fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?

  
 
chiron
Offline

p.1 #1How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?

How much of an advantage is it to keep your lenses in the same family, e.g., all Loxia or all Batis or all Sony or all Voigtlander, or Sigma, or Rokinon, etc?

There is something nice about having the same ergonomics and color and general sizing, but is that mostly an obsessive tweak?

Or are the disadvantages of mixing and matching real?
Jan 26, 2019 at 07:28 AM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.1 #2How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
My sanity is worth a lot! Really depends though, some mix and match seemlessly, and some have obvious color cast and contrast differences. If you want to display photos together it can be maddening to process similar.
Jan 26, 2019 at 07:56 AM
KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.1 #3How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Holds no weight with me. If you shoot Raw most images look similar before editing anyway. Its,as you say,an obsessive tweak or a rationalization to buy/sell
I have 2 Batis,2 Zony's and 2 G lenses. I use them all at gigs. That said,I do love the weight & image quality of the Batis...but it'll never propel me to sell the Sony 50/1.4 to get the Batis 40.

Edited on Jan 26, 2019 at 08:31 AM · View previous versions
Jan 26, 2019 at 08:07 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.1 #4How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Funny you ask this question as I typically bought the best lens you can get regardless of money but in IQ value and really did not care if I had several diffrent brands when I first got into Sony. I think part of that maybe the evolution of the system in the beginning since we where limited. I think I can safely say most of us where in that position as the offerings where quite slim back when the A7R hit the streets. For me at least that has changed more so with my MF kit than my AF kit per say. Although they both changed. Case in point I had at one time most Loxia glass on the MF side. I had every Loxia lens at least once. 21,25,35,50,85 and some a few times. Let’s not count here my wife could read this.

But recently I’ve gotten very frustrated actually shooting them. Hard to get on and off but for me the aperture ring drove me nuts. It’s the same size as the focusing ring and too close to the body. Not to mention the focusing ring is just too smooth in texture. I had to always had to look at the lens too shoot the dang thing and I change lenses all the time. Now no question some of the best IQ around but after buying the CV 15 several years ago . I really liked the aperture ring out front and the knurled focusing ring. Reminds me very much of old Nikon glass from years past. Recently I sold off all my Loxia glass the 25,85 and before that the 21. Now these are the best Loxia lenses around but functionally they got under my skin. My MF is my pleasure kit and I wanted it to be Guy friendly. Not so much work friendly. So I grabbed the CV 40 1.2 which is a no brainer than I did something crazy sold the Loxia 25 which I loved, sold the Batis 25 which is a nice lens than bought the CV 21 which is maybe 90 percent of the Loxia 21 which by my standards of having the best I can get was a strange move but I wanted that CV feel and I grabbed the Sony 24 for my AF kit. Than I sold the Loxia 85 which was another strange move but again the ethos where killing me. I grabbed a Leica 75 summarit which pairs better with my 40 and has the same ergis as CV glass. So overall maybe gave up a little IQ but got lenses that I just like better to shoot plus the kit also got even smaller which I was after as well. So my kit today is CV 12,21,40 and the Leica 75 and I’m thinking of adding the CV 110 at some point. I’m much happier

On the AF side I like Sony lenses as well for there Ergos and more important on some of them there manual focus feel. I love the Sony 24, 50 and 84 1.4 lenses for there feel over Batis lenses. I don’t have the GM 85 anymore but the Batis 85 but that was a AF speed issue not a ergo issue. But today it’s a split between Sony and Batis but I do wish it was all Sony as you get the extra button in some of them and a manual aperture ring too. Like to see the whole line like that. So I’m still working the AF side but I’m happy with my CV manual focus kit. If they had a great 75 that was small and high IQ I would grab it.

I guess the bottom line is I have changed as the evolution of the system has changed
Jan 26, 2019 at 08:16 AM
AGeoJO
Online
Details
p.1 #5How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
chiron wrote:
How much of an advantage is it to keep your lenses in the same family, e.g., all Loxia or all Batis or all Sony or all Voigtlander, or Sigma, or Rokinon, etc?

There is something nice about having the same ergonomics and color and general sizing, but is that mostly an obsessive tweak?

Or are the disadvantages of mixing and matching real?


Peter, even lenses of the same line vary in ergonomic handling; they are of different sizes and weights . Frankly, I am not paying much attention to that. I buy and use lenses I like mostly based on the optical performance and characters; I do have a few MF lenses although most of my lenses are AF ones. Somehow, our ability to make the adjustment based on what you put on on your camera from the operational point of view is actually quite great. IMHO, no big deal in mixing and matching, in other words.
Jan 26, 2019 at 09:06 AM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.1 #6How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Only a minor consideration for me.

