether they will ever run MTF tests on their Voigtlander stock, but he indicated they don't have sufficient quantities on-hand to generate 'average' MTFs for those models.