Juha Kannisto wrote:
Here are a few samples with the 75/1.5 on my Sony A9 (OOC fine JPEGs), most of them are taken wide open but there is one aperture series were I stopped down gradually while shooting from the counter-top. There are probably a couple others that were stopped down a bit too.
I didn't get a very successful "brick-wall test", I tried a few shots on the Cosina photo wall but they didn't come out very consistently with my handholding and people moving in the front. The lens is not corner-to-corner sharp wide open on A9 when focused on the center but I think the corners start getting pretty good by f2.8 or so. Wide open the lens is plenty sharp at least centrally though not razor-like. It sharpens up noticeably more when stopped down to f2. The first aperture click-stop after f1.5 is f2 and from there on it's half-stops. Bokeh balls don't seem to have any onion rings.
I like the rendering very much and the handling felt very nice, the focus ring is very smooth and easy to turn and this version of "Vintage" design doesn't seem to have any handling quirks. The lens felt pretty nice in size and weight too, didn't feel heavy at all.
This is what the Cosina area looked like, with the demo shooting area in the middle: ...Show more →
Wow, thanks Juha!!
Here's my interpretation of the 75 from your photos: rendering seems fairly consistent with their recent releases - on the fairly neutral side with good corrections, but not to the point of perfection. Images mostly look smooth and definitely are sharp enough with good contrast and color. There's a touch of LOCA/bokeh color fringing, but nothing like past Voigtlander fast normal/short teles, which is great to see. Some bokeh nervousness at some distances, but with reasonable separation, reminds me of their other recent lenses, as well as many other recent short teles. I think I see a touch of field curvature, which seems to be confirmed by the 'brick wall' test shots. Refocusing on the light in the upper left results in central focus moving forward. There's a hint of it in the fabric of the blanket in frames 6991 and 6996 along with possibly a slight drop in mid zone sharpness, but insufficient sampling to determine.
My biggest disappointment from these samples is CV's use of straight aperture blades. If at least they could have made the effort to curve them, OOF speculars between f/2 to f/4 would have IMO looked much better. OOF roundness improves at ~f/5.6.
Throughout the samples I was thinking how much the rendering reminded me of my Canon EF85/1.4LIS. Not exactly the same, but often similar. One area where the Canon is IMO superior, is moderately stopped down OOF speculars. I very frequently shoot it in the f/2-2.8 range and cannot tell that it's stopped down (other than the size of the OOF speculars). This always annoyed me with my v1 EF85/1.2L because of it's eight straight blades. The 75's 12 blades are an improvement, but the straight edges in the f/2.8 range are regrettable. That said, one of my favorite lenses, the 50 Lux ASPH, has the brutal ninja-star aperture opening also in the f/2-4 range...
In any case, it's another promising lens from Cosina!
rscheffler wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteHere are a few samples with the 75/1.5 on my Sony A9 (OOC fine JPEGs), most of them are taken wide open but there is one aperture series were I stopped down gradually while shooting from the counter-top. There are probably a couple others that were stopped down a bit too.
I didn't get a very successful "brick-wall test", I tried a few shots on the Cosina photo wall but they didn't come out very consistently with my handholding and people moving in the front. The lens is not corner-to-corner sharp wide open on A9 when focused on the center but I think the corners start getting pretty good by f2.8 or so. Wide open the lens is plenty sharp at least centrally though not razor-like. It sharpens up noticeably more when stopped down to f2. The first aperture click-stop after f1.5 is f2 and from there on it's half-stops. Bokeh balls don't seem to have any onion rings.
I like the rendering very much and the handling felt very nice, the focus ring is very smooth and easy to turn and this version of "Vintage" design doesn't seem to have any handling quirks. The lens felt pretty nice in size and weight too, didn't feel heavy at all.
This is what the Cosina area looked like, with the demo shooting area in the middle:Wow, thanks Juha!!
Here's my interpretation of the 75 from your photos: rendering seems fairly consistent with their recent releases - on the fairly neutral side with good corrections, but not to the point of perfection. Images mostly look smooth and definitely are sharp enough with good contrast and color. There's a touch of LOCA/bokeh color fringing, but nothing like past Voigtlander fast normal/short teles, which is great to see. Some bokeh nervousness at some distances, but with reasonable separation, reminds me of their other recent lenses, as well as many other recent short teles. I think I see a touch of field curvature, which seems to be confirmed by the 'brick wall' test shots. Refocusing on the light in the upper left results in central focus moving forward. There's a hint of it in the fabric of the blanket in frames 6991 and 6996 along with possibly a slight drop in mid zone sharpness, but insufficient sampling to determine.