If I buy a "first" lens in a given line and really like it, I'll look at others in the same line, but buying in the same line isn't a primary concern.

Sometimes lenses in the same family share the same quirks, and if those are a net negative for me, I'll typically pass on that line but it's not because of the "lens family" per se.


Jan 26, 2019 at 11:19 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.1 #7How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I like having lenses with different looks. Sometimes the lenses are similar (say Loxia and modern CV lenses—close though with somewhat different color profiles) and sometimes they are quite pronounced in color differences and/or drawing style. Maybe this reveals weaknesses in my photography or post processing technique, but say if I take a picture of a waterfall say with my CV 40 and a similar image with my C/Y 35-70, I will often prefer the rendering of one over the other for reasons I find hard to express—drawing style, color palette, native contrast, or some combination. For another example, flower shots taken with and STF 100, Loxia 85, and CV65 will allow different looks including bokeh. So for me, having all the same line might make for ergonomic simplicity, but it would deny the variation of styles that I find quite enjoyable and enable me to make perhaps better (or less bad) pictures of a given scene. Having said this, if I were a portrait photographer and shooting different focal lengths and wanting to batch process lots of images, then having similar looks at varying focal lengths would greatly simplify post processing and ergonomic similarity in a fast paced environment is doubtless important. For me, most of my shooting is landscapes and off a tripod and so working slowly and with a relatively small volume of images. Thus, for me, having the same family is not a consideration. The only thing that matters to me is the quality and character of each lens that I am using.
Jan 26, 2019 at 11:48 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #8How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I don't see much advantage and imo it's just more consistent. (AF vs MF, barrel design, filter thread, etc.)

Instead, I go for "focal length" and shoot with lenses that appeals the most to me and my needs.

The Loxia line has lenses with different rendering and IQ. Example: Loxia 35 vs Loxia 25.
The Batis line has the 85 and 135mm primes but I think they have different characteristcs.
The ZA line is completely different in look and rendering: Example: 55/1.8 ZA vs 50/1.4 ZA.
The Voigtlander line also has lenses with completely different looks and rendering: CV 40 vs CV 65
Jan 26, 2019 at 12:03 PM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.1 #9How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
There are some advantages:

- similar lens color profiles (but these can be quickly equalized between lens families in LR)
- lens families often share the same filter size (ie: 52mm for Loxias, 67mm for Batisii except the Batis 18mm uses a 77mm filter, etc..)
- similar ergonomics makes handling the lenses a bit easier for some

In my experience, the main disadvantages have been design limitations related to efforts to keep the same barrel size and overall form.
Jan 26, 2019 at 12:07 PM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.1 #10How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
One of the reasons I chose and continue to stick w/ the Zeiss Batis system is the uniform color characteristics. This attribute alone can be very helpful. For Emount, this may be the only color matched system so far?

Jan 26, 2019 at 12:13 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.1 #11How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I do prefer that my lenses focus and have aperture rings the work in the same direction particuarly for MF lenses. That is why my MF lenses are Leica R; M mount including Leica M, M-Rokkor, and Zeiss ZM; and Canon FD. I only have but 1 Sony lens, my 100-400mm GM. But for my MF M lenses, they all have their focus rings and tabs in the same location and the aperture rings in basically the same position. My Leica R lenses and Canon FD lenses basically have their focus rings and aperture rings in the same place. So, I am able to switch back and forth between my differents lenses more easily. Filter thread size is not generally an issue to me since pretty much all of my lenses for my Sony Cameras and for work with my Cambo Actus are 77mm or smaller and I use step up rings to adapt my lenses to use 77mm filters or for my Lee 100mm filter system.

Rich
Jan 26, 2019 at 12:20 PM
Kalainen
Offline
Details
p.1 #12How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Having a consistent look between different lenses is more important thing in cinematography where there is a greater demand for the consistent output (one movie might consist of thousands of takes and it needs to look more or less the same). Therefore having color matched lenses across the range is important and Zeiss have been working a lot with this with their cinema-lenses. This also trickles down to photography lenses, for example, Milvus, Batis, Loxia and Otus all have a similar color rendering within the family (older Loxia designs 35 & 50 being exception here). Not sure if other manufacturers do anything like this, but then again, there are lot of details Zeiss pays attention even if they are not found by reviewers or such. I believe Sony does something similar with the GM lenses (similar colors across the range), but regular Sony lenses and G lenses are definitely inferior. And again in my own experience the Batis lens family have similar rendering as well across the lenses. If your work requires consistency then this might be important (wedding photographers, photography artists, technical photography), but let's admit that many enthusiast never reach that level of consistency that they would require matched lenses as well.
Jan 26, 2019 at 12:37 PM
Jtacdf
Offline
Details
p.1 #13How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I kept most of my gears Sony, G and GM as I believe eye af to have the best implementation from OEM. Case in point where the current batis 40mm does not seem to be working correctly with it? There is also the benefit, for recent Sony lenses, of hitting the maximum of 20fps on the a9 should I need it.
Jan 26, 2019 at 12:51 PM
orso
Offline
Details
p.1 #14How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Very interesting topic, thanks for bringing it up. I thought it was only me...

