p.2 #1How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Short answer: no. Too much of a restriction in my book, despite the considerable number of options available for e-mount by now.
For one the signature isn't always identical throughout a lens family, as Fred correctly pointed out. But even if it was, I don't really care, as similar color rendition across my lens line-up isn't important to me.
I can see the point of having similar controls (placement of focus ring, aperture ring) across multiple lenses, but it's not high on my list of selection criteria.
p.2 #2How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I do tend toward "families" of known quality that I consider are good value. I don't stick to one family, so I have an assortment of Zeiss Loxia and ZE/ZF (I've given up on the old Contax Zeiss due to clumsiness and different rendering and contrast), many Canon EF "L" lenses, a few great Sony zooms (12-24G and 24-105G), Sigma Art series, a number of Canon FD and Nikon AIS lenses (I do hate the opposite Nikon rotation, but it's manageable for the imaging).
I've yet to try any of the new Cosina Voigtlander, as I'm pretty well covered on the focal lengths I might be interested in. 40/1.2 might be a possibility at some point.
I am usually looking for great colors with high contrast and sharp resolution, and that can be found in almost any brand with care. But I also like some softness, as a recent examination of Canon 35/1/4L and 50/1.2L shot wide open showed.
p.2 #3How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Cross posted from the image thread, sorry. I believe this comparison is more relevant here.
Nothing scientific, different post processing and point of view, but same subjects and weather conditions…. one year later.
For sure it’s my lack of skills in Capture One, but I cannot seem to match Zeiss colors regardless of the effort applied!
I do not intend to show images side by side, except for this kind of direct comparison, but still...
Sony Zeiss 35/2,8 (first) vs Zeiss Milvus 50 (second)
p.2 #4How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
If I were a working pro where efficiency and a consistency in delivered product were important and post production a key cost driver I would be all over consistent physical and optical qualities. As an amateur enthusiast I am all about lenses that appeal to me and that can mean many different, even opposing things.
p.2 #5How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
orso wrote:
Nothing scientific, different post processing and point of view, but same subjects and weather conditions…. one year later.
Sony 35&Milvus 50 picture pair: There is at least 1 1/3 stop exposure on midtones (judging from phone screen), would be next to impossible to make them match before matching exposure. In addition to exposure also white balance should match, and I mean real white balance (=take photo of gray card on same light as subject). After these two fundamentals are in place then you can start the actual matching process. I personally do the actual matching using curves tool (adding S-curve) and adjusting black level (levels tool bottom left corner) in Capture One.
orso wrote:
For sure it’s my lack of skills in Capture One, but I cannot seem to match Zeiss colors regardless of the effort applied!
In my opinion Sony FE35 (2.8 or 1.4), FE55 or FE50 1.4 do not have Zeiss colors nor rendering style, not even close - they use Zeiss names like sonnar & planar (good luck finding double gauss design, into which word Planar refers to, from optical diagram of 50mm 1.4...) and T* coating, but are just Sony designs as far as I have understood, the Zeiss name is there for marketing purposes. Colors and contrast goes hand in hand, and to me Sony Zeiss lenses' mikro and makro contrast is very different when compared to real Zeiss lenses.
p.2 #6How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Samuli Vahonen wrote: orso wroteNothing scientific, different post processing and point of view, but same subjects and weather conditions…. one year later.Sony 35&Milvus 50 picture pair: There is at least 1 1/3 stop exposure on midtones (judging from phone screen), would be next to impossible to make them match before matching exposure. In addition to exposure also white balance should match, and I mean real white balance (=take photo of gray card on same light as subject). After these two fundamentals are in place then you can start the actual matching process. I personally do the actual matching using curves tool (adding S-curve) and adjusting black level (levels tool bottom left corner) in Capture One.
orso wroteFor sure it’s my lack of skills in Capture One, but I cannot seem to match Zeiss colors regardless of the effort applied! In my opinion Sony FE35 (2.8 or 1.4), FE55 or FE50 1.4 do not have Zeiss colors nor rendering style, not even close - they use Zeiss names like sonnar & planar (good luck finding double gauss design, into which word Planar refers to, from optical diagram of 50mm 1.4...) and T* coating, but are just Sony designs as far as I have understood, the Zeiss name is there for marketing purposes. Colors and contrast goes hand in hand, and to me Sony Zeiss lenses' mikro and makro contrast is very different when compared to real Zeiss lenses.
p.2 #7How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Samuli Vahonen wrote: orso wroteNothing scientific, different post processing and point of view, but same subjects and weather conditions…. one year later.Sony 35&Milvus 50 picture pair: There is at least 1 1/3 stop exposure on midtones (judging from phone screen), would be next to impossible to make them match before matching exposure. In addition to exposure also white balance should match, and I mean real white balance (=take photo of gray card on same light as subject). After these two fundamentals are in place then you can start the actual matching process. I personally do the actual matching using curves tool (adding S-curve) and adjusting black level (levels tool bottom left corner) in Capture One.
orso wroteFor sure it’s my lack of skills in Capture One, but I cannot seem to match Zeiss colors regardless of the effort applied! In my opinion Sony FE35 (2.8 or 1.4), FE55 or FE50 1.4 do not have Zeiss colors nor rendering style, not even close - they use Zeiss names like sonnar & planar (good luck finding double gauss design, into which word Planar refers to, from optical diagram of 50mm 1.4...) and T* coating, but are just Sony designs as far as I have understood, the Zeiss name is there for marketing purposes. Colors and contrast goes hand in hand, and to me Sony Zeiss lenses' mikro and makro contrast is very different when compared to real Zeiss lenses.
I prefer Sony lenses simply because most of them operate the same way and have the Focus hold button to assign and many have the AF/MF switch and I like the feel of the focus rings and aperture rings when equipped with one. I also like the looks.