My biggest disappointment from these samples is CV's use of straight aperture blades. If at least they could have made the effort to curve them in the f/2-2.8 range, OOF speculars would have IMO looked much better. OOF roundness improves at f/4-5.6 (assuming I correctly guessed the apertures used in the aperture sequence).
Throughout the samples I was thinking how much the rendering reminded me of my Canon EF85/1.4LIS. Not exactly the same, but often similar. One area where the Canon is IMO superior, is moderately stopped down OOF speculars. I very frequently shoot it in the f/2-2.8 range and cannot tell that it's stopped down (other than the size of the OOF speculars). This always annoyed me with my v1 EF85/1.2L because of it's eight straight blades. The 75's 12 blades are an improvement, but the straight edges, particularly at f/2 are regrettable.
Still, it's another promising lens from Cosina!...Show more →
Thanks for your very detailed analysis based on the samples, Ron! I can never analyze my own shots with such level of detail e.g. when it comes to impact of aperture blades on OOF speculars etc. I also felt that there is probably some level of field curvature, which could be related to VM lens on Sony sensor stack as well...
I did the aperture series starting from f1.5, then stopping to f2 and further stopping down full stops at a time until f8, I think. However, it looks like I might have accidentally got 2 f1.5 shots at the start of the series before moving to f2 and onwards, as the 2 first shots have identical exposure time and they look very simlar too, and when I count from f1.5 to f8 based on the way I think I shot it, there is one shot too many.
I miscounted the aperture series. I assumed three shots wide open, but the third is slightly stopped down because vignetting clears a bit and the central OOF details get slightly smaller. I was zoomed in at the upper left specular highlights and interestingly those don't change from f/1.5-f/2.0... I'd have to see more images at f/2, but maybe the straight edges of the aperture blades don't become prominent until f/2.8, where it's quite noticeable in the upper left. I've changed my comments above to reflect this.
Similar to what I see with their 35/1.7M, stopping down from wide open to f/2 doesn't seem to make much difference, especially in the outer 1/3 of the image and the a9's exposure only changed 1/3 stop.
Did Cosina show a dedicated hood for the 75? I haven't seen anything mentioned.
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Here are a few samples with the 75/1.5 on my Sony A9 (OOC fine JPEGs), most of them are taken wide open but there is one aperture series were I stopped down gradually while shooting from the counter-top. There are probably a couple others that were stopped down a bit too.
I didn't get a very successful "brick-wall test", I tried a few shots on the Cosina photo wall but they didn't come out very consistently with my handholding and people moving in the front. The lens is not corner-to-corner sharp wide open on A9 when focused on the center but I think the corners start getting pretty good by f2.8 or so. Wide open the lens is plenty sharp at least centrally though not razor-like. It sharpens up noticeably more when stopped down to f2. The first aperture click-stop after f1.5 is f2 and from there on it's half-stops. Bokeh balls don't seem to have any onion rings.
I like the rendering very much and the handling felt very nice, the focus ring is very smooth and easy to turn and this version of "Vintage" design doesn't seem to have any handling quirks. The lens felt pretty nice in size and weight too, didn't feel heavy at all.
This is what the Cosina area looked like, with the demo shooting area in the middle: ...Show more →
The 75 looks good. I'm impressed by its size, that's a nice surprise. Quite tiny, like the 75/2.5. The samples look good...Ron is pretty on point with his analysis. It'll be worth looking at when it comes out, that's for sure. Too many nice lenses hitting the streets this year!
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Here are just a couple of samples on the 21/1.4 in the Voigtländer demo area at CP+ with my A9, all were taken wide open.
Thanks also for the 21mm samples! I really like what I see here! Very pleasing rendering and sharp looking images with nice 3d pop. Lucky that I hadn't bought the color-skopar yet. Was planning to, as this lens wasn't expected from Cosina. Now the more I think about this new 21mm f/1.4, the more I want it. I had actually secretly wished that Cosina would have made the 21mm f/1.8 ultron for Sony, but instead we seem to have gotten even something better. As I don't have ANY wider lenses than 35mm now, this will make a great pair for the 40mm Nokton. Not just ultrawide but also ultra-fast.
This is gonna be a looooong wait for me. But most likely worth it.
philip_pj wrote:
Good to hear, Dave, I finished up film with Astia for the extra stop. My light conditions need low contrast and often a lot of post, so 'forgiving' lenses like the CYs with good tonal separation are ideal. I'm on a lightweight kick and CV are just the ticket. The new 75/1.5 will get plenty of interest if in E mount for sure.
I always thought Astia had a certain gentleness, added a certain 'class' to images, if that makes sense. Loved that emulsion. I think it informed how I like to shoot people and, honestly, I'm a big fan of Vancouver's cloudy winters for that. Maybe it's the other way around? Vancouver tuned my eye for Astia haha.