I certainly value homogeneous color cast. I really like Zeiss color rendition and struggle to try and match it in processing raw files from other lenses (e.g. Voigtlander 65/2 Apo, which I love for other characteristics...)

I also find a bit annoying mixing AF and MF lenses, but, since a double kit is not justified by my limited use, I make do.

Stated that, I agree with Luvwine's point of view and think that different looks and characters can be beneficial to improve creativity and originality.

So in the end I just use the lenses I like most by focal length and... keep selling and buying them

Ciao
Claudio
Jan 26, 2019 at 12:56 PM
Samuli Vahonen
Offline
Details
p.1 #15How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
chiron wrote:
How much of an advantage is it to keep your lenses in the same family, e.g., all Loxia or all Batis or all Sony or all Voigtlander, or Sigma, or Rokinon, etc?

It depends. I used to care a lot about this, but as I used to shoot with Canon (2001-2013) and all Canons have similar color it was really nice to have same "family lenses". When I moved to Sony it was immediately clear that different bodies have different colors, and now 2 of my 5 bodies have Kolari v2 modification and their colors are quite far from Sony standard cameras. If I would shoot with just one camera, I would find it beneficial to have lenses from same "familty". But as I never change lens on the field AND I shoot with 2-5 body+lens combos (2x A7 mkI Kolari v2, A7r mkI, A7 mkII, A7r mkII) every time I go shooting it anyways requires hard work to make colors to match if it's needed.

From ergonomics standpoint I have never cared anything else than that the focus direction is Zeiss/Leica/Canon direction. When I shoot with Nikon focus direction lenses it takes many weeks to get to mode where I can automatically without thinking focus to moving targets with "correct" focus direction lenses. This also used to matter more earlier as I did shoot more variety of subjects, but now I shoot nature details and landscapes from 99% tripod and focus speed is no longer relevant.

Rendering style (focus plane microcontrast, focus plane flatness/3d-ness/pop/whateveryoucallit, boke character, DOF-boke transfer zone character & speed, DOF/boke contrast difference, sharpness/contrast distribution inside DOF etc. etc.) is still something I care when combining lenses. In my opinion it would be really stupid to combine low contrast, low microcontrast, flat rendering lens (e.g. Voightländer 90 APO) to lens which has opposite rendering style e.g. Loxia 25 if there is any need to present photos from both lenses at same time and they should look similar. However being same lens "family" doesn't mean that rendering style is similar, e.g. Loxia 25 & 85 go well together, but Loxia 50 does not have similar rendering style, or Carl Zeiss 2.8/60 C/Y-mount makro (S-Planar) & same mount/"family" 1.4/50 (Planar) do not look at all similar, or Carl Zeiss "classic" ZE/ZF where 28, 2/35, 1.4/50 and 1.4/85 all have quite similar rendering and 2/25 & 2/50 were dramatically different (and 21&100 somewhere in between) or Leica APO-Summicron-M 90mm f/2 vs Summicron-M 50mm f/2 look quite different.

Then there is the "mental" factor, at least for me. I just happen to enjoy shooting with set of lenses from same era&"family" and which preferably have similar rendering style together. I use this kind of lens sets from time to time, when I don't feel like shooting with my main lens set. My mostly used "similar rendering style"-sets are "Carl Zeiss classic SLR"-set [2.8/28C/Y, 1.4/50ZE (or C/Y) and 3.5/100C/Y] and "Carl Zeiss G"-set [G28, G45 or G90 - G21 can be added, but it's extreme rare to have any subjects requiring anything wider than 28mm]. As this is hobby to me, it's nice to enjoy shooting...


In practice I did most 2018 shooting with 3 lens set: Zeiss APO-Sonnar 2/135, Sigma Art 50mm and Sigma Art 24-35mm (2019: Sigma Art 28mm if it's good). All are high performance lenses and I have selected them as they render focus plane flawlessly and forest scene boke scene rendering is pleasing (not optimal, these are all too modern rendering style = harsh => polarizer is required for 100% of boke photos). Rendering style of lenses is similar enough that similar look can be achieved with some effort (different cameras cause me more headache than lenses, if I really need to match colors).