I have the CV 110, Loxia 21 & 85, Batis 135 and a couple Canon EF lenses so it certainly does not stop me from using other lenses. However if I had a choice for these lenses I would prefer for them to have the focus button and AF/MF and similarly knurled focus rings.
p.2 #8How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
You pretty much leave out a lot of fine lense if you stick to a single series of a manufacture. Want a tilt shift lens? Sony doesn’t make one. How about a 100mm F1.4? Ditto.
p.2 #9How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
SoundHound wrote:
You pretty much leave out a lot of fine lense if you stick to a single series of a manufacture. Want a tilt shift lens? Sony doesn’t make one. How about a 100mm F1.4? Ditto.
I agree. I choose the best lens for a given focal length irrespective of its make. Best depends on the use of that lens and is a combination of image quality, size, weight, AF / MF, and cost.
p.2 #10How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I don’t disagree at all with picking the best lens for your needs even different brands in your mix and I think this was more a product of when Sony came out with the A7r we did not have tons of choices. I do think the tide has shifted though with brands and there lens lineups. For Example let’s say Batis lineand if a buyer went all Batis 18,25,40,85,135. You look at that line there really is no dog in there. Sure something maybe better in a Sony or Loxia but you honestly would have a great lineup. Same with Loxia 21,25,35,50,85. Here are some exceptional MF glass. Take Voightlander is it really that hard to not like the 12,15,21,40,65,110. Everyone right there are outstanding. Look at the Tamron 28-75 which iOS a great lens, now the lineup needs to expand. Sony itself with 24,35,55,50,85 and add there GM zooms. Really hard to ignore this line
Point is they system overall has grown so much and even you went one lens lineup. There really are no dogs in here. Sure some lenses in the lower levels of Sony are just okay you can still get good images. Maybe not to some of our standards but you get my drift.
Really we have gone from begging for glass to a point we are getting spoiled. I view that as outstanding evolution of a system
Maybe better said . It’s getting damned hard to bitch anymore. Okay,okay,ok a 35 1.8.
p.2 #11How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I want Sony lenses if I'm doing sports or events in low light; there are too many issues with acquiring focus otherwise (ex.: Canon lenses with a Metabones V), to say nothing of reverse zooming directions. Other than that, it doesn't matter to me. I have a Leica R 19mm that I'll probably never part with! And I have a feeling it will be a long time before Sony comes out with a T/S lens that could replace my Canon 17mm T/S.
p.2 #12How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I think it's almost impossible to get every lens you'd like within the same family. i've got
minolta
24/2.8 ⌀55mm
35/1.4 ⌀55mm
50/1.4 ⌀55mm
58/1.2 ⌀55mm
85/1.4 ⌀72mm
200/2.8 ⌀72mm
all of these are remarkably similiar in rendering. A couple of these were acquired in part from OCD. Other lenses i've got are from a variety of lines:
rokinon 14/2.8
voigtlander 40/2 ⌀52mm
leica 50/1.4 ⌀55mm
zeiss 50/2 ⌀67mm
zony 24-70/2.8 ⌀77mm
i wouldn't say there's much of an advantage of family, other than consistency in colour, contrast, bokeh, filter size (sometimes), but consistency doesn't really matter all that much, atleast to me. often i only bring 1 lens along so no opportunity to be inconsistent. i guess not able to swap filters and some lens' focus ring directions would be the only apparent disadvantage.
Jan 31, 2019 at 01:23 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.2 #13How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
chiron wrote:
How much of an advantage is it to keep your lenses in the same family, e.g., all Loxia or all Batis or all Sony or all Voigtlander, or Sigma, or Rokinon, etc?
There is something nice about having the same ergonomics and color and general sizing, but is that mostly an obsessive tweak?
Or are the disadvantages of mixing and matching real?
I think I'd get bored. With them all the same.
Shot 30+ year old nikkors and ef-s on canon lately. Playing around Russian lenses a while back, plenty of OM etc around
p.2 #14How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
GMPhotography wrote:
I don’t disagree at all with picking the best lens for your needs even different brands in your mix and I think this was more a product of when Sony came out with the A7r we did not have tons of choices. I do think the tide has shifted though with brands and there lens lineups. For Example let’s say Batis lineand if a buyer went all Batis 18,25,40,85,135. You look at that line there really is no dog in there. Sure something maybe better in a Sony or Loxia but you honestly would have a great lineup. Same with Loxia 21,25,35,50,85. Here are some exceptional MF glass. Take Voightlander is it really that hard to not like the 12,15,21,40,65,110. Everyone right there are outstanding. Look at the Tamron 28-75 which iOS a great lens, now the lineup needs to expand. Sony itself with 24,35,55,50,85 and add there GM zooms. Really hard to ignore this line
Point is they system overall has grown so much and even you went one lens lineup. There really are no dogs in here. Sure some lenses in the lower levels of Sony are just okay you can still get good images. Maybe not to some of our standards but you get my drift.
Really we have gone from begging for glass to a point we are getting spoiled. I view that as outstanding evolution of a system
Maybe better said . It’s getting damned hard to bitch anymore. Okay,okay,ok a 35 1.8. ...Show more →
Yes, when the A7R came out, we only had two ZA lenses. (35/2.8 and 55/1.8)
During that time, most of my lenses were Zeiss ZE and Canon TS-E adapted to Sony. I was really after the sensor IQ superiority and didn't care about adapting my favorite lenses.
Over the years, we got more ZA lenses and at least a couple lenses for each new E-mount line (Loxia, Batis, Voigt, G-GM)...It was a growing pain but at this point, we have pretty much complete lines competing for similar focal lengths.
Currently, the Batis line seems to be the most complete but I think that mixing the best lenses from different lines is a great choice to have.