I treated myself to the Loxia 25/85 combo for Christmas so I feel that the 75/2.5 would make a sort of counterpoint in terms of rendering, hence me seeking one out. The 35/2.5 is similar, though a mushy, colour shifting mess on the edges, so it needs help in post or it's B&W only. I'm glad to see the 75/1.5 is going to be available in my preferred matte silver as well, it will be worth a look. Meanwhile I've got the Loxias to run through their paces and man, they're turning out to be truly excellent lenses.
rscheffler wrote:
I miscounted the aperture series. I assumed three shots wide open, but the third is slightly stopped down because vignetting clears a bit and the central OOF details get slightly smaller. I was zoomed in at the upper left specular highlights and interestingly those don't change from f/1.5-f/2.0... I'd have to see more images at f/2, but maybe the straight edges of the aperture blades don't become prominent until f/2.8, where it's quite noticeable in the upper left. I've changed my comments above to reflect this.
Similar to what I see with their 35/1.7M, stopping down from wide open to f/2 doesn't seem to make much difference, especially in the outer 1/3 of the image and the a9's exposure only changed 1/3 stop.
Did Cosina show a dedicated hood for the 75? I haven't seen anything mentioned....Show more →
Thanks!
None of the displays showed a hood for the 75mm and Cosina didn't have the hoods for the demo samples either so I guess they might not have fixed the hood design yet. I hope it won't come with a long hood as the size is quite nice without a hood but would be compromised with a long one.
Tonzah78 wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteHere are just a couple of samples on the 21/1.4 in the Voigtländer demo area at CP+ with my A9, all were taken wide open.Thanks also for the 21mm samples! I really like what I see here! Very pleasing rendering and sharp looking images with nice 3d pop. Lucky that I hadn't bought the color-skopar yet. Was planning to, as this lens wasn't expected from Cosina. Now the more I think about this new 21mm f/1.4, the more I want it. I had actually secretly wished that Cosina would have made the 21mm f/1.8 ultron for Sony, but instead we seem to have gotten even something better. As I don't have ANY wider lenses than 35mm now, this will make a great pair for the 40mm Nokton. Not just ultrawide but also ultra-fast.
This is gonna be a looooong wait for me. But most likely worth it. ...Show more →
Oh yeah, it should be a good one to cover the wide end while also being fast. I used to have the Voigtländer 10mm in e-mount and the 1st gen LTM version of 15/4.5 and later 15/4.5 III VM and the 21/1.8 Ultron VM but I eventually went for the Sony zooms G 12-24/4 and GM 16-35/2.8 for the wide end and GM 24/1.4 for a general purpose fast wide that is reasonably small. I often use wide angle when travelling and the zooms are very flexible for that.
For my MF kit for general walk-around use I figured that the 21/3.5 Color-Skopar is good for covering the widest end and can be carried in the bag with other lenses without adding much weight. The next longer FL in my MF kit is covered by 28/3.5 Avenon LTM which works great with Sony sensor but needs to have a thinner adapter than my Rayqual. It works very well on my Voigtländer close-focus adapter at hard infinity. I've had the first gen silver version of this lens for a while (introduced in 1982 or so, 6 aperture blades) but I recently bought a later 1997 black MC version with 10 aperture blades, those are much harder to find in 2nd hand market. The new version has a focusing tab (which I know you don't like e.g. with Ultron 28/2) but for me it's no problem.
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Oh yeah, it should be a good one to cover the wide end while also being fast. I used to have the Voigtländer 10mm in e-mount and the 1st gen LTM version of 15/4.5 and later 15/4.5 III VM and the 21/1.8 Ultron VM but I eventually went for the Sony zooms G 12-24/4 and GM 16-35/2.8 for the wide end and GM 24/1.4 for a general purpose fast wide that is reasonably small. I often use wide angle when travelling and the zooms are very flexible for that.
The GM24/1.4 sounds stellar but also a bit too expensive for my taste and zooms like 16-35 just aren't my thing. This is why I just sold my Tamron zoom. It was great, but I really couldn't get myself to pick it up instead of a prime like CV40/1.2 or the FE85/1.8. Lately I've used the CV40/1.2 for just about everything. Even for landscapes, as it's so easy to take series of shots and merge them in LR. This 21/1.4 actually sounds like of a lens that combines everything I've been looking for in a wide lens, the more I think of it. It's wide enough for my landscape use and not too wide for environmental portrait-style photography when used right (which for I had hoped for a compact native CV28/2). Easy to crop to get more narrow view when needed and should also work as a nice 32mm f/2 eqv. lens in crop mode for some casual shots, not needing all the megapixels. Definitely fast enough for that too. It's gonna be a killer lens indoors and it ain't too large or heavy either, even if not the lightest.
In the meanwhile I might buy the CV21/3.5 and could sell it when the 21/1.4 is available. Just hope I won't fall in love with it too much.
Tonzah78 wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteOh yeah, it should be a good one to cover the wide end while also being fast. I used to have the Voigtländer 10mm in e-mount and the 1st gen LTM version of 15/4.5 and later 15/4.5 III VM and the 21/1.8 Ultron VM but I eventually went for the Sony zooms G 12-24/4 and GM 16-35/2.8 for the wide end and GM 24/1.4 for a general purpose fast wide that is reasonably small. I often use wide angle when travelling and the zooms are very flexible for that.The GM24/1.4 sounds stellar but also a bit too expensive for my taste and zooms like 16-35 just aren't my thing. This is why I just sold my Tamron zoom. It was great, but I really couldn't get myself to pick it up instead of a prime like CV40/1.2 or the FE85/1.8. Lately I've used the CV40/1.2 for just about everything. Even for landscapes, as it's so easy to take series of shots and merge them in LR. This 21/1.4 actually sounds like of a lens that combines everything I've been looking for in a wide lens, the more I think of it. It's wide enough for my landscape use and not too wide for environmental portrait-style photography when used right (which for I had hoped for a compact native CV28/2). Easy to crop to get more narrow view when needed and should also work as a nice 32mm f/2 eqv. lens in crop mode for some casual shots, not needing all the megapixels. Definitely fast enough for that too. It's gonna be a killer lens indoors and it ain't too large or heavy either, even if not the lightest.
In the meanwhile I might buy the CV21/3.5 and could sell it when the 21/1.4 is available. Just hope I won't fall in love with it too much. ...Show more →
You may just fall in love with the 21 3.5. Fair warning
I do want to try this 1.4 though at some point even though I have the 24 1.4 but they usually don’t go in the same bag
Tonzah78 wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteOh yeah, it should be a good one to cover the wide end while also being fast. I used to have the Voigtländer 10mm in e-mount and the 1st gen LTM version of 15/4.5 and later 15/4.5 III VM and the 21/1.8 Ultron VM but I eventually went for the Sony zooms G 12-24/4 and GM 16-35/2.8 for the wide end and GM 24/1.4 for a general purpose fast wide that is reasonably small. I often use wide angle when travelling and the zooms are very flexible for that.The GM24/1.4 sounds stellar but also a bit too expensive for my taste and zooms like 16-35 just aren't my thing. This is why I just sold my Tamron zoom. It was great, but I really couldn't get myself to pick it up instead of a prime like CV40/1.2 or the FE85/1.8. Lately I've used the CV40/1.2 for just about everything. Even for landscapes, as it's so easy to take series of shots and merge them in LR. This 21/1.4 actually sounds like of a lens that combines everything I've been looking for in a wide lens, the more I think of it. It's wide enough for my landscape use and not too wide for environmental portrait-style photography when used right (which for I had hoped for a compact native CV28/2). Easy to crop to get more narrow view when needed and should also work as a nice 32mm f/2 eqv. lens in crop mode for some casual shots, not needing all the megapixels. Definitely fast enough for that too. It's gonna be a killer lens indoors and it ain't too large or heavy either, even if not the lightest.
In the meanwhile I might buy the CV21/3.5 and could sell it when the 21/1.4 is available. Just hope I won't fall in love with it too much. ...Show more →
I also had the Tamron zoom but I sold it as I found I like the Sony 24-105/4 G much better. I mainly use zooms when traveling where I want to be able to cover different types of shooting without changing lenses, including wide-angle cityscapes and other type of stuff. On my local walk-around shooting I mostly use primes and mainly the smaller ones.
I traded in 2 lenses for the upcoming CV 50/1.2 on Sunday, so it's almost completely paid for in advance. Now waiting for April I still have 2 more to trade as well, which I will probably do when the 75/1.5 becomes available.
I really like the 24/1.4 GM, Loxia 21/2.8 and CV 40/1.2 lenses and therefore have no interest in the new CV 21/1.4 or CV 50/1.2.
Like Guy said, the 21/1.4 could be a special lens though.
GMPhotography wrote:
It certainly is a interesting choice I think. Will depend on IQ of course but I think that’s the fastest widest angle we have as a lens in MF.
For me my Cv 21 and Sony 24 are not in the same bag . So having a fast super wide 21 could be a barrel of fun
Right now I only have one fast lens in my MF bag the CV 40. Love to try it for sure
Agreed. I love the 24GM. But as a manual kit it would be hard to resist pairing the CV 21 1.4 with the CV 40