Samuli
Jan 26, 2019 at 02:40 PM
JohnJ
Offline
Details
p.1 #16How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
My standards must be very low as i only want my mf lenses to focus in the same direction, the rest i can work with. As a result, no Pentax or Nikon lenses in my kit. Alright alright, I do have the 2.8/55 micro-nikkor but it's too good to resist.

The real pain for me with using a bunch of different legacy brands at once is all the adapters required for each different lens, which are quite bulky. Compare this to using the same brand where you'd bring one adapter which would stay on the body instead of different adapters fitted to each lens.
Jan 26, 2019 at 02:42 PM
Samuli Vahonen
Offline
Details
p.1 #17How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
smpetty wrote:
- lens families often share the same filter size (ie: 52mm for Loxias, 67mm for Batisii except the Batis 18mm uses a 77mm filter, etc..)

As I always shoot with polarizer (OK, there are exceptions like long exposure shooting, but >95%), and I don't want to change polarizer from lens to another all the time while I'm shooting -> I find it annoying to buy same size polarizer many times. Due to Loxia 52mm standard I have two 52mm polarizers. Two 46mm polarizers for Zeiss G-series. Multiple 55mm polarizers due to it being common with Zeiss C/Y, Leica R etc. If Sigma Art 28mm is good then I need to buy 3rd 77mm polarizer as Sigma Art 50 and Zeiss 2/135 have also 77mm thread. However I think generally it's positive to have same filter size, and this is just my personal problem

JohnJ wrote:
The real pain for me with using a bunch of different legacy brands at once is all the adapters required for each different lens, which are quite bulky. Compare this to using the same brand where you'd bring one adapter which would stay on the body instead of different adapters fitted to each lens.

I have taken different approach. I modify all adapters to lens specific (I mask&flock as much as possible for the adapted lens without causing vignetting, and add special flocking to hide bright parts of backside of the lens). Some of my legacy FL/FD-lenses have so worn out lensmount that I have glued them to adapter. Only Metabones EF-FE-adapters & Sony AlphaSLR->FE adapters are standard and they are all really well flocked/masked - also they would be way too expensive to make lens specific.


Samuli
Jan 26, 2019 at 03:08 PM
Dave Sanders
Offline
Details
p.1 #18How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
I'm not sure that I care or even notice when I switch lenses. I mean, I notice, but it so rarely effects me on an operational level. I consider ergonomics when I buy a lens, to be sure, but once I've made the determination that I like it, I learn to use it and that's it. I used Nikon and Sony side by side for over 4 years and never had even a hiccup when I went between. Unlike Guy, I really, really like my Loxia's and I may be the only person on earth who has never really had any difficulty taking them on and off my camera haha. I read a lot about that issue before I bought my 25 and 85 and was so excited to use them that, when I got them, I forgot I was supposed to have difficulty putting them on and off. A few days into my ownership I sort of of thought 'oh yeah, these are supposed to be hard to mount' and that's kind of the last I thought of it. Doesn't bother me. They're constructed like such little jewels I only find pleasure in handling them. My personal favourite AF design gestalt right now are the GM lenses...my first and only is the 100 STF and I really like it. Can't wait to get another.

I've used a number of CV M mount lenses and like those too...the older LTM versions with the little tab/handle sticking out for focus are great in use. The new knurled focus rings are very nice, like Guy, they remind me of the old Nikons I loved. So, to answer your question, no, I don't consider lenses from the same 'line' to be essential. In fact, the opposite, I love the variety. As long as they 'work' for me in their own way, I'm a happy camper. As for colour, I find my post processing routine takes care of most of that. Things like contrast and rendering, again, I like to have a large array of tools that accomplish different jobs differently. As Sony users, we are properly spoiled, both with native and adapted glass.
Jan 26, 2019 at 03:44 PM
imagesfromobjects
Offline
Details
p.1 #19How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?
Only thing that drives me nuts about the Laowa 15/2 is that it focuses the opposite way than almost all my other lenses. Seriously jams me up. I've gotten used to it, but I have to make a mental note every time I put it on, and just rack back and forth a few times so I get it.

I also like lenses to have similar ergonomics- placement of aperture ring, resistance of focusing ring, similar focus throw, etc.

Beyond that, I don't mind some variety in rendering, so mixing it up is all good.
Jan 26, 2019 at 04:04 PM
phototiimo
Offline
Details
p.1 #20How much of an advantage to keep your lenses in the same family?


LBJ2 wrote:
One of the reasons I chose and continue to stick w/ the Zeiss Batis system is the uniform color characteristics. This attribute alone can be very helpful. For Emount, this may be the only color matched system so far?



I thought the G and GM lines have very similar colors as well, though?
Jan 26, 2019 at 09:57 